17 ms·
Diet, not lack of exercise, drives obesity, a new study finds
- bko 1y ago> "So if we burn more of our energy every day on physical activity, on exercise, after a while our bodies will adjust and spend less energy on the other tasks that we sort of don't notice going on in the background," Pontzer says. I also think this is true related to food. Your body adjusts its metabolism based on the amount of food you eat as long as it's not chronic. That's why you can have competitive eaters that can eat a weeks worth of food and not be overweight. Spikiness and variability are probably good for you. Its funny that the Bryan Johnson types who closely control every calorie in their body have such a bad reaction to any variability. I don't know if its him, but I heard someone not be able to sleep and their levels got all messed up from one sweet. And their conclusion was sweets are so bad for you, rather than you're building your body to be too fragile to shocks. The interesting thing is when this breaks down. Obviously if you eat a weeks worth of food every day for a sustained period of time, you will start to gain weight. Or if you run 12 miles every day, you will be in such a deficit that it won't be possible to lower your metabolism enough. Outside of the extremes, I think it's a cliff, where you have to have some kind of shock for some period of time for your body to react.
- mhogers 1y agoInteresting - training for spikiness/variability is a positive view, e.g. embrace the lack of occasional sleep, it trains you to be more resilient.
- bko 1y agoThis is built into a lot of religions and cultural practices with fasting or restrictions. Spikiness is lindy
- BJones12 1y ago> That's why you can have competitive eaters that can eat a weeks worth of food and not be overweight. Nope, they do gain weight, or avoid gaining weight by counting calories [0] [0] https://youtu.be/SVS0ioOdfuE?t=225 https://youtu.be/SVS0ioOdfuE?t=225
- goda90 1y agoThat's exactly the point the grandparent comment was making though. Because they aren't chronically eating at competition levels is the reason they aren't overweight. They have a high calorie moment, followed by low calorie stretches.
- baseballdork 1y agoThat wasn't my takeaway from that comment. > Your body adjusts its metabolism based on the amount of food you eat as long as it's not chronic. Suggests that your metabolism is changing, as though your body becomes more or less efficient at burning calories because you're eating more or less. Instead, these guys eat a huge surplus of calories and then go into a deficit to get back to their standard weight.
- bko 1y agoSure he cuts back his calories, but 70 hotdogs is about 21k calories. I don't think he goes into a 21k calorie deficit over the next few weeks. That's an insane deficit. That would be the equivalent of not eating for 8.5 days, which is not possible since it would mess with his training. He probably cuts it back some fraction of that, say 10k and his body's increased metabolism adjusts for the rest.
- baseballdork 1y agoDoesn't that beg the question of why anyone gets fat if your metabolism can just... increase to cover some arbitrary amount of calories?
- BobaFloutist 1y agoIt's because our bodies want to get fat, because storing calories is evolutionarily advantageous (or at least was).
- EvanAnderson 1y ago
- boringg 1y agoDepends on the goal is. If you life is full of shocks then build for shocks. If you life is not build for shocks it makes sense to optimize for your existence. You certainly don't want to overfit the model as you are describing but you don't want to build a life around expecting shocks when none arrive. As with all things, it is a balance.
- nordsieck 1y ago> The interesting thing is when this breaks down. Obviously if you eat a weeks worth of food every day for a sustained period of time, you will start to gain weight. Or if you run 12 miles every day, you will be in such a deficit that it won't be possible to lower your metabolism enough. Outside of the extremes, I think it's a cliff, where you have to have some kind of shock for some period of time for your body to react. Objectively, I don't think this is accurate. Most people who are overweight got that way slowly. Dr Mike[1]'s theory is that modern processed food is to blame - not because it's unhealthy, but because it's too tasty. Companies that make food are in an evolutionary arms race with other companies to get consumers to choose their products. And one of the best ways to do that is to make the food as tasty as possible. Another things many companies probably try to optimize their food for is low satiety[2]. That way consumers consume, and therefore buy, more of their products. --- 1. From Renaissance Periodization 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satiety_value https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satiety_value
- MichaelNolan 1y agoIn addition to food being much tastier than ever before, it’s also much cheaper. Despite current inflation and cost of living concerns, we spend far less on food than any time in history. Food in the 1960 was almost twice as expensive as it is today. Food costs used to be higher than housing costs! https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2020/november/average-share-of-income-spent-on-food-in-the-united-states-remained-relatively-steady-from-2000-to-2019 https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2020/november/average-s... https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/04/how-america-spends-money-100-years-in-the-life-of-the-family-budget/255475/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/04/how-ame...
- 0x737368 1y agoCompetitive eaters throw their food up and keep it secret as "I'm just calorie counting" sounds a lot better than "I pretty much have an eating disorder". You can't eat large portions once a week and still train your stomach to stretch enough to eat those gargantuan amounts of food that they need to perform.
- BrawnyBadger53 1y agoSome do this, some go on binge fast cycles. Others just eat the food. It's different for everyone. Binge fast cycles are probably the easiest way to train this though.
- a3w 1y agoThe timing of when I eat changes, if I gain weight. Eating pizza after jogging? Fat on belly. Eating as much pizza as I want, but going to bed after on empty stomach after running, or putting the running in the morning while doing about 12 to 16 hour slots of intermitted fasting? Hello, six-pack.
- ricciardo 1y agoThat is a pretty interesting observation. I always thought it was solely on the amount of calories consumed vs burned. For example, you burn ~2500 through just living, if you eat a pizza that contains 3000 calories, no matter the time at which you eat it, will you not still gain fat?
- schmidtleonard 1y agoCalorie counting works, but "use this one weird trick to target belly fat and achieve six pack" sells books.
- mecsred 1y agoIts all anecdotal all the way down, so here's another grain of salt to add to the pile. (Calories in - calories out) is correct enough to be the single most reliable metric, and will serve you right 99% of the time. My "one level deeper" understanding is that there are a few transfer functions applied to calories in. So of the technically available calories you eat, how much does your body absorb. Then, when the calories are biologically available, how does your body spend them? So the idea would be, if you eat the pizza at the right time you reduce calories in. Either you will digest less calories, or your body will allocated them differently at different times of the day. Unfortunately these things aren't really measurable so it's very hard to separate from hearsay.
