10 ms·
The fish kick may be the fastest subsurface swim stroke yet (2015)
- bryancoxwell 1y agoVery cool. Should probably have a (2015) though.
- cjcenizal 1y agoAmazing! This is about the dolphin kick performed on its side, rechristened “the fish kick.” I couldn’t fathom (ha) why the same kick rotated 90 degrees could be faster but it turns out that the kicking motion is constrained by the motion of the water around it. In the dolphin kick, the water moves up and down and is limited by the water’s surface and pool’s bottom. The swimmer frees themself of these constraints by turning on their side.
- bravesoul2 1y agoDoes that give advantage to those in the middle lanes?
- pfooti 1y agoThey should just make the pool wider with a big unused area on either side.
- onlypassingthru 1y agoAny turbulence created by waves and vortices smashing into hard surfaces is going to slow the swimmer down. To paraphrase an old adage, smooth is fast.
- mojomark 1y agoI'm inclined to concur with onlypassingthrough. If the resulting wake is similar to fish locomotion (e.g. thunniform or similar) vortices will shed off in a Karmen Vortex Street that spreads laterally with distance behind the swimmer (potentially into other lanes, and propulsive efficiency of propulsors are generally less efficient in turbulant vice laminar open-water flow... but not always, it can depend on the 'structure' [how chaotic] the flow is). The magnitude of the energy in that turbulent wake will depend on how efficiently the oscillating fin interacts with water over time to produce forward thrust. The cool thing about oscillating foils as opposed to rotating thrusters, is that when the fin 'swoops' once it creates Vortex 'A' spinning clockwise, and when it 'swoops' back the result would be a Vortex 'B' spinning counterclockwise, and the two vortices will partially cancel out. That cancellation serves to recover energy from Vortex 'A' and the energy is transferred back into forward thrust. In other words, fish tails create trails of contrarotating vortices and continually push off of them. It's like walking up a springy staircase, where each step you make, a little energy is recovered to bounce you up to the next step. In theory, if you had a swimmer in front of you, generating a Karmen Vortex Street and not effectively canceling out those vortices, but instead just shedding vortices, you can use the energy from the swimmer in front of you to 'spring' yourself forward - barely using any energy yourself. Those complex hyrdodynamic relationships could be why some swimmers/flyers tend to fly in specific formations with other animals in their school/flock. Bottom line, I would bet that any residual vortices that spread into adjacent swimming lanes will tend to interact chaotically and result in unstructured turbulance, which should yield less optimal swimming conditions for swimmers in those lanes.
- onlypassingthru 1y ago>you can use the energy from the swimmer in front of you to 'spring' yourself forward This bears out in the real world. Much like a peloton in cycling, swimming directly behind another swimmer can be far more energy efficient than swimming by yourself and feel like you are getting pulled along for the ride.
- nradov 1y agoEven swimming slightly offset another swimmer saves significant energy. It also reduces the chance of getting kicked in the face. We do this when possible during triathlon open water swims.
- pdonis 1y ago> you can use the energy from the swimmer in front of you to 'spring' yourself forward When I swam competitively in the early 1980s, we did this during workouts; we'd all swim in a line with very close spacing, and switch off who was in front after every lap (two lengths--this was in a 25 meter pool). Being in front you could feel the extra work you were doing.
- analog31 1y agoIndeed, and as a consequence there are rules for who gets which lane.
- foobarbecue 1y agoMiddle lanes are faster, and for some reason swimmer with the fastest record gets the middle in most events, which always seemed weird to me -- it's a positive feedback system. Seems like you should give the advantage to the people who are behind, not ahead... but that's common in sports and in modern society for some reason.
- Scarblac 1y agoIt's strange to reward slower contestants in sports.
- sim7c00 1y agoyeah, otherwise good ppl will do bad in qualifiers to get good position...
- koolba 1y agoReminds me of the final boss in Smash Bros. If you purposefully let him whip you at first, the adaptive play would nerf him enough to let you easily finish him.
- pfortuny 1y agoIIRC Ecclestone suggested getting rid of qualifiers and just putting the F1 cars n the inverse order of their last race. This idea was in order to get more overtakes (the best parts of F1 races). I think it would be great.
- bravesoul2 1y agoMakes sense. More interest in F1. More money for Bernie.
- philistine 1y ago1. Ecclestone has been out of the sport for nearly a decade. 2. A race weekend is a three-day affair, with tickets sold for each day. What do you do on Saturday if there are no qualifs?
- fracus 1y agoYou can't reward failure in competition. You will get people purposely going slower to get the middle lanes. What they could swim in a pool in which they aren't using the outer lanes, so bigger pools, or less swimmers.
- xarope 1y agothe rescue/combat side stroke is very efficient too, and that's due to the very large kick you can use since you are sideways
- MengerSponge 1y ago(2015 article) I get that it's a quirk of the sport's history, but it's funny and dumb that swimming awards medals and records for being the fastest at a slower stroke. It's like if track meets would have a 100m sprint, a 100m skip, and a 100m run-backwards. If I could change things in the world, I wouldn't eliminate the extraneous strokes in swimming, but I would include additional competitions in all the track distances: backwards running, handstand walk, and one-legged hopping.
