9 ms·
When A Kickstarter Campaign Fails, Does Anyone Get Their Money Back?
- JulianK 14y agoThe article says "a year later, there are still no PopSockets." But the PopSockets Kick Starter page says it was launched Jan 8, 2012 and funded on Feb. 12, 2012. Am I crazy or was something not researched properly? That being said, I am personally surprised that most people are willing to fund many of the things that get funded and assume that people are treating it as a purchase rather than funding. It will be interesting to see how all the parties handle the first time something goes horribly wrong.
- cjbprime 14y agoIt was funded -- which means that the project owner received the money -- but the actual product wasn't created and delivered to the users who funded it. So, it failed. The NPR article is telling you that things are going horribly wrong sometimes, and PopSockets is an example of that.
- RandallBrown 14y agothey were saying that it's only been 7 months since it was funded. It's not a year later with no PopSockets.
- tene 14y agoThe point of pointing out the dates is to demonstrate that it has been less than a year, which contradicts the text of the article.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoHmmm, I'm guessing no and no. Which is to say that if it fails to reach its funding goal then there is 'money' transferred so you don't get back what you didn't pay out. And no, since there isn't any contract involved with a Kickstarter there is not compelling reason for the person who tried and failed to return any money. Besides if they really did try they probably spent all the money in the attempt anyway. As for Oouya, if you know anything about the tech buisiness this should tell you everything you need to know about this 'investment': "I visit Uhrman in San Francisco, where she's meeting with a dozen designers to hash out Ouya's boomerang-shaped controller."
- azakai 14y ago> no, since there isn't any contract involved with a Kickstarter there is not compelling reason for the person who tried and failed to return any money The article says > [Kickstarter]'s policy says creators have to give refunds on failed projects
- ChuckMcM 14y agoFrom their Terms of Use, their entire section on refunds: "Kickstarter does not offer refunds. A Project Creator is not required to grant a Backer’s request for a refund unless the Project Creator is unable or unwilling to fulfill the reward. Project Creators are required to fulfill all rewards of their successful fundraising campaigns or refund any Backer whose reward they do not or cannot fulfill." Except there are two problems with that, 1) These people don't have the funds to begin with, that is why they are running a Kickstarter campaign. 2) The actual contract language is that they "Backer" funds a "Project Creator" to attempt something rather than to deliver something. So when you go to sue the person who has your money you have to contend with the fact that they have no money (and insufficient assets probably to get a lien against, and if they do they will just do the personal bankruptcy thing) and then you have to convince a court (or a jury) that they didn't try in good faith to deliver the project. They will argue the Backers knew there was a risk when they started and that due to problems unforseen by the creators these risks actualized and there project failed to materialize. They will argue the Project Creator is just as harmed as the Backer. The only way you might get any money back is if you managed to prove fraud. Kickstarter has only been around for a short while, so we have time to watch this unfold. This is not 'new' (while Kickstarter is, crowd funding is not). I recommend you look up previous cases where the product wasn't delivered. There were a whole bunch in the 60's when a bunch of 'movie producers' were raising money to make movies. I took a cinema class at USC (it was a fun elective) where the professor claimed that a lot of the contract language that exists today for production companies came out of the lawsuits of that time.
- danso 14y agoWow, I'll be the first to admit that after reading lots about Kickstarter's business, and even funding a few projects myself, I still had no idea there was language that required refunds. Even if it is fuzzy language (a creator can claim to be "willing" to fulfill a reward...just as "the spirit is willing but the flesh is weak").
- jedberg 14y agoHere's the worst part -- as far as the IRS is concerned, that money is considered income and anything you don't spend in the same calendar year is considered profit and is taxed as such. So after a year, assuming you spend no money at all, you'd still be in the hole to pay back your backers. I personally only use Kickstarter to play "patron of the arts". I fund art projects with the assumption that I will get nothing in return. If I'm lucky, I get some nice art to enjoy (so far one of the projects has come to fruition, where I backed the recording and distribution of an a cappella album, and recently got my CD).
