6 ms·
Atlassian terminates 150 staff
- gnabgib 1y agoSmall discussion (5 points, 2 days ago, 10 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44740709 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44740709
- andrewstuart2 1y agoIt's a pretty impersonal way to announce layoffs but I think they all tend to be impersonal. I do think the 6 months of pay says a lot more than the fact that they used a video.
- SoftTalker 1y agoYeah the severance is nice but the execution is lame. If you don't have the balls to tell an employee to his or her face that they don't have a job anymore, you shouldn't be a manager or executive. Maybe it's a very distributed team, I guess then there's isn't a great way to do that.
- geodel 1y ago> If you don't have the balls to tell an employee to his or her face that they don't... This is just bullshit. Managers don't have to do any such thing as it may become unnecessarily confrontational. Similarly lot of people resign via email. There is no need to have "guts" to tell manager in their face.
- chrisco255 1y agoI mean, if you want to burn a bridge you can do so. Sometimes it's warranted. However, if you have a good relationship with your manager then it's absolutely ideal to tell it to their face (or with a 1 on 1 call). It's not about guts it's about mutual respect. Likewise for layoffs.
- geodel 1y agoRight. If situation allows doing face to face is nice. But thing as they are lately doing via canned message or email is perfectly fine and one need not think any less of manager or employee just based on their communication method.
- ilc 1y agoYou can do both. You should ALWAYS write a formal resignation letter that's about 3 lines at most, before talking to the manager. It just stops a ton of confusion, hope, etc. It allows that discussion to focus on "Do you want the two weeks?" and "What do you want me to do with those two weeks if you want them." Part of being a good employee is making things clear to your manager.
- mingus88 1y ago150 people is huge. The logistics of doing this in person just don’t make sense. Are you going to send out hundreds of calendar invites spread across weeks for the sole purpose of being nice to people? Are affected employees expected to queue up to get their personal “you’re fired” before their access is cut?
- rdoherty 1y agoI worked at Yahoo in 2008 when they laid off thousands and yes every single person got a calendar invite and met in a meeting room 1:1 with a manager. It was difficult but they did it. Times definitely have changed.
- xp84 1y agoWow, just the logistics of that is impressive. I feel like I would watch a 60-minute documentary on pulling that together because it no doubt took dozens or hundreds of people weeks of logistics to do that, and unlike almost any other major project, literally no one involved was happy about any part of it.
- resize2996 1y agoDoing unhappy work at Yahoo probably wasn't unusual in 2008
- xmprt 1y agoDid the people who got a calendar invite know that they were getting laid off in advance?
- Macha 1y agoI worked at Yahoo some years later and the process was the same when I was there. Yes, people generally put two and two together when there was a calendar invite with their manager and HR. We were in a European office though, so layoffs aren't American-style "escorted from the office with immediate effect".
- dennis_jeeves2 1y ago> If you don't have the balls to tell an employee to his or her face that they don't have a job anymore, you shouldn't be a manager or executive. What if your balls get ripped off? Just saying...
- neilv 1y ago> Maybe it's a very distributed team, I guess then there's isn't a great way to do that. If you want to do it all at once, for all time zones... If there's overlapping "core hours" for different time zones, or you can schedule an all-hands videoconf time, you can do it then. Or do one for the global West, and one for the global East (which will have different cultural nuances anyway, and possibly separate management structures). It's not that different than in-office. Except, for in-office, remaining colleagues see a person boxing up their stuff and walking out with their stuff in a box, or (worse) security escorting the people off the property. And then there's usually the desk of a terminate colleague there as a visual reminder for awhile. One in-office layoff I saw, they arranged for all the people to be laid off to have impromptu meetings with their managers, and to go to conference rooms, at the same time... and then notified everyone still at their desks to go to an all-(remaining)-hands meeting, in a different office space, where they were told of the layoffs. Most of the axed people were already gone when the others returned. It might have been good intentions, but I'm not sure that was a good move. It's a tricky problem, whether in-office or remote. Partly because the situation isn't right. ICs are more often let go because management failed, rather than any fault of the ICs.
- SoftTalker 1y agoI was part of one mass layoff. They had two meetings at our site, one for the people being retained and one for the people being let go. We had an idea what was happening but you didn't know until your meeting started which group you were in. It was done in person though not via a video message.
