5 ms·
Repasting a MacBook
- gepardi 1y agoOooorrr… Next time buy a Framework 13.
- daneel_w 1y agoGood advice. Looking forward to your guide on getting an identical experience running modern macOS on it.
- nottorp 1y agoMaybe I'm old fashioned, but I use a laptop for real work as little as possible. Long term high CPU usage goes on a properly silent and easy to repaste (and LARGE ofc) desktop. As a consequence, the oldest laptop I have around (a 2009 macbook white) is just fine(tm) noise wise.
- kzrdude 1y agoMaybe a dumb question then, but is dust buildup just as much a function of work/use as of time? I guess that is reasonable.
- nottorp 1y agoI don't know, because right now I'm replying from my laptop while being on my balcony, which is open to the real world(tm) and thus has a lot more dust than the inside of my home. I've used all my laptops like that and they're still silent [1]. [1] Silent, but the keyboard is broken on the old emoji keyboard macbook pro, may whoever designed it and stuck to it burn in whatever hell they believe in forever.
- unsupp0rted 1y agoYou are old fashioned. An M-series MacBook Pro is the most “work” machine almost anybody needs. Almost anybody.
- nottorp 1y agoYeah I have one. And a mac mini plugged into 2 monitors. And a beige box running linux and windows, depending on what i need at the moment.
- throwaway328 1y ago> Four years later, this MacBook Pro is still a delight. It’s the longest I’ve ever owned a laptop Is this normal? Changing laptops every 2 or 3 years seems absolutely bonkers to me
- ido 1y agoI keep macbooks longer, but PC laptops I've had would often start breaking in ways that were too expensive to be worth repairing around that time. I had a Dell XPS whose screen had issues and replacing it (some custom touch screen that didn't have many options aside from dell's official replacements) was something like €600 (conveniently this happened shortly after the extended warranty expired), which at that point in the laptop's life was not worth the expense.
- swiftcoder 1y agoI used to keep laptops 5+ years, but recently I've realised that as a software engineer, this may be a bit of a false economy. It's my primary tool - if I can buy a ~20% performance bump sooner than that, it's absolutely worth it (and a deductible business expense into the bargain)
- notpushkin 1y agoOn one hand – absolutely. On the other hand, I suspect this is the main reason we have those Electron abominations and bloated web apps nowadays.
- swiftcoder 1y agoYeah. Unfortunately as a software engineer I'm constantly on the losing side of that battle - many of the tools I'm obligated to use have long-since become enshitified :/
- nikanj 1y agoIf you hire Wayne Gretzky, don't skimp on skates. A software engineer costs more than a laptop per month, and it's insane that companies have devs waiting on builds a single second longer than necessary. The faster the edit-compile-test cycle, the more value you get for the massive investment of engineer salary.
- noname120 1y ago@dang Can you remove the editorialization of the title? The original title is “You should repaste your MacBook (but don't)”
- tomhow 1y agoThat original title is a little on the baity side ("You should ..." is classic title bait), and I've softened it even further now.
- noname120 1y agoIt's good now. For reference, the previous editorialized title was “Repaste Your MacBook”[1], which used the imperative mood. That made it even more click-baity than the original title “You should repaste your MacBook (but don't)”. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20250711190104/https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44531569 https://web.archive.org/web/20250711190104/https://news.ycom...
- ksec 1y agoI have yet to read a valid reason why PCM isn't used by default on these Laptops other than $10 increase in BOM.
- haiku2077 1y agoFrom a product page for Carbon Black, a similar material to the stuff Apple uses, these look like the advantages over a phase change thermal pad: - Fortified with glass beads to maintain uniform bond line over the life of the device - Eliminates die/component hotspots caused by incomplete heatsink contact seen with use of other thermal compounds Additionally, a thermal pad requires a presssure mount with a narrow gap, while Carbon Black is designed for non-pressure-mounted components.
- zdw 1y agoIf you have any of the Air models which lack fans, there's a common hack of putting thermal pads between the CPU heatspreader and case, effectively turning the bottom case into a large heatsink, and giving your system a longer maximum performance before throttling. The downsides is that this makes the bottom of the case quite hot on a place you can touch, but putting a plastic hardshell over the entire laptop deals with that, and also gives protection.
- evanjrowley 1y agoThanks for that info. I've been interested in this hack and use plastic hard shells, but have been concerned that the plastic covering might prevent proper heat dissipation. It sounds like the tradeoff is worth it.
- ianferrel 1y agoMaking the bottom case a heatsink and then putting a plastic insulator around it seems to defeat the purpose of the whole attempt?
- delusional 1y agoI take him saying: > a longer maximum performance before throttling. As implying that the purpose is to increase the thermal mass, not necessarily the dissipation. It should still be able to reach maximum performance for longer, it will then just also take longer to settle back down again.
- zdw 1y agoThis is the correct interpretation - you get a bit longer max clockspeed due to the thermal mass (and thus more heat overall). Is the added plastic shell case a "bandaid on a bandaid" sort of solution to deal with that heat? Absolutely. But you might want that case anyway - I've had several laptops that would have had broken screens or were yanked off a desk by an attached cable and survived by the sacrificial plastic shell taking the impact. Like all things, it's a tradeoff to consider.
- 1y ago
- gruez 1y agoThe author should benchmark a few months afterwards. A common problem with using "PC" thermal pastes (for lack of a better word) is that they experience more pump out than whatever they use for laptops, so a few months later the performance might end up worse than before he changed the paste.
- LorenDB 1y agoMaybe thermal pads then? I use PTM7950 in my desktop.
- arresin 1y agoThat’s pcm. A thermal pad is a thicker thing. I use the same one in my pc and it’s awesome.
- LorenDB 1y agoOut of curiosity, where did you get your PTM7950? I bought from LTT but I'd be interested to know if there are other good sources.
- craftkiller 1y agoI'm not the person you asked but I got all of my PTM7950 from moddiy[0]. I've put it in my laptop, desktop, and steam deck. Benchmarked my desktop and laptop before putting it in and both of them saw improved performance and lower temperatures. [0] https://www.moddiy.com/products/Honeywell-PTM7950-SP-Super-Highly-Thermally-Conductive-PCM-Pad.html https://www.moddiy.com/products/Honeywell-PTM7950-SP-Super-H...
- dsego 1y agoI recently paid 60 euros to get my 14" m1 macbook cleaned, it was extremely dusty inside, so much so that the left fan started making strange squealing noises and then a pinging sonar-type sound every few seconds. Luckily with the combination of the fan control app and the built in apple diagnostic tool I managed to determine it was probably the fan and brought it to the local service shop to disassemble and clean. Now the only things left are to replace the original battery which is at 75% and replace the rustling speaker which was damaged by ants getting inside through the vents and chewing on it.
- gdbsjjdn 1y agoI love "the process was quite friendly" coupled with "two of the connectors broke when I looked at them and one costs hundreds of dollars to replace".
- diggan 1y agoTo be fair, compared to the typical Apple experience of modifying stuff, that is quite friendly. Although author seems to have broken the TouchID sensor and button in the process, which is less neat and maybe not so friendly even for Apple.
- pier25 1y ago> that is quite friendