11 ms·
Conspiracy theorists unaware their beliefs are on the fringe
- PaulHoule 1y agoLove the use of ‘false conspiracy’ which has been an increasingly popular phrase in conspiracism research.
- bell-cot 1y agoIIR, it was the Bavarian Illuminati who first used that phrase - as part of a double-false-flag op (run through their Society For Truth, before they lost control of that front org to the Invisible Emperor's Legion of Elba). /s?
- js8 1y agoRight. I think a "conspiracy theory" is more than just a theory about some conspiracy. I think an important attribute of conspiracy theories is that they are unfalsifiable. Any piece of evidence or witness against them is either labeled to be in the conspiracy or being fooled by it. Conspiracy theories are thus logically self-consistent theories, which effectively exclude all evidence against them as invalid. Therefore, it's impossible to counter them rationalistically, they can only be countered empirically.
- LargoLasskhyfv 1y agoI need to work harder on my zen, to produce better qualia in my solipsism.
- lastcat743 1y agoStrange, I observed the very conspiracy culture absorb main stream governance and sociological narratives. I do believe their coup worked. Next the views asserting this move into fringe conspiracy and the ouroboros continues devouring its own.
- PaulHoule 1y agoAs I see it, Donald Trump was factually false but Kamala Harris was emotionally false. As a rhetorician, if I had to choose one or the other, I’d pick the first. [1] I am thinking a lot of how to explain the ‘emotionally false’ bit to those who don’t bellyfeel it but it will probably be another two years or so before I have an explanation that’s transmissible. [1] but I am not just a rhetorician!
- pjc50 1y agoIsn't that entirely a product of which news channels the voters were watching?
- PaulHoule 1y agoNo. A facial expression that comes 0.5 seconds after it should can create a perception of inauthenticity as can the use of measured-seeming words. (Yet, an emotional expression that breaks gradually can be the most powerful of all —- Biden’s performance where he feels how “you’re fired” makes him feel or Pelosi’s tears at Trump inauguration 2 hit hard in a way that her usual mask never does) If there was anything characteristic about Biden to Trump voters it was that they didn’t watch or read the news much at all https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/democrats-need-to-face-why-trump-won/id1548604447?i=1000699618199 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/democrats-need-to-face... Klein would say he got a huge amount of hate mail from people who said the Times was not putting up strident enough headlines (won’t use the F-word or N-word for Trump) but that the kind of people who read the Times weren’t that the kind of people who need to be persuaded. Psychoanalysis has been out of fashion for 50+ years but I also think a presidential candidate who looks like your mom evokes feelings of helplessness you had a a child which has to do why I couldn’t stand Clinton II and many blacks couldn’t stand Harris. In two years of chewing on it and people coming around I will have emotional and factual truth reconciled more than I have it now.
- catlover76 1y ago[dead]
- 1y ago
- BLKNSLVR 1y agoSemi-related: I'm currently interested in how people get into the seemingly closed and endless maze of believing in things that are relatively provably incorrect or at odds with their own interests. My daughter has recently been diagnosed with an eating disorder, and she cannot get past wanting to lose weight, no matter that she's in hospital due to her heart rate having slowed down to alarming levels. She still wants it to go slower, as a challenge, as a goal, to show how strong she is in fighting her own body's will to live. It's fucking crazy, but it's her reality. I do not understand how this kind of fantasy gets a foothold. I feel like the power of an idea is woefully underestimated. Same goes with conspiracy theories. Maybe an idea has to fit like a puzzle piece into a real life scenario as a convenient surface-level explanation for something unpleasant or just unresolved. I used to think the brain was a logic machine, but I think there are strong elements of it that are coping mechanisms. Cling to a fantasy that makes unpleasant thing less unpleasant. Don't know how that relates to potentially starving oneself to death, but that seems to be entirely on the table for ye olde brain. Careful what you consider plausible folks!
