5 ms·
I asked four former friends why we stopped speaking (2023)
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- rambojohnson 1y agowas expecting to find boring navel-gazing solipsism, was not disappointed. one can easily see why the group drifted apart.
- andreaja 1y agoFor a lot of articles like these, looking at the answers to see if they're interesting is futile. The real insight is in the questions. In this case, you can reflect on your own friendships, and how the other side of them might see them differently.
- glxxyz 1y agohttps://archive.is/eiZHj https://archive.is/eiZHj
- QuinceOver 1y ago[dead]
- muyuu 1y ago[dead]
- rendall 1y ago> "But eventually, we broke away—you, to join the funny kids, a group of hilarious and friendly people who could match your unparalleled wit and high-octane energy... That is not how people actually talk in real life. > ...and me, to join the kids at the back of the bus, literally and figuratively. People really do not make other people the main character like this. "My crew were shy introverts who were hilarious once we got going" is how people describe themselves: more description, adjectives and familiarity. "You were doing your own thing with the party crowd" is how people describe others: vague and sparse in descriptive detail. This passage inverts that.
- windowshopping 1y agoThat jumped out at me too.
- neilv 1y agoSome people do talk like that. For example, the well-read humanities major analogue of "10x techbro" can effortlessly whip out a more sophisticated analysis or assessment, with better prose. And some of those will say things like that with one or more levels on top. Such as if they know the person they're talking with will get the reference or archetype, or the allusion they're making, and they're really saying something more. Like (just one example) it means: "I like you, and there's some literal truth to what I'm saying, but you get the real thing I'm saying, because we get each other, like not everybody can, and also you should remember to have a sense of humor, and I think you needed me to say it this way". (But I'm highly skeptical of people on social media, claiming "my young child just said: [something sounding like a speech crafted by the poster]".)
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- zahlman 1y ago> the well-read humanities major analogue of "10x techbro" can effortlessly whip out a more sophisticated analysis or assessment, with better prose. Such a person certainly can do so, but also really ought to know better.
- devilbunny 1y agoThis piece is in Vogue. Could have been in Elle. Ever wonder about why articles in Sports Illustrated go off on politics? Same reason. These writers, by and large, went to Ivy League schools. Their classmates were hired at the New York Times (serious) or Saturday Night Live (funny). They want to point out hey, I have a great vocabulary and know art and such, too. Even if I just nominally write about clothes or baseball.
- cma 1y ago
- readthenotes1 1y agoAmazingly, even though this is perfect fodder for a self-absorbed attention-seeking post, it's actually quite good, focusing on the different perspectives people in a relationship have as contact fades
- avereveard 1y agoLife Transitions 4 Lack of mutual effort 4 Diverging values 3 Miscommunication 2.5 Geographic distance 2.5 Emotional disengagement 2 (Since article is lacking a conclusion - or the conclusion is a weird direction, "should I talk to my ex" - I guess I'm not the target demo)
- hinkley 1y agoDiverging values I think is why it’s not a bad thing that marriage is being postponed closer to 30 now. Promising to be with someone forever when you don’t even know who you or they are yet is wishful thinking at best and lying at worst. If we ever find a way to delay puberty without delaying formation of the prefrontal cortex, I think humanity will be in for a better time. You’ll get a few more years of being able to have kids after you know who you are.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Telemakhos 1y agoDo people who get married and have children diverge in values at the same rate as unmarried people who live together? Or do they tend to converge rather and align their attitudes to the common interests of the family? "Who you are" is not a stable thing, nor is it a mystery suddenly revealed at a certain advanced age: it is something you continuously construct and reconstruct all your life. I suspect that marriage and family play a massive role in that ongoing psychological construction rather than being independent states that might be invalidated by some sudden discovery of "who you are."
- hinkley 1y agoIf the issue is immaturity I suspect they can diverge faster. Some people grown up when they have kids. Others don’t, and that becomes a frequent source of argument. Others collapse their lives entirely, which can be shocking for the person who saw something in you that you’ve now abandoned.
- 1y ago
- rado 1y agoIn Summary – What Was Learned • Friendship loss in adulthood is common and often tied to life transitions. • Direct communication with an ex-friend can be enlightening, even if the relationship doesn’t restart. • Personal growth often comes from understanding your role in the ending—not assigning blame or regret, but acknowledging patterns. • Reconnection does not guarantee reunion, and in many cases, the value lies in what you learn about yourself, not whether the relationship is revived.