- nkrisc 1y agoSeeing backwards running races would be impressive. Seeing the fastest human runners is also very impressive, but it’s also less interesting in a sense because they’re doing exactly what our bodies evolved to be able to do. It is interesting to see that ability pushed to its natural limits, but I think it’s a bit more interesting to see people excel in things we didn’t evolve to do: like swimming or running backwards.
- bravesoul2 1y agoDiagonal running!
- aleph_minus_one 1y ago> Seeing backwards running races would be impressive. For cars, such races seem to exist (have existed?) in the Netherlands: > Dutch Reverse Racing > https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lLgPTJWAysY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lLgPTJWAysY These kinds of races seemed to be popular in the Netherlands because DAF (a Dutch manufacturer) produces the Variomatic transmission system > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variomatic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variomatic "Because the system does not have separate gears, but one (continuously shifting) gear and a separate 'reverse mode' (as opposed to reverse gear), the transmission works in reverse as well, giving it the side effect that one can drive backwards as fast as forwards. As a result, in the former Dutch annual backward driving world championship, the DAFs had to be put in a separate competition because no other car could keep up."
- djmips 1y ago
- nkrisc 1y agoI thought the comparison to running was interesting. As an almost exclusively terrestrial mammal, there is a very natural way for us to run. No one is going to discover than running on our arms and legs is faster, or something other than ”unnatural” way of running is faster. But that’s not really the case with swimming. We didn’t evolve a natural swimming instinct or form for speed. When I learned that (nearly?) all terrestrial mammals can swim to some degree (even ones that look like they shouldn’t be able to - like ungulates), I was a bit surprised, but it’s not too surprising upon reflection. But that got me thinking then: what is the best terrestrial mammalian body plan that also happens to be good for swimming? What terrestrial mammal would also be fast swimmers if they could learn and train for it as humans do? Maybe my thinking is clouded by anthrocentrism, but the human body plan which is good for bipedal running also seems to work out pretty well for swimming. Of course, top human swimming speeds are pretty terrible compared to human running speeds and the swimming speed of basically any other aquatic animal, but we’re not made for it!
- ethan_smith 1y agoBears, particularly polar bears, are terrestrial mammals with impressive swimming capabilities - they can swim up to 60 miles without rest and use a modified dog paddle that's remarkably efficient.
- seszett 1y agoTo be precise though the species is called Ursus maritimus and it is often considered a semi-aquatic species rather than just a terrestrial mammal.
- CorrectHorseBat 1y ago>No one is going to discover than running on our arms and legs is faster, or something other than ”unnatural” way of running is faster. Surprisingly not everyone seems to be convinced of that https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4928019/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4928019/
- 1y ago
- comrade1234 1y ago> I reach out to Misty Hyman, who won gold in the 2000 Olympics... Her name always makes me laugh because I then think about her brother's name: Buster.
- bravesoul2 1y agoMisty could mean smoky too!
- _9ptr 1y agoHave you ever heard of Fanny Chmelar?
- maxden 1y agoIn what sport does she compete for Germany? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_Klz5qncZQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_Klz5qncZQ
- owenversteeg 1y agoMany years later, Bradley Walsh actually met Fanny Chmelar: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rb-DYY0upBo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rb-DYY0upBo
- sebastiennight 1y agoCan a native English speaker please explain this thread to me? (and any other lost ESL readers) I've tried reading all these names out loud and don't get what's funny.
- _9ptr 1y agoFanny Chmelar is pronounced "Fanny Schmeller", which sounds a bit like "Fanny Smeller"
- fainpul 1y agoReminds me of the fascinating efficiency of fish, where even a dead fish can swim upstream, given the right kind of vortices. I wonder how much potential for improvement there still is for the human body. https://fyfluiddynamics.com/2018/07/when-i-was-a-child-my-father-would-take-me-trout/ https://fyfluiddynamics.com/2018/07/when-i-was-a-child-my-fa...
- swarnie 1y agoWhat improvements are you thinking? I see three avenues: 1) Clothing - Already banned in the Olympics 2) Medication - Also officially banned in the Olympics but the Enhanced Games look like a promising test bed. 3) Go full Cult Mechanicum?
- fainpul 1y agoI was thinking of optimized movement patterns to increase efficiency / reduce wasted energy. This numberphile video explains how fish and other swimming animals barely lose any energy, even though they create vortices, because the vortices are in turn used to propel the fish forward. https://youtu.be/wYDh5d9pfu8?si=TkPs2xcngduz_Qem&t=600 https://youtu.be/wYDh5d9pfu8?si=TkPs2xcngduz_Qem&t=600
- trhway 1y agogrowing your body optimized for swimming. The training is one thing. I mean shaping your body into the hydrodynamically optimized form, like say growing some muscles (or fat - shaping yourself into a more dolhpin like shape :) here and there mostly for the purpose of better resulting hydrodynamic shape. With the medicine advances it may start earlier in life and be non-catchable by the sports authorities. And, if you look at one of the Chinese Olympic winners last year - the wave in front of him was significantly smaller than in front of anybody else. Have no idea how he achieved that though.