- _red 14y agoAgreed. Its too bad kickstarters just can't sell super-minority shares with a nominal face value. So if they are trying to raise 50K, just sell a 1% share of the company for $50K (so each share is a $1 say, and there are 5M shares). It would make the process much more enticing from the funding side, since you could feel you were perhaps getting in on the ground floor of something significant. There are other complexities that prevent this however, for instance SEC regs would certainly get in the way (only qualified investors, proper risk disclosure, etc etc).
- mistercow 14y ago>There are other complexities that prevent this however, for instance SEC regs would certainly get in the way (only qualified investors, proper risk disclosure, etc etc). Not to mention, as I understand it, there are some pretty strict rules about how you a company is allowed to solicit investments, and the Kickstarter format would be in violation of approximately all of them.
- _red 14y agoYep, its a minefield (of course like most things, these regs exist to protect special interest). I'm sure there is some bright attorney who could figure a way around it (ie. its an unsecured loan, that contains a very permissible default clause, which is potentially convertible to an equity share upon event a, b, c happening). Or more simply, just host the site in Hong Kong or somewhere and escape US jurisdiction. I know that none of this will never happen, just talking out loud....honestly, the first time I heard about Kickstarter, I thought this was the idea and I was excited. Then I discovered it was "act like a angel investor, fund my idea, and if 1000 things go right you will get a free tshirt". Meh.
- kijin 14y agoIf you invest in a company that has nothing more than a rough sketch of a product on their roadmap, and the company folds 6 months later with no actual product, do you get a refund for your worthless stock? Usually not. Investing is a risky business. Crowdsourced investing only distributes that risk over a much larger group of investors. An honest founder might do his best to return the remaining funds, and Kickstarter might even decree (as the article suggests) that a refund be made, but there's no guarantee that any funds will remain by the time the project is declared a failure. So the real question is: When you fund a project on Kickstarter, are you making an investment with a certain amount of risk associated with it, or are you simply pre-ordering a shiny new gadget? If any failed Kickstarter project actually went to court, this might be the single most important question to be raised.
- underwater 14y agoKickstarter projects are different from traditional investments because the absolute best case for consumers is that they get the product they were promised. If the project succeeds in a big way and spawns a successful company the project creators who reap 100% of the benefit. Whereas for investors failures are balanced out by the successes.
- sillysaurus 14y agoIf [a Kickstarter] project succeeds in a big way and spawns a successful company, it's the project creators who reap 100% of the benefit. I'm completely fine with that. Could it be any different? Maybe, but changing the Kickstarter equation may also have the consequence of killing the magic that makes it currently work.
- bigiain 14y agoThat's not totally true. I've personally reaped the benefit of knowing I've helped launch projects for people who might not have been able to accomplish it themselves. There's a bunch of music projects, a documentary, a short film, and an Arduino Shield that wouldn't have existed without my (and a bunch of likeminded people's) help. There's a few things that clearly _would_ have existed without my help (Amanda Palmers current project, for example), things that clearly didn't need my tiny bit of help, but that I feel good about being part of anyway. The hundred or two dollars that those Kickstarter projects cost me was worth every single cent, and would have been even if a few or even all of them had failed. At least we tried… And more power too all the project creators - I hope they all get corruption-inducingly-rich out of the things my $5 or $50 or $300 helps get started. Anybody who thinks "investing" to the tune of a couple of hundred bucks entitles them too, or even stands any chance of that resulting in a significant equity stake in something - probably hasn't thought that through very hard... big
- kennywinker 14y agoDon't like how Kickstarter basically lies: > So I call Kickstarter founder Yancey Strickler, and ask: What if Uhrman isn't able to deliver the consoles? Would Kickstarter get involved? > "You know, that would be new ground," he says. "I don't know. I mean, no, I don't think that we would. But certainly, the kind of thing you're talking about is not a bridge that has been crossed yet. Someday it will. And you know, I think if something did go awry, it would be — it wouldn't be my favorite day." And yet as far as I know there are a number of projects that have failed. Can't find any names via casual googling, but I remember last time Kickstarter came up on HN a few people were citing projects they had backed that had given up. I'm a PopSockets backer, and even though he still says he'll deliver, I have some serious doubts. Coupled with this: http://techcrunch.com/2012/07/16/allegation-kickstarter-is-still-hiding-data-about-failed-projects/ http://techcrunch.com/2012/07/16/allegation-kickstarter-is-s... I'm really starting to think Kickstarter, the company, is acting shady. Still believe in the idea of crowdfunding, but my trust in Kickstarter is waining hard. edit: here is the thread I was thinking of http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3473360 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3473360
- azakai 14y agoThat was definitely the shocking part of the story. Kickstarter seriously has no idea what it would do in the case of a project failing..? Even if it hasn't happened yet (and I don't believe that), they didn't think a little ahead?