- mmmlinux 1y agoa. people change b. you moved to Kenya.
- silisili 1y ago> Matt said a lot of wonderful things about me and our friendship during our conversation, but one thing meant the most. “In my mid 20s, I was really selfish,” he said. “But I’m currently at a point where I don’t really care about things for myself. Now that I’m almost 30, my loved ones and my friendship are all that really matter.” Not to discount anyone else's story, but Matt's is probably the most prevalent. It's a shame we spend 18ish years making friends, then in our 20's more or less have to make a mad dash to establish a place to live, a career, a partner, etc. Everyone loses touch "temporarily" in what goes by like a blur, and by your 30's you still remember everyone, but it feels weird to reach out because of how long it's been.
- munificent 1y agoIn the US, I think we should consider that many people go through four socially traumatic transitions: 1. Moving away to college. 2. Moving for work. 3. Getting married. 4. Having kids. Each of those tends to sever many friendships in ways that are more painful than a lot of us realize or acknowledge. We might even consider what it says about us as a people that we seem to value all of the points on that list more than we value being a member of a community with deep social ties. When I graduated high school in Louisiana, I couldn't wait to get the fuck out of my small suburb. Then I dropped out of college and couldn't wait to get out of Louisiana entirely. I looked down on everyone who stayed in my home town and got a job at Shell or Entergy. I still believe I did the right thing by leaving—the community there goes against many of my most deeply held values. But as I've gotten older, I realize more what the people valued and kept by staying there: a consistent set of close ties and community maintained throughout their entire lives.
- selimthegrim 1y agoAre you from New Orleans or Lafayette? Edit: holy shit I had no idea you’re from Louisiana.
- munificent 1y agoLived 10 years in St. Charles Parish, then another 4 in Baton Route.
- windowshopping 1y agoAdvice from someone in their 30s who has successfully kept the majority of their closest friends from high school and college (around 10 people) but also lost several key people over the years: - Keep a semi-regular communication channel. For me this is easy, it isn't a chore for me to just text people. I know some people find this harder. If I see something I think they would find funny, I send them a link. If I start wondering about something I know they're knowledgeable about, I send them a question. If we have a shared hobby, I talk to them about it. Texting someone even just every other month can be the difference between keeping a friendship alive and letting it rust. - Make sure to care about them and where they're at. Keep track and a week later ask "how did that interview go?" (for example.) Ask about their lives and sympathize with it, and make an effort to remember. Don't just tell them about you. One really easy way to make a difference is to keep track of people's birthdays, by the way. Just write it down in a text file somewhere if you have to. I know the birthday of everyone in my life - it actually takes borderline zero effort to write it down once and check that file once a month - and I think that makes a difference. - Meet people where they're comfortable. Some of my friends are happy to jump in discord and just chat. Some would rather phone call every couple months. Some do neither but will respond to texts daily. Don't think like "this method works for my other friends, why are you being difficult?" Figure out what fits them. (And there are some people out there who won't want to do any of these things, and those people can be harder to keep up with. And that's just how it goes. But in my experience those people are very rare. I only know one, personally.) - Getting along with their chosen significant other is paramount. I've lost two formerly-very-close friends to spouses who I'm not compatible with. You don't have to be good friends with them, but you do have to avoid insulting them or going against their values when you're around them. Eventually you may sometimes have to answer a question for yourself: do I value my friendship with this person enough to accept being around this person I really don't like? And sometimes the answer is no, and again...that's life. - Over time part of why relationships fall apart is that you're not sharing experiences together anymore. You don't live together in college anymore, for example, so you no longer have that shared experience to bond over. You live a thousand miles apart and don't know any of the same people, so you only care because it's happening to them, not because you're experiencing it too. It can make a huge difference to plan trips together when possible. "Let's go hiking together." "Let's go to Disney together." "Come stay with me for a few days, I'd love to just have a guest. You can work in my spare room and we can hang out at night and make dinners." WHATEVER. ANYTHING. You don't have to go to Disney, you can just go grocery shopping together. That's still a shared moment. Maybe the cash register will be rude and you'll both be taken aback. That's a new shared memory. And having shared memories is the biggest key.
- oniony 1y ago>Though I’m Kenyan by ethnicity, I grew up abroad, in the US and UK, and I’ve found that my foreign accent and perspective other me, even within my family. I had to read this sentence four times before I even considered that 'other' could be a verb!