- xp84 1y ago> the situation isn't right. ICs are more often let go because management failed, rather than any fault of the ICs. That is pretty much guaranteed to happen though, unless you have a system where the assumption is employment for life at all costs. Management's job is to make decisions, many decisions won't work out, and for some of those, the consequences mean some change in what roles are going to be needed. Sometimes it's a management success that means a certain role isn't needed too ("we successfully rolled out software to book business trips, so we don't need 17 travel bookers anymore"). And anyway, let's stipulate that managers should also be punished by being sacked for any big mistake: That wouldn't save ICs, since if you're, say, pivoting away from making furniture, you still don't need the furniture makers, even if you sack the "VP of Furniture" or the CEO. And it'd be stupid to appoint a new VP of Furniture over and over to keep trying to 'make furniture happen' just to save the jobs.
- jfengel 1y agoDoing that for 150 people is a pretty long, ugly day, while everybody waited for their turn. You could gather everybody in the same room, and announce it there, but that's still not really face-to-face. Delegating it to their direct managers is even worse. They're generally not the ones who made the decision. Even if they were the ones who submitted a list of their people they could live without, it was the higher-ups who approved the layoff en masse. There's just not a great way to give bad news. A video sucks, but it attracts attention only because it's different from the other sucky ways people do it.
- themadturk 1y agoI worked for Weyerhaeuser, a major US forest products firm in the Seattle area during the early 2000s. In 2009 they decided to get out of the forestry products business and become nothing more than a land owner. Multiple thousands of workers were let go. At least at the company headquarters, managers met with every worker to tell them whether they'd been laid off or not. The announcement came in the summer, a couple of months before the actual lay-off date, and salary and benefits were extended until year end. It was by far the most humane layoff I'd ever experienced.
- belter 1y agoWhat about if they upgrade it to 12 months, and a fire by SMS ?
- ozgrakkurt 1y agoPretty sure vast majority of people would prefer that
- Hammershaft 1y agoIf a company is bigger than Dunbar's Number I would absolutely take that trade as a prospective employee! I think firing by SMS also serves the noble purpose of illustrating to prospective employees that these are purely transactional relationships and that, no, this isn't a family, the exec's heart will not bleed.
- notahacker 1y agoMake it 24 months and most people will be happy being fired with a robocalled "fuck you"...
- pmkary 1y agoI actually have seen a very random company who fired its employees by SMS in the middle of the night... And not a single penny of severance packaging. They only got their last payment and that was it. It's a shame I forgot the company name to have them face some shame here...
- WesolyKubeczek 1y agoI think it still sucks but at least it’s not made to look personal but not really. When you were sorting your damn spreadsheet where I ranked at the bottom, you cared zilch; you could give my cognitive abilities some credit by not pretending you suddenly got infected with empathy or something.
- xp84 1y agoI realize that it sucks to be laid off. But business really is just business and it has nothing to do with how much any person values you. You would rightfully stop working immediately if your company can't pay you even for a week. They stop employing you if it no longer makes economic sense. It's the same thing in the reverse. I could be told tomorrow to lay off some or all of the people who report to me if we can't afford to pay them. I'd hate it, I'd cry and feel sick and not be able to sleep all night wishing I could avoid it. I know that from experience. Nobody wants that and even CEOs feel like shit when they implement layoffs. The alternative to having the 2-sided at-will employment system would need to be a two-way commitment, which seems far worse. Would you want to work under a system where everyone was expected to honor a 3-year employment contract, and to renew it like a New York apartment lease? So that you can't accept a new higher-paying job because you're committed to your company for 2 more years? And if you quit your job "early" you could be sued or be ruled as unemployable by future employers? I don't see how there is much practical room between "anyone can terminate the relationship at any time and it's not personal" and "2-way long-term commitment and neither party can."
- WesolyKubeczek 1y agoYeah, I was just musing on some companies trying to make "dear John" talks when laying people off. I prefer to work where I might be dehumanized, but with everybody being honest about it. > The alternative to having the 2-sided at-will employment system would need to be a two-way commitment, which seems far worse. You probably just haven't tried it, or have little knowledge of how it works in practice, because your example is way radical. Learn about the actual conditions under which it works over here in Europe (you don't get locked in to a duration of employment, the notice period in Poland, for example, may be up to 3 months if you worked at one place for three years or more — to give time for knowledge transfer).
