9 ms·
> Does everyone at Oxide have the same equity grant? I thought I saw this question answered in a previous thread and the answer was basically “no”, but the que
by Aurornis 1y ago
> Does everyone at Oxide have the same equity grant?
I thought I saw this question answered in a previous thread and the answer was basically “no”, but the question has been avoided a lot.
Aspects of equity compensation would inherently need to be different over time due to valuation, fundraising stage, and so on. However I always thought it was strange that they made a big deal about paying everyone the same base salary but then were silent on the equity comp strategy. Everyone knows that in a job like this the total comp is important.
The old Oxide compensation discussions were interesting. There was discussion about how they thought candidates asking about compensation to be something of a negative signal because they wanted people who weren’t in it for the money, basically. I heard this from a now ex-employee of Oxide who was describing how to navigate their hiring process, so take with a grain of salt.
EDIT: I checked their website again. The compensation link goes to a blog post ( https://oxide.computer/blog/compensation-as-a-reflection-of-values/ https://oxide.computer/blog/compensation-as-a-reflection-of-... ) which has this section about equity:
> Some will say that we should be talking about equity, not cash compensation. While it’s true that startup equity is important, it’s also true that startup equity doesn’t pay the orthodontist’s bill or get the basement repainted. We believe that every employee should have equity to give them a stake in the company’s future (and that an outsized return for investors should also be an outsized return for employees), but we also believe that the presence of equity can’t be used as an excuse for unsustainably low cash compensation. As for how equity is determined, it really deserves its own in-depth treatment, but in short, equity compensates for risk – and in a startup, risk reduces over time: the first employee takes much more risk than the hundredth.
Which doesn't answer the question.
- ethbr1 1y agoAnyone who doesn’t ask about compensation (at least at a later point in the interview process) would be a red flag to me. Most valuable people know they’re valuable, and do (and should!) negotiate compensation.
- ge96 1y agoself esteem problem ha (not asking or thinking low)
- Aurornis 1y agoRed flagging a candidate for not asking about compensation during the interview is not a good practice. This is an example of penalizing people for not following a specific script or candidate archetype you have in mind instead of judging them by their skills and abilities.
- steveklabnik 1y agoI am not sure I fully agree with the characterization above (that asking about salary is a 'red flag' in our process), but if I had to try and steelman it: we prominently put > Everyone at Oxide makes $207,264 USD, regardless of location. (Some sales positions have a lower base salary and contain a commission component.) On our applications page (see it here: https://oxide.computer/careers/sw-control-plane https://oxide.computer/careers/sw-control-plane) It's also a pretty well known aspect of the company. Combine this with the fact that our hiring process is different, where interviews are the very last thing before possibly being hired, and someone who has missed this fact could come across as having not done some very basic research about the company that they're applying to. To be clear, I still think calling it "a red flag" is a stretch. I fully agree with you in a general sense, for places that are willing to negotiate compensation in the first place, but we make it very clear up front that we do not.
- ghaff 1y agoFWIW, my last job I didn't negotiate. Company I really wanted to work for. Wanted to close the deal. So I didn't gum up the works with salary negotiation and it ended up being very good for me in a lot of ways.
- Aurornis 1y ago> (that asking about salary is a 'red flag' in our process) > To be clear, I still think calling it "a red flag" is a stretch. In my comment above I did not call it a "red flag". My specific wording was "somewhat of a negative signal". That seems consistent with what you said about judging someone for asking about a well-known aspect of the company because it signals they haven't done enough research. It also dodges the question that keeps getting asked: Does everyone receive the same equity compensation as well? As far as I can tell, that question is not answered on your website. Asking it seems like fair game.
- steveklabnik 1y ago> In my comment above I did not call it a "red flag". The person I was responding did, you are right that you did not. > It also dodges the question that keeps getting asked: This question gets asked in every thread about this, nobody is trying to dodge anything. The equity portion is variable, and the salary is identical. We do not do bonuses.
- mystraline 1y ago> There was discussion about how they thought candidates asking about compensation to be something of a negative signal because they wanted people who weren’t in it for the money, basically. I've heard this from multiple hiring managers and C levels. The cognitive dissonance is amazing. Do you know why I show up and work? Because I am paid for it, and in this country, medical is also gatekept by employment. If I wasn't paid, I wouldn't work for them. But somehow, I'm supposed to not care about money at the same time caring about money.
