7 ms·
36B solar mass black hole at centre of the Cosmic Horseshoe gravitational lens
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoA bit off topic: Is there any theoretical upper limit on the mass of a black hole?
- cft 1y agohttps://youtu.be/EGzvGgNmaiY?t=58s https://youtu.be/EGzvGgNmaiY?t=58s
- jameskilton 1y agoGiven things like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TON_618 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TON_618 and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoenix_Cluster#Supermassive_black_hole https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoenix_Cluster#Supermassive_b..., probably not. Seems like you can just keep shoving mass into it.
- bee_rider 1y agoPoking around those articles (and knowing nothing really), it is interesting to note a couple references to a 50B solar-mass limit for “luminous accreting black holes hosted by disc galaxies.” (In your Phoenix cluster link). I guess these ones are easier to spot, based entirely on the word “luminous.” There are other larger ones out there, looming in the darkness.
- pantalaimon 1y agoThose supermassive black holes are very old, from a time when the universe was much denser - they likely collapsed directly without any star formation
- MurkyLabs 1y agoIt doesn't seem like there's a limit to how big they can get just a limit to how quickly they can get bigger due to what's called the Eddington Limit which explains how matter falling into the black hole emits radiation and if enough radiation around the accretion disk builds up, it can overcome the pull of the black hole and push matter away, at least until enough matter is pushed away that the radiation levels fall back under the limit and matter starts falling in again.
- zamadatix 1y agoImportantly, the Eddington limit does not apply to black hole mergers, theoretically allowing as much growth rate as you're able to feed in from smaller black holes.
- pixl97 1y agoThis said, the final parsec problem isn't solved/understood. We know black holes do merge, but we don't understand what energy is being bled out of the system so supermassive black holes crash into each other in the timeframes we're seeing it occur.
- allemagne 1y agoSo then the only theoretical limit on black hole mass would just be how fast you can put matter in black holes and/or merge existing black holes versus how fast the universe expands?
- MurkyLabs 1y agoI'm 100% an armchair physician so take my words with a grain of salt but it seems like according to the math there is no limit to how massive a black hole can get. There are limits on the size of how big and small things can get and how hot or cold they can get, the second part is pretty cool, Physics Explained on yt has a good video on it (he's got a lot of good videos) but I enjoyed this one on what the maximum temperature is in the universe: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVlEQlz6n1k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVlEQlz6n1k
- ghurtado 1y ago> I'm 100% an armchair physician Not to be that guy, but a physician is a doctor.
- dotancohen 1y agoBut that's not important right now.
- tromp 1y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_massive_black_holes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_massive_black_hol... shows the maximal theoretical limit as 270B solar masses.
- BurningFrog 1y agoSo what happens if two such black holes collide?
- msk-lywenn 1y agoCan black holes even collide? I guess their horizons can merge somehow... Probably a spectacular show.
- ryandamm 1y agoThat’s precisely what LIGO measures, the gravitational waves from black hole mergers (or neutron star mergers, etc).
- bookofjoe 1y ago>Cosmic Heavyweights Collide – LIGO Detects Largest, Fastest-Spinning Black Holes Yet https://scitechdaily.com/cosmic-heavyweights-collide-ligo-detects-largest-fastest-spinning-black-holes-yet/ https://scitechdaily.com/cosmic-heavyweights-collide-ligo-de...
- 20k 1y agoDisclaimer: This is my own work https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=doS85Mh78Vc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=doS85Mh78Vc This is what they look like when they merge, its pretty darn cool
- boothby 1y agoI love to contemplate galactic-scale synchrotrons that accelerate supermassive charged black holes to collide at relativistic speeds. The thought never really goes anywhere, but I'm sure it'd be a spectacle to behold.
- bell-cot 1y agoYes - but it's basically the same as the total mass of the universe. EDIT: I believe the above could be incorrect - if the universe has too much electrical charge or angular momentum. (And some other cosmological properties, so you couldn't get around the charge & spin issues.) Might there be a black hole astrophysicist in the house, to comment on this?
- radicalbyte 1y agoThere is this whole theory that the observable universe is inside a black hole.
- nashashmi 1y agoSo the upper limit is the weight of the universe.
- henearkr 1y agoAbout 9000 times the mass of the supermassive black hole at the center of our galaxy (Sagittarius A*).
- BaseBaal 1y agoMind boggling. Wish they included images of the scale compared to our sun, solar system, galaxy etc to help me wrap my head around this beast.
- msk-lywenn 1y agoWith good quantization, I bet we can get it down to 8B and it will easily fit on consumer grade galaxy. (Sorry, I had to, with all the AI flood, I really was about to skip this info after the first 3 characters)
- ghurtado 1y agoDon't be sorry, that was pretty good
- freddier 1y agoThey very rare great HN joke.
- maybelsyrup 1y agoHow true this is
- deafpolygon 1y agothat's too good, haha
- positisop 1y agoGlad you wrote it, the title took me down the same path for a few seconds :-D
- belter 1y agoResearchers discovered the black hole has been consuming AI VC money, at the rate of $50M per day, and so finally explaining why it is gotten so big.
- gibolt 1y agoThat sounds low...
- ozim 1y agoI had a bit of a pause trying to figure out if someone named a model „black hole” from that title. Hype is strong.