- kennywinker 14y agoI feel like they are counting on projects to fail in protracted collapses, rather than a shocking sudden failure. I would rather they get much much more proactive about explaining to people what they are signing up for.
- danso 14y agoYeah, that's more than a little disturbing that either the founder is not above making an outright lie to national media or that he is completely out of the loop. If he had told the truth of Kickstarters terms, did he think that that would somehow hurt the comapny's fortunes? Perhaps the question was phrased in a more specific context? That is, the reporter actually asked something like: "What happens when a multi million dollar project fails and so many individuals are out hundreds of dollars?" it may be the case that no failure of that size has happened yet.
- nickm12 14y agoOne of my pet peeves about Kickstarter is that they considered funded projects successful projects and it's difficult to know what percentage of projects are actually successful in the sense that they delivered the goods (or even see a list of them). That said, I did just buy my first batch of Stack Soap, which was a Kickstarter-funded venture. nifty.
- shardling 14y agoIt really bothers you that they consider funded projects successfully funded? The goal of a kickstarter project is to raise money for the attempt. Once the money is raised, the kickstarter is successful. I think the site is pretty upfront about this. And any additional judgement is out of their hands. They could allow backers to fill out a survey after the tentative delivery date has passed, and that might be interesting to see. But it's hard to deal with the delays inevitable in any project.
- nickm12 14y agoIf they said "successfully funded" that would be accurate. My pet peeve is that everywhere on the site they say "successful" they mean "funded".
- shardling 14y agoIf you look at a project, it will say "Funded! This project successfully raised its funding goal on MMMM DD." And again, saying just 'successful' is accurate, because a kickstarter is a fundraiser for a project that has independent life outside of that website. Some projects that take money through kickstarter will fail, but some that fail to raise money will find other funding sources and succeed.
- vacri 14y agoFrom the few kickstarter projects I've seen, it seems that there's a lot of people who underestimate the costs of producing hardware and shipping it. I'm reminded of the story of the guy contracted to write an iOS game. The game itself was trivial to code and he had it up in no time. But then he had to add the menu overlay, high score system, save system, so on and so forth. It's the same with hardware - prototyping is expensive and takes a long time, and you have to think of a ton of corner cases before you make a sample item. Sometimes your plastics or metalworks subcontractor takes weeks or even months to return samples. And if you didn't get it right first time, rinse, repeat.
- michaelhoffman 14y agoFailing Kickstarter projects reminded me of a blog post by Matt Haughey: "Lessons for Kickstarter creators from the worst project I ever funded on Kickstarter" http://a.wholelottanothing.org/2012/01/lessons-for-kickstarter-creators-from-the-worst-project-i-ever-funded-on-kickstarter.html http://a.wholelottanothing.org/2012/01/lessons-for-kickstart...
- markmm 14y agoMy question is, why isn't Kickstarter International in terms of startups? I am based in the UK and we could do with a successful service like KS here!
- jiggy2011 14y agoI'm amazed this hasn't been exploited by an out-and-out scam yet, I guess kickstarter must have some serious vetting process. What's to stop somebody setting up a kickstarter for something highly desirable but somewhat impractical (but not totally out there) raising a few million $ and just riding off into the sunset?