- diggan 1y ago> If I wasn't paid, I wouldn't work for them. That's great, but useful to know not everyone thinks the same. When I transitioned to software development (from basically random "whatever pays my rent" jobs), besides my first software job, they were all because I liked the particular product in some way or another, and what the compensation was is basically the least interesting thing for me. Of course, some level of base payment is needed, because I still needed to pay rent, but if I was choosing between two jobs where one was utterly boring but paid 3 times more than a fascinating job, I'd take the latter in a heartbeat. And no, I'm just an individual contributor who wants to like what I work with, not an executive, manager or similar.
- mystraline 1y agoThe hypothetical situation you set up is interesting, in that past a base amount of money to survive and thrive, that you would choose the more intellectually stimulating position. And I do get that. For me, if the hours were equal, I would choose the higher paying one. And then, I would create and make outside of work. And since I have that much higher wage, it could be a jump start on my own business. And, enough money can buy independenance in that you can get this flexibility of doing as you choose.
- diggan 1y ago> For me, if the hours were equal, I would choose the higher paying one. And then, I would create and make outside of work. And since I have that much higher wage, it could be a jump start on my own business. Yeah, I guess I've been lucky to be able to chose daily jobs in the past that basically gives me what you would create outside of work, except I got a fixed payment each month for doing something I really enjoyed. So I never had the need to do that stuff outside of work to derive enjoyment of most of my time, which I guess is my top priority and been most of my life.
- conjectures 1y ago> There was discussion about how they thought candidates asking about compensation to be something of a negative signal It's not an unusual way of thinking, but every time I see it, it seems bizarre to me. If the candidate was to propose any project once hired, I'm sure these folks would want them to think about costs and benefits. This policy selects either for people unable to reflect on their life with the same wit they apply to work; or people who will front about their motivations. Both seem like poor outcomes.
- tshaddox 1y ago> There was discussion about how they thought candidates asking about compensation to be something of a negative signal because they wanted people who weren’t in it for the money, basically. I think companies avoiding discussions about compensation is a negative signal, because they’re only in it for my labor.
- 999900000999 1y agoAt this point I've accepted most equity comp in a non public company is worth less than toilet paper. When it comes time to actually cash out or you notice some animals are more equal than others, the excuses start. The drama happens. No one knows what the equity is worth. If you try and advocate for yourself you'll be told the equity is actually worthless. From here the 200k salary seems fair. Just don't live in SF. Chicago , Philly, Pittsburgh, Cleveland, quite a few cities are perfectly livable on 200k. In fact, in any of the above metros you will be living nice.
- oooyay 1y ago> The old Oxide compensation discussions were interesting. There was discussion about how they thought candidates asking about compensation to be something of a negative signal because they wanted people who weren’t in it for the money, basically. I can't say anything of Oxide because I don't really know the people involved other than reading their writing. This is an attitude a lot of industry veterans have. Most of them were in software pre-2015 and have long made their money and paid their debts. They saw the haydays of job hopping, massive salaries, massive equity, and "rockstars" (that never were). The people I know that joined software post-2015 and onward are not in the same financial position.
- singron 1y ago"total comp" (salary+equity) is really hard to quantify for a private company. In order to qualify as ISOs, the stock options need to be priced at the Fair Market Value (FMV), which makes them essentially worth ~$0 on paper on the day they are granted. In order to value them differently, you need to guess if/how the company will increase in value in the future. If the gains were guaranteed, then that should be factored into the current FMV, so options always have significant uncertainty. This is unlike an RSU from a public company, where you can sell the value of your shares as they vest and add that to your income with minor risk of price volatility.
- timerol 1y ago> Does everyone at Oxide have the same equity grant? > equity compensates for risk – and in a startup, risk reduces over time: the first employee takes much more risk than the hundredth. I think that paragraph answers the question pretty clearly. As an Oxide employee you will get equity. It will generally be less than the people that came before you, but more than people that come after you. So it's obviously not the same as everyone else
- Aurornis 1y agoIt doesn’t answer it clearly at all. Do two people hired at the same time get the same equity? Or is there room for one candidate to get more equity due to their experience or simply because they negotiated more? Obviously early employees get more equity. The question is whether or not there’s room for negotiation. They heavily imply that everyone is paid the same, but all of those claims are about base salary.
- mrcwinn 1y agoExactly right. It doesn’t answer the question. It does some cartwheels to avoid to the reality: despite their philosophies and soap boxing on compensation, equity is a form of compensation and their equity is no doubt distributed very, very differently. It’s intellectually dishonest. I look forward though to their “in depth” follow up post.