- BSOhealth 1y agoWith all the lensing going on out there, is it possible for us to observe the light from our sun (and potentially our planet) billions of years ago? A cool achievement would be, observe the moon/earth separation event(s)
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- throwup238 1y agoTheoretically yes but although this black hole is big enough to make that more realistic, the redirected light would be have lost so much energy we’d likely be unable to observe it. We’d need an orbital hypertelescope to even stand a chance. Even then we wouldn’t see the earth because it would be drowned out by the sun. The bigger problem is all the dust and other stars in the way. I’m not aware of any black holes close enough that would have a direct path for the light to cross without being absorbed and scattered.
- LeifCarrotson 1y agoThe other problem is the angle at which the light must be redirected. The Cosmic Horseshoe is composed of two systems almost directly in line, the light comes from the farther system and bends infinitesimally around the black hole to come to us. I don't know if a 180 degree bend is possible. Also, the foreground galaxy/supermassive black hole in the Cosmic Horseshoe is 5.6 billion light years away, so any light that could come from our solar system, go around the black hole, and come back to our hypothetical hypertelescope would be over 11 billion years old - almost triple the age of our sun. Saggitarius A* in our own galaxy is, of course, directly in the elliptic and therefore badly occluded by dust, but it would be interesting to look at as it's only 27k light years away. In the absence of that pesky dust, it would give us a picture of the solar system as of the Paleolithic. Andromeda, at 2.5 million light years away, would give us 5-million-year-old light. There are other black holes in the Milky Way on the order of a thousand light years away which are not at the center of the galaxy but have masses comparable to or slightly larger than our sun, these are far closer (within a few thousand years) but have much smaller gravitational fields. Luminous intensity drops off with the square of the distance, but I'm not sure how the gravitational field strength affects the ability of a particular galaxy to bend light.
- chiffre01 1y agoHow big would the diameter of this be ? Something like 8 light days ?
- myrmidon 1y agoSounds about right. Wiki has a correctly scaled picture with the two biggest known black hole event horizons and the solar system: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TON_618 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TON_618 Event horizon radius would be about roughly 1000 times the distance between Earth/Sun.
- ethan_smith 1y agoThe Schwarzschild radius would be approximately 106 billion kilometers or about 7 light days (r = 2GM/c²).
- dweinus 1y agoUsing the formula for black hole density, a black hole of this mass would have an average density about the same as the near-vacuum atmosphere of Mars(!) https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/26515/what-is-exactly-the-density-of-a-black-hole-and-how-can-it-be-calculated#218816 https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/26515/what-is-ex...
- tlogan 1y agoAnd it would take 10 days from event horizon to the singularity.
- dotancohen 1y agoHow so?
- proteal 1y agoThe black hole has two conceptual parts - the event horizon and the singularity. The event horizon is a one-way imaginary shell where once you pass it, you will end up at the singularity which is a point at the center of the event horizon. It’s the hole in black hole. Because the radius of the spherical horizon grows linearly with mass, but the size of the hole is fixed at effectively 0, it allows for a bit of sightseeing on your way to impending doom if the mass of the hole is large enough.
- reactordev 1y agoThis is also the light barrier where light can no longer escape the gravitational forces (causing the blackness of the black hole). Your “sightseeing tour” would be a kaleidoscope of light as it brushes past you on its way to the singularity.
- lazide 1y agoUh, that is the event horizon?
- readthenotes1 1y agoCosmic Horseshoe galaxy, with pics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_Horseshoe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_Horseshoe
- tenthirtyam 1y agoInteresting. Given that the horseshoe shape is due to gravitational lensing of one far off galaxy ~19 Gly away by another "only" 6 Gly away, wouldn't that mean that any motion of those galaxies, or our galaxy, would realign the lensing and alter the shape of the horseshoe? So... how long before we see the shape change? How fast do galaxies move anyway?
- physix 1y agoThis reminds me of when I was a physics undergrad way back in the mid 80s. We used to spend nights drinking beer and hacking some simulations from the Computer Recreations section of Scientific American. Once we wanted to simulate the dynamics of galaxies. I don'it think it was an SA article, but we did it the slow way by calculating the force on every star individually from each other star. It was excruciatingly slow and boring. Then some time later, I don't recall where I picked that up, I updated the simulation to just model the force on each star coming from the galaxy's centre of mass. I could simulate many more stars, have galaxies collide and see them spin off with their stars scattering around. What struck me was that they looked like real galaxies we see out there. I wasn't aware of the postulations made in the 60s/70s about there being supermassive black holes at the centre of galaxies, but to me, this simplified simulation was kind of like a smoking gun for that... from an 80286 IBM PC AT.
- sebastiennight 1y agoIf we're assuming that the galaxy is radially symmetrical, doesn't it immediately follow that the combined gravitational force on a given star is the same as if we applied the force from a combined mass at the center? This wouldn't work for something like the Solar system with a very sparse distribution of mass, but at the galaxy level it seems right even without the presence of a black hole.
- physix 1y agoEven when the distance between the centres of mass of two colliding galaxies become comparable to their size? It's a long time ago, but what I remember was being fascinated by the shapes of the galaxies emerging from a collision under this centre-of-mass approximation, and that it created shapes we see out there. It was as if the main effect were a central mass in each galaxy dominating the dynamics.
- ubercow13 1y agoEven the largest SMBHs mass is a minute fraction of their host galaxies' total mass so it is not the case that everything is just orbiting the SMBH.