5 ms·
Yes. One of the biggest complaints that computer science departments used to get from students is that they weren't learning any languages that employers are us
by SoftTalker 1y ago
Yes. One of the biggest complaints that computer science departments used to get from students is that they weren't learning any languages that employers are using.
- cess11 1y agoI'm not so sure someone who's good with Scheme will be bad with Python or Java. On the contrary, I suspect that such a person is likely to be better suited to build software in either of the latter two. I also suspect that Python is not a particularly good first language for someone who aims for a professional career building software.
- masklinn 1y ago> I'm not so sure someone who's good with Scheme will be bad with Python or Java. The problem likely has always been the companies / HR rather than the students. > I also suspect that Python is not a particularly good first language for someone who aims for a professional career building software. It's not a particularly bad one either, certainly better than Java. IIRC a secondary benefit is that it allows overlap between some of the basic CS, and the CS/CE courses for non CS track students
- Jtsummers 1y ago> I'm not so sure someone who's good with Scheme will be bad with Python or Java. They won't be. But students don't understand that, they want to learn marketable skills and are 18 years old. They haven't figured out that if your skills transcend language choice you will be more marketable even if it means you have to spend a few weeks learning a new language for a new job. They lack maturity, which isn't surprising given their age and experience, and so they complain.
- icedchai 1y agoWhen I went to university in the 90's, Scheme was used in a couple of early courses. I had already learned C and Java on my own, but greatly enjoyed how Scheme made me think about problems differently. (I didn't learn Python until much later when I was out of school.) As long as students are exposed to multiple languages, I think starting w/Python is fine. Every language has its issues.
- ok123456 1y agoThere were plenty of less rarefied CS departments that were concerned about this, and they taught C, C++, or Java in their introductory classes. Ultimately, it doesn't matter. It's your first language, not your last.
- olddustytrail 1y agoHow many people do you know who are monolingual?
- ok123456 1y agoOnly knowing the language you were required to know to pass a bunch of tests when you were 18 is a negative signal. If someone is interviewing and they only have Java listed, and their school is known for teaching Java for their introductory classes. They're probably not that strong of a programmer.
- bluGill 1y agoHuman languages and programming languages are not comparable. You will need a lot more effort to become fluent in a second human language than in second programming language. Even if the human language is Esperanto (designed to be really easy for speakers of European languages), and the programming language is C++ (perhaps the most inconsistencies and foot guns) the programming language will need a lot less effort to learn to a high level.
- exe34 1y agoMultiple computer languages are probably more like learning vocabulary in different domains of life and learning to write for different media.
- olddustytrail 1y agoThey're not directly comparable because humans have an inbuilt ability to learn human languages. The vast majority of people on the planet know more than one human language and know zero computer languages. It's literally the opposite of what you're claiming.
- 90s_dev 1y agoTo be fair, if you learn computer science well enough to thoroughly understand Scheme, I don't think it'll take more than a few weeks during the summer to learn Python.
- kstrauser 1y agoI disagree. You can learn the language itself pretty quickly. Finding your way through the expansive standard library will take longer. Getting a good handle on the package ecosystem is a lifetime learning project.
- acuozzo 1y agoKnowing your way around the ecosystem of one programming language does not build up the intuition necessary for identifying O(n²) (or worse!) algorithms and choosing/writing O(log(n)) (or better!) ones instead. Computer Science has little to do with science, but what it teaches you is certainly closer to science than just building a huge mental index for a bunch of work done by other people. There's certainly value in that skill, but it has no place in a Computer Science curriculum. This would be like taking Astrophysics students and telling them to study the details of all of the different kinds of telescopes they can buy.
- kstrauser 1y agoThat's not really what we were talking about here. The context was that compsci students want to learn marketable skills, and the claim was that if the student had learned Scheme in class, they could quickly pick up Python. And that's true, for the language itself. But knowing only the language, like never importing code you hadn't written yourself, doesn't go far along the road to marketability. I'm not arguing that compsci should be job training, not at all. My disagreement is solely with this specific claim. But FWIW, while I understand your analogy, an astrophysics department that didn't tell the students that there are these things called telescopes, and here's why you might use one over the other for various situations, and that they're how you're going to get the observation data you'll test your theories against, would be doing a disservice.
- nextos 1y agoI always found this to be a shortsighted complaint. Getting exposed to languages where computation models are clear gives you an excellent background to switch to the language du jour and become a master. Going through e.g. HtDP or CTM makes it easy to transition to Python and write excellent code, whereas traversing the opposite path is going to be tough.
- delecti 1y agoI agree, but those don't need to be the languages you use in all classes. I learned a few assembly and academic languages (MIPS and LISP) in classes for those two topics, and it was absolutely useful to learn how to think in terms of those languages. The vast majority of our classes were Java though, and that's also been the vast majority of what I've done since graduation. (I think my school has since moved to Python as well) So I graduated with that really helpful knowledge about why modern languages work how they do, but also a lot of practical experience of actually using those modern languages too.
- ajkjk 1y agoeven better is learning the languages you want to learn why are you paying a school to teach you something adjacent to what you want to learn so you can learn the thing you need yourself?
- aleph_minus_one 1y ago> why are you paying a school to teach you something adjacent to what you want to learn so you can learn the thing you need yourself? Because some topics are easy to learn by yourself, and some are not, so the latter ones are better learned in a college setting.
- kelipso 1y agoLearning a language definitely belongs in the first category. Learning computer science goes in the latter category.
- vouaobrasil 1y ago
- zer0zzz 1y agoI always found scheme to be a clean slate where no one’s high school experience benefited them in the first year. My program did Java for the second course, which was very popular in industry and I loathed it. I do think Python is not so bad to standardize on because it’s stood the test of time and is one of the most popular ways to write code for many disciplines and has applications outside of computer science so it helps everyone that takes the cs requirement even if they aren’t a cs major. What im saying is Python can even serve as a better version of spreadsheets for folks that aren’t cs.
- djoldman 1y agoI think someone who learns computer science well from the theoretical side can pick up a new language quickly. After all, if it's turing complete, it's turing complete, they're all the same at that level. Problems creep in when the person doesn't learn CS well, chooses an approach that is deeply reliant on overly complex/opaque libraries without good documentation, or the like.
- zelphirkalt 1y agoThat's kind of a useless argument. Universities often also don't teach people any web development. In many cases a graduating student has never worked on any real project. If the university's idea is, that the student can learn those things in their free time, then surely asking someone to learn a little bit of Python or another language is not too big an ask either. So which one is it? Learn that stuff at home on your own time, or university should teach it, because it is needed on the job? Then what other things are they not teaching that is used on the job?
- billy99k 1y agoWhen I was in college, we had our base software development courses and could choose web development as an elective. Our class taught .NET.
- toolslive 1y agoindeed. The problem with being expose do to something so much more clean/elegant/powerful than the languages employers are using is that you no longer want to do it. It's like having tasted good whisky. You no longer think Jack's acceptable. These days, employers more or less get what they wanted. We're doomed.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]