- SoftTalker 1y agoIt's not, at least not in any dictionary I've consulted. Though in context it works, I guess.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jama211 1y agoIt’s slang, but I’ve heard it.
- Adrock 1y agohttps://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/other https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/other Added in November 2017 according to https://www.merriam-webster.com/wordplay/other-as-a-verb https://www.merriam-webster.com/wordplay/other-as-a-verb
- netsharc 1y agoI've started hearing "x" be used as a verb as well... As in "We need to 4x our output!". I hate it as much as I hate MBA wankers using "ping" as if they're ICMP compliant...
- terribleperson 1y agoPerhaps you should try consulting Merriam-Webster then.
- jama211 1y agoHaha well said
- jeffhwang 1y agoI appreciate the vulnerability of the OP in researching and writing that article. It can be pretty hard to reconnect with friends you’ve lost touch with or actually broken up with. And to do this publicly!
- ferguess_k 1y agoOn my side, once we formed families we sort of lost contact gradually. We still gather around once or twice a year for Christmas and another holidays, but other than that we keep to ourselves. My wife doesn't really like staying with my friends so she always asked me to go alone, but I mean, it's usually family gathering, and going alone is really weird. We do get a couple of new ones though, from my wife's side. They are very good people and very fun to stay with. I have to admit that I enjoy staying with my wife's friends more than she does with mine, but that's fine with me. Maybe I'll get a few days off and coffee chat with my side of the friends.
- programmertote 1y agoIt's okay to lose touch with former friends (that is, to not feel guilty). This is part of life and I'm always convinced that my friends, whom I lost contact with, will understand as well. Plus, although we were friends at one point due to common interests, shared environment, etc., we grow up and apart. If chances collide, we will cross paths with some of them. During my thirties, I felt a bit guilty about not keeping in touch with most of my friends from high school and college. As I reached mid-forties, I have learned to live with the above realization. I think I'd have a good chat with some of my old friends when I meet them by happenstance again.
- SoftTalker 1y agoFriendship requires proximity. Very hard to maintain a friendship or any relationship with physical distance or even just mostly disjoint social circles. Nothing to feel guilty about, it's how we work.
- rimunroe 1y ago> Friendship requires proximity. This is clearly false as plenty of long-term long-distance friendships exist. It does make it harder, but there's a difference between "harder" and "impossible". I have several multi-decade friendships where we have no friends in common and either never met in person or met only a few times.
- rendall 1y agoElderly people, particularly but not only men, suffer social isolation and loneliness. It is a social problem across the developed world. That's because people tend not to make new friends in middle age. That trend begins in the mid 20s. No matter your age, learn the trick of making, and keeping, new friends. Of all ages, sexes, cultures, types. It is extremely vital to your mental and physical health.
- 9rx 1y ago> learn the trick of making, and keeping, new friends. The trick is having time and energy. The challenge is finding the time and energy in your mid-20s and beyond when things like your career, children, etc. come crushing down upon you, all while, at the same time, your body starts to lose is youthful vitality.
- rendall 1y agoI understand. I have been there myself. I found it very difficult to crawl out of that hole. It helped me to understand that since a series of decisions led me there, that a series of decisions could lead me out. It took some irrational risk that paid off in my case. Since you mention a family with children, modeling good health and socialization will help the children in your life too. Do try, if you can. No shame, if you sincerely cannot. Good luck.
- rendall 1y agoThis thread might be illuminating https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44913663 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44913663
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoOne thing about the author, is that she's a traveler (not a Gypsy, but someone that has traveled a lot; even as a kid). So am I. I spent the majority of my early childhood, bouncing around a number of nations. It has given me the "ability" to drop even very intimate relationships at the drop of a hat. I've heard that this is a characteristic of "military brats." I will not have talked to someone for a decade, then, when I see them again, I assume that we can just pick up where we left, and they are like "Who the hell are you? No way!". I've learned to correct for this. It means that I need to make the effort to stay in touch, but I have also learned that some folks aren't interested in reciprocating, so I have learned to let those go.
- SoftTalker 1y ago> Can anybody hear me? Do I matter? No, almost certainly not. This is difficult for many people to accept but once you do a lot of weight comes off your shoulders. You're no longer thinking about what you do in terms of how others perceive it, and not seeking approval or validation from them.
