8 ms·
It is all almost making richer even more richer, instead of properly hiring people for HR, AI bots. Instead of having more people at the supermarket, have the
by pjmlp 1y ago
It is all almost making richer even more richer, instead of properly hiring people for HR, AI bots.
Instead of having more people at the supermarket, have the customers work as if they were employees, the only thing missing is fetching stuff from warehouse when missing on the shelves, but still pay the same or more.
Instead of paying to artists, do job ads using generated AI images with code magically showing off monitor's back.
Instead of paying translators, do video ads with automatic translations and nerve irritating voice tones.
Gotta watch out for those profits, except they forget people also need money to buy their goods.
- PicassoCTs 1y agoIm half expecting the appearance of virtual people any day. Basically cooperate sponsored UBI - but for bots, so they can buy virtual goods and services, finally decoupling the economy from the desert of the real.
- weikju 1y agoThat is sadly a likely outcome. An evolution of the companies forcing/encouraging employees to buy the company’s goods.
- askonomm 1y agoDoes that mean that Company Towns are coming back?
- grues-dinner 1y ago"Societies" (YC25) seems like a good first step! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44755654 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44755654
- linker3000 1y agoAt least one of my local, out of town, supermarkets doesn't have a warehouse any more. It's all Just in Time, with a residual amount above the main shelves. If you can't find what you want, they don't have it 'out back', because apart from an unloading area, there's no 'out back'.
- raincole 1y agoIt sounds... amazing? Less stockpile and spoilage. Less carbon footprint from transportation.
- lm28469 1y agoAmazing until covid hits and everything is out of stock at t+ 5 minutes. Every major city is like 24 hours away from MAJOR riots if anything serious happens to the supply chain.
- Majestic121 1y agoCOVID happened though, and shortages of commodities were extremely temporary, with no dire consequences overall. What was actually unavailable with dire consequences, like masks/etc... was not unavailable due to lean manufacturing, but simply because it was a new demand that did not exist at this scale before.
- lm28469 1y agocovid was nothing. Try a few bombs on the major highways and airport runways, now you have to deal with a war AND your entire capital starving. Millions of people will go from somewhat civilised to starvation mode real quick. All in all covid was a blip on the radar. There is a huge different between just in time and even a month of stock > What was actually unavailable with dire consequences, like masks/etc... was not unavailable due to lean manufacturing, but simply because it was a new demand that did not exist at this scale before. Well yeah that's what stocks are for. France had hundred millions of masks in stock in the early 2009 because they were expecting H1N1, we scraped the project because the pandemic didn't hit as bad as we thought, fast forward 10 years later and we spent twice as much to get half as many masks Wait until ww3, Europe will discover that having one week of ammunition stock is not enough... all of that is expensive so let's not plan anything and pray for the best case scenario
- HWR_14 1y agoJIT shipping doesn't necessarily mean less carbon footprint from transportation. A single large shipment is far more efficient than many small shipments.
- ekianjo 1y agoon one hand people complain about sweatshops but on the other hand when the repetitive, soul crushing, low paid job is replaced by technology people complain as well. you can't have it both ways.
- Eisenstein 1y agoWhen did sweat shops get automated?
- spauldo 1y agoI'm working on it, give me time.
- pjmlp 1y agoPeople forget that in some parts of the globe sweatshops are the only jobs people can get, where are they supposed to work instead? There is a middle ground, no need to treat people like slaves, nor throw them into the street without alternative source of income.
- pydry 1y agoThe people telling us that sweatshops are a necessary thing are the same people telling all of us that we will be replaced by a robot shortly. They're the same people that will proclaim that the sky will fall if you raise the retirement age due to a shortage of labor. Their stories are not consistent, and all they really care about is the value of their stock portfolio.
- lm28469 1y agoPeople would rather have a low pay repetitive job and be able to barely afford living rather than no job at all and being homeless Also the "people" of the beginning of your sentence aren't the same people as the "people" in the end of your sentence. People complain about min wage repetitive jobs but it still beats being homeless
- GuinansEyebrows 1y agowe don't want it either way.
