4 ms·
Shale Drillers Turn on Each Other as Toxic Water Leaks Hit Biggest US Oil Field
- soyNsurf 1y ago[flagged]
- bickfordb 1y agoWhen I read things like this, I'm amazed that 50% of the nation thinks this practice is preferable to solar and windmills
- jagged-chisel 1y agoIt’s only preferable because they’re doing their best to annoy their political rivals.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 1y agohttps://archive.today/gaQ5x https://archive.today/gaQ5x
- billfor 1y agoIs it really a lot of water? There are significant variations but I thought, as a broad generalization, an average fracking well uses, in its lifetime, about as much water as an average golf course in two weeks.
- tokyolights2 1y agoFTA > pumped so much fluid underground in the Permian Basin that it leaked into a prolific oil-producing layer of rock, making it all but impossible to extract crude, according to an April court filing. > The Permian produces almost as much oil as Iraq and Kuwait combined. But its wells generate up to five barrels of chemical-laden waste fluid for every barrel of crude, creating a growing disposal challenge. its a lot of water
- moomin 1y agoI have no idea if your rule of thumb is accurate but you’re not comparing like with like. The problems being described here are to do with the disposal of contaminated wastewater. Whatever you think of golf courses, dealing with the wastewater is a pretty solved problem.
- codingdave 1y agoThat is not a fair comparison... not that I love the high use of golf courses, either, but at least that use is just water. It flows back into the water cycle, and thereby can be re-used infinitely. But fracking water has been poisoned. It removes the infinite re-use and makes it into toxic waste.
- ryao 1y agoThe water cycle involves a natural distillation. Distillation removes pollutants, so the water can be reused.
- jasonephraim 1y agoAt least in Colorado, they use "injection wells" to inject the fracking liquids deep below aquifers. This water does not (at least, by design) re-enter the water cycle. It is permanently sequestered in deep geologic formations.
- chiffre01 1y agoAccording to the USGS: Water use per well can be anywhere from about 1.5 million gallons to about 16 million gallons. I think a Golf course might use a bit more per year, but this is per well and the state of Texas has 279,615 active oil and gas wells. Not sure of all of them are fracking wells or not.
- freejazz 1y ago> about as much water as an average golf course in two weeks. That's a lot of water, no?
- maxglute 1y agoChatgpt napkin math, entire lifetime of US shale water uses is ~2% of annual US agriculture irrigation (300k wells, 5 million gallons per well, 1.5 trillion gallons lifetime) Or About 1 year worth of US almond production.
- conception 1y ago1.5 trillion gallons removed from our fresh water reserves and out of the water cycle. Doesn’t seem great!
- joules77 1y ago[flagged]
- tomrod 1y agoUnsurprising. Over a decade ago I was searching for a dissertation topic and a self-reporting fracking site had come online (only CO and TX were required to track IIRC) that showed promise for helping to assess impact. Before jumping blindly into the data, I interviewed several former field workers and engineering professors. The consistent narrative was that water spills with the fracking chemicals where extremely common and only had to be reported under a very limited set of situations, if they were even reported at all. To the person, the field hands were personally worried about future cancers and other health conditions. All the field hands had since moved on to graduate school themselves, several in medicine. Further, not all the chemicals being leaked, spilled, or entered into the water supply via bad casings were reported, as any that had trade secrets (at the time and to the best of my recollection) were excluded. EDIT: https://archive.is/gaQ5x https://archive.is/gaQ5x
- jasonephraim 1y agoIn Colorado, that’s starting to change, but it’s far from resolved. Following SB 19-181, the Colorado Oil & Gas Conservation Commission (now ECMC) overhauled many rules. One rule now requires operators to disclose all chemicals used in fracking and in spills, including trade secret ingredients, but there's a catch: They still don’t have to reveal the exact chemical identity to the public — only to regulators and, in limited cases, medical professionals. Additionally: The rule rollout has been slow, and compliance remains spotty. There's no standardized enforcement mechanism to verify what’s actually used on-site. If a spill happens, the data available to the public is still often vague or incomplete — and trade secret protections can render the chemical list nearly meaningless if you're trying to assess toxicity. (As we've tried, ourselves)
- iancmceachern 1y agoI was part of a forensic engineering team that did some accident reconstruction for an insurance company after a worker backed their truck into a franking tank and caused it to break open and flood a farmers field and home. The amounts of water involved are truly remarkable.