- RandomBacon 1y agoIt's probably a mixture of A and B, and maybe some C, etc. I believe a necessary element is that people want to be "better" (eg. ahead, smarter, or etc) than others, whether that's having some sort of "secret" knowledge or just wanting to be a contrarian.
- esseph 1y agoI'm very sorry to hear about your daughter, and I hope.... yeah. I "hope" for you, best way I can explain it. One dad to another.
- justusthane 1y agoWishing your daughter the best. I can’t imagine how devastating it must be to watch your child go through something like that and feeling powerless to help.
- throwaway8333 1y agoI've been through that. Even with a BMI below 18 when you already look like a walking skeleton and can't do more than a minute of physical activity without having to rest, you still continue seeing yourself in the mirror as obese, focusing in on small imperfections and exaggerating them to absurd levels. I really saw myself as fat, even though the weight was far below the normal range. You don't believe what other are saying because the mirror is objective and won't lie to you. It can be fixed though — the hospital stay after passing out from low glucose levels finally straightened me out, but she really needs to figure this out for herself. Good luck.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- coolspot 1y agoNSA spying on most of the internet traffic was a crazy conspiracy theory before Snowden.
- griffzhowl 1y agoNot if you believed Bill Binney, who was the technical director responsible for designing the surveillance programs, but blew the whistle when they were set on US citizens after 9/11 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Binney_(intelligence_official) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Binney_(intelligence_o...
- SirFatty 1y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- mc32 1y agoLots of “so-called” conspiracies end up being true in one sense or another if not exactly matching a sometimes misled conspiracy. I mean, take a look at the freaking Epstein episode -what the fick is that all about? If that’s not the “swamp” calling the shots, I don’t know what in hell is.
- catlover76 1y ago[dead]
- burningChrome 1y agoALex Jones was talking about Epstein during the Clinton years and all these flights powerful people were taking to his island. It was an open secret Epstein had a thing for young women so naturally Jones start inferring that Clinton and others were pedos. Everybody labeled him a kook at the time, mainly because this was just one of the many outlandish theories he had on the Free Masons and Illuminati.
- mc32 1y agoAlex Jones has a credibility problem. While he has used thinktank & other quasi-governmental institutions's papers to find nuggets of information he contaminates that with "interdimensional beings" blah... So yeah, frogs's hormones were out of whack and he predicted aspects of 9-1-1, government spying on citizens and some other things, he also has whoppers like sandyhook.
- Sharlin 1y agoSome relevant cognitive biases: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_projection_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_projection_fallacy https://www.lesswrong.com/w/typical-mind-fallacy https://www.lesswrong.com/w/typical-mind-fallacy
- heresie-dabord 1y ago> Conspiracy belief is a growing issue, thanks to an “expanded marketplace for conspiracy theories” online and on social media platforms, Pennycook said. Biases that are strengthened by for-profit disinformation business. Which raises an interesting point: In another time is sociological history, fringe thinking would have had to overcome a much more robust social challenge. People "on the edge", who might have re-calibrated effectively, have become less likely to self-critique.
- bokoharambe 1y agoI really don't think it's about social media. Conspiracy theories were a big deal on the leadup to the French revolution (look up the Famine Pact and the Great Fear), and there was no social media back then. The conversation that no one wants to have is that American society is in a similar process of collapse, and conspiratorial thinking is only gaining traction because no one trusts that the state holds the general interest anymore. The real social challenge to overcome is government legitimacy. If in our time conspiracies are perpetuated because of for-profit incentives, it is only because profit is what our society is structured around at a fundamental level. When the time for collapse has come, it brings itself into being by means of any and all existing institutions. EDIT: and for the record, it's not about cognitive biases either. No one here has a real historical perspective.