- stonemetal12 1y ago>solely on the amount of calories consumed vs burned. It is, but CI\CO as advice doesn't take in to account that you aren't a machine and we aren't calculating gas mileage. The system is both adaptive and reactive. CI and CO changes based on the situation, and you have no way to accurately measure.
- com2kid 1y agoThis is true to an extent and I'm very fond of the saying, but beyond a certain point you can indeed outrun a bad diet. I used to spend ~4 hours a day training martial arts (kickboxing, BJJ, etc) during which time I could eat almost anything I wanted without gaining weight. I'm sure if I had downed a cheesecake a day it would've been bad for me, but I was able to get away with a level of excess back then that I am unable to today. So you can indeed outrun a bad diet, it just takes more running than most people want to do!
- jchw 1y agoYeah. Sure, your body can adjust how much calories are burned when you're idle, but it can only do so much. If you're burning thousands of calories on daily activity, it's gotta come from somewhere.
- coffeefirst 1y agoYeah, this is a scale problem. You can hop on a plane and go from a driving-city to a walking city, look around and see the difference. I can't accept that this doesn't matter. But if you take the common American diet where the bread of your sandwich is shelf-stable because it's packed with sugar and oil, and that's before we even talk about portion size, "more running than most people want to do" quickly becomes "recreate the scene from Forest Gump."
- robertlagrant 1y ago> I can't accept that this doesn't matter. It's not that it doesn't matter, it's the asymmetry. You can eat a small chocolate bar that costs $1 (or whatever) in about 15 seconds, and it will take you 2 hours of walking to wear off the calories.
- const_cast 1y agoIt's more complicated than this, because muscle raises your basal metabolic rate. If you look at bodybuilders, they're buring 400 calories a day, regardless of exercise. Having an extra 100 pounds of muscle means your body just burns A LOT of calories doing absolutely nothing. This is part of the reason why men burn more calories than woman just right out of the gate.
- testing22321 1y agoI’ve been thinking about writing a book on this topic: “No overweight person eats well”. By very definition of a person is overweight, they got there by eating poorly, and are continuing to do so. They have eaten more energy than they use, this energy storage in fat.
- snapcaster 1y agoI think there are an infinite number of true statements you could make about unhealthy or overweight people. What makes for a good book or article is finding the true statement you can say that actually sways behavior. I'm skeptical your message would succeed in this
- standardUser 1y ago> They have eaten... Notice the past tense there?
- testing22321 1y agoAnd / or continue to eat. Present tense. If they were currently eating well, they would lose weight and not be overweight
- sophia01 1y agoThe title is disappointing: it implies a causal relationship. The study was an observational study. Indeed, you can outrun a bad diet: we all know that. The study just shows that the lack of activity isn't the main reason for obesity. Both things can be true simultaneously.
- BrawnyBadger53 1y ago"Running is a statistically ineffective means of weight reduction" doesn't make for a catchy headline. This can suffice.
- npteljes 1y agoI agree. A good title could be "You can outrun a bad diet. You just won't".
- momocowcow 1y agoNice clean journalistic blurb from NPR. Case close! Too much food makes you fat, not genetics. Until the next article in a month.
- gry 1y agoToo much food is not the conclusion. It's the food itself.
- taeric 1y agoReminds me of a video I saw recently that pointed out the absurd number of calories professional athletes burn. Upshot of that video was that you almost certainly can run to lose weight. Just don't expect it to be an easy task. At a personal level, I can also say that it is flat out hard to eat large amounts of food if you are staying active. The stereotype of wanting an after meal nap is legit. It is also somewhat interesting to see other places try and contend with just how much food your average person in the US has at their ready disposal.
- alistairSH 1y agoAt a personal level, I can also say that it is flat out hard to eat large amounts of food if you are staying active. I've never had that problem. When I exercise a lot, my body just starts to crave a higher proportion of calorie-dense foods - ice cream, cheese, breads. The actual volume of food might not go up all that much, but the balance changes. Of course, "a lot" for me is 10-15 hours cardio/week plus 3-4 hours/week weight training. My baseline is 3-5 hours cardio and the same 3-4 weight training. I only ramp up to 10+ hours cardio if I have a major event planned (100 mile mtn bike race or similar).
- taeric 1y agoI think it is safe to say that 10-15 hours of cardio a week is far far more than most people get. Hick, 6-10 hours of exercise a week is almost certainly multiples of what most people do. :D But, yeah, I was meaning volume as well as certain types. As I understand it, at the elite levels, you actually have to train your body in how to consume enough to stay active for the full event. It isn't like you can just down a few cheese burgers and then head off to a race. Ice cream remains an amusing one, to me. People are convinced it is among the worst snacks you can do, and yet I have yet to meet a very active person that doesn't love some form of ice cream on a regular basis.
- Barrin92 1y agoIt ought to be obvious. A chocolate donut, large Frappuccino or pick your unhealthy food of choice are about equivalent to half an hour of running. Given how many people throw in a snack like that several times per day good luck burning that off with exercise. One of the most straight forward things to lose weight is just limiting yourself to two or three actual meals, black coffee, tea, etc.
- RankingMember 1y agoStarbucks did an impressive job of convincing people they love coffee when a lot of them actually just like morning/mid-day dessert with some trace coffee flavoring.
- astura 1y agoNobody who is ordering a frapachino is convinced they are ordering because they like coffee, especially considering that the half of the frapachino menu is non-coffee flavors.
- chasd00 1y agoI make coffee at home but have noticed how fast the sugar jar needs to be refilled. I'm the only one who drinks coffee, it's surprising how much sugar i consume drinking coffee. I bet i use 2-3 tablespoons of pure sugar from my coffee consumption alone.
- hermitcrab 1y agoI used to have sugar in my tea. I gradually reduced it to zero and now I don't miss it at all.
