7 ms·
A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about economic growth (2022)
- jahnu 1y agoGiven recent news* does that mean light at night could be used to measure US economic growth this year? https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-fires-commissioner-of-labor-statistics-july-jobs-report-erika-mcentarfer/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-fires-commissioner-of-lab...
- whynotmaybe 1y agoYou can rely on a better source : https://institute.bankofamerica.com/economic-insights/consumer-checkpoint-july-2025.html https://institute.bankofamerica.com/economic-insights/consum...
- namuol 1y agoSure, but for how much longer before our private institutions succumb to the same intimidation tactics?
- UltraSane 1y agoThe Rich would stage a coup before losing access to accurate economic information
- heisenbit 1y agoThe rich would pay handsomely to tilt the playing field by locking up good information. There is profit in being an insider.
- tialaramex 1y agoThere is no sign that "the Rich" will even be smart enough to understand that you can't placate the orange buffoon over a meaningful period. They keep paying him other people's money and throwing their staff under the bus. I'm sure they'll be angry when he demands their money and chucks them under the bus but that's too late isn't it?
- potato3732842 1y agoYou think they weren't already juicing the numbers up or down based on whatever they or their business partners favored?
- Leary 1y agoDid it with https://sites.google.com/site/jiaxiongyao16/nighttime-lights-data https://sites.google.com/site/jiaxiongyao16/nighttime-lights... USA (2013-2023 CAGR: 2.3%) 2014: 6.2% 2015: -5.3% 2016: -1.8% 2017: 15.2% 2018: -4.9% 2019: 4.5% 2020: -5.4% 2021: 6.7% 2022: 14.5% 2023: -3.6% China (2013-2023 CAGR 7.9%) 2014: -1.7% 2015: -1.2% 2016: -5.1% 2017: 53.3% 2018: -1.0% 2019: 7.5% 2020: 6.5% 2021: 11.4% 2022: 4.2% 2023: 10.8%
- abdullahkhalids 1y agoIndividual yearly number are unlikely to be useful. Likely you can only predict long term trends with the help of fits.
- neuroelectron 1y agoWow, 2017 was a good year
- potato3732842 1y agoThat "feels about right" IMO
- golem14 1y agoWell, how does it compare with published numbers?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- msgodel 1y agoLight at night would overstate success for the incumbent US population actually. Since (contrary to popular belief) we're significantly less nationalistic than these other countries and have a much larger and more successful migrant population.
- bjackman 1y agoI think in a highly financialised free market like the US the executive is pretty powerless to really hide important economic data like this, even within their own country. There would be so much alpha in knowing stuff like the true employment rate that private agencies will be extremely well-funded to collect this data (in fact this probably already happens for some data, there might be alpha in having a second opinion even if you think the government data is trustworthy). I think the worst-case outcome would be that the mass populace doesn't have access to the info because it's paywalled. But to the extent that journalism continues to exist, journalists will know the employment rate, GDP, that kinda stuff.
- immibis 1y agoMoney is a proxy for power, but it doesn't have to be so. If you lose money but gain a cult following, is that positive or negative alpha?
- SlowTao 1y agoIt feels like it is something that could show broad long term accuracy over say a decade but short term the noise level would make it difficult to extract a signal. Even then I would guess there would be a lot of other leading signals than lighting that would also correlate.
- contingencies 1y agohttps://archive.md/8asa5 https://archive.md/8asa5 I spent a lot of time living in China. Nobody believes the government figures. But I'm also skeptical that using artificial light as a proxy for economic growth is rational, particularly when you realise that Chinese people overwhelmingly live in vertical high density buildings and the amount of light used when moving from last-gen 'heavy industry' to next-gen 'value add'/'light industry'/'design work'/whatever is going to be reduced. Therefore although I am a big fan of the Economist and like the idea, I think the premise of this particular study may be somewhat flawed. Where the article states "the mismatch between satellite and GDP data did not appear in dictatorships until they were too rich to receive some types of aid" I think what they may be discovering is "when people move in to dense modern housing and shift to white collar work the model breaks down". There are other factors too: more modern lighting is more efficient, people increasingly socialize through phones, and outdoor living spaces are reduced in relatively inhospitable climates, somewhat limiting light pollution. Thinking back to first principles, the majority of outdoor light pollution is probably from freeways and city centers, and if you proxy that with economic growth it's probably significant as a pre-emption at a certain phase of transition from agricultural/low-development-level economy through highly developed economy, but becomes irrelevant rapidly once those development prerequisites have been achieved. It doesn't help that this guy is trying to sell a book.
