6 ms·
Unemployment rising in remote-friendly occupations (2024)
- marcosdumay 1y agoWait, it's lower but increasing faster? All of that text and the data looks exactly like a reversal to the mean. And not even a strong one.
- AtlasBarfed 1y agoAlthough I have no direct knowledge of the implementation of these policies People need to keep in mind that return to office is going to steadily be a more and more orwellian affair. Monitoring of internet was always kind of standard at this point of course, and attempts to track users remotely for attention and activity were already partially in the works. But one thing that was nice about having your home is that they can't put cameras and those types of things outside of an approved device. You have no such assurances in office in office. They can monitor you every second of the day and now they have AI that they can apply to those data streams. Governments of course desperately want these capabilities and will fund them to no end so that they can apply a AI agents to the fire hose of monitoring information that governments have at their disposal. Corporations will be happy to pilot these in the environments that they have greater totalitarian control of over compared to "the public". Combined with the massive unprecedented labor bargaining hammer that AI gives them, acceptance of this by the United States and Democratic workforces is inevitable. And with that, it'll pave the way towards total societal monitoring and control.
- ryandrake 1y ago> But one thing that was nice about having your home is that they can't put cameras and those types of things outside of an approved device. Don't give them any more ideas...
- no_wizard 1y agoWhile some of this is murky because the ZIRP period ending also coincides with the RTO movement, I think this bit is interesting: I think its interesting that its driven more by RTO policies than it is driven by say, offshoring of jobs, which is the downside risk of full remote companies[0], instead its by the desire for control[1]. One thing RTO should make plain for everyone is executives and their managers value control over substance. Productivity did not decline with the rise of remote work[2], to quote the BLS study >Looking at a more aggregate level to measure the impact of remote work on economic performance across 43 private sector industries, Fernald et al. (2024) find little relationship between labor productivity and the ability of workers in an industry to work entirely remotely, suggesting remote work neither hindered nor helped raise aggregate productivity growth [0]: Said in a different way: when a company becomes efficient at employees being remote, there's less barrier of entry for them to hire workers in different countries. [1]: Companies seem to be using return to office as a two pronged thing: a silent layoff, that is, shrinking headcount that doesn't get replaced but done in a way where they're counting on natural attrition (IE people quitting) and a way for them to take back more control, which ultimately is the point, no matter what the headline reasoning is. [2]: https://www.bls.gov/opub/btn/volume-13/remote-work-productivity.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/btn/volume-13/remote-work-productiv...
- yojo 1y agoRe [1]: it’s much better than a layoff (for the business), in that you don’t pay any severance, have 0 exposure to wrongful termination lawsuits, and don’t get the “you just fired my friends/will you fire me next?” culture of insecurity.
- no_wizard 1y agoExcept nearly everyone seems to be in on the game at this point. My observation is that RTO mandates tank morale similarly to how layoffs do. I'd be interested to see studies on morale before and after RTO. Not to mention the challenges it induces on retaining good talent.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoI have an acquaintance who was forced to RTO (finance), and they’re both looking for a new remote job on company time and sabotaging [1] [2] internally (not illegally mind you) by doing as little as possible to keep the job until they bounce. Don’t blame them in the slightest. [1] https://www.cia.gov/stories/story/the-art-of-simple-sabotage/ https://www.cia.gov/stories/story/the-art-of-simple-sabotage... [2] https://www.cia.gov/static/5c875f3ec660e092cf893f60b4a288df/SimpleSabotage.pdf https://www.cia.gov/static/5c875f3ec660e092cf893f60b4a288df/...
- keeda 1y agoYou should look into the work of Nick Bloom, an Economics prof at Standford (active on various social media platforms) who has been researching remote work for quite a while: https://economics.stanford.edu/people/nicholas-bloom https://economics.stanford.edu/people/nicholas-bloom While I can't recall a study on your precise question about morale, he did share a lot of findings strongly supporting hybrid and remote work, including lower attrition.
- ajmurmann 1y agoThe BIG downside to the business is that you have little to no control over who you'll lose. I'd even go a step further and argue that you are more likely to lose the most competent employee since they have more options. I suspect, however, that the people enacting these policies are unable to see that dynamic and equate eagerness to come to an office with seriousness and commitment to the business.
- hn_throwaway_99 1y agoI was always surprised that the "remote work boosters" rarely considered the double-edged sword they were rooting for. If your job can be done remotely, why pay you American-level salaries if the job can be done just as well with LatAm or European-level salaries? I've worked with fantastic engineers from Argentina, Poland, Ukraine, etc. and since everyone is on Zoom anyway, them being remote makes no difference (this was not the case prior to about 2015 or so, when video conferencing got good enough), and they all adapt to US time zones. I've seen lots of CEOs announce layoffs and plug how AI is making them so much more efficient, but I think the reality, besides previous over-hiring in general, is that it's much easier to find and utilize high quality offshore talent. I know some managers at Google who say they have drastically reduced junior engineer hiring in the US (and obviously they had layoffs at Google), while still hiring in lower cost countries. Be careful what you wish for.
- rawgabbit 1y ago> "I've worked with fantastic engineers from Argentina, Poland, Ukraine, etc. and since everyone is on Zoom anyway, them being remote makes no difference". If so, why do companies constantly demand increases to the H1B quota? Why do you need to bring developers into the US as H1B and all we're doing is Zoom meetings anyways?