- Hammershaft 1y agoYeah I'm personally against the spectacle of empathy theater for layoffs at companies that long outgrew Dunbar's Number. The actual quality of severance packages and the dignity / professionalism of the process should be more central to how the public responds to these layoffs.
- Seattle3503 1y agoWhen I was laid off I was cutoff from all my colleagues because my Slack was cut. In fact everything was cut in the middle of my standup and I just dropped out of my Zoom call. I think you can be big and still grant dignity and closure to folks.
- throwawaylaptop 1y agoI know it probably sucks personally, but you gotta admit that's straight out of a comedy movie.
- AlexandrB 1y agoDoesn't a pre-recorded video speak to dignity (or lack thereof)?
- duskwuff 1y agoAny announcement of a mass layoff is going to be a one-way conversation regardless of how it's conveyed. (A 150+ person conference call with the participants unmuted would inevitably be a fiasco.) Making it available to employees as a prerecorded video does at least mean that it's likely to be better rehearsed, and that the recipients can listen to it at their own pace, e.g. by pausing to take notes.
- RowanH 1y agoIn New Zealand we have an absolutely shit employment law process where the company has to 'propose' a restructure (in a formal fashion). Then 'consult' with employees for feedback. Then 'consider' the feedback. And then 99% of the time it's all just the same and people get made redundant. It is absolutely brutal as it invites the chance of hope during the downsizing - and implies staff will be able to provide alternative suggestions. Which is quite plainly bananas. It's enshrined in law and if you don't follow the process as an employer you can get taken to task by the governing body around it. It's just far easier, and less harmful emotionally, to rip the band aid and provide a good package.
- brk 1y agoAt this point a firing or layoff might as well just be a text message: "You're fired. K, thx, bye". Any words beyond that are just fluff anyway. To the person getting let go, it really doesn't matter if the decision caused the CEO to get ulcers, or if it was the easiest decision ever. Executive teams only take responsibility in words.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Someone1234 1y agoI understand your point, but employees do need to know a lot of important information that cannot be communicated like that e.g. health/dental benefit lapse, severance, references, etc. It is actually really important in mass layoffs to have this information immediately to hand.
- drozycki 1y agoWhy bother with a text? Just lock them out of their accounts. They'll figure it out. The termination ritual is for the people that stay and who the company may wish to hire in the future.
- abyssin 1y agoIs this sarcasm?
- gosub100 1y agoaccording to this, a 2024 tesla layoff just locked people out the building: https://futurism.com/the-byte/tesla-staff-locked-out-layoffs https://futurism.com/the-byte/tesla-staff-locked-out-layoffs
- hn_throwaway_99 1y agoThank you. I always get frustrated whenever there are layoffs that everyone pounces on "but they didn't say exactly the right things, in exactly the right way, exactly how I expected!" Layoffs suck, period. Like the good advice goes when starting a new relationship "Just ignore everything they say, and only focus on what they do." A generous severance package is loads more important than nitpicking the format of the layoff announcement. Plus, Atlassian famously has a global, distributed team that embraced remote work. Someone somewhere is getting the recorded clip regardless.
- ReptileMan 1y ago>"but they didn't say exactly the right things, in exactly the right way, exactly how I expected!" There is no right way to lay off someone. Only different shades of bad.
- tonyhart7 1y agoYep, only worse and less worse just make it fast and not painful at least
- armada651 1y agoThere are right ways and wrong ways to lay off someone. They aren't determined by words, but by actions. If the company has a healthy cashflow it can afford to give the employees that have been laid off a larger runway in terms of how many months of salary they will still pay out. If you've given them stock options, you can give them more time to decide whether to exercise the vested option. I'd gladly take a "Good riddance" with 6 months of salary and 2 years validity of my options over a "We regret that it has come to this point" with just a one-month notice.