- JKCalhoun 1y agoI have been, rather lazily I suppose, trying to tweak my diet in such as way as to lose weight; and with little to show for it. I'm not sure that there is much if any processed food still in my diet (maybe just the English muffin in the morning?). I stopped buying/drinking soda pop decades ago (a low-hanging fruit indeed — I lost almost 10 pounds within a month of making that dietary change alone). And since I have tried little things like switching to peanut butter that contains only peanuts (no salt, no sugar, not palm oil — sure, I have to stir it when I open it for the first time). I've moved to whole grain bread. Other small changes like that I can't remember right now. I still have a BMI that's too high. The only time I have significantly lost weight was when I was prepping for intestinal surgery nearly a decade ago. I was at the time worried that eating too much would literally kill me (I was worried about bursting my intestine) that I ate very small portions for each meal. I'm not sure why I can't change my habits such that I continue to eat those small portions (now that the fear is gone).
- knicholes 1y agoTry a diet plan where you prep your own meals and intake a specific amount of calories. I've used Clean Simple Eats in the past. Diet only works. Diet+exercise works better, and adds all of the benefits of exercise.
- JKCalhoun 1y agoI walk over 2 miles a day. My doctor suggested weight training (which I had not thought of as a way to lose weight — I don't think of it as an aerobic workout).
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- SeanAnderson 1y agoDiet to manage your weight. Exercise to manage your fitness. It's real simple in theory and real difficult in practice. Super worth it, though. Your entire world starts opening up when things take less energy to do and you have more energy to give. It's very challenging to convey how important it is without living the experience.
- goda90 1y agoDon't "diet". Change your eating habits permanently. Too many people go through theses cycles of "I'm going to cut out this, this and this to lose X pounds" and then drop it once they hit their goal or it ends up being too hard. While you might not shed pounds as quickly, if you focus on making sure you get varied, satiating, nutritious food(actually nutritious, not falling for the abundance of marketing out there), then you'll have an easier time resisting the temptation to gorge on treats and getting too many calories.
- lanfeust6 1y ago> Don't "diet". Change your eating habits permanently. Colloquially the former can mean the latter. But yes, anything that cannot be sustained is doomed to fail.
- SeanAnderson 1y agoI think you read "diet" and "exercise" as verbs when I was using them as nouns :) My grammar wasn't great, though, so that's on me.
- neogodless 1y agoLanguage changes over time, and "diet" is very commonly used as shorthand for "restrictive food intake" or "caloric restriction." But a reminder that "diet" is short for "dietary intake", and is not prescriptive. "A healthy diet" is a common phrase for "permanently good eating habits." The parent used context in an appropriate way that it's safer to assume they meant "dietary intake" than "restrictive food intake."
- post_break 1y agoHaving lost 40lbs in the past couple of years, diet and walking have been key. It's just so much easier to burn fat by not eating it, than it is to try to burn it off with exercise. You'll find that burning 500 calories on a treadmill feels like an eternity, but eating one chocolate chip muffin? You can do that and gulp down a big glass of milk in 5 minutes like it's nothing.
- SirMaster 1y ago>You'll find that burning 500 calories on a treadmill feels like an eternity That's because you are doing it on a treadmill... Try doing a more fun activity outside in the world and in nature. Like cycling. I can cycle for 120 miles outdoors in about 6 hours in a single day and have a positive experience and memory of doing it and that burns about 8200 calories according to a calculators for my weight.
- post_break 1y agoI live in Houston. Cycling is too dangerous.
- kelnos 1y agoUnfortunately I think you'll find that many people just don't actually enjoy these sorts of activities. To me, cycling 120 miles (or even just 20 miles) is not something I'm interested in doing regularly. I've tried various things, and I've found that I can get myself to go outside running (usually 3-5 miles in one session) a few times a week, but even that feels like a chore. I've been doing hot yoga (as well as a yoga-adjacent class that I think of more as "strength training and cardio with yoga features") for the past year and a half, which I actually somewhat enjoy. But it took me double-digit years to find exercise activities that I can actually get myself to do. Go to the gym regularly? Really hard to find the motivation, though I do my best to go if I'm traveling in a place where I can't go to my (national chain) yoga studio. Cycling? Not my cup of tea. Playing a sport? Nope. Climbing? Tried it, didn't find it interesting. Hiking? Sure, on occasion, but not regularly enough to count as regular exercise. I'm just not really interested in any of those things enough to do them multiple times per week. And I think that's the case for many people. If I could maintain my weight, leg muscle tone, and cardiovascular health without running, I'd never run ever again. I don't get that "runner's high" that people talk about (or if I do, it's not very intense, and fades very quickly). In addition to whole-body muscle tone, the yoga gives me some nice mental benefits, so I'd probably keep that up, but if it didn't, I'd drop it immediately.
- laurent_du 1y agoAt some point in my life I was eating 400g of nutella every day. I was also running 26km per day. I didn't get fat.
- freetime2 1y ago> We also excluded those listed as “athletes” in the database and those with TEEs greater than 25 MJ/d (all of these excluded individuals were from High HDI populations) This study specifically excluded athletes, so its conclusions would be applicable to someone running 26km per day.
- Lerc 1y agoI think it is fairly accepted that most of the health benefits of exercise apply regardless of your weight loss.
- Delphiza 1y agoUnsurprisingly, the title is sensationalist and not representative of the study. The study compares energy expenditure across different economic groups i.e. western people sitting in offices versus hunter-gatherers in Africa, and found that difference in energy expenditure does not account for differences in obesity, so points to consumption as the likely reason. The sample dataset explicitly excluded 'athletes', so would exclude people that _are_ outrunning a bad diet. We know that a little weekly jog around the park doesn't mean you can eat a cheesecake every day, but anyone who has done extensive 'athletic' physical activity knows that if you don't up your calorie intake that you will lose weight. The study does not conclude, at all, that you cannot outrun a bad diet. Instead, it suggests "that dietary intake plays a far greater role than reduced energy expenditure in obesity related to economic development." Edit: My point is specifically not about running. I am merely pointing out that if you read the study you will find that it is more of a study on economic development, and not really useful for personal or localised health advice. It observes that economically developed population groups may be more sedentary, but do not expend significantly more energy - so a hunter-gatherer picking berries all day does not burn significantly more energy than an office worker (at least not enough to explain why the office worker is obese). Therefore, the link between economic development and obesity is likely related to food (dietary intake) than daily activity.