- fsckboy 1y ago>Unsurprising. Over a decade ago I was searching for a dissertation topic and a self-reporting fracking site... it's unsurprising because in all human endeavors, success has many parents, while failure is always an orphan. Has nothing to do with fracking.
- chiffre01 1y agoDrill baby drill ?
- jeffbee 1y agoBookmark it as a reply for the next time someone tries to claim that end-of-life wind turbine blades are a major waste problem in West Texas. Like these idiots https://www.texasmonthly.com/news-politics/sweetwater-wind-turbine-blades-dump/ https://www.texasmonthly.com/news-politics/sweetwater-wind-t...
- nocoiner 1y agoHorrifying. That beautiful property at the corner of Industrial Drive and Robert E. Lee Street has been desecrated. Will Sweetwater ever recover?
- setr 1y agoThis article seems perfectly valid? They aggregated all of the blades, and it’s ugly, and it Sweetwater never actually gets to processing (eg bankrupts), it’s effectively permanent. Though I don’t see why sweetwater cant simply put up a fence and call it a day
- jeffbee 1y agoThere are fields of unneeded pipes in the area that are multiple times as large as this little lot full of fiberglass, and unlike the fiberglass the drilling pipes are contaminated with heavy metals from the "thread compound" which is 30% lead. Spending any time or attention to the supposed waste of wind energy in West Texas is completely ridiculous, and lending any credence to it as a valid issue is to be a pawn in the petrochemical propaganda game.
- antisthenes 1y agoI opened the article, read '30 acres of wind turbine blades' and immediately closed it. Come on, 30 acres in Texas? What a nothingburger compared to the footprints of other dirty industries.
- jeffbee 1y agoHere's a 300-acre pipe yard. https://www.google.com/maps/@31.8107601,-102.3917116,2359m/data=!3m1!1e3?hl=en&entry=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI1MDcxNi4wIKXMDSoASAFQAw%3D%3D https://www.google.com/maps/@31.8107601,-102.3917116,2359m/d... 30 acres is probably, what, 2 H-E-B parking lots?
- davidw 1y ago[flagged]
- sgt101 1y agoThe peak and decline of US oil production is going to be one of the geopolitical stories of the next 25 years. If US renewables and nuclear don't fill the gap the need for global naval dominance is going to come knock knock knocking again. It looks very like there are three factors that are going to mean that reasserting dominace isn't just very hard: - Missile tech has advanced and proliferated. - US ship building is crippled, and expanding it (especially where needed) is going to be very difficult. Basically the US is going to need a lot of SSN and it won't be able to make them. - There is a competitor power with sufficient resources to make it a real competition, and a very different conceptualisation of how the world should work.
- downrightmike 1y agoDon't worry, I'm sure they are working to deliver war drones via ICBM
- mempko 1y agoI don't think people realize that at current growth rates we have only 60 to 100 years or oil left. Growth will obviously flatten and decline way before then. The age of oil is over folks.
- cryptonector 1y agoWe've been saying that for 60 years.
- vdupras 1y agoI don't think people care. After all, they don't care about the degradation of our life support, which doesn't have much more than that either, at least at a civilization-sustaining level.
- chasd00 1y ago> The peak and decline of US oil production is going to be one of the geopolitical stories of the next 25 years people have been saying that since the 70s at least. The reason why no one is fracking is because oil/gs is so cheap it's not worth it. If the price rises enough the wells turn back on and everyone starts doing it again. Renewables, demand, and regional stability is keeping prices low so putting in the extra effort fracking requires just isn't worth the return. Google says the average break even price of a fracking well in the Permian Basin (SW Texas) is $65/barrel. And the price of oil as of this comment is $65.98 so that would mean a lot of wells are just sitting there because it's not worth the money to pump.
