3 ms·
Appreciate you highlighting the need for unions. Hopefully the skilled trades shortage persists indefinitely, otherwise they’d be treated just as you mentioned:
by toomuchtodo 1y ago
Appreciate you highlighting the need for unions. Hopefully the skilled trades shortage persists indefinitely, otherwise they’d be treated just as you mentioned: disposable and interchangeable. The scarcity is the only thing protecting these folks at the moment.
https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/rebuilding-construction-trades-workforce https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/rebuilding-construction-tr...
- sobellian 1y agoThere is so much work for skilled tradesmen that they would rather see more automation so they can take more jobs. Even many unions, e.g. carpenters' unions, think this way. I mean no large group is a monolith so I'm sure one can find opinions either way among tradesmen. But IMO the problem is so big that it's no longer revenue maximizing for anyone, even the workers. By some measures productivity has actually been declining for construction. If that was good for workers then we should just set them to digging a second Panama Canal with spoons.
- earnestinger 1y agoReal men would dig Route 66 canal instead of Panama.
- nine_k 1y agoSoftware engineers have recently had a chance to taste how does it feel to be plentiful and disposable, after decades of shortage.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- seanmcdirmid 1y agoScarcity also creates automation and efficiency pressure. You either get more of that human resource, or you make it so you use less of it, productivity increases also allow for the resources used to make more money without increasing project costs. This is also a very boom/bust industry, so the 2008 bust washed a lot of people out, especially juniors who would be experienced seniors today. A union is not going to protect labor from a building bust, they will stop hiring and the pipeline stalls.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoThere is a housing shortage of between 3.5M and 12M units; there will be no bust for at least the next decade, as housing production rate dropped substantially after the 2008 global financial crisis and did not recover. (typically, union workers go on unemployment during slow periods; this includes electrical linemen/journeymen, automotive, pipe fitters, etc based on first hand conversations with union tradespeople in my examples) Housing Supply and Housing Affordability - https://www.nber.org/papers/w33694 https://www.nber.org/papers/w33694 - April 2025 The Housing Industry Never Recovered From the Great Recession - https://prospect.org/infrastructure/housing/2024-12-11-housing-industry-never-recovered-great-recession/ https://prospect.org/infrastructure/housing/2024-12-11-housi... - December 11, 2024 APM Marketplace: In an uncertain housing market, home builders face a range of challenges - https://www.marketplace.org/story/2024/11/26/in-an-uncertain-housing-market-home-builders-face-a-range-of-challenges#in-an-uncertain-housing-market-home-builders-face-a-range-of-challenges https://www.marketplace.org/story/2024/11/26/in-an-uncertain... - November 26, 2024 U.S. Housing Shortage: Everything, Everywhere, All at Once - https://www.fanniemae.com/research-and-insights/perspectives/us-housing-shortage https://www.fanniemae.com/research-and-insights/perspectives... - October 31st, 2022 Fannie Mae: The U.S. Housing Shortage from a Local Perspective - https://www.fanniemae.com/media/45106/display https://www.fanniemae.com/media/45106/display - October 2022
- zer00eyz 1y ago> There is a housing shortage of between 3.5M and 12M units; The problem with this stat is that the historic data does not support it: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RSAHORUSQ156S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RSAHORUSQ156S The supply is just fine, more so with a declining population, how we use housing has changed dramatically. https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2023/06/more-than-a-quarter-all-households-have-one-person.html https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2023/06/more-than-a-q... U.S. Housing Shortage: Everything, Everywhere, All at Once: that you called out states "While the United States does indeed have a national shortage of affordable housing, every state and city's path to addressing it is relatively unique, and the tools and tactics used to create badly needed new housing supply will have to be tailored." This is a gross understatement of the issue. The problem is voters. No one will vote in more housing, housing benefits for others or more affordable housing. Because the people who vote own homes and go into the voting booth and protect their own interests and assets: https://www.route-fifty.com/management/2022/08/problem-homeowners-being-more-likely-vote/376521/ https://www.route-fifty.com/management/2022/08/problem-homeo... . There isnt a law about having to be a landholder to vote but there is a very strong correlation between the two. Planing and zoning is hyper local, hyper political and very active. This is why mixed use zoning is harder to find, you can't run a garage out of your garage. The is why the "missing middle" is a thing in America. This is why "corporate ownership" of housing wont get fixed (it is a hyper local issue and the people who would show up to vote against it are the same ones whos property prices are being propped up by it).
- kryogen1c 1y ago>> people are bad at their jobs so I fire them > need for unions What in the world? This is the exact opposite use case for unions. Unions help protect workers from single, dominant/ monopolistic employers where workers have no other options and can get taken advantage of. The construction industry is nearly the polar opposite, where there is almost no barrier for entry and the employment space is very competitive, including the ability to start your own business. Construction unions would be an absolute nightmare.
- pjmlp 1y agoConstruction unions do great across European countries. Any company that can take advantage of workers will do it, no need for "dominant/ monopolistic". There is a reason why security measures that put the workers life at risk are almost nonexistent on countries where unions hardly have a presence. No helmets, no eye protection, no masks when dealing with chemicals, bending metal bars with bare hands, no protection shoes, hopping into a ladder alone,.... Some examples of what I have seen in practice.
- rafaelmn 1y ago>Construction unions do great across European countries. Do not know about your country - but over here the construction sites are full of people who couldn't even write the word union (mostly Asian countries like Philippines, Nepal, etc.)
- pjmlp 1y agoGermany, and yes if I go to southern countries, Portugal my home country, alongside the other ones, there is a certain flexibility between the law, unions, and what actually happens at the construction site, unless someone does a complaint to the respective goverment authority responsible for checking worker conditions. I can also add that Scadinavian countries, and UK tend to be similar to Germany. Naturally all of them have black sheeps that ignore good work conditions if they can manage to, that is why work inspections are also a thing. Al