- AtlanticThird 1y agoI agree with the theme of your message, but it's actually very challenging legally to change an options expiration date after its issued, and likely has negative tax implications
- jackmottatx 1y ago[dead]
- gchamonlive 1y agoMy last layoff was a lot more impersonal and they still called me. I had expressed a couple of months before my desire to leave. They then called me to say it was "a hard decision but it was best for the company to let me go". I almost laughed. How hard is it really to let someone go that wants to go? Worse than using a pre-recorded video is doing a live meeting with a default script. These corpocrats are like robots.
- nomel 1y ago> These corpocrats are like robots. I'm from the US, so employment here is at will. There were layoffs at every company that I worked for, and are entirely expect by anyone what has worked a while, when the economy turns down a bit. Out of them all, the "red envelope on your desk" was the best approach, in my opinion. It let people have a moment to themselves to react to and accept something that they were, at that point, unable to change. Then, the manager would have one-on-one with everyone, to explain the packages. In my opinion, I wouldn't want a manager to tell me. It would be awkward and unnecessary, since it's usually entirely out of their control.
- burnt-resistor 1y agoMeta did/does layoffs by email (rather than internal messaging because it disconnects access to everything) and makes everyone in the company WfH that day. Devices get FedEx'ed back. Zero communication other than "Sorry, not sorry" impersonal boilerplate.
- blitzar 1y agoStay classy Atlassian
- geodel 1y agoYou have issues, you open JIRA ticket.
- fHr 1y agoNow thats the spirit!
- flappyeagle 1y agoIf I got laid off I would want it in an email. I’m losing my job no matter what might as well have it in writing and no bullshit
- sokoloff 1y agoPretty much this. I have a great relationship with my boss. If the time comes where he needs to let me go, I need 2 words from him [which could be in email] and then the only things I care about that day are the details of the severance. No disrespect given nor received, but this is all business at that point. Some other day, we can work out any transition plan we need to work through and I'll happily hang out with him socially afterwards, but the things I need from the company at that moment are the severance details, nothing else. Emailed attachments are perfect.
- blitzar 1y agoIf I got laid off (by Alassian) I would want it in the form of a JIRA ticket assigned to me.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- renewiltord 1y ago1% layoff, 6 months severance. There, saved you the trouble.
- herval 1y agohonestly this is the least cruel layoff I've seen in recent years. At least someone went through the trouble of recording a video (instead of dismissing people with a chatgpt-generated email) and it includes a 6-month payout...
- froggertoaster 1y ago6 months severance speaks volumes more about this layoff than the video does.
- kulahan 1y agoInteresting how this is downvoted when the top comment is essentially saying the same thing.
- nsksl 1y agoHow exactly should they be terminated? 150 1:1 meetings?
- belter 1y agoI suggest a coding challenge, and the first five to submit it and pass the functional tests can stay?
- jesol 1y agoYes.
- fkyoureadthedoc 1y agoNot only should my boss behave like he's putting down the family dog, I should be able to face my VP in single combat with my weapon of choice.
- tuesdaynight 1y agoI know your comment is going to be deleted because HN is not the place for these kind of comment, but you made me laugh loudly, so thank you.
- amlib 1y agoBest we can do is a 20 frag limit quake 3 deathmatch duel in q3dm17
- BeFlatXIII 1y ago
- flappyeagle 1y ago1% layoff why does this even matter. They have more than that in natural attrition in a quarter
- MBCook 1y agoI suspect it’s more about how they gave the announcement than the size of the layoff itself. Plus general AI hate, and they’re obviously blaming this on not needing people because of AI.
- dpedu 1y agoI don't see what AI has to do with the layoff story. The first mention of AI is "The company has also embedded AI in its customer contact form" and it appears the author decided to include this for no apparent reason. The article also has a footnote stating "Updated to remove claims of AI replacing jobs." so I suppose there was probably a stronger - but still invented by the author - claim included that has since been removed.
- MBCook 1y agoThe original version appeared to claim that they were doing it because AI made the people unnecessary, or at least they might think so.
- criemen 1y agoPresumably because the layoff is targeted at a specific (set of) teams in customer service, rather than a 1% haircut across the company?
- fkyoureadthedoc 1y ago6 months severance is very good compared to my last company who gave people a week per year of service when they had layoffs. They did have the direct manager personally deliver the news, but I'd take a slap across the face from the CEO for that 6 months if I was looking at a couple weeks.
- andoando 1y agoGive me 6 months severance and I'd be unhappy if I didn't get laid off.