- potato3732842 1y ago>Which raises an interesting point: In another time is sociological history, fringe thinking would have had to overcome a much more robust social challenge. In a world of razor thin survive/starve margins there's more incentive to keep things stable on the day to day and if that means we all gotta convince ourselves the king is ordained by god and Saddam did have WMDs (or whatever) then so be it, at least you all get to work the fields in relative harmony and importantly not starve, not having dissent is more important than getting to the truth on any one issue. As society gets richer we need (in the strict "bottom of the pyramid" sense) social cohesion with those around us less so we're freer to adopt beliefs from wherever even if not shared with those around us.
- xhkkffbf 1y agoBut why does it matter if you're on the fringe or not? Galileo was on the fringe, but he ended up wrong. Hitler was very popular and not a fringe person after he assumed power. Yet, he was pretty wrong. Somehow I bet Kate Blackwood is certain that she's not on the fringe. She probably also thinks she's on the side of righteous change and history, something that already suggests she's not in the center of popular thought. I'm sure she also feels that people who disagree with her are on the fringe.
- potato3732842 1y agoRemember back when libertarians had bumper stickers that said things like "married gay couple should be able to defend their weed with machine guns"? Back in ye olden days if you said that someone was a conspiracy theorist it was a boolean that meant that they believed that literal conspiring was happening and now "conspiracy theorist" this whole diverse spectrum that people who believe various things are not exactly as portrayed exist on. Oh how the goalposts of fringe have shifted over time. Never mind how it shifts simply based on who you're asking. I'm sure there's beliefs that are fringe among the Cornell faculty who did this research that are wholly uncontroversial over in the maintenance department.
- Hasz 1y agoUnfortunately, dismissing ideas based on who supports them is pretty common and used by people who are unwilling or unable to discuss the ideas directly. This is mostly used incompetently, but occasionally used maliciously. I think I see this most commonly in politics, where if <obviously bad> person supports an idea, then that idea must be also bad.
- bill_joy_fanboy 1y ago> This is mostly used incompetently, but occasionally used maliciously. It can also just be a good heuristic. If a person or group/org with a reputation for dishonesty tells you an "idea", it's reasonable to throw shade. > I think I see this most commonly in politics, where if <obviously bad> person supports an idea, then that idea must be also bad. The conclusion is not always this direct, but it is completely reasonable to question ~why~ the obviously bad person holds that idea. What do they gain from pushing the agenda? Some people are so intellectually dishonest that everything they say is suspect.
- cubefox 1y agoNote that the study didn't test for mainstream conspiracy theories. In such a case I presume the conspiracy theorists correctly determine that their beliefs are mainstream. There is then also the question of non-conspiracy fringe theories. Do people who believe them still think that they are mainstream?
- madmaniak 1y agoArticle's author doesn't believe his awareness is on the fringe :))
- sxp 1y agoCan't this statement be generalized from "conspiracy theorists" to "most people"? E.g, "Religious people unaware their their religion is in the minority"? Unless a person has subjected their belief to rigorous scrutiny and debate, they will probably be unaware about how many people in the world agree or disagree with it.
- kemayo 1y agoI think the more interesting one is "religious people unaware their religion is in the majority".
- Lendal 1y agoI don't believe rigorous scrutiny and debate would have this effect at all. Most people would just get defensive and entrench. There has to be another way to reveal reality to them that doesn't result in their entrenchment.
- antisthenes 1y ago> There has to be another way to reveal reality to them that doesn't result in their entrenchment. Before you reveal anything to them, make sure you are actually revealing reality and not just your version of the story.
- arp242 1y agoThere are degrees of things. It's true that many people have some beliefs that are unconventional, irrational, or even radical, but many also realise at least to some level. There are many religious people who will admit they can't prove any of it. Similarly, in general people tend to overestimate how much people agree with them, but you can overestimate by a little or by a whole lot. It's my general observation that many conspiracy theorists are far more sure of "the truth" as they see it than the average person. This is also why so many keep banging on about it in any venue, whether appropriate or not.