- mistersquid 1y agoA popular meme YouTuber ("Daily Dose of Internet" [0]) featured a clip of someone lighting their tap water on fire. Commenters explained that flammable water is common in places where fracking pollutants have contaminated the ground water. Among the many examples: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfHcypKLxgc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfHcypKLxgc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LP5fIKqobm0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LP5fIKqobm0 (This is not an example of fracking pollution, according to child comment.) I was stunned, to say the least. [0] https://www.youtube.com/@DailyDoseOfInternet https://www.youtube.com/@DailyDoseOfInternet
- rcxdude 1y ago>Commenters explained that flammable water is common in places where fracking pollutants have contaminated the ground water. I don't think it's the contaminants from the fracking fluid itself, more that you can get natural gas finding its way into the water supply that creates this (and it can happen naturally even without fracking). The stuff in the fluids that's a problem is mainly a problem because it's toxic, not flammable.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- hippich 1y agoFirst video comment from author: The rods in my hot water tank were separating the hydrogen and oxygen. Called electrolysis
- stockresearcher 1y agoPowered water heater anodes are now a thing. Supposedly they can make your water heater last almost indefinitely and get rid of any bad smells from sulfur in the water. Perhaps just a little dangerous if you've got fracking contamination? https://www.corroprotec.com/ https://www.corroprotec.com/
- toomuchtodo 1y ago
- jasonephraim 1y agoI've been involved in a grassroots effort fighting a massive fracking project near our homes in SE Aurora, Colorado. If anyone's curious, I built this site with more details: https://savetheaurorareservoir.org/ https://savetheaurorareservoir.org/ The plan includes over 160 wells across a dozen pads—right next to a major reservoir serving Eastern Denver/Aurora, a Superfund site, a landfill, and a growing suburban community. In April, Chevron had an uncontrolled blowout at their Bishop well in Galeton, CO. Cleanup is still ongoing. Meanwhile, a new study from the Colorado School of Public Health showed increased childhood leukemia risk linked to proximity to oil and gas wells. We've asked regulators to address how their current rules fall short in light of these findings. There are over 40 existing pads nearby, all relying on a small volunteer fire department. We've documented consistent gaps in spill/leak reporting and monitoring. Despite this, the State and County continue approving new pads. We organized over 2,000 public comments against the largest proposed pad—more than any public-works project in County history. Our group was also the first activist group in the state granted “affected party” status to participate in hearings for a Comprehensive Area Plan (CAP). The CAP was approved anyway. So were the well pads. Regulators thank us for our feedback, then move forward regardless. One example: I flagged that a pad's construction would disrupt Mule Deer mating season. The operator paid a $6,000 preemptive fine and got the green light. Another time, I pointed out that a required public document wasn’t posted—an error that should’ve triggered a new comment period. It didn’t. The site was approved after a closed-door session to review the issue with the document not being made available. To borrow from my recent comment: "Lastly, I want to return to a point raised by one of the Commissioners today, drawing a comparison between Commission approval and a driver’s license: that by the time the license is stamped, the tests have been passed and the boxes checked. It’s a fair analogy. In fact, I’ve used it myself to describe both the County and ECMC processes. But I would add this: imagine an applicant standing at the DMV counter, ready to be approved. Now imagine 100 people surrounding them—neighbors, relatives, retired law enforcement, health professionals—each holding documentation of prior violations or evidence of risks, warning that issuing the license could result in injury or death. Would that clerk still confidently apply the stamp?" The pressure to approve these projects seems to outweigh the purpose of the review process itself. We’re still fighting. If you want a real idea of the scope of these operations: Invite you to check out the Colorado GIS mapping tool https://cogccmap.state.co.us/cogcc_gis_online/?lat=39.572042&lon=-104.633938&scale=12000 https://cogccmap.state.co.us/cogcc_gis_online/?lat=39.572042... click the toggle for "directional wellbores" and look north of Denver. Then, look at SE Denver and see how they are starting to build out around my home.