4 ms·
I go out and do different activities that involve socialization. There are more people than ever going to the climbing gyms, meeting at the hiking trailhead, ha
by Aurornis 1y ago
I go out and do different activities that involve socialization. There are more people than ever going to the climbing gyms, meeting at the hiking trailhead, hanging out in the ski lift lines, and so on. All of the social places I’ve been going and activities I’ve been doing since a teenager are more crowded than ever, at a rate far faster than the local population growth.
Many of the people doing these activities discovers them online or met others to do it online.
I don’t buy the claim that everything social and in-person is in decline.
Though I could see how easy it would be to believe that for someone who gets caught in the internet bubble. You’re not seeing the people out and about if you’re always at home yourself.
- garciasn 1y agoDepends on where you live. Areas that have a culture of outdoor activity and strangers talking to one another is a requirement. Here in MN, for example, outdoor activity does exist year round but strangers talking to one another is not.
- vitaflo 1y agoGo to WI, you'll have both in abundance.
- abeppu 1y agoYou're basically saying that people who aren't social mistakenly view the rest of the world as not social because of their specific experience, but doesn't that effect also cut the other way? You're seeing people being social because you're going to those situations. But there are time use surveys etc which provide a quantitative view of a lot of people. Because they're voluntary, they can't be a perfect representative sample of the overall population. But I think the broad, systematic view is still the best view we have of the overall trend. Also note that the scale and pace of the trend is slow enough that any individual _can't_ really provide an anecdotal view of it, because their own life is in a different place. E.g. one source [1]: > Atalay reports that, between 2003 and 2019, people spent an increasing amount of time alone. Over this 16-year period, the portion of free time people spent alone increased, on average, from 43.5 percent to 48.7 percent, representing an increase of over 5 percentage points. Any given individual's time-use would probably change over 16 years regardless of what the population-level trends were just because that duration might also be the difference between e.g. being in school vs being married with young children or from being a busy professional to being a retiree. [1] https://www.philadelphiafed.org/the-economy/macroeconomics/how-time-spent-alone-in-the-us-has-changed-over-the-past-two-decades-and-implications-for-well-being https://www.philadelphiafed.org/the-economy/macroeconomics/h...
- Aurornis 1y ago> You're seeing people being social because you're going to those situations. No, I’m saying the same social activities are more popular now than they were 10-20 years ago. I’ve been doing some of the same activities and going on some of the same hikes, bikes, runs, trails, and parks on and off for two decades. The popularity of these activities has exploded. Even previously hidden trails and hikes are now very busy on Saturdays and Sundays because so many people are discovering them via social media. If you’re just staying home and consuming doomerism news you’d think everyone else was doing the same. > Over this 16-year period, the portion of free time people spent alone increased, on average, from 43.5 percent to 48.7 percent, representing an increase of over 5 percentage points. That’s hardly equivalent to the claim above of a collapse of socialization.
- zhivota 1y agoWhat you're missing is that the activities you're doing were not the activities people were largely doing 10-20 years ago to be social. Going to bars was probably at least 100x more popular than hiking, so even if you see a 10x growth in hiking, if going to bars goes down even 10%, it dwarfs hiking's contribution to overall social activity of the population.
- Aurornis 1y agoWe have more bars than ever before. Existing bars have expanded a lot. Bars are crowded and some even have lines now.
- esseph 1y agoThis is very unique to the locale you are at, and the economic conditions of that area. I am in a "top 20" US city and all of these things are in extreme decline.
- Aurornis 1y agoI don’t which city you’re in where everything is in “extreme decline” but that’s not my experience traveling for work or to visit friends either. I think it’s more likely that your experience is the unique one. Or you’re not experiencing the activities you’re not attending.
- godot 1y agoOne thing that not enough people realize is that the gap between haves and have-nots widen in almost everything when technology advances, and I don't mean just wealth (that is one too), but also knowledge (LLM/AI widens knowledge gap between the curious and not-curious by a lot), and in this case socialization -- the availability of technology (in both organizing activities like your example and in AI loneliness like the article) widens the socialize and not-socialize people. In the old days, not-socialize people tend to be forced to socialize anyway; but techonology enables them to not-socialize 99% of time now. Likewise, socialize people needed to put in more effort to socialize in the old days, but now it's easier than ever. When more people realize this, the discourse should shift from "technology creates this trend" to "technology widens the gap between X and not-X".
- Aurornis 1y ago> In the old days, not-socialize people tend to be forced to socialize anyway; but techonology enables them to not-socialize 99% of time now. Likewise, socialize people needed to put in more effort to socialize in the old days, but now it's easier than ever. This is my favorite point from the whole thread. It has never been easier for someone to stay home, get a remote job, and even order grocery delivery to their door if they want. A couple of my friends started going down that path unintentionally. Once you have a well paying remote job and your city makes it easy to get groceries and food delivered, combined with the infinite availability of entertainment on Netflix or from games, social skills and relationships can start to atrophy rapidly. It’s even worse for people who never had much of a social life. When there are so many paths forward to continue avoiding a social life, it takes a lot of effort to break free and change your routines.
- socalgal2 1y ago> I don’t buy the claim that everything social and in-person is in decline. I'm pretty confident this is a well measured fact. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9811250/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9811250/
- s1artibartfast 1y agokeyword everything
- luckydata 1y agoThe crowd you see is because options are dwindling faster than people willing to use them.