- mvieira38 1y agoWould you say Luka, Neymar and others are outrunning their diets? Did Shaq, too? You don't automatically get a good physique by being an athlete, you still have to earn it. People just see that all of the top athletes have earned it and take it for granted, like they don't have world class dieticians and a huge financial incentive to maintain a strict diet
- bsoles 1y agoMichael Phelps did outswim his diet. He famously ate a lot of junk food and pizza, and yet remained fit because of his huge daily calorie expenditure. A direct quote from an interview with him, where he states: "I just sort of try to cram whatever I can into my body. It’s pretty much whatever I feel like eating, I’m going to eat".
- Beijinger 1y agoDeja vue, but it is really a new article. There are older studies: Epub 2015 It is time to bust the myth of physical inactivity and obesity: you cannot outrun a bad diet https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25904145/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25904145/
- kingstnap 1y agoEveryone in bodybuilding or adjacent crowds already knows this. How fat you are is entirely a function of how much you eat. If you want to put on weight, you bulk by eating more. If you want to lose weight, you cut with reduced calories. The idea you could instead bulk by doing less cardio and cut by doing more sounds completely crazy. In reality, you do more exercise on a bulk because, duh, you can recover from more volume when eating a surplus.
- siliconc0w 1y agoIf you eat 4k calories but burn 5k, you'll lose a lot more weight than if you ate 1000 and burned 2000. So running can help but you still need a calorie deficit. Eating and burning more boosts your metabolism - if you measure a body builder during a bulk they are like a furnace, burning 1-2k over baseline. They still put on fat but it's a lot less than what you'd think given the amounts they're eating.
- snozolli 1y agoIf you eat 4k calories but burn 5k, you'll lose a lot more weight than if you ate 1000 and burned 2000. Each of those is a 1,000 Calorie deficit. if you measure a body builder during a bulk Incidentally, the terms "bulking" and "cutting" come from bodybuilders taking steroids. I know that non-chemically-enhanced people have started using these terms, but it's honestly foolish. When you're not cycling anabolic steroids against metabolic stimulants like Clenbuterol, it really doesn't apply.
- siliconc0w 1y agoSo you're saying your metabolism is the same when you eat 1k calories vs 4k?
- dragonwriter 1y agoYour metabolism differences are already accounted for when you talk about how much you are burning, you don't get to count metabolism twice.
- Kirby64 1y ago> Incidentally, the terms "bulking" and "cutting" come from bodybuilders taking steroids. Since when? Are you sure you don't mean 'blast' and 'cruise', which specifically has connotations of steroid usage? > When you're not cycling anabolic steroids against metabolic stimulants like Clenbuterol, it really doesn't apply. Why wouldn't it apply?
- 1y ago
- 71153750 1y agoThis reminds a little of Usain Bolt famously having chicken nuggets before his final at the Beijing Olympics. Although hardly indicative of a bad diet that he may or may not have had. I think as well there is some difficulty with variability between people that isn't clear or maybe doesn't matter at scale. The article linked study was across 43 nations with 4213 adults. Yet there may still be individuals who can argue differently. CICO (calories in vs calories out) must apply to us all, but the composition has an affect on what the body chooses to store vs how energised or hungry/satiated we feel. A bad diet could perhaps me we feel we have less enthusiasm for running or other activities. Age, lifestyle, and even cultural factors are massive in affecting metabolism (more the foremost) and of course what we consume (the latter two). I run a fair amount (over 2000km/1200 miles in 2025) and find that once I start doing above ~70km/43 miles in a week whatever eating habits I have are indeed outcompeted by my running and weight loss is inevitable. Even so it does slow around a BMI of 23 for me for longer than I am able to be consistent with the running to observe further effects. Still my point is that my diet isn't anything to write home about and I anecdotally I feel that as far as weightloss is concerned I can very much outrun it.
- SeanAnderson 1y agoThe chicken nugget thing is to avoid food poisoning though, right? It's because McDonald's food logistics results in hyper-consistent food irrespective of where you're at in the world and the last thing an Olympic competitor wants is to risk getting food poisoning from eating foreign food. I don't think Usain eats chicken nuggets on the reg.
- 71153750 1y agoI don't know the reason and think your reasoning is probably sound. Although at the same I wonder if chicken nuggets were really the only option? I'll make a grand assumption that most athletes weren't on the chicken nugget diet.
- pqtyw 1y agoChickens nuggets aren't necessarily that unhealthy even? They have about as much saturated fat as generic chicken thighs. Inherently food at Mcdonalds isn't that bad for you as long as you don't overeat and take a few supplements.
- mglvsky 1y agoNeither good diet can solely help avoiding to be skinny-fat edit: grammar
- RobKohr 1y agoI cut out drinks with sugar in them, eating after dinner, and in general just eating healthy meals. I lift weights about 3 days a week, and am fairly fit strengthwise. All this lowered my fat levels down to a reasonable level, but still left me with about 23% body fat and a bit of a belly, and that remained consistent. Trying to diet didn't really cause any maintainable change. What I found has helped is doing a 24 hour fast once a week. This really means just eating one dinner a little earlier (4:30pm) and then skipping breakfast and lunch and drinking water with electrolytes added. With keeping the rest of the days calorie intake the same, I have shaved off consistently 1 pound a week and 1/2" from my waistline. This has been going for 5 weeks now, and I have gone from 23% to 19.7% based on navy body fat formula. What is great is I have no cravings or feelings that I am depriving myself except for the last 8 hrs of the weekly fast. The rest of the week, I eat well. My plan is to bring myself down to 15% and then continuing to measure. If I get above 15% I fast that week, if I don't then I don't fast, so it basically becomes like a controllable throttle.
