4 ms·
You haven't actually worked this example out. Try it. The wealthy buy the extra supply; they now compete with all the existing supply for tenants. What happens
by tptacek 1y ago
You haven't actually worked this example out. Try it. The wealthy buy the extra supply; they now compete with all the existing supply for tenants. What happens next?
- nielsbot 1y agoDepends on how many tenants there are: is is a buyers' or sellers' market?
- tptacek 1y agoWhether it's a buyer or seller's market depends on supply!
- nielsbot 1y agoIf the wealthy buy up existing limited housing supply and there are many tenants looking for housing, then they can continue to raise rents, no?
- tptacek 1y agoThe premise here is investors that just continually buy up all the supply, even as supply continues to increase, in the hopes that some day housing, the single largest asset class in the United States, will reach the limit of all possible supply? You don't feel like this is "spherical cow" calculating? The amount of investor-owned housing in most metro markets is a rounding error, and the amount of vacant investor-owned housing is smaller than that. The logic you're using here depends on deliberate vacancy; as soon as you concede that investors let out properties, you force them to compete in the market for housing with all the other supply.
- Avicebron 1y agoYeah except it almost always gravitates to a cartel, almost always, because that is how people work, even when piloting corporate machines. I'm speculating here, but I'm guessing you haven't been month to month rent in a while.. EDIT: you seemed to have tried to redirect the question to this "always buy up more land as an appreciating asset", when both can be true. "Buying that land is an appreciating asset (we haven't made much more I'm aware)" and that "forming an asymmetrical power relationship with the renters improves owners life" are mutually beneficial activities
- wredcoll 1y agoI'm trying to track this argument through this thread but I feel like something has gotten lost here, is there someone arguing against increasing the housing supply? Like, did someone upthread say something like "no, I think we should not build more houses"? Or is the argument that merely building more houses isn't sufficient? (Also presumably you could build an infinite amount of houses, but the land itself is somewhat of a fixed supply...)
- stale2002 1y ago> is there someone arguing against increasing the housing supply? Yes. The central thesis of the blog post is that increasing the housing supply solves the housing price issues. And other people in this thread are going: "Uhh, well actually, have you considered that this is the fault of wealthy investors, and/or collusion or something"? Anything to distract from the extremely simply and obvious idea that building more housing causes prices to fall.
- ch4s3 1y agoHousing returns have constantly lagged behind equities in the US. In the long run it’s almost always preferable to hold stocks as most of your investments in the US.
- Schiendelman 1y agoAgain, that means the answer is to stop limiting how much housing is built.
- baby_souffle 1y agoIf - hypothetically - I had a ton of money and buying another house or two or fifteen wasn't a big deal, wouldn't there be a clear-ish signal that I should stop my demand for more housing lest too much supply screw with my income? I would also have an incentive to deploy some of my resources/capital to making sure that the supply of housing is juuuuuuust right for my extractive needs.
- pixl97 1y agoThats what I'm trying to figure out myself, which bank is going to give out loans on a depreciating asset. Funding will dry up as supply increases.
- Ekaros 1y agoIt is all fine as long as repayments on principal are faster than depreciation. Might mean larger down payments or shorter durations. As long as you can reasonably expect collateral to stay above principal math does work out in my mind. Car loans have been a thing. And they attach to depreciating asset.
- elevaet 1y agoTheir point is that an increased housing supply should shift it to a buyer's market - it's not just how many tenants there are but how many housing units vs how many tennants.
- simpaticoder 1y ago>What happens next? We'd revert to the state that applied for most of human history: 99% of humans will be serfs renting from 1% hereditary landlords. We'll have shown the American mid-century home-owning middle-class phenomena to be an historical anomoly. Average living standards will plummet and equity barons will never have lived so well. Any short-term rental rate drops will quickly be erased by a combination of growing population and well-known market manipulation, in particular further wealth consolidation. Mere millionaires think they are safe; they are not. We live in a world that has a ~10 OOM wealth scale; being at level 7 does very little to protect you from 8s 9s and 10s, just as 2s are powerless to 4s and above. To a 10 a 7 may as well be a New Dehli beggar.
- tptacek 1y agoI was thinking more along the lines of a simple math problem and less along the lines of an outline for a dystopian novel. Like, show the work.
- simpaticoder 1y agoIf capital returns 5% and the economy grows at 1%, where does the extra wealth come from? Spoiler: it's a transfer from the poorest to the wealthiest. Asset classes include stocks, bonds, real-estate, art, and metals. So if artists make more art, will this make art ownership more accessible to the average person? Or will it be a small transient soon erased by the monumental financial forces pulling all assets into the ownership and control of a tiny few? That art that your grandparents bought for $500 is now work $100k; you have student debt and high rent, so of course you sell it. The house your parents bought for $18k is worth $1M and they need end-of-life care, and you're own kids are expensive, so of course you sell it. The movement is irrestable.
- bgwalter 1y agoThey leave it empty (that actually happens a lot, especially with foreign investors) or convert it to their 100th AirBnB.