- netsharc 1y agoI remember reading about how regional Chinese governments measure economic growth, given that the numbers they have are doctored. One proxy was electricity usage.
- jasonfarnon 1y agoThat's actually mentioned in the article. The information came from a diplomatic cable. It's very damning, although as evidence it does come down to one (important) person's view.
- bobthepanda 1y agoLi Keqiang also made those comments over a decade ago at this point. The Chinese economy has changed a lot in that time.
- Leary 1y ago[flagged]
- metalman 1y agoI cant imagine that light is a good proxy for growth, unless there were very good baseline maps that have been properly calibrated for the significant changes in the types of lights used and how they are bieng used......"dictators" lying should be a simple presumption....... which historicaly was confirmed by basic spycraft, in that least sexy of industrial chemicals ,hydrochloric acid, is still a very good indicator of total industrial capacity as it is used for all primary industrial production, and is the most used chemical world wide, but is now bulk shipped, instead of bieng produced localy. Back to light as a proxy and an indicator, the flip side would be to restrict light, and hide industrial locations, as is common in war zones....so....back to spycraft 2025 as to China....they realy REALY are building out there electrical grid , road and rail networks, and no one can doubt that they are not producing massive amounts of everything, andwhile they have an incetive to exagerate there growth, there wester adverseraries have an incentive to lie about the same thing..... the basic truth is that the world is definitly heading towards manufacturing overcapacity for everything, but that this is perversly bieng treated as a bad thing.....
- almosthere 1y agoYeah more led lit greenhouses growing pot go up.
- more_corn 1y agoHow could they possibly lie? Don’t people just report the facts and then the facts show a bad jobs report and the labor economists who used to write the jobs report gets fired and replaced by a lying stooge and. Wait.
- WalterBright 1y agoUnder the Biden administration, the jobs reports were usually rosy, and then a few months later would be revised downwards. This suggests one of: 1. collecting jobs data is a fuzzy thing and guesses are made 2. reporting jobs data is subject to political influence
- heisenbit 1y agoNobody lies about the number st the end but also almost nobody understands the math behind it. The input are fuzzy numbers which later may be known more accurately (e.g. state data coming in later). They are weighted by historical importance that may drift. They may be computed indirectly from other statistics. and last but not least there seems also some tendency whether cultural or political to be optimistic. The size of the negative surprise this time is worrying raising the distinct possibility that the part of the model which is extrapolating from the past is insufficient and reality shifted a lot more.
- ggm 1y agohttps://archive.md/v5rGj https://archive.md/v5rGj
- kouru225 1y agoYes the “good hitler years” were a lie and so are all the “effective dictators” And the fact that no one just assumes that is weird. In general, let’s imagine you had a politician who took power of a country that was recovering, and then by the time they left power their country was a literal pile of rubble and they shot themselves and their family in the head in order to avoid the consequences of their own actions… you’d assume that any positive story about them is probably bullshit. But for some reason the moment it’s Hitler everyone’s got an excuse. And if someone accidentally killed 6 million of their own citizens we’d naturally all recognize them as one of the worst politicians in human history, but for some reason when they kill 6 million of their own citizens on purpose it’s not a raucous failure that deserves endless ridicule.
- msgodel 1y agoNot that Hitler is an example of one but there is actually a long history of good dictators. Remember the original dictatorships in Rome were time boxed (among other things) to overcome crises. England had a similar idea in the form of its protectorates. I don't like everything Cromwell did for example but he absolutely was a dictator in all but name.
- goopypoop 1y agoWhat things that Cromwell did do you like?
- _zagj 1y agoLee Kuan Yew (whom the late polymath and Berkshire vice chairman Charlie Munger greatly admired) and Park Chung Hee are two examples that quickly come to mind. I distrust technocrats and dislike dictators, but pretending every dictatorship has been a disaster for its people is short-sighted.
- golem14 1y agoDoes China today qualify as dictatorship? I think that’s an interesting question with probably no simple correct answer.
- SanjayMehta 1y agoWhile satellite data can’t be fudged, how are they determining which country is free and which is not? For example, one “free country” has been arresting people for Facebook posts, and praying silently outside clinics.
- SanjayMehta 1y agoDownvoted immediately, as expected. Can’t question western “democracies.”