- lanfeust6 1y ago> Trying to diet didn't really cause any maintainable change. That's not a surprise. Changing diet composition can in the short-run lead to lower caloric intake than what preceeded (e.g. SAD diet), but doesn't guarantee a sustained caloric deficit, which is why controlling for macros like fat or carbs eventually hits a wall. What are you going to do when there are no more carbs to cut? If you have a lot of excess to lose, you can't "intuitively" eat your way down to your target. The fasts work similarly owing to deficit: a fasted day lowers the average caloric intake for the week (assuming you don't overcompensate other days). As with macros, here again, what are you going to do to increase deficit further? Fast for 48 hours? If with a fast your caloric intake isn't dropping further week-to-week, weight loss will stagnate. Whichever approach, one of the pitfalls is steep deficit followed by metabolic adaptation i.e. crashing metabolism. This is why it's helpful to keep a small caloric deficit, and incrementally change your intake target. That is only reliably achieved by tracking calories.
- scns 1y ago> What I found has helped is doing a 24 hour fast once a week. Another protocol that is sustainable is 4:3, ie 4 days of normal eating and 3 of intermittent fasting.
- specproc 1y agoI'm from a western country, but live outside the OECD. Currently on a trip back home and the food is disgusting. Everything tastes sweet, is invariably hyper-processed, and supplied by a narrow pool of companies. My diet in my host country isn't great, but it's so much easier to eat well. Fresh fruit and veg is more readily available, cheaper and frankly tastier. I wouldn't say people are any more or less sedentary, particularly in the capital city in which I live. The study is supported by my limited experience.
- nunez 1y agoMaybe I'm reading the study wrong, but it doesn't seem like they accounted for caloric intake at all? https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2420902122 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2420902122 They accounted for total EE and basal EE, but the data they've supplied in the appendix doesn't track caloric intake. This seems like a huge miss to me, as it is absolutely possible to have a sky-high TEE while being insanely fat (American football linebackers) and also having a low TEE and being skinny as a rail (by basically not eating, i.e. most fad diets). Also, they categorize most of Africa as either horticulturalist, agropastoralist (why couldn't they say "farmers"???) or hunter-gatherer) despite the table at the bottom ranking their economies as "lowHDI", and the BEE for this cohort is N/A, which invalidates their PAL ratio (TEE/BEE). idk this seems like a "fat ppl bad" study to me.
- dragonwriter 1y ago> This seems like a huge miss to me, as it is absolutely possible to have a sky-high TEE while being insanely fat (American football linebackers) Linemen would be a better example than linebackers here. Linebackers tend (like most positions other than line, and especially offensive line, positions) to have body fat percentages at the high end of the normal range, rather than being “insanely fat”.
- SirMaster 1y agoYou can, it just takes work and discipline. For example jogging at about 7mph for 2 hours a day for a 180lb man would burn about 13,200 calories a week. I know people who jog like this. Or I know people who cycle 250-400 miles a week which burns about 17,000-27,000 calories a week!
- 71153750 1y agoSomewhat orthogonally related, I saw post on X by Nassim Taleb [1] concerning the idea that if you are very active then your heightened consumption of food may cover your nutrient bases better. So perhaps, loosely paraphrased, you could outrun and thus out-eat your nutrient imblance? 1: https://x.com/nntaleb/status/1684885140093206528 https://x.com/nntaleb/status/1684885140093206528
- tartoran 1y agoI personally lost some weight and am now lean by simply changing my eating habits to intermittent fasting. I got so used to it that now it's effortless to continue.
- amai 1y agoRun 10 km 4 times a week and you will loose weight. Try it or your money back!
- simmerup 1y agoGood luck getting an obese person to do that
- TMWNN 1y ago>Run 10 km 4 times a week and you will loose weight. No. I ran 10km three times a week and didn't lose a pound. <https://np.reddit.com/r/running/comments/1vq3k1/should_i_do_anything_after_running/ceupy9g/?context=3 https://np.reddit.com/r/running/comments/1vq3k1/should_i_do_...> Every bit of my weight loss has always come from counting calories.
- amai 1y agoThats why I’m saying you need to run four times ;-) But jokes aside, not doing sports and only counting calories will make you loose muscles pretty fast. This will lower your baseline of calorie consumption of your body. So when you stop counting calories you will grow even more fat than before. If you don’t loose weight from running then most probably you are increasing your calorie intake unconsciously. This overeating happens sometimes when people do sports.
- roguecoder 1y agoIn twin studies the only things that have been associated with obesity are past calorie restrictive diets and soda consumption. All these other studies are usually picking up on either socio-economic or environmental factors, rather than actual behaviors we can control. The reason to exercise isn't to avoid obesity: it is because the health benefits of exercise have nothing to do with weight. Careful, moderate exercising is good for our bodies, all on its own. Whereas there is shockingly little evidence that obesity itself causes most correlated health conditions, rather than being a symptom (of stress, alienation, environmental contamination, inflammatory conditions, etc) correlated with the causes of those conditions. The weight with the lowest all-cause mortality is being "overweight". But of course, "work less" is a lot harder to make money off of than "lose weight", so any science that can be twisted to prop up the weight loss industry will get spread far and wide.
- cthalupa 1y agoYes, exercise is good for you regardless of weight. We should all do it. But the idea that there is little evidence that obesity causes health issues is absurd. There's absolutely mountains of evidence, and we have very firm understandings of the mechanisms underlying many of these issues, too. Hell, just being bigger, even if it's all muscle mass, is bad for your heart. The all-cause mortality curve is J shaped because many more of the people at 10% bf are there because of disease and not because they're shredded from a strict diet and a consistent exercise. I've lost roughly 100lb of fat over the past 9 months. I have gotten back to lifting 5 days a week, but even before that with just losing weight my health markers improved significantly, I've felt better, aches and pains and discomforts have all but disappeared, etc. My stress, alienation, environmental contamination, etc. conditions are all the same, and I'm working just as much, if not more.
- benabbott 1y agoWhenever the topic of weight loss comes up, I always make the same recommendation: Lift weights. Lifting weights increases your muscle mass. Muscle burns calories, even at rest, which raises your TDEE. (A bodybuilder will burn more calories sitting on the couch than someone who doesn't lift weights). For most folks (myself included) cardio sucks. You _could_ jog for an hour every day and burn x-hundred calories due to the increased energy expended... Or you could go lift weights a few times a week, and after a couple months, naturally burn more at rest due to increased muscle mass. I say this as not a nutritionist nor a doctor, but I don't believe I'm off base here. Feel free to correct me on this if I am.