- ch4s3 1y agoEmpty properties barely exist as a percentage of total housing supply in high cost of living areas in the US. You’re looking at no more than a few tenths of of a percentage point of NYC’s more than 4 million units.
- quodlibetor 1y ago> a few tenths of a percentage point of NYC Feb 2024 (last year there's data, I think) was a record low and it was 1.4% empty, according to NYC[1]. But I don't really know the methodology, and according to other nyc gov data it's surprising, since we still haven't recovered our population from COVID[2]. The first statistic (housing pressure) is based on population growth, but the NYC population statistics suggest still meaningful population loss since 2020. I have seen articles in the past that suggest that apartment vacancy rates in NYC are self-reported and misleading at best, but I don't really understand how that would work and I can't find any sources on that now. It's also my understanding that some classes of landlords can mark empty apartments as income losses, basically or partially making up for the loss of revenue in tax rebates. But that's also not something I understand well, just something I have seen asserted. [1]: https://www.nyc.gov/site/hpd/news/007-24/new-york-city-s-vacancy-rate-reaches-historic-low-1-4-percent-demanding-urgent-action-new#/0 https://www.nyc.gov/site/hpd/news/007-24/new-york-city-s-vac... [2]: https://s-media.nyc.gov/agencies/dcp/assets/files/pdf/data-tools/population/population-estimates/new-york-city-population-estimates-and-trends_may-2025.pdf https://s-media.nyc.gov/agencies/dcp/assets/files/pdf/data-t...
- tptacek 1y ago1.4% vacancy in a housing market is extraordinarily low. Remember: there is structurally always some material amount of vacancy, because people vacate housing units well before new people move into them. This, by the way, is a stat whose interpretation you can just look up. Real estate people use it as a benchmark.
- arrosenberg 1y agoThe total housing supply remains static - the number of owners goes down and the tenants increase, so the S/D curve for housing stays the same. Then the wealthy consolidate the supply into smaller, more powerful groups who drive up rents via monopolist and cartel behavior (eg RealPage).
- tptacek 1y agoIt costs money to hold on to a unit of housing. Supply is increasing (that's the premise; nobody is proposing a one-time increase in supply). How does the investor profit?
- arrosenberg 1y agoIf a small number of landlords continue to control the supply (which I understand to also be part of the premise) then they can charge whatever rate allows them to profit. Housing is pretty inelastic and is a first order priority for most people, so they will pay the maximum they can afford if they have to. At least near me, most of the housing being created is owned by large corporations like the Irvine Company, it’s not individual owned.
- tptacek 1y agoI'm asking: how does a small number of landlords continue to "control the supply" of an ever-increasing supply of housing when each of their holdings is non-remunerative (and, in fact, incurs tax and maintenance costs). This seems like a pretty simple math problem, a bet that you would not take if it was laid out in front of you, but I'm waiting for someone to explain how that might not be the case. Keep in mind: as soon as you concede that investor-owners are letting out properties, they are competing in the market: further supply of housing decreases their returns, because they compete with all other suppliers of housing, the high-order bit of which is existing owners. You have to make this math work with owners who deliberately keep their units vacant, or it doesn't even work as an idea.
- 1y ago
- gopher_space 1y agoCollusion using online management services to fix prices across a region. I think Washington State is working on legislation around rental services due to this already being a problem in the Seattle area. “Extra supply” is added to the portfolio containing housing they’ve already purchased. They own part of “existing supply” too.
- Schiendelman 1y agoI live in Seattle, and this is a scapegoat. it's another way to point a finger at anything but massive restrictions on supply. The easiest solution to collusion to keep prices high is to let lots of other people build and compete down price. In Washington, most new construction happens on a very small number of parcels, because that's the only place we allow it.
- gopher_space 1y agoNobody concerned about rent price fixing thinks that we don't also need to build more housing here. This is just another part of the problem. Are you defending the practice?
- Schiendelman 1y agoI think it simply doesn't matter. The only reason it could have any impact at all is in an incredibly constrained market. Unconstrain the market and they just won't be able to; it wouldn't work. Also - I don't think it actually affects prices. It's just that they've gotten good at seeking price equilibrium.
- bugglebeetle 1y ago“Yes” would’ve been a sufficient answer.
- crooked-v 1y agoAnd yet action gets taken about the rent price fixing, but not about actually encouraging more building.
- joe_the_user 1y agoYeah, Neither you nor the parent have worked the forces out to describe what's happening now. What's happening now is the wealth and the middle are buying houses and apartments not for rental income but for appreciation. This motive is what stands in the way of new home building in any given area. This is why rents rise beyond an area can sustain at all - rents are set to maintain the ostensible value of a property - selling an empty property is fine, even encouraged. The situation is visible everywhere.
- Schiendelman 1y agoThere's just no evidence to support this. Appreciation is nowhere near as cost-effective as putting that same money in the stock market.
- danans 1y agoA lot of the supply will become second or third homes for the affluent, or short term rentals, not residentially leased property. That's already the case with a lot of properties in highly desirable locales whether high demand cities or holiday destinations.