- SanjayMehta 1y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44811564 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44811564
- SanjayMehta 1y agoMore on western democracies: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44856426 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44856426
- Nevermark 1y agoBy one set of measures [0]: US is country #57 (about 25th percentile, from the top) with a score of 84/100 for its general "Freedom of the World" score. And number #13 (roughly 7% percentile, from the top) with 76/100 for Internet freedom. [0] https://freedomhouse.org/country/scores https://freedomhouse.org/country/scores
- SanjayMehta 1y agoFreedom House is funded by the US govt, USAID and the OSF (Soros) et al, so pardon me for not having any faith in their data. Which comes back to my point: how do you really determine who is “free” and who is not. Looking at the state of the UK, Europe with people being arrested for social media posts, and the US with deportations for speeches, it appears to be a useless criteria.
- immibis 1y ago
- maxglute 1y agoThe frequency of Martinez Democracy vs Autocracy study reposts, especially in western MSM, borders the PRC collapse retardation news cycle. Nvm it got dismantled by various people who use nightlight metrics for living. NBER also did a sophisticated night lights study of PRC in 2017 - same year as OG Martinez study using naive methodology as Henderson original work from early 2010s - and found PRC's reported GDP was actually _underestimated_ using night light data. But useful idiots will gobble up authoritarian gov inflate narrative. For obvious reasons this study by multiple staff economists at the FED doesn't get any attention in western MSM, but one by an assistant prof of public policy somehow does. Also note scope, multiple staff economics focusing on PRC, versus assist prof who managed to collate data for every country. Almost as if it's good self marketing considering Martinez keeps updating study with same rudimentary methodology every few years to get clicks. E: I'm guessing this is now going to make rounds with the Shih/Elkobi's 1/3 of PRC local gov spending all their revenue on debt repayment wank graph being popularized recently that's comparably retarded.
- bcraven 1y agoFewer abbreviations would make this easier to read, understand, and perhaps take seriously.
- maxglute 1y agoWhat's there to elaborate. First version of Martinez study (when researcher was an assistant prof in public policy) has methodology criticized to death way back in 2017 by experts who specialize in satellite imagery, remote sensing etc. The same year NBER, National Bureau of Economic Research aka... one of the preeminent eco analysis think tanks US gov draws from had 3 credentialled staff economist ran a more sophisticated light study and alleged PRC (China) underreports economic activity. Yet every year since 2017 the Martinez study gets play in mainstream media (MSM) because autocracy incompetent vs democracy plays well. In 2022 Martinez updated the study (I think also 2019, 2024 i.e. milked forever), with same methodology issue said insisted trend continues. Cycle repeats usually synced to some other retarded reporting to PRC economy going to explode (will also be milked forever). In this case I'm assuming the chart making it's way around reddit and now socials on Shih/Elkobi study that inflate PRC subnational debt situation by conflating principle+interest (tldr bad methodology using non-standard metric to exaggerate debt risk), which like Martinez has been called out back in 2022 after publication. Customary in these discussions of unserious providence is bringing up the unserious Martinez study, which useful idiots continue to take seriously.
- safety1st 1y agoThe Economist is really tackling the hard topics here :)
- RagnarD 1y agoSuggest? The only surprise would be dictators actually telling the truth, at any time.
- rurban 1y agoCounter fact: In our city district, which is the richest and biggest district of our 600k developed city, we decided to turn off the street lights at night on purpose to help with sleeping better. There is no street criminality, people feel safe without street lights. Our city is the richest in our country, which is at the top 5 in the world
- Ballas 1y ago> Counter fact: In our city district, which is the richest and biggest district of our 600k developed city, we decided to turn off the street lights at night on purpose to help with sleeping better. To me that seems like a really alien solution. What about closing the curtains?
- rurban 1y agoI was in the prep-meeting for that decision. We don't like curtains. We don't like wasting energy. We don't like light pollution. We prefer peaceful nights
- seszett 1y agoTurning the lights on and closing the curtains to block it seems the really alien solution to me. If you don't want the lights, why not just turn them off? It's really common in many cities in France too, also in the countryside to reduce disruption for bats in particular.
- Ballas 1y agoWhere I'm from moonlight on it's own will disrupt my sleep frequently enough that even if my neighbor did not forget his back light on, I would still sleep with my blockout curtains closed. When it comes to driving, I would definitely prefer they keep the street lights on, for the increased visibility/safety.
- gsk22 1y agoA top "5 in the world" city is obviously an outlier. It seems self-evident that simply turning off street lights in the vast majority of cities will not cause them to become world-leading bastions of calm and safety.
- otabdeveloper4 1y ago[flagged]
- cybervaz 1y agoplain, vulgar and simple: - everybody and their mama knows that they lie not only about economy but also about all other indicators too. - honestly I don't think that using city lights to demonstrate economic growth might be a little flawed. Especially when people start living in vertical residential complexes.