- Rantenki 1y agoThis paper runs very parallel to Dunning-Kruger, and it's surprising that nobody here has commented on it (although the paper itself DOES reference Dunning-Kruger). It's a bit sad, really. When you realize that most people that buy into this stuff are trapped by a lack of cognitive ability, rather than being rooted in malice. There's a dose of https://harmful.cat-v.org/people/basic-laws-of-human-stupidity/ https://harmful.cat-v.org/people/basic-laws-of-human-stupidi... in there too, as even well educated, otherwise intelligent people can get trapped in these conspiracy theories. "Conspiracy believers not only consistently overestimated their performance on numeracy and perception tests"... Compared to: "The Dunning–Kruger effect is defined as the tendency of people with low ability in a specific area to give overly positive assessments of this ability."
- fiddlerwoaroof 1y agoAlthough, from what I can tell, there’s a lot of new evidence that the Dunning–Kruger effect is an artifact of the experimental protocol and not some interesting fact about psychology.
- intended 1y agoI saw that as well, it reminded me of dunning-krueger immediately. Although in this case, they assume not only that they reasoned correctly, but that their position is the median position for the population.
- mung_daal 1y ago[dead]
- coolhand2120 1y ago[flagged]
- ks2048 1y agoOf course it all hinges on what one considers a "conspiracy", but from my view the of the word, NO the conspiracy theorists have not won - the earth is not flat, the moon landing was real, aliens and reptile-man hybrids are not running the show.
- exe34 1y agoBack on Earth, we get about 1 good theory for every 1000 "conspiracy theories" (in your nomenclature). Yes they laughed at Galileo, but they also laughed at Bozo the clown.
- roxolotl 1y agoResponses like this muddy the waters by trying to equate the reality that understanding changes overtime with what are opinions that are largely unfounded. There are two big differences between scientific consensus and theory building and conspiracy theories. First the scientific method tests these theories. This approach tests theories and continually responds as new information arrives. Second the theories are useful. Science’s goal is to estimate reality to the point that it is useful. It is not a disqualifying ad hominem to say “you provide no nor respond to evidence and your theory doesn’t provide a useful testable hypothesis.”
- sharkjacobs 1y agoThe "conspiracy" part of "conspiracy theories" is that other people are deliberately and knowingly concealing the truth for their own ends. - "The moon landing is faked" : the conspiracy is the media campaign selling this fake lunar landing - "Princess Diana’s death was not an accident" is a royal assassination coverup - "Dinosaurs never existed" means an anti-religious conspiracy of scientists and experts pretend Dinosaurs exist as an attempt to discredit the bible The difference between theories and conspiracy theories is that Copernicus' opponents didn't actually secretly know that his theories were true
- krapp 1y ago
- redavni 1y agoThe dichotomy of conspiracy theory / not conspiracy theory is semantic poison. This entire article is reinforcement. Do you see it? Are you the kind of person who believes convincing sounding research from an Ivy League school posted on social media and wikipedia articles? Is your epistemology based in socialmediaism?
- intended 1y agoDo you know that we've seen a difference in how information cascades through conspiracist networks vs science oriented ones? If you want a better differentiation, is computer science the same as magic? Is there no difference between the skills someone develops as a professional and expert in their field, and the lay person? Everyone has the same level of ability and willingness to understand a subject? For example, did you read the article before commenting?
- redavni 1y agoConspiratorial networks? I'm not wasting my time reading research which is probably entirely intentionally incorrect conspiracy theories that people believe. Might was well have done research into whether people believe Gone With The Wind was actual history. Reading the research is not necessary because of the framing. The framing makes the research useless for truth seeking. The idea here is exactly what you say, belief in authority because science people spend time on it. Essentially this is science as religion. Which was exactly my point.
- labrador 1y agoIf I was wealthy conspiracy theorist I might even build an AI molded after my beliefs and call it the "source of truth"
- clickety_clack 1y agoI can’t remember where I heard it, maybe a Joe Rogan clip, but he made a good point that believing that there are _no_ conspiracies is also an extreme viewpoint that is obviously wrong, given that some conspiracy theories eventually turned out to be conspiracy facts.