- wolvesechoes 1y ago> except they forget people also need money to buy their goods. As implied by the sibling comment, the final stage is that they do not need people to buy anything. Dead internet theory is too narrow in its vision.
- aaron695 1y ago[dead]
- chii 1y ago> they forget people also need money to buy their goods. the goods ought to have become cheaper if the ai/mechanization/industrialization is cheaper than labour. And also when "the rich" have more profit, they now want to spend that profit on things, which spawns new luxury good industries. Of course, the news cycle and the sob stories always revolve around people losing their existing jobs, but there is new jobs around that previously didnt exist. Jobs that people previously never thought was even "a job". Of course, it is up to the individual to search and find their niche, and to produce value to sustain their own existence. The advent of AI is not going to be different.
- pjmlp 1y agoOne such kind of jobs have leaders like in those mythical Robin Hood stories. Those jobs certainly never go out of fashion, as seen in poorer world regions, where you as well say, people find new jobs all the time.
- mzhaase 1y agoThe trickle down effect you mention here is simply not present in the data. Instead, wealth inequality keeps going up.
- spwa4 1y agoYes it is. What you're conveniently forgetting is that governments and banks (which are kind-of government, except profits go to private hands) think this is a very, very, very, VERY good thing indeed. Why? Well, what is wealth inequality? It is people and companies (indirectly also people) not spending money. Just keeping it. "For the future". In bank accounts. On the stock market. In government bonds. Under their pillow. This also explains that a very large chunk of "the rich" is in practice people's pensions. This means that governments can create almost unlimited new money, without taxing anything, and know it'll be hoovered up by the wealthy. What happens in practice? Wealthy people and companies will provide goods and services to hoover up that money, but they won't want (any new) goods and services in return. In other words: it is a way for governments to acquire almost unlimited goods and services in return for ... nothing at all. A few updates to a database "to be paid in the future". And if you look at what governments spend money on, it's "everyone", the "public good", in other words: on the poor. In other words: this is a way for the poor to get more stuff now. You want to kill this effect? Expect every government employee, every pensioner, every unemployment benefit receiver, every sick or disabled person and so on to scream bloody murder, because you'll have to seriously cut a LOT of benefits. Or, frankly, if recent history is any indication, to actually just kill you with a 3d printed gun. Of course, because the government is still overspending, and debt servicing is becoming bigger and bigger. New debt is adding less and less spending power to government budgets. In some countries debt servicing is already bigger than the growth in debt (and not just Argentina and Pakistan). You can calculate: if Trump continues like this, the US will cross this critical threshold halfway through his term (assuming 5% interest rate). At that point the US government will lose the ability to trade government debt for goods and services. And last Trump term spending went up and up and up as his term progressed, and so far the same is happening this term. Had we elected a deceased possum instead of Trump, our country would have been fiscally better of than we are now. So you'll see the maga republicans join the democrats in shouting and screaming how evil banks and "the rich" are, in 3 years or less. What's scary is that due to Trump this moment is coming towards us a LOT faster than it was under Biden, despite, of course, Trump getting elected on the promise that he would make the opposite happen. But, as said before, a dead possum would have far outperformed Trump on the fiscal front.
- 9rx 1y ago> except they forget people also need money to buy their goods. Do they? Money is simply the accounting of debt. You do something for me, and when I can't immediately do something in return for you, you extend a loan to me so that I can make good on my side of the bargain later. If we record that I owe you something at some point in the future, we just created money! But if I don't need anything from you — because, say, magical AIs are already giving me everything I could ever hope and dream of — I have no reason to become indebted to you. Money only matters in a world where: You want/need people to do things for you, they won't do something for you without a favour returned in kind, and you cannot immediately return the favour.
- pjmlp 1y agoDirect trading kind of died out towards the end of middle age, are we supposed to go back in time?