- mritterhoff 1y agoI'm a fan of weightlifting, and agree that there are numerous health benefits to doing so, but I think the extra calorie burning is over-hyped. From what I've read you get 6-10 calories per pound of muscle per day, at rest. Not nothing, but for folks who aren't looking to body build I'm not sure it makes much of a difference. Or maybe over a long enough time span it does, I dunno.
- aethrum 1y agoYeah it's not terrible, but having 10 extra pounds of muscle burning almost 100 calories a day extra, thats like a pound of fat every month and a bit.
- machomaster 1y agoAnd that is the same amount as having 10 extra pounds of fat burns. 1kg of muscle tissue burns pretty much identical amount of calories as 1kg of fat tissue. Heart, kidneys, brain etc. tissues burn more than muscles/fat, but you can't really grow those. Xkg person's basic energy burn rate is the same, regardless of his fat percentage. Therefore it is definitely a myth to promote weightlifting on the merits of muscles being some kind of great energy expenditure machine.
- kelnos 1y ago
- lrvick 1y agoI do not have time for lots of exercise beyond the occasional walk but I hated that I was 40lb over my healthy/ideal weight I used to be. So I simply ignored all the tactics of others in my life chronically struggling to lose weight or keep it of and did the research on the Standard American Diet. All data pointed to Americans simply consume way way too many processed foods, carbs, and artificial sugars. No one should be surprised, but no one wants to change this because shit food tastes so good. I simply dropped all high processed foods, dropped to about 100g of carbs a day, and cut out soda completely. All the extra weight fell right off over 6 months. I did nothing else. Also my dopamine response has changed and healthy food and canned sparkling water now feels as good to consume as fast food and soda used to. Meanwhile friends with the same problem try lots of exercise and never lose any weight, and others use ozempic with no diet changes and also lose no weight. No one wants to hear they have to do something as hard as a permanent major diet change, but blame biology and terrible nutrition education. I am just the messenger. YMMV, but my own experience certainly agrees with this study. Commit to stop eating like an overweight American long term and you are likely to stop looking like one.
- alberth 1y agoI know this can be a touchy subject, but honestly, it shouldn’t be surprising. It’s just basic thermodynamics. The energy (calories) you take in has to go somewhere. Some of it gets used for daily activity, but if you take in more than you burn, your body has to store the extra—it doesn’t have any other way to deal with it. At the end of the day, it really is just a matter of calories in vs. calories out. Exercise just helps burn more of your excess energy so that it doesn’t get converted into (weight) storage. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laws_of_thermodynamics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laws_of_thermodynamics
- somethingAlex 1y agoYeah it's odd we needed a whole article for this. "You can't out exercise a bad diet" has always been true outside of the most extreme cases (competitive athletes).
- BobaFloutist 1y agoThermodynamics only apply to closed systems. Your body can easily expel unprocessed calories/sugar in urine and feces (hence diabetics historically being diagnosed by their characteristically sweet urine). Whether it's more likely than the average human body to do so, to process them for immediate energy, or to process them for longer term storage in conjunction with how it benchmarks your hunger and satiation signals is colloquially known as your "metabolism". Want to tell me next how the laws of mechanical engineering conclusively prove that no one human being can be stronger than another, since we all weigh the same?
- npteljes 1y agoMaybe it shouldn't be surprising, but without the knowledge, the opposite of the thing can be explained the same as the thing itself. For example, "The energy you take in has to go somewhere", but I also poop everyday, so maybe I just poop out the unnecessary calories? I know it works for water soluble vitamins for example. Hindsight is 20/20 in this case. It's nice that the explanation is not complicated ("calories in, calories out"), but many other simple things have been thought of as true, only to be put on their head by science. I welcome the scientific confirmation, and I hold that the path to knowledge it's not straightforward at all.
- just-working 1y agoCalories in, calories out: the pareto-optimized answer to weight loss
- tonymet 1y agoFor most people, a 1 hour moderate run is only about 1-2 cookies worth (and only half a Crumbl cookie). Even a marathon run might only burn 2000 calories . a chipotle burrito is 1600 . In other words, for 95% of people doing activity, they shouldn't eat any surplus if their goal is to maintain or lose weight. It's actually best to do most of your activity undernourished, as it helps develop true intuitive nutrition feedback sensation. You'll start to sense how every macro and salt feels when you ingest it. Loss of this sensation is a major obesity driver. A numbness for nutrients.
- cassepipe 1y agoEating while actually being hungry is a great sensation. That's why I stopped snacking/sugar treats, it always spoil my hunger for when it's meal time. On the other hand, when I have having my meal, no restriction on veggies/meat/fish, open bar, I eat as much as I want. I always welcome hunger knowing that I live in a society of calorie abundance. I generally tend to feel annoyed when people that are hungry start treating like an emergency.
- procaryote 1y agoYou're right that it's easy to out-eat the running you can sustain as a regularly fit person, but there's no "only" about 2000 calories 2000 calories is pretty near the daily calory requirement for a healthy weight human. If you are of healthy weight and eat appropriately, you pretty much have to eat twice as much to compensate for that marathon
- SirFatty 1y agoSomething my doctor has told me on more than one occasion, be he was also quick to add a statement about the importance of exercise for overall fitness. But.. want to lose weigh, change your diet.
- Rendello 1y agoI find when I exercise more, I tend to eat better: - I enjoy running, and eating poorly will affect my ability to run in the short-term, as lots of junk food makes my running experience that day poorer; and - Recently I've started going to the gym. Best to be fairly lean to see those new muscles, though I don't take it to an extreme. I prefer a balance. Shifting the consequences from long to short- and medium-term helps!