- deanmoriarty 1y agoSeriously, someone laying me off right now with 6 months severance could be one of the best things that ever happened to me.
- halfmatthalfcat 1y agoIn the past I got laid off with 6mo severance and it was legitimately one of the best things to ever happen to me - hated the job and paid off all my credit cards. Found another job in a month.
- bgnn 1y agoIf it is about the European office as the article mentions, specifically the Netherlands office, 6 months severance is quite low as the layoff is due to an arbitrary reason (moving to AI) instead of a necessary reason (financial difficulties). I would sue them if it was me, get minimum a year pay as severance.
- justsomehnguy 1y agoA couple of questions: a) why a year? why a 6 months is not enough? b) if this was a burger joint and people were replaced with a robots would you require a year too?
- tartoran 1y ago> employees they would have to wait 15 minutes for an email about their employment. Those who were terminated had their laptops blocked immediately. So you get an email explaining you were made redundant and halfway through reading that your laptop locks itself out?
- dmoy 1y agoPresumably it was sent to both corporate and personal email addresses?
- deathanatos 1y agoI have yet, in my entire career, to work for an employer that was at all disciplined about sending email that needs to address me, in the capacity of my employment, to the right email address. They almost all default to internal. When I was involved in a mass layoff, all of the emails went to an email that was going to be cut off.
- MBCook 1y agoI took it as they said you’d get an email in 15 minutes but immediately (before then) locked your computer so you wouldn’t be able to read it anyway. Telling people “wait to see if you’re fired” is absolutely cruel. Hold a virtual meeting, even if it’s just to play a video, and hit send on all those emails the instant it’s over. What a horrible thing to do to people. Can’t even do it yourself? Gotta pre-record it?
- genidoi 1y ago> is absolutely cruel. > What a horrible thing They offered 6 months severance which dispels any serious notion of 'cruelty'. Substance over form.
- superb_dev 1y agoSure I stabbed you, but I gave you a million dollars!
- tiffanyh 1y agoGenuinely curious: for remote based company with large numbers of employees - what is the best way to handle this? Note: you typically want it to all happen on the same day, which makes it impractical for someone in HR to call 150 separate people. Note2: I’m not saying I agree with how this was handled. Just curious.
- evrimoztamur 1y agoSoon we shall see headlines of AI HR personnel being deployed to appropriately 'therapise the employees and mentor them for future opportunities' and HR companies which coordinate them for you. The second extreme that follows is one where we do away with HR and operate on a perfectly managed gig market where you will be hired and fired automatically!
- al_borland 1y agoWhy would being remote mater? If a typical on-site situation would involve HR and your manager bringing you into an office to tell you, I'd assume a remote situation would be the same, just over a video call instead of having to walk down to an office. It shouldn't really take any more time.
- gopher_space 1y agoTell your employees as soon as the idea pops into your head, and make sure they know there'll be something in it for them if they stick around until then. A layoff in nine months gives people time to plan. Sort of a moot point though. Laying off spooled-up knowledge workers is probably the stupidest thing you could do if you're creating software and not investment opportunities.
- ardit33 1y agoWell, at least it is a video. Meta had its layoffs with emails when they did all those rounds in 22-23 and 24. You got an email if you were safe, and another if you were terminated plus some links to some portal etc. Plus, there was some video/zoom call for some I think. Anyways... modern corp culture, don't expect too much from larger companies. Once a company grows beyond a certain limit, it becomes impersonal as it has to.
- kazinator 1y agoEvery problem I ever had with an Atlassian product turned out to be related to an unimplemented 5+ year old feature request. A simple chatbot could pass along that information.
- betaby 1y ago“Every person should be using AI daily for as many things as they can.” and not Atlassian products , but that part didn't make it to the final cut.
- xp84 1y agoIn case anyone was wondering, the "CSS Team" described in the video's title is Customer Service & Support, rather than Cascading Style Sheets. My personal hope based on their products' performance would be that they hire some people who know how to make performant code, but that's clearly never going to happen.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- nwmcsween 1y agoSadly the time when an org wanted people to excel and really grow at is over, the new normal is peak capitalism of maximizing value. People develop relationships with coworkers, you care if someone has issues, you're happy if a solution makes customers/coworkers happy but none of that matters to the lawnmower, it just mows lawns.