- ohthanks 14y agohttp://www.kickstarter.com/projects/zioneyez/eyeztm-by-zioneyez-hd-video-recording-glasses-for/ http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/zioneyez/eyeztm-by-zione... seems like a pretty clear example of this. Backers are actually starting a separate forum to discuss legal action. Doesn't seem to be any sort of recourse via kickstarter.
- bigiain 14y agoI saw this via @textfiles on Twitter earlier today: Jason Scott @textfiles Probably a little weird to run a kickstarter http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1386333480/manhattan-lullaby-a-documentary-about-colony-recor http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1386333480/manhattan-lul... and then a 18 months later run an Indiegogo. http://www.indiegogo.com/manhattanlullaby http://www.indiegogo.com/manhattanlullaby Admittedly, the Kickstarter project which got him $8k in Jan 2011 claimed: "These next few months of production are crucial to get the film to the next stage of presenting to grantmakers and broadcasters", and the current Indigogo one is also saying "I am trying to raise 50,000 which will get me through 30 days of shooting and 8 weeks of editing with a full crew and basic expenses covered. I will have to raise more money to get this film finished but if I can raise 50,000 in the next 8 weeks I can at least be secure in the knowlege that we can all work as hard as we need to to finish shooting the film before the store closes and not have to constantly worry about the next credit card bill or not being able to book people because they already have paid work."
- rocky1138 14y agoTo be honest, I'm not sure why crowdsourcing and Kickstarter are so confusing to so many. If you put money into anything on Kickstarter and it fails, you have lost that money. It is a gamble. End of story.
- cdixon 14y agoIt turns out startups are risky.
- danso 14y agoOut of curiosity, has anyone here invested in a Kickstarter project that entailed physical goods that actually made its proposed deadline? Between the three I've paid for so far, all of them have been at least two months late of the deadlines they made after funding was successful. This includes the Elevation Dock, Kickstarter's first $1M+ project, which is shamefully late. I doubt mine will get to me before the iPhone 5 comes out, which is somewhat extra bitter to me since I just had my iPhone 4 stolen and am waiting for the 5 to come out...so I probably won't be using the Elevation Dock at all, if it ever actually comes.
- doug11235 14y agoI can't remember schedule exactly, but I feel like the Adonis Jot was on time. http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/531383637/jot-capacitive-touch-stylus http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/531383637/jot-capacitive... I've backed one other project. It is severely late.
- RyJones 14y agoOpenBeam was delivered on time. http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/ttstam/openbeam-an-open-source-miniature-construction-sys http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/ttstam/openbeam-an-open-...
- jseliger 14y agoI think this titanium pen: http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/mikebond/ti2-pen http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/mikebond/ti2-pen was delivered on time. I'm actually annoyed because I'd like one, but Kickstarter is already done, but a conventional online store hasn't been set up!
- replicatorblog 14y agoA board game called "Zombicide" published by a company called CoolMiniOrNot.com - They've run three successful KS campaigns so far and seem on track to deliver all of them on time. It also helps they've been in business for a decade or more giving them a comfort level with design, sourcing, shipping, etc.
- jcfiala 14y ago
- hk_kh 14y agoWhat I miss here is why some projects are not being honest on their pitch videos. It is not a problem with backers not understanding how funding works: If someone advertises their project as being finished, and is just asking money to get into the manufacturing phase, backers will expect that. The same way, if they show a nifty idea, explain that they do not even know how it will look like, but sell their team as someone that could eventually do it, backers will also know and accept failure as a possibility.
- danso 14y ago> During a break from the meetings, I ask her, "Would you have to give money back to your backers if you weren't able to deliver?" She takes a deep breath and pauses before answering. "Technically, from the Kickstarter perspective, I actually don't know the answer to that," she says. "But from a doing-the-right-thing perspective, we will treat our backers the best possible way." Um, what? She doesn't know how the Kickstarter system would or could transfer money back to the funders? Or she doesn't know if there's "technically" an obligation to make a refund? The answer to the second question should have been well known to her and her lawyers. It's a little troubling that she can't give a straight answer so early in the infancy of a project that is ostensibly rooted in openness.
- mynameishere 14y agoHave no idea how this site hasn't been shut down by the SEC. Absolute violation of regulations wrt accredited investors.