- onlypassingthru 1y agoIIRC, the backstroke races at the 1996 Olympics were pushing the boundaries of human potential as competitors swam some or all of the races underwater. The optics of an underwater race were not good (ha!). As a result, FINA made it mandatory to surface and compete in actual backstroke instead of underwater dolphin kick.
- fouronnes3 1y agoReally would love to see a true freestyle category — with the 15m rule removed. I'm curious why it's not a thing.
- NooneAtAll3 1y agolet's start by not disallowing butterfly underwater restriction at least makes safety sense - stroke restrictions do not
- onlypassingthru 1y agoI think the rule was created because underwater racing is not that interesting to watch for spectators and more difficult to officiate from the surface. Maybe all we need is a bunch of GoPros stuck around the pool and we can see a new race category?
- fouronnes3 1y agoBeing interesting for participants is not enough?
- onlypassingthru 1y agoAside from swimmers themselves, nobody else cares about competitive swimming outside of the Olympics.
- viburnum 1y agoA swim coach told me that in 1950s people used to do the first lap of breaststroke underwater but people kept passing out. It wasn't safe for youth sports.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- xhkkffbf 1y agoThe real reason is safety. People have known about the efficiency of swimming under water for the longest time, but competitors would pass out or even die when they held their breath too long. So the rules changed to force people to the surface.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- yawpitch 1y agoHmm, divers have known the dolphin kick for years (decades?) as a way to move underwater at speed, but you’re rarely near the surface or the bottom to have effects from the surface interfaces. Interesting.
- lacrosse_tannin 1y agoThey have dynamic apnea competitions. It's in the freedive scene not swim/race scene. I'm not sure if turning sideways is popular there. If people start racing underwater, there will probably lots of blackouts.
- refulgentis 1y agoDumb q, never learned to swim and don't understand the sport contextually. Given: "Some especially strong underwater swimmers stayed submerged almost the entire length of the pool, since there was no rule against it. That all changed in 1998, when FINA, the world governing body of competitive swimming, ruled that swimmers performing the backstroke had to surface after 15 meters." This is used to explain a conclusion used throughout the rest of the article, namely, the dolphin/fish strokes aren't useful in competitive swimming because people using them have to surface. But I don't understand: the rule says swimmers performing the backstroke have to surface, and when I look up backstroke, it is someone laying on their back? Which doesn't sound like either of these
- senkora 1y agoThese short videos should clear it up: Backstroke start technique: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xwq-IsGNa28 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xwq-IsGNa28 Backstroke flipturn technique: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B-WNtRGwSjQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B-WNtRGwSjQ Underwater dolphin kicks can be done on your front, back, or (I guess) side, so it also works for backstroke. And the way that starts and turns work in backstroke still puts you underwater at the start of each lap.
- snowwrestler 1y ago> the rule says swimmers performing the backstroke have to surface, and when I look up backstroke, it is someone laying on their back? Which doesn't sound like either of these The updated rules essentially say a swimmer in a "backstroke race" must perform the backstroke for 35 meters. Prior to this rule, top swimmers would stay underwater for most of a length and only do a few actual back strokes before their flip turn. In other words, before this rule they mostly were not performing the backstroke, despite the name of the race.
- refulgentis 1y agoAhhhh, after reading this, I think the part I was missing is swimming events aren't general w/r/t method i.e. I'm familiar with track and field - it's "transport yourself X distance, fastest time wins" With swimming, its "transport yourself X distance using method Y" And you could have used the methods described in a race where method Y == backstroke at some point, as the requirements for backstroke were such that you just did a couple things quick, then could go underwater and do your thing till you finish...but that workaround is no longer available given the 15m rule. (ty all)
- manithree 1y agoI must be way above the median age here if I'm the first to mention how much this looks like what when I was a teenager we called the "Man from Atlantis" stroke. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Man_from_Atlantis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Man_from_Atlantis
- kevbin 1y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mTn59Ud77k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mTn59Ud77k
- PaulHoule 1y agoPersonally I think finswimming is the way to make up for humans being land animals. Fins can extend the range I can swim at least 20x to what I can do without them.
- BrenBarn 1y ago> “It’s hard to fathom that this could happen in track and field,” says Rick Madge, a swim coach and blogger. This was an amusing comment considering it is pretty much exactly what happened with the Fosbury Flop. Cool article though. I wonder if eventually a new event will be added for it in competitive swimming.
- empiricus 1y ago20 years ago when I was learning to swim by myself (spoiler: i still do not swim) I had the intuition that a movement like this would work. I actually felt it in muscles, not sure how to better explain it. Very similar to preparing for a climbing route. But after a couple of complete failures I gave up.
- trhway 1y agoi'd guess it is faster than the physically the same, just 90 degree rotated, dolphin kick only because of the proximity to the surface - in the dolphin kick significant energy gets wasted as the surface wave (i.e. instead of pushing yourself from the large mass of water, you push the smaller amount of water above you into a surface wave, the same reason you want your boat prop to be as deep as possible). My bet would be that the fish and dolphin kicks would give the same performance if both performed at sufficient depth, like 5-10 meters.