- arp242 1y agoI don't think there is anyone who believes there are no conspiracies. The terms "conspiracy" and "conspiracy theory" have very different meanings. This is essentially just a linguistic sleight of hand, not too different from when creationists say "evolution is just a theory". "Conspiracy theory" is somewhat unfortunate term.
- mike_hearn 1y agoMaybe not zero conspiracies in total, but academic social science does take it as axiomatic that public sector organizations never engage in conspiracies. That's why their papers always assume any belief that they might do so is automatically false and must be explained via other factors. Occasionally you see recognition that private sector actors might genuinely conspire, but never public sector. Invariably, such papers use an ad-hoc set of beliefs that are labelled as false with no explanation or investigation. The authors just assume that because everyone they know believes something, it must be true. Ironically that's the same sort of faulty belief system they claim to be investigating.
- clickety_clack 1y agoIsn’t it the “deep state” and “government coverup” type of theories that are conspiracy theories? The flat earth thing is an example of that, where the theory is that “they” (the government or big globe or whoever) are trying to convince you that the world is round when it’s actually flat. Note that the article we’re discussing specifically mentions “people who believe in conspiracies” in the first line.
- arp242 1y ago> Note that the article we’re discussing specifically mentions “people who believe in conspiracies” in the first line. Which obviously refers to conspiracy theories in this context. Words can have more than one meaning (again: see "theory", among others). Watergate was a government cover-up. No one denies that happened. Or Iran-Contra, or the Snowden leaks. Or the WMDs in Iraq.
- intalentive 1y agoHere's an idea: treat conspiracy theory as theory, an explanation of a set of facts, rather than as social contagion or pathological disorder. Allow open discussion of all sides of an issue, admit controversial facts, and structure the discussion in such a way that truthfulness and explanatory power rises to the top. I'm picturing some kind of hybrid of Reddit and Wikipedia. Censorship, ostracism, and certain debunking styles are counterproductive in the sense that they harden the "conspiracy theorist" in his beliefs, confirming that "the establishment" is protecting sacred cows and forbidden knowledge. These approaches are unnecessarily combative and condescending. I think a more open approach is called for. Sabine Hossenfelder handled "flat earth theory" in a way I found refreshing. She said, "Huh, this is interesting. I appreciate that they aren't afraid to question fundamental assumptions. That is a scientific attitude. But here's why I think they're wrong."
- Majromax 1y ago> Here's an idea: treat conspiracy theory as theory, an explanation of a set of facts, rather than as social contagion or pathological disorder. Allow open discussion of all sides of an issue, admit controversial facts, and structure the discussion in such a way that truthfulness and explanatory power rises to the top. That's well worth doing when evaluating the merits of a potential conspiracy theory for yourself. However, it's not evident that this approach will convince people who incorrectly believe conspiracy theories of their errors. Eponymous conspiracy theories have a built in 'immune system' to reject logical, scientific argumentation, since most if not all refuting facts can be attributed to the untrustworthy or malicious conspiracy itself. Ultimately, scientific argumentation depends upon all involved parties having a shared understanding of what observed facts are true or false, and if that agreement is not there then otherwise rational parties can still reach different conclusions with no persuasion possible. > Sabine Hossenfelder handled "flat earth theory" in a way I found refreshing. She said, "Huh, this is interesting. I appreciate that they aren't afraid to question fundamental assumptions. That is a scientific attitude. But here's why I think they're wrong." Was this approach persuasive to any 'flat earthers', or was it instead interesting to watch as a 'round earther'?
- regularjack 1y agoIf you make outrageous claims for which there is abundant proof of the contrary (e.g. flat earth), it's on you to provide proof, it's not on me to pretend that you're not making outrageous claims.
