8 ms·
Are Mozilla’s donations still roughly equal to their CEO’s compensation [1][2]? [1] https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/annualreport/2024/article/financin
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
Are Mozilla’s donations still roughly equal to their CEO’s compensation [1][2]?
[1] https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/annualreport/2024/article/financing-an-open-internet-mozillas-path-forward/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/annualreport/2024/a... ”$7.8M in donations from the public, grants from foundations, and government funding” in 2023
[2] https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2022/mozilla-fdn-990-ty22-public-disclosure.pdf https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2022/mozilla-fdn-990... $6.9mm in 2022, page 7
- saurik 1y agoThat's insane :/. But, maybe, "on the bright side", The Mozilla Foundation is unrelated in some sense to Firefox? AFAIK, they don't spend any of their money on it anyway. The whole Mozilla situation is even more of a scam than how the Wikimedia Foundation uses sob stories about paying for Wikipedia to get people to donate money to an entity which spends almost no money on Wikipedia... but, at least it does run Wikipedia! lol :/. There is another interesting detail from your reference that makes it seem even worse to me: it says the CEO's salary is "paid only by a related for-profit"; at first, I was thinking "ok, at least the Foundation in fact is spending the money it is being donated (though, not on Firefox)"... but then I realized that means the Corporation is, in fact, spending $7m that it could have spent on Firefox.
- anonymousab 1y ago> AFAIK, they don't spend any of their money on it anyway The glass-half-full take I heard a while back was: at least every dollar they take from the foundation donations for these causes is a dollar that they could have found a way to take from Firefox development instead.
- hoseja 1y agoEvery dollar they take from the foundation donations for these causes is a dollar that enables them to better sabotage Firefox development actually. If they were starved like cancerous tumour the body might heal and survive.
- margalabargala 1y ago"If we destroy the organization responsible for this thing I like, then only the bad parts of the organization will die and the thing I prefer will become better!" No, if you destroy the flawed-but-sometimes-okay organization you just wind up with something worse. There is no magic save-the-thing-you-like fairy. Large bureaucracies don't "learn their lesson" from being torn down. Vote against increased taxes because the road department already has "such a large budget" and "maybe this will teach them to cut the administrative fat"? No, you'll just wind up with more potholes. Vote for Donald Trump because you think the Federal Government is wasteful and the Democrats need to be taught a lesson? No, you'll just get billionaire tax cuts, erosion of civil liberties, and absolutely no behavior change from the people you wanted to "punish". Everything just gets worse.
- hoseja 1y agoAnd eventually, out of the blue sky, Kali will reach with her crimson palms.
- KPGv2 1y ago> The whole Mozilla situation is even more of a scam than how the Wikimedia Foundation uses sob stories about paying for Wikipedia to get people to donate money to an entity which spends almost no money on Wikipedia... but, at least it does run Wikipedia! lol :/. I don't think these are comparable at all or how it's a scam. The CEO of the entire wikimedia foundation makes half a million a year. The foundation is considered a GREAT charity to donate to by Charity Navigator. https://www.charitynavigator.org/ein/200049703 https://www.charitynavigator.org/ein/200049703
- knome 1y agowikipedia still being around after all this time and still maintaining links to just download the entire thing and having no ads makes whatever they're doing good to me, ha.
- NewJazz 1y agoI love other wikimedia projects like Wiktionary and wiki commons too.
- ashoeafoot 1y agoAnd they do experiment and i think the passion for the society upholding project that is the encyclopedia is still there. Its the same wirh web archive.
- twelvechairs 1y agoWikimedia is run transparently which is great but I dont really believe they need the money when you see their financial statement (link below) and think about what they need to run. Plenty of really deserving charities running on the sniff of an oily rag not paying 100m in salaries plus travel, conferences etc. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/f/f6/Wikimedia_Foundation_2024_Audited_Financial_Statements.pdf https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/f/f6/Wikim...
- 1y ago
- BeetleB 1y agoI don't really understand the angst against the Wikimedia Foundation. They are transparent. No one's being conned into donating. As long as Wikipedia is running fine, and is not degrading, and they're not actively harming it, I don't care. People routinely spend money on much worse things. Is donating $3 to Wikimedia once a year really worse than giving 50-100x more to Starbucks?
- LtWorf 1y ago> No one's being conned into donating You've never seen the banners asking for money to cover the costs of the servers?
- aydyn 1y agoThey're saying its not a con because they agree with it and its a good thing. It's doublespeak, maybe even to themself.
- aspenmayer 1y agoSophists railing against Socrates seems about right.
- Eostan 1y agoPeople get annoyed at them for their massive banners begging for money making it seem like wikipedia is on the verge of being closed down unless you donate despite the fact they have a ton of money they have saved away which could keep wikipedia running for decades. Even long running wiki editors and donators get pissed off with the behavior of the wikimedia foundation as not enough of this money actually seems to get spent on Wikipedia. Kinda similar to the whole Firefox situation now I come to think about it.
- solarkraft 1y ago> No one's being conned into donating They are. The banners are dishonest every year, making it seem like they can barely keep the lights on.