- BanazirGalbasi 1y agoTo add: Exercise builds strength, including cardiovascular. Just having a low bodyfat % isn't the epitome of health, there's plenty of facets to focus on. I have a friend with a heart condition, prior to surgery he couldn't even walk 100 ft or stand for more than a minute. He put on significant weight, partially due to lifestyle changes when his heart was failing. Now he _has_ to walk a lot to strengthen his heart again, and he's working on his diet to lose weight as a whole separate component. The walking has nothing to do with weight loss for him, it's purely about strength. I think a lot of people fail to make any kind of distinction there, and they just think of exercise as a way to lose weight.
- bfrog 1y agoAny athlete really knows this to be true. You don't lose weight running/lifting/biking, you lose it in the kitchen. Multi-day hiking forces the issue as you have to carry the kitchen on your back.
- thewebguyd 1y agoYep. This has been pretty much common knowledge as long as I've been alive. As someone who lifts, it's been ingrained in my mind "abs are built in the kitchen, not the gym." Sleep is also a commonly overlooked but incredibly important aspect. You could be busting your ass in the gym, have your diet on point, but not be making gains if you don't sleep or sleep poorly. For hypertrophy focused folks, muscle isn't built in the gym, it's built while you sleep - you tear it down in the gym so that it can rebuild during recovery.
- 0xbadcafebee 1y agoIn other news: a group of scientists announced today the results of their recent study, where they conclude that drowning is not caused by a lack of swimming, but instead seems to be due to water. Other scientists have refuted the claim and point out defects in the study criteria. In response, US officials have pulled funding from the National Science Foundation for any further studies into the causes of drowning, calling any claim of drowning that doesn't end with the sentence "the will of God" as unpatriotic.
- regnull 1y agoAnecdotal evidence: I found that it's super easy to eat way more than you should by just having some food laying around. And I don't mean just Cheetos - "healthy" food will set you back rather quickly as well. The amount of exercise doesn't matter that much - with the calorie density of common snacks, you will out-eat your exercise really fast. I don't think I'm that bad in that sense, but until I started keeping a track of what I eat and the count the calories, nothing worked. Yes it's a hassle, but I vibe-coded an app that does image analysis and tracks your calories. Shameless plug: HeartLens on app store, https://apps.apple.com/us/app/heartlens-your-health-tracker/id6747299126 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/heartlens-your-health-tracker/...
- kelnos 1y agoTotally the case for me too. I used to keep lots of different snacks stocked at home. Eliminating that (except for a few things in small quantities) has been great for weight maintenance for me. At this point there are more treats for our cats in the house than snacks for me.
- josefrichter 1y agoI thought this is common knowledge. 1 Snickers bar = 30 minutes of running. You can lose 100 pounds without getting up from the couch, but you cannot lose 100 pounds by running, if you keep eating Snickers bars.
- recursive 1y agoYou can lose 100 pounds either way.
- larrik 1y agoMore data: I once lost 80 pounds purely through dieting. I really didn't change my exercise habits at all throughout (vs before I dieted). I was partially testing this theory, in fact. This was a decade ago, but I was aware of this line of thinking at the time. Specifically, that dieting is more important for losing weight, and exercising is more important for being healthy (losing weight alone really didn't make me noticeably healthier, btw). I found that, for me, this was entirely true.
- cluckindan 1y agoThe more processed foods one eats, the more one is exposed to PFAS and plasticizers with endocrine activity. That is the smoking gun here, not the amounts of calories people are eating.
- Whatarethese 1y agoCalories in vs Calories out. Just stop eating so much.
- mousethatroared 1y agoOur resting metabolic rate is pretty high. Turns out livers, and brains use a lot of calories. But the value of exercise is that you form more capillary structure to oxygenate blood
- lizardking 1y agoAbs are made in the kitchen, as they say.
- hbn 1y agoThat advice is usually more for people who are already fit but don't have abs. You can maintain a healthy level of fitness by adding some exercise into your life and being mindful of what you eat. But maintaining abs is a whole other project you practically have to center your life around. And indeed, it's mostly a matter of very strict dieting.
- lizardking 1y agoOkay then, how about "you can't outrun a bad diet"? Pick your favorite conventional wisdom fitness aphorism as it applies to you, but it's the same underlying principle.
- hbn 1y agoI think that would be more appropriate, but yes I am aware I'm being a pedant!
- lizardking 1y agoIt wouldn't be HN without some pedantry ;)
- hermitcrab 1y agoThe only time I ever got close to having a 6-pack was from 16 days trekking in the Himalayas, culminating in summitting Mera Peak (~21,000 ft). I did not reduce my calorie consumption. But it was just a temporary change.
- nixass 1y agoIt's dead simple. Calories deficit makes weight loss, everything else is laziness
- mullingitover 1y agoThere is a simple and very low-impact exercise which affects obesity: the fork put-down.
- kelnos 1y agoCitation needed. A quick search suggests this is mainly pushed by influencers and life-coach type people. I'd be incredibly skeptical of anything pushed by people like that, unless it's backed by research... which doesn't seem to be the case here.
- kazinator 1y agoWe already know that in "thin countries", it's not that way because of everyone exercising like mad.
- Steven420 1y agoThis has been known for a very long time and is definitely not news worthy
- stevenwoo 1y agoThis was only proven by Pontzer and others with double labelled water studies when the cost of double labelled water went down enough for testing with humans to become affordable. Initially it was so expensive that only trials with a few small animal subjects were done so doing this large study was impractical until recent years. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0002916523007013 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000291652...
- reassess_blind 1y agoCalories in vs calories out. This isn’t news.
- blu3h4t 1y agoI just lost 50 kilos in 10 months. Quit sugar, walk 10km a day and most importantly ate almost only soup. So kind of low carb vegetable oriented stuff.
- kelnos 1y agoThe 10km per day thing is certainly great for your health, but I suspect you'd still have lost most of that weight if the only change you made was to your diet.
- ozgrakkurt 1y agoThere is a psychological method that I found to be very helpful. Thinking of companies that sell packaged foods as your adversary. They want to take your health, make you addicted to what they are selling and also take your money. Not very different from a drug dealer. When in this mindset, avoiding these things feels like winning and taking care of myself, don’t need to worry about if sugar is really bad or if eating these things is normal. Or if I deserve a treat after working hard all day etc. After some time I just keep winning and losing weight and don’t really have any cravings to eat bad “food”. And fruit tends to be cheaper than packaged food too.