- axelpacheco 1y agoThere’s a lot of friends to whom I don’t talk much now and never occurred to me that they might think we’re no longer friends. This article made me aware of that, not sure if I’ll do something about it though
- 9rx 1y ago> never occurred to me that they might think we’re no longer friends. Me neither and the whole idea seems inconceivable. Unless there was some kind of breakup, why would anyone think that periods of disconnect equals no longer being friends? > not sure if I’ll do something about it though Is there anything to do? If someone truly believes you are no longer friends then you are no longer friends. No need to beat a dead horse.
- TrackerFF 1y agoSome people become friends for life. At least for me, they were the people I became friends with during my formative years. From my teens and up until young adulthood. Looking back, we became friends due to shared interests (movies, books, music), hobbies, and just general chemistry. Other people, you become friends with due to some shared situation. School, work, place you live, the places you go/frequent, etc. Once that changes (you graduate, switch jobs, etc.), your friendship can change. And, of course, your other responsibilities will influence how much time you can use on people. Especially children can have a huge impact on that - kids just take up so much time, and combined with work and other things, it is really difficult to prioritize other things. It is not at all uncommon that once people get kids, they disappear for a solid 5-10 years, and will want to catch up again when things calm down. As young adults, most people have few responsibilities, and impulsivity is high. What I miss about being a young 20-something was how easy and willing everyone were to do stuff. Go on a hike, go watch a movie, go on a pub crawl? Sure, just give me 15 minutes. Book a trip to some other country? Could do that just a couple of weeks ahead. These days you'll have to check your calendar 3 months in advance to just shoot the shit. I think the change started when me and my friends started nearing 30 / late 20s. That's when people were really bogged down with work, met their future spouse / partner, and started focusing on self-realization (working out, hobbies, side hustles, whatever), and of course - kids. Now that most of us are in our late 30s, things are a bit easier. Those that got kids have more spare time, as the kids have grown older. Seniority at work means they aren't giving it all for the sake of promotions. More financial freedom. Things more stable, and people can catch up again. With that said, some days I really do miss the days of youth.
- y-curious 1y agoThis is a common sentiment, that your friends during formative years are those that are lasting relationships. I remember hearing a theory that correlated with my learnings: friendships are made stronger by having intense experiences. As a kid, you are constantly learning and doing things for extended periods with friends. You have way more chances to do something new or reckless or whatever. Similarly, many veterans are friends for life with their brothers in arms because, well, they were doing crazy intense stuff together for years. As an adult, friendships are hard to grow for the same reason. Grabbing dinner with someone is not going to leave the same impression as, say, getting shot at. The adult friendships I have that are close I attribute to: 1. Friend's dad died shortly after we met, and we bonded throughout that time. 2. I went on an impromptu Vegas trip with friend 3. We went through grad school stress together 4. We spent a lot of time together at chess club. Nothing was intense, but frequently seeing this person solidified our relationship. Oh, he was teetering on divorce at one point, it could be that too.
- malshe 1y agoAs much as I hate Meta and its digital properties, I have to admit Whatsapp has been instrumental in keeping me in touch with my old friends. Now whenever I travel, I make it a point to let my friends in that city know about my trip and try to meet with at least some of them.
- elzbardico 1y agoThis. I could even say that whatsapp helps me a lot with my mental health by allowing me to talk to really distant friends almost every single day. It is my small village's piazza
- ranguna 1y agoImo it was better before meta bought it. Thanking meta doesn't feel right. But to each, their own.
- ericmcer 1y agoWhat is this article, she answers her own question in the first paragraph. "Since I moved to Kenya why am I not still friends with people who are now 10,000 miles and 12 hours behind me." Uhhh does that required 5,000 words to figure out?
- 202508042147 1y agoI stopped speaking with my high-school friends in my 40s. I had realized at some moment that I didn't enjoy most of the discussions that we were having. I still met them and talked to them, thinking that that's still "friendship". But I was wrong and I shouldn't have done it! Not for so long! Since I stopped talking to them, I feel very relieved.
- netsharc 1y agoThe article starts with: > On a warm July evening, I dove into bed and grabbed my phone, giddy and anxious. As I scrolled through TikTok, attempting to calm my nerves, a Google Calendar notification flashed on the screen: “VIDEO CALL WITH SIMONE.” > Before I could swipe the reminder away, Simone FaceTimed me. That makes me want to build a "Tinder" for rebooting relationships: select who of your friends you want to talk to, and after they do the same, the app will schedule a video call, and you'll be connected with... a mystery friend from your past! For people who don't like surprises, if both parties vote to reveal their names, you'll know who you're reconnecting with. Or if you don't get any matches, the app will connect you to a mental health/relationship councillor...