- adaml_623 14y agoThere is no way that anything on the KS website could mislead you into thinking that you are investing your money to get a share of the company running the project. Nothing to do with securities, stocks, options or ownership. Therefore it is really nothing to do with the SEC.
- jordanthoms 14y agoPerhaps because that would be an absolutely horrific example of government overreach. When you put money into a kickstarter project, you know the risks - stop looking for big daddy to look after you.
- mynameishere 14y agoThe whole point of the status of an "accredited investor" was to separate (typically) savvy/knowledgeable people from complete amateurs. This designation was created specifically to prevent people from throwing money at poorly-researched/fly-by-night/scammy/hopeless investments. An accredited investor like PG has the knowledge and means to do due diligence before he commits money. Some local loser...not so much. That's the point. I'm not going to argue this so much as reaffirm my mystification that regulatory bodies haven't interfered with this obvious conduit of fraud.
- jordanthoms 14y ago"There are too many stupid people in the world. I'm not saying we should kill them all or anything. Just take the warning labels off of everything and let the problem solve itself." -- Unknown
- shardling 14y agoIf someone took your money on kickstarter with no intention of working on the project, I'm sure the government would be happy to investigate that as fraud.
- Frencil 14y agoThe number one rule for KickStarter is that it is NOT eCommerce. When a campaign operates on the mindset that it's a platform to sell goods, and when backers also operate on that same premise, both parties end up on the hook for something they weren't expecting.
- xfernandox 14y agoI think it's pretty clear through Kickstarter's use of the term "perks" for the different reward levels project founders can create that you are donating money to the cause. The fact that a lot of project creators have changed some backer's perception of the transaction doesn't change that Kickstarter is clearly a tool for raising funds through donations, not as a product pre-order transaction or investment into the company. I think any sane person should be able to see the risks involved and consider them carefully before donating. Maybe there are clueless folks out there who think Kickstarter is basically Amazon. But I think it's clear from the website that it's akin to demanding money back from your local school's fundraiser because you didn't like the gift basket they sent you.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- goodcanadian 14y agoI am finding the discussion rather strange. It has always been quite clear to me that Kickstarter was a modern patronage model--I give to the arts because I like the arts--nothing more, nothing less. There is no investment, no sale; it is a pure gift. The artist may show her appreciation by gifting me something in return. I concede that a games console might stretch some people's definition of art, but it is still a speculative and creative project which may or may not succeed. Clearly, I am in the minority on this subject. Most people seem to view it as a pre-order website, or even an investment. This is quite different from my understanding of the whole thing.
- URSpider94 14y agoI've said this before, and I'll say it again. Funds collected by Kickstarter aren't "investments." They aren't "pre-orders." They are DONATIONS. In many cases, they are donations to for-profit companies, which I still can't really wrap my head around. Like all donations, Kickstarter pledges are freely given, with no promise of anything in return. Yes, many projects pledge to provide you with a sample of their finished product, or a DVD of their documentary, or your name tattooed onto the creator's tush, or something like that, but there's zero legal obligation for anyone to deliver on those promises.
- gfodor 14y agoYeah, when people refer to kickstarter donations as "investments", it's an instant flip of the bozo bit for me.
- scanr 14y agoI'm not sure this is accurate. The Kickstarter terms of service say: "Project Creators are required to fulfill all rewards of their successful fundraising campaigns or refund any Backer whose reward they do not or cannot fulfill." http://www.kickstarter.com/terms-of-use http://www.kickstarter.com/terms-of-use
- d0de 14y agoThe problem is that if that provision were actually enforced, kickstarter would be of much less use to those people it was originally conceived of to help. If you are a small independent games company, film maker, or musician, the threat of failing to complete your project (e.g. it was too ambitious, you set your funding goal too low, you run into legal issues you hadn't anticipated, etc.) and being required to pay back tens of thousands of dollars you have already spent is enough disincentive to not use kickstarter in the first place. In other words, if kickstarter campaigns have to repay backers if they fail, kickstarter becomes radically less useful and interesting as a proposition.