- monster_truck 1y agoCharitably, because the developers they wish to hire want to be in the US. Uncharitably, because it's an excellent form of leverage and control
- esseph 1y agoLeverage. If they get fired they get shipped right back to their home country. They can abuse the hell out of them, make them work exceptionally long hours or under insane pressure and demands, and absolutely get away with it because the employee has extremely little recourse. They can't complain.
- zeroCalories 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- phony-account 1y agoThe company I work for expanded enormously from 2021 onwards, aiming to recruit the absolute best talent available regardless of location. None of this was ‘offshoring’ - we just cast a broad net over Europe and genuinely hauled in the highest level of programmers, designers and managers I have ever worked with in over thirty years in the software development business. In 2024 a new CEO decided to encourage RTO and from then onwards the level of recruitment has just tanked. The only criterion for employment is pretty much “how enthusiastic are you about working at the office?” Now we have compulsory office-days and I see firsthand the way these people just waste time walking around with a coffee-cup shooting the breeze, or sitting in half-day meetings. No-one seems to care or notice.
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y agoUnless you own the company, pretty much all anyone cares about is doing the least amount of work possible and getting promoted and making more money. I don't think anyone should be terribly surprised that you work with a lot of people that would rather shoot the breeze than get things done.
- jgilias 1y agoHis point was that they exchanged hiring people who are not like that because of the good deal they got to people who are like that because the deal they got is not as good comparatively.
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y agoAnd my point is, the people who are making those decisions are just bubbling it down from the top, and they don't care if it's a good decision or not, just that they're going to look good for following orders. If everyone's doing nothing, and their boss is happy, then they're happy, too, because maybe they'll get promoted and a better raise and a better bonus. If everyone's getting a lot done, and their boss isn't happy, then they're not happy either, because they probably won't get the raise and the bonus and the promotion that they wanted. They don't care about the business. At all. Obviously some people do. But that's not the norm.
- stego-tech 1y agoOffice work is increasingly just adult daycare much of the time. Even in manufacturing I'm seeing more folks killing time in rest areas or meeting rooms because the work is getting done faster (but they're not going to say so and get laid off for doing a good job), and a demand for acting/performative rituals ensnares higher performers in these practices to maintain the guise of "work" for out-of-touch managers and leadership still nostalgic for ye olde days of men in suits and casual harassment in the workplace. Honestly, I'd much rather we drop the whole pretense of appearances and fixed schedules in favor of shorter, flexible work weeks with a handful of fixed appearances (generally meetings/standups/lunches) to ensure folks stay on the same page. For all their crowing about technology changing how we work, they're staunchly opposed to actually letting that happen and mandating the same fixed structures we've had since being an Industrial Powerhouse in the early 1900s. The workers want to modernize. It's leadership that's the problem.
- nyarlathotep_ 1y ago> Office work is increasingly just adult daycare much of the time. And the 'metrics' for productivity are completely gamed, in any direction, at any time arbitrarily. Management/those that set these policies can 'turn up the heat' or relax them at any time, without warning. I've been on both sides of this. Sure, you can hit some metric if some real product is produced, like widgets or something, but even in that hypothetical example, what if someone is top producer but skimps on quality or something resulting in a shorter lifespan of the product? Before I left a recent employer a very (statistically and materially; i.e he was both very good at 'playing the game' and actually doing, you know, skilled work) high performer was PIPd (for "low performance"). In the previous half-decade+ he was there, he got 'exceeds' and top rankings every single year and was presumably paid more than the managers but was forced out, likely due to pay and internal politics. I take most measures of 'productivity' to be totally fake, just based on my experience.
- stego-tech 1y ago> I take most measures of 'productivity' to be totally fake, just based on my experience. Same. Having worked everywhere from tiny storefronts all the way up to the SV Big Leagues, "productivity" and "performance" as a measure is complete bullshit. The only measure that matters at the end of the day is corporate profit, and so long as the company is earning more than it spends while compensating workers to thrive in their communities, then any other measure of human capital is irrelevant. Instituting KPIs for human capital only leads to the most toxic people thriving in an organization, because they have no compunction gaming the system for their own ends. Remove the KPIs and force management to deal with interpersonal conflicts and skill gaps again, and suddenly your org will start dropping bad people and retaining good workers. EDIT: Adding that, especially in technical fields, KPIs will miss substantial improvements 100% of the time because they only measure what the business wants to measure. No KPI can accurately track replacing a six-month timeline for bespoke OS images with a 15 minute Packer pipeline, and most managers can't or won't recognize the outsized impact of such a contribution. Worse yet, organizations overly dependent on measuring human capital via KPIs will penalize such an efficiency gain, because it harms those gaming the KPIs for their own ends. Stop measuring human capital with KPIs is the lesson, here. Evaluating performance is literally why you have managers.
- Animats 1y agoNeeds a 2025 update, now that AI is better.
- spicyusername 1y agoStill, stretched-thin HR teams say it’s the only way to handle thousands of applicants. Then you don't get to handle thousands, you get to handle whatever you can handle. We all have a responsibility to not participate in degrading the human experience, and part of everyone's job is to say no when they are being asked to do things like this.