- 1y ago
- KurSix 1y agoMozilla's setup feels more like a shell game
- nick0garvey 1y agoIt says "PAID ONLY BY A RELATED FOR-PROFIT", which looks to be the Mozilla Corporation. Donations are not directly paying the CEO, although I agree more of the profits from the Corporation could flow into the non-profit.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- setopt 1y agoThe reasonable assumption here is that without any donations, most of that money from Mozilla Corp would have had to cover what the donations paid for instead. So in practice, every dollar donated might have increased the CEO bonus by say 90 cents, which feels like donating to the CEO. I currently still use Firefox but stopped donating to Mozilla after that.
- Forgeties79 1y agoI mean if you reduce something enough you can say “x pays for y” in almost any case for anything since it’s all technically one big pot for one group. Even earmarked money. If I give you $500 to help pay for your medical bills and a few months later (bills have been paid by then) I see you bought a PS5, can I say, “not cool you used my money to buy a PS5”? Don’t get me wrong I think Mozilla/FF has been very poorly managed. But I have just never liked these kinds of “transitive property” arguments or whatever we want to call it. Unless they’re straight up funneling donations into the CEO’s bank account I just don’t see it that way.
- ozgrakkurt 1y agoYou could say “you bought a ps5 with my money” though. If that person had the money, they should have spent on medical bills. If they got it after, they should have paid you back before buying a ps5 maybe. Or if you just gave them the money and don’t expect any accountability, it is ok.
- sothatsit 1y agoBut that's the whole point: they did pay their medical bills. It's not like they didn't pay their medical bills and instead bought a ps5. They did both. Mozilla develops Firefox, and they also pay their CEO a lot. Their CEO may be overpaid, the company may be mismanaged, but at least they are still upholding their commitment to maintaining Firefox. Picking out one expense that you don't like and saying "all the donations go to this, see!" is just disingenuous. Whether donating is worthwhile is another question, and it seems like the answer would be no. But it is a very different thing to say "All the donations just go to the CEO" instead of "I think the CEO is paid too much". We could also cherry-pick in the other direction and say the CEO is negotiating deals to bring in the 90% of non-donation revenue of Mozilla, in which case you could easily say that his pay is a result of that revenue creation.
- rishav_sharan 1y agoI think the key here is that they didn't have money to do both. If they had money enough for medicine, then why beg for donation?
- c0nducktr 1y agoWow, I could run a brand into the ground for far less than $6.9mm.
- MathMonkeyMan 1y agoBut could you do it while convincing yourself and everyone you're beholden to that you're not?
- theteapot 1y agoIsn't that most software devs?
- KurSix 1y ago$6.9M just seems like overkill
- redeeman 1y agoi dont know, the way they have managed to consistently roll down a hill that seemingly is the wrong one, despite how obviously it could have been done better, is frankly quite impressive
- thesuitonym 1y agoAnd that's why you're unqualified to be a CEO: Never offer to do something for less money.
- ramsj 1y agoMeredith Whittaker at Signal made < $800K [1]. I can't fathom how $6.9M is even remotely acceptable. [1] https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/824506840 https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/824...
- echelon 1y agoA plant from Google. Firefox is an antitrust litigation sponge, but you have to keep it rudderless and ineffective.
- eecc 1y agoHow on point. In my limited career I have been in several projects whose plight didn't make any sense -- with all the smart people and the effort poured over them, how could the disaster continue to unfold! -- until I realized failure rather than success was the goal.
- shmeeed 1y agoIMO that's basically all there is to say about FF, sadly. Any other speculation and commentary seem moot to me. I'll still keep using it for as long as I can, though.
- novaRom 1y agoWho else? I wonder what other companies play such role?
- motorest 1y ago> Firefox is an antitrust litigation sponge, but you have to keep it rudderless and ineffective. I don't know what makes you believe Firefox is ineffective. It's by far the best browser around. What do you think is missing?
- sickofparadox 1y agoThe people using it.
- guelo 1y agoShe's not the ceo anymore.
- Sephr 1y agoThe new CEO isn't any better. According to their first CEO (Brendan Eich) "Mozilla is being looted now, mitchell taking $38M+ out over 9 years was just a start"
- KurSix 1y agoMakes it hard to justify chipping in as a user. Transparency is great, but alignment with mission matters more.
- giancarlostoro 1y agoIf you cut that compensation in half you could have funded a small team of devs to have finished Oxidation of Firefox and have a really interesting browser, and potentially a really rich GUI stack, JavaScript Engine and who knows what else for Rust itself as a result, on top of it all being production ready and proven because of the nature of Firefox's reach. There were major noticeable speed differences in Firefox when they implemented key component in Rust. I say this having used Firefox since 2004.
- ekr____ 1y ago> If you cut that compensation in half you could have funded a small team of devs to have finished Oxidation of Firefox and have a really interesting browser, and potentially a really rich GUI stack, JavaScript Engine and who knows what else for Rust itself as a result, on top of it all being production ready and proven because of the nature of Firefox's reach. I'm not sure exactly what you have in mind here but this really isn't true for basically any plausible value of "finished Oxidation of Firefox". As context for scale, during the Quantum Project, Mozilla imported two major pieces of Servo: Stylo and WebRender. Each of these involved sizable teams and took years of effort, and yet these components (1) started from pre-existing work that had been done for Servo and (2) represent only relatively small fractions of Gecko. Replacing most of the browser -- or even a significant fraction of it -- with Rust code would be a far bigger undertaking.
- giancarlostoro 1y agoI mean it could take longer sure, but the funding would still be there ;)
- ekr____ 1y agoNo, not really. It's just not even in the same order of magnitude in terms of level of effort.