- 9rx 1y agoNo, why? If people still want other people to do things for them, accounting isn't going anywhere. It has already been invented. We don't have to un-invent it. But, if this our future, then humans remain relevant, so there is no concern about job loss or anything of that nature. If, however, some future plays out where people aren't needed to work anymore, there will simply be no need for trade. The magical AIs, or whatever it is that someone has dreamt up that they think will eliminate the need to hire people, will provide instead. You only need people to buy things from you if you need to buy things from them as well.
- nikolayasdf123 1y ago> except they forget people also need money to buy their goods. this is why we having population collapse
- betaby 1y agoWe don't, fertility rate is 2.24 which is with curent medical advancement is above replacement rate.
- disqard 1y agoNot all countries are at 2.24 -- USA is at 1.62, so whether correlation or causation, many developed countries are nowhere near the replacement rate. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_fertility_rate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_f...
- betaby 1y ago> USA is at 1.62 And Afghanistan is at 4.66 > developed countries are nowhere near the replacement rate Doesn't matter because of the immigration. Population of developed countries is growing.
- preachermon 1y agoFortunately the US has solved the immigration problem
- immibis 1y agoIn places which don't have this structure.
- hansmayer 1y ago> the only thing missing is fetching stuff from warehouse Amateurs, IKEA solved that one decades ago ;) But that's Scandinavian practicality or whatever they use to sell themselves these days :)
- bdisl 1y agoWhen IKEA does it it’s good because IKEA is European.
- nothrabannosir 1y ago*because ikea is cheap. Crucial element in GPs complaint was lack of passing on savings to consumers.
- octo888 1y agoPre COVID, IKEA had a lot of decent value stuff (prices were low, relatively better built items too, relative to the other stock). There were also plenty of staff on the tills and on the shop floor to ask questions or get assistance. You genuinely felt they passed on the savings They also had decent online shopping. These days though they're just like everyone else and have cut cut cut and prices have risen. The restaurant has gone to crap too
- ajsnigrutin 1y ago> These days though they're just like everyone else and have cut cut cut and prices have risen. The restaurant has gone to crap too Aren't restaurants a totally local thing? They have vastly different offers eg in slovenia compared to italy (i visit both quite often), except for maybe hotdogs and cinnabuns... somehow the main ikea prices are different too.
- szszrk 1y agoKind of. I just compared US to PL. We have much more choices here in PL, and breakfast is completely different. Meals are mostly different, but have a lot of common ingredients ( like iconic beans and meat balls). Us has no soups at all, while we have 5 kinds. Cakes are similar, but again we have much more choices.
- EGreg 1y agoWell, people may need money to buy the goods, but soon the robots will do it instead. Problem solved!
- KingOfCoders 1y ago"but still pay the same or more." Yeah margins in groceries are great.
- betaby 1y ago> Yeah margins in groceries are great. On some definitely are. At least in Canada grocery stores can get better margins by not selling prunes which go from green to dry (or rotten) hile on shelf. Various fruits are sold at loos and I see why. At the same time I don't think kind-of AAA beef sold for $55-$110CAD has bad margins.
- KingOfCoders 1y agoEverything in groceries has bad margins. Grocery shops are not making the money, food conglomerates are making the money if you look at earnings.
- bad_haircut72 1y agoSmall grocery stores are going bankrupt, larger chains now all are becoming food conglomerates who also own the point of sale - so called "private label" is noted as a huge threat in the shareholder reports of traditionally large food companies - go to a whole foods, aside from a few high profile products like CocaCola its all in-house brand products
- KingOfCoders 1y agoWhat kind of margin are we talking? e.g. Walmart groceries? I can't imagine it being >5%
- Aurornis 1y agoFor those who don’t get the reference: Grocery stores have low margins. It’s the textbook example of a business that many assume is high margin and rolling in profits, but when you look at the numbers they have very poor profit margins.
- jstummbillig 1y agoCounterpoint: AI in its current form is democratizing and allowing exactly the not rich to be relatively more dangerous. So yeah, the rich might use it to get richer. But so can everyone* else.