- xacky 1y agoI worked a physically active job from 2003-2015 and was still obese.
- speby 1y agoI think it is very easy for the average person to forget or not realize how incredibly easy it is to get calories into the body and how little food is necessary to do so. Most people in the world (I know, this is not everywhere and everyone), live in an era of food abundance. It's cheap enough, extremely accessible, often easy to eat or ready to eat, and that has simply made it very convenient to get calories in, often while barely thinking about it. Mindless eating, not thinking about what you should eat, etc. All of these factors have played into why obesity is such a problem (at least in the USA).
- mrandish 1y agoN=1 but I lost over 100 pounds in 8 months by changing to a keto diet with zero exercise (consciously going even more sedentary than I already was) and have kept it off for over eight years now. After I reached my ideal weight I restored exercise to my previous normal level (which is minimal but not absolutely sedentary). After a year I slowly transitioned from strict keto to low carb for life. I feel great, look good and my health improved dramatically. Before changing I was on meds for pre-diabetes, high blood pressure and poor HDL/Trig along with having bad apnea and tectonic snoring. All resolved after 8 months and still off the meds today. In the prior decade I'd spent a lot of effort and money trying various diets, including medically supervised, but they were hard, stressful and none worked long term. Even though I've never been athletic or remotely a gym-rat, intentionally going sedentary was an unusual choice because I'd always heard "eat less, move more" but exercise made me hungrier. So when I got serious about doing keto hardcore, I decided to pause even the minimal token "faux exercise" like an occasional pleasure bike-ride or short walk on weekends. Frankly, that occasional, brief exercise probably never did anything in terms of weight loss anyway but it did provide a psychological excuse to slip on diet. So eliminating that excuse and putting all my focus on diet may have been the main benefit of going zero exercise during my weight loss period. After I got below my target 'dream weight', I returned to my usual minimal exercise and since then it's increased even more because now I actually enjoy exercise. It turns out that exercise is a lot more fun when you're not obese and winded after 90 seconds! I think Keto worked for me when other diets hadn't because it's so strict but also brutally simple. I've also always liked the low carb foods like meats and cheeses. As a significant and long-term success case, I'll share my personal "keys to keto success": 1. Commit to doing it hardcore for at least 30 days. 2. Rigorously track every molecule of food intake in a tracking app for the first month. Yep, get measuring spoons and a kitchen scale for weighing things. Think of it as a cool lab experiment and you're the rat. Get used to cooking at home and bringing lunch to work until you get the hang of the low carb lifestyle. 3. For the first week do not track calories, just limit carbs religiously. Seriously, stuff all the calories you want. Steaks drenched in butter and sour cream, a quarter pound of cheddar, whatever. Why? The first week is the hardest and this makes the transition easier. The calories will be much easier after you get control of your blood sugar by limiting carbs. 4. You MUST supplement electrolytes (sodium & potassium) for at least the first week. "Keto Flu" is real, excruciating and so easy to avoid. I didn't take all the warnings seriously and failed my first attempt at keto in utter misery after just 38 hours. 5. Start on a quiet weekend where you can just focus on this from Fri afternoon to Mon morning. 6. Absolutely, positively DO NOT CHEAT on carbs for the first 30 days. Keto is different because the first 3-ish days of transitioning off carbs are pretty hard. If you cheat, you'll keep having to redo some or all of that transition over and over. It's like crossing a wall of fire. You can get through it fine the first time with focus and planning but you definitely do not want to be wobbling back and forth through it. Keto works because strictly limiting carbs controls blood sugar which reduces hunger making cutting calories much easier. If you need to cheat, cheat on calories not on carbs. It's not as hard as it sounds. Just get past the first month and it all gets a lot easier. The results come fast. I lost 10 pounds in 10 days and 20 pounds in 30, which provides a lot of motivation! At around six weeks I became 'fat-adapted' which is a long-term metabolic transition to primarily burning fat instead of carbs (glucose) for energy. It felt absolutely amazing in every way - physically, mentally and emotionally, like nothing I'd ever experienced before. I was mentally sharper, physically quicker and emotionally more grounded in a positive mode. Everything just felt and worked better in subtle but tangible, meaningfully real ways. It made me never want to go back to living inside a primarily carb-adapted metabolism. Of course, I hadn't physically craved carbs since the first month and by around 60 days my old habitual eating patterns and reflexes had faded. Then at around 90 days my palate shifted, meaning I even lost my taste for carbie foods. If I tried a small bite of something carb-laden that I'd loved my whole life, it didn't even taste particularly good to me anymore. I also became hyper-sensitive to sugar. Sugar-soaked foods just taste poisonously over-sweetened (which they kind of are). A normal apple now tastes as sweet as I'd ever want, like a dessert that has extra sugar-added. For most of my life my weight was a metabolic mystery seemingly out of my control. Today, it's hard to even remember what it was like being a slave to my raging blood sugar and constant hunger. Now I feel closely attuned to my body. This makes my weight and appearance an almost trivial conscious choice. Fortunately, going low-carb is a lot easier today than when I started in 2017. There are many more delicious low-carb food choices at the grocery and everyone has heard of keto so it's not as weird. Even Wal-Mart has a selection of keto-breads and, recently, bagels! Standard disclaimer: Every metabolism is different and what worked so effectively for me may not work as well for you.
- 42772827 1y ago>"For decades we've been telling Americans that you're lazy, it's your fault, you're not moving enough, you're eating too much," Mozaffarian says. "And I think what this study shows is that there's really complicated biology happening and that our food is driving this." The industry that invented the bliss point [0] has every reason to blame the individual and not the system they created. One quibble: the article blames ultraprocessed foods, but that's not a category of foods with a stable definition. What we do know is that food has been engineered to be more delicious and less filling, so staying away from those foods is a better way to think about it. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bliss_point_(food) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bliss_point_(food)
- slantaclaus 1y agoThis is not a new finding