- shivekkhurana 1y agoI have friends across the world. I talk with 7 of them every quarter. We have scheduled video calls on our calendar. And after every call, we put notes on the call schedule. Before the call, we get notified and we confirm if both parties will be available over text message.
- pjerem 1y agoThat’s pretty cool, actually.
- schwartzworld 1y agoThey already built the app for rebooting relationships. A few times. A lot of the enthusiasm about web2.0 sites like MySpace and Facebook came from the ability to reconnect with people from your past. If they’d kept Facebook what it was in 2007 it would still be a useful tool.
- gwbas1c 1y agoYears ago, I met someone at a large company and they perused a friendship with me. I was always friendly, and I invited them to larger parties because I considered them part of my extended group of friends. But, they really struggled at life. I moved away, and I never made the effort to keep in touch. A few years ago they called me to talk. We caught up, and it was clear they still struggled at life. A few phone calls later, they got "stuck" on a topic and wouldn't converse, instead arguing with me when there was no argument to have. I ended the call, and I don't really want to hear from them again. (Basically, they were going off on their opinions about guns and not listening enough to me to know when I was agreeing and when my opinion differed.) It became clear why they struggle at life, and it's disappointing that they don't have the insight into why they struggle.
- calf 1y agoThen why is it clear that they struggle at life? Just because they have bad cognitive logical skills? I don't buy that argument.
- gwbas1c 1y agoI don't like to go into personal details, so I'll offer a high-level summary: They insist on living in a high-cost-of-living area, but can't hold the kind of job needed to live there. Moving to a lower-cost-of-living area where they can be employed isn't considered. They don't have insight into who makes a good romantic partner / spouse. (Think of the stereotype who imports a "Russian Bride.") They get into bar fights, in part because they will talk without listening to others' opinions. (And because they don't understand important differences between US culture and where they immigrated from.) --- I have a few people in my life who stop listening when they get agitated, so I personally have little patience for changing people. Trying to get these people to listen to reason is a fools' errand, so I no longer try and just end the conversation as quickly as possible.
- fragmede 1y agoSounds like they reached out to you because they remembered your kindness. Maybe they were hoping for a bit of grounding. You noticed something about why they struggle. Something they clearly don’t see. That insight, offered with care, might actually help them. It’s not your job to fix anyone, but since you’ve seen the pattern, you’re in a position to say something. You might be the only one who can break through.
- swaggyBoatswain 1y agoFriendships come and go over the years is something I have learned in my life. We dont always have the same value systems and because of that, its natural to drift apart and not talk as frequently as we used to This is something I am learning as a late bloomer in life, as I didnt have too many friends more so business acquaintances growing up The hardest lessons I hace learned though is during major life transitions - sometimes you are off on your own, you have to manage that transition yourself and cannot rely on anyone in particular through it Friendships require work but sometimes they arent on equal terms either, and when things shift away that created that strong bond to begin with, people drift apart. Thats something that is hard to cope with, that sense of loss in wanting that nostaglic connection again
- pjerem 1y agoIf that can help you, I learned that most "gone" friendships are not really dead and can be reactivated. I’ve talked back to a few friends I lost for years and it was hard because I’m actually pretty sensitive to rejection. To what should not be my surprise, not a single one rejected me and all of them where happy to be in contact again. And you can even re grow friendships. Actually one of my best friends today is someone I lost contact with for about a decade. This relation was so lost to me that I didn’t even bother to invite him to my marriage. And now we see each other every week since the last 5 years. That’s one case where I did the effort to build back the relation. But that was worth it and was way easier than a new friendship. It looks like if anything is universal it’s both that most people somehow miss their old friends and that most people are feeling more or less lonely.
- sinuhe69 1y agoI have friends where, when we text or call, no one mentions how long it’s been. We just continue as the most natural thing of the world. To me, that’s what real friendship looks like. You may not be in each other’s lives all the time, but deep down, you both know — if one of you ever truly needs the other, you’d be on the next flight without hesitation. That’s why it reminded me that time and distance don’t erase true connection.
- Janet085 1y ago[dead]