- FirmwareBurner 1y ago>So yeah, the rich might use it to get richer. But so can everyone else. N'ah as long as the AIs the everyone else has access to are heavily censored and lobotomized to prevent wrong think, while governments and corporations will have access to the raw unbiased data.
- miltonlost 1y agoThe raw data will still be incredibly biased, and the AI will have its own biases on top of what's in the training. Grok will be racist no matter what.
- lm28469 1y ago> AI in its current form is democratizing and allowing exactly the not rich to be relatively more dangerous. Which part exactly ? The part where everyone pays 20+ a month to a few megacorps or the part where we willingly upload all our thoughts to a central server ?
- whynotminot 1y ago$20 a month for a nearly unlimited stream of high intelligence isn’t really undemocratic imo
- selfhoster11 1y agoTo call GPT-4o high intelligence, is aspirational (to put it more plainly: GPT-4o is such a bad model it's not worth paying for compared to what's out there). And yes, it is undemocratic - when was the last time you got a say over what the AI is allowed to do for you, let alone a say over any of the ideas for how to improve it?
- gruez 1y agoDoesn't this describe all automation, from elevator attendants to weavers?
- rvz 1y ago> It is all almost making richer even more richer, instead of properly hiring people for HR, AI bots. That is the real definition of "AGI" from the VCs shilling all of this rather than their bullshit utopian definition. > Gotta watch out for those profits, except they forget people also need money to buy their goods. They (companies) do not care. And that's why lots of bunkers for the executives are being built in anticipation of any civil unrest.
- vonneumannstan 1y ago>Gotta watch out for those profits, except they forget people also need money to buy their goods. The end state for this system is the incredibly rich selling things to the other incredibly rich and ignoring everyone else.
- MrBrobot 1y agoThe self-checkout is the one that gets me. I'm paying you money for products, and you both continuously raise prices, and make it less convenient for me to shop there. That is, unless I want to order it for delivery online, and pay an extra fee. Every retailer doesn't need to be Amazon. I don't even want Amazon to be like Amazon anymore. Maybe this is me getting older, or me having worked in technology too long - but I'm growing tired of the hyper-fixation we have with optimizing every possible thing, at the loss of human interaction.
- 12_throw_away 1y agoSelf-checkout feels analogous to certain digital goods platforms - at certain times, it makes stealing/piracy the easier and more rational choice than paying for the product. They're both giving consumers great training in how and why to evade shitty corporate security tech!
- SoftTalker 1y agoI like self-checkout on balance. The stores have a lot more self-checkout stations than they had cashiers. Most of the time I'm buying less than a dozen or so items. The work of having to scan and bag them myself is hardly more than taking them out of the cart. It's way faster than waiting in a queue behind someone who's apparently buying groceries for two weeks for a family of 8 and then has several dozen coupons and finally is writing a check. Or waiting behind several such people. I guess if I were buying two weeks of groceries for a family of 8 I might prefer the cashier to scan them and the bag boy to bag them for me.
- hn_go_brrrrr 1y agoSelf checkout is just fine, except for UNEXPECTED ITEM IN THE BAGGING AREA.
- satyrun 1y agoIf you don't like the self-check out line then go to the register with the cashier. I always go to the self-check out because I can scan things faster myself.
- kjkjadksj 1y ago>Gotta watch out for those profits, except they forget people also need money to buy their goods. And then we get the great turn of it all. Where governments opt to just sign contracts with these companies. Just hook the money printer up directly to the investor class and skip all these middle class middle people and the requirement to build a business that can stand on its own two feet. What gets scary with this is people like Peter Thiel and friends are building a world for fewer people pretty overtly. There's the famous clip of him where Thiel hesitates to predict if humans will survive in the technological future. Probably because in the back of his mind he hopes the population of the U.S. diminishes to a couple hundred thousand people if that living a life of technologically supported luxury, while the descendants of the wageslaves have died out by then and don't threaten the power structure.