- recursivedoubts 1y agoThe term "conspiracy theory" is a psychological kill shot designed to socially ostracize anyone who questions the mainstream (read: elite) narrative, instilling fear in questioning that narrative. Yes, there are crazy people who think crazy things. There are also sane people who think "crazy" things might be true, but keep it to themselves out of fear of the social ostracization associated with being called a "conspiracy theorist." As designed.
- potato3732842 1y agoThe powers that be keep changing how conspiracy theorists are measured to hide the true rate of conspiracy theorist-flation!!!1!1!1!! Joking, but also not joking, back in the day a conspiracy theorist was someone who believed that something was explained by a literal conspiracy with literal conspiring going on. Now every Tom, Dick and Harry that thinks a press release isn't telling the whole truth gets to call themselves one. The reason the definition got watered down was for exactly the reason you state, various people found it useful to apply that label much more broadly.
- krapp 1y agoMy person in deity, the American government is currently run by anti-vaxxers, white supremacists and UFO grifters, and was elected by people who believed the weather was controlled by Jewish space lasers, COVID vaccines were full of mind-control chips and the Democratic Party ran a sex cult under a pizzeria. You need to update your priors. It's become de rigueur to virtue signal how radically untethered one is to consensus reality, to the point that even on Hacker News, which is ostensibly full of rational people, you'll get ostracized far more for believing in the mainstream narrative than for questioning it.
- recursivedoubts 1y agohuh, must be why my post got downvoted
- hackingonempty 1y agoThe White House is pushing the "lab leak" consipriacy theory. https://www.whitehouse.gov/lab-leak-true-origins-of-covid-19/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/lab-leak-true-origins-of-covid-19... Here's a good review of the science, which contradicts the assertions made above: https://www.annualreviews.org/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-virology-093022-013037 https://www.annualreviews.org/content/journals/10.1146/annur...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- goodluckchuck 1y agoThis is tautological. They’re effectively defining conspiracy theories to be things which are not widely believed, and then proclaiming that the things which are not widely believed are not widely believed… Okay?
- mike_hearn 1y agoTheir definition of conspiracy theory is found in Appendix A, where they just present an ad-hoc list of things they personally believe are false beliefs. Some of the things they present are very widely believed, and at least a few of them have actually been proven true (more or less). It's always like this with such papers. 100% of them are pseudo-science.
- jfengel 1y agoI wonder if that was always true. When I think of "classical" conspiracy theorists, like the JFK assassination or the moon landings, I think of somebody who believes that they have special knowledge that most people do not have. They believe themselves to be a valiant minority struggling against an oppressive force -- one that has gotten to practically everybody except them. I suspect that conspiracy theories have gone mainstream, and have categorically changed in the process. These beliefs aren't fringe any more. They may not be held by a majority, but they no longer need to seek out obscure chat rooms to share them. They'll be affirmed in the media, by politicians, and by many of their neighbors.
- burnt-resistor 1y ago> special knowledge that most people do not have. A signal of likely mental illness or a deliberate simulation of such by an unserious person. It's unreasonable to reason with unreasonable people. - My late grandfather
- kova12 1y agoI constantly see beliefs dubbed as "conspiracy theory" later found to be actual true facts. Does that indicate that truth is sometimes on the fringe, and if yes, then what "fringe" really is?
- theyknowitsxmas 1y agoGiordano Bruno wasn’t killed for no reason.
- disambiguation 1y agoThe paper linked in the article is paywalled, but after a bit of sleuthing I found a full access pre-print (I assume hosted legitimately) https://osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/d5fz2_v3 https://osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/d5fz2_v3 The section on measuring over-confidence is interesting, specifically how they address the shortcoming of self-reporting confidence (if you're bad at the task in the first place, you're also going to be bad at estimating your performance, where the act of estimating resembles the task itself). Another fun activity is to visit the appendix (p. 47) which lists all of the True and False Conspiracies used in their assessment.