- giancarlostoro 1y agoSo let me get this straight, they emailed what? 12,000 employees, and told them they would be fired or not in about 15 minutes? Please tell me they didn't email 12,000 employees this ticking time bomb of a revelation. If I were at Atlassian and survived the lay offs I would be sprucing up my resume. There's no good way to lay off people, but this is even worse.
- sokoloff 1y agoAt a consulting company I worked at, we were told on Wednesday that layoffs affecting around 1/3 of the company would happen on Thursday and Friday and that the company was paying for an all-company event at a nearby pub-restaurant where the execs and senior managers did not attend, but most of the company did. Much emotion, team reminiscing, and a fair amount of drinking happened and it was an interesting but honestly pretty decent way to handle it I thought. I was largely indifferent to whether I was in the 2/3 or 1/3 and ended up quitting on my own a couple months later.
- Animats 1y agoHave we had the first layoff announced by an AI yet?
- xcke 1y agoI think the layoff sucks, but there are proper ways to communicate it, and this was not the right way. The proper process is for the manager to carry out this sensitive procedure—quickly, but with empathy. (I'm not a manager, but I'm sure it's easy to be a "Happiness Manager"; the coin has two sides.) Even if individual meetings weren't possible, they could have just held a 150-to-1 live session. Saying the exact same thing as the video would have been different. Why? Because it wouldn't be a pre-recorded video. For those who are willing to accept an employer sending a goodbye SMS, I have to wonder how much commitment you really had to that workplace. If you had none, fine, who cares. But if your commitment was more than just a transactional job, like someone selling groceries from 8:00 to 17:00, I don't think you'd want to work for a company that follows such processes.
- MortyWaves 1y agoThere’s something oddly fitting about the company that forced the Jira monopoly on so many companies also being cruel and cold with prerecorded firing videos.
- jasonephraim 1y agoThe people being laid off didn't get told by a video. The video was sent to the general staff and informed everyone that those who were being let go would get an email direct to them shortly after. So, they announced the layoffs with a pre-recorded video versus a company-wide meeting - or - as is more common in my experience: No warning or explanation beforehand.
- nielsbot 1y ago"Why Nintendo's Satoru Iwata refuses to lay off staff" > "If we reduce the number of employees for better short-term financial results, employee morale will decrease," he said. "I sincerely doubt employees who fear that they may be laid off will be able to develop software titles that could impress people around the world." https://www.polygon.com/2013/7/5/4496512/why-nintendos-satoru-iwata-refuses-to-lay-off-staff/ https://www.polygon.com/2013/7/5/4496512/why-nintendos-sator... Just something to think about. I get that every company is different.
- hakfoo 1y agoThis is Atlassian. The only way their software impresses people is with how bad it is.
- cr125rider 1y agoYou don’t choose atlassian, you end up on atlassian. Just like M365.
- s5300 1y ago[dead]
- cbsmith 1y agoIs there a good way to lay off 150 people?
- stego-tech 1y agoYet another tech company sacrifices perfectly useful labor while earning $1.1bn in profit last quarter rather than retraining or reallocating that labor elsewhere within the organization and reducing recruitment costs - costs which will surely be higher, now that they've joined their counterparts in shoving their reputation into a rusty woodchipper. Unnecessary actions that squander scarce resources (trust, labor that understands the enterprise and its customers) in the name of vague platitudes about AI and shareholder returns. Almost like none of these people actually know how to manage an organization for any length of time longer than a fiscal year.
- heybales 1y agoThis is good news for customers though. I'm sure those savings will be passed on, right? Right?
- jlarocco 1y agoLOL! Passed on to the AI company is more like it. Because their software never gets tired of giving you the run around, while actual people do.
- sour-taste 1y agoBest of luck to all employees. I almost accepted an offer there but decided to go elsewhere. The remote work was very appealing.
- kyleee 1y agoI wish they’d lay off Jira
- dvfjsdhgfv 1y ago> “Every person should be using AI daily for as many things as they can.” This is getting even more ridiculous than I had previously expected.
- thealistra 1y agoCouldn’t they add a ChatGPT like bot that would answer questions about confluence or jira content as first AI feature instead of adding unhelpful chatbots for customer support