3 ms·
> neither side has a viable air force. If one of them had, it could win the war simply by theatre isolation Ok, why isn't EU/NATO helping Ukraine with an airfo
by amelius 1y ago
> neither side has a viable air force. If one of them had, it could win the war simply by theatre isolation
Ok, why isn't EU/NATO helping Ukraine with an airforce then?
- anovikov 1y agoBecause with air force, critical asset is both people and planes. Just planes is not enough. You can't train pilots not having planes yes, but when you got planes, hard part starts, not ends. It will take many years to have prepared Ukrainian pilots to go into hostile airspace SEAD missions. No one except USAF can do it today. It requires very complex collaboration of many different assets in a manner that is incredibly lengthy and expensive to train for. This is why America leads in it: it has time, space, and cash. There's no way to shortcut it. This is also why Russia concentrates on ground-based SAMs and it's air force is shit: because training SAM operators is cheap and quick. They provide good defence. Ukraine has the same, for same reason. So they are stuck hitting each other with drones because none can do an air offensive.
- amelius 1y agoThis does not answer the question, though.
- anovikov 1y agoIn light of my answer, only way it can help is direct participation with their own units, not just supplying equipment. This is a line West is not ready to cross. Especially since it will only have considerable effect if Westnern planes with Western crews operate over internationally recognised Russian territory (over Ukraine-controlled territory Ukrainian air force dominates as it is, over occupied territory, there are few military significant assets). It means going from a proxy war to a real war.
- amelius 1y ago> over occupied territory, there are few military significant assets Are you sure about that? I'd say that the war could be ended rather quickly if Russians were attacked the moment they set foot on Ukrainian land. Also, an air force could destroy supply lines going deep into Ukraine.
- corimaith 1y agoBecause they are scared of Putin firing nukes. Also training an air force takes alot of time and money, only USA and China can really do it tbh.
- amelius 1y ago> Because they are scared of Putin firing nukes. I think the only reason to be scared of Putin firing nukes is if he or the existence of Russia was threatened in some way. But he can stop this war any time he likes.
- ExoticPearTree 1y agoAnd what a good strategy be like?
- amelius 1y agoMaking Putin understand that this war leads him nowhere, without going as far as threatening the existence of Russia. This means US/NATO planes above Ukraine are OK, but not above Russia.
- ExoticPearTree 1y agoAnd those planes should do what over Ukraine?
- amelius 1y agoPut simply, bomb enemy ground forces.
- ExoticPearTree 1y agoAha, US/NATO jets bombing Russians. Sure, seems like a solid plan.
- oldpersonintx2 1y ago[dead]
- IAmBroom 1y agoBecause of politics. This war has been nothing but a blessing to the West. Putin's forces and weapons have been very publicly tested (and failed expectations). His reserves are being drained; in some cases emptied. Western weapon systems are being field-tested, at the low-low cost of their purchase cost, plus shipping and handling. It took a while for me to realize that the West doesn't want Ukraine to win, outright. First, they want Ukraine to bleed Putin until he's too feeble to stand. That will take a while.