- giulianob 14y agoThey have to fulfill the rewards it says. Which really means that you shouldn't promise a version of your product if you can't deliver it. Rather it might be better to make the rewards things that are easy to deliver such as shirts, stickers, etc... Definitely some projects like Ouya that have promised a console will technically have to refund people potentially millions of dollars if they can't ship the device.
- ommunist 14y agoThe article ends up with a misleading statement. Kickstarter is not a crowddonation, it is not a crowdpurchasing site. Its crowdfunding, which means there are risks involved and there is mo money back guarantee. As a backer you expect a product as return on your investment, but it is not 50% guaranteed.
- jakeonthemove 14y agoWell, d'uh, you don't get your money back, period. That's the first thing I learned when reading their FAQs and other pages. It's like a donation towards something that you find great/interesting/useful, with the added benefit of some kind of return. Or you could consider it an investment, small loan, without security or guarantees of any kind. I don't know, the article makes it seem like a negative thing for those who first hear about Kickstarter... Fund raisers should not do "the right thing" and return any money, either - it sets a bad precedent, especially if you return the money only to some and not everyone.
- gcb 14y agoAlways inquired them about that, never got a decent reply. That case in the article was enlightening. I will not go to kickstater without an LLC to hide behind!
- raesene2 14y agoPersonally I think that there's a big risk of Kickstarter acquiring a bad reputation here. Whilst a lot of the comments on this thread show that some people look at Kickstarter contributions as donations or investments, I don't think that that's the case for the large number of people putting money into some of the kickstarters that get funded via the site, in particular kickstarters focused on making a physical product, where the product features heavily in the reward tiers I'd also say that the site itself doesn't make it that clear, that the money is an investment or gify. From the Kickstarter proposals I've read I don't see them heavily mentioning the idea that the backer won't received the reward at the tier that they donate to if the project doesn't succeed in creating the product. If you look at some kickstarters that have big delays on their delivery (e.g. Zioneyes http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/zioneyez/eyeztm-by-zioneyez-hd-video-recording-glasses-for?ref=live http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/zioneyez/eyeztm-by-zione... ) there seems to be a large percentage of backers who were expecting a product and aren't very happy not to be getting one after over 12 months)... Definitely from a personal perspective I'm more careful now about what I back and specifically the track record of the project creators (i.e. have they done this before).
- pge 14y agoMany of these comments treat "kickstarter" as a homogenous group of companies. Each project on Kickstarter is different, and the resulting liabilities would be different. In many of the most successful cases, the funding is tied to a pre-order of a product. In that case, the company has an obligation to the funder to deliver the product (or possibly refund the cash). Whether the funder acts on that obligation is a separate question, but s/he is a creditor to the company.
- brackin 14y agoI hope people aren't put off from the Crowdfunding model thanks to kickstarter. All they have to do is bolster up their accountability tools to improve the current experience massively. Maybe show the likelihood of complication based on past projects. This what I'm working on in the charity sector, which isn't competing with Kickstarter at all apart from the fact that we both start with crowdfunding.
- jdlshore 14y agoKickstarter does not provide a way for projects to give refunds. (Or if they do, they've hidden it well.) My kick-started Test-Driven Javascript screencast [1] was very successful and I'm actually delivering on my promises [2]. But I have had a few people complain about the videos, and one person took me up on my offer of a refund. I offered to write him a check, but he's in England (I'm in the US) and the check-cashing and currency-conversion fees would be higher than the value of the check. So I went looking for a refund option. I couldn't find a way to do it in Kickstarter or Amazon Payments. I offered to send the backer the money through Amazon Payments (he'd have to sign up for it, though) or to transfer his account to someone else, but ultimately he decided he'd rather just keep his subscription. Kickstarter rules say you're supposed to provide a refund if you don't deliver. But they don't provide a way to do so. It's my only disappointment with them. If one of my customers is unhappy, I want to provide a refund. [1] http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/188988365/lets-code-test-driven-javascript http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/188988365/lets-code-test... [2] http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/188988365/lets-code-test-driven-javascript/posts/299166 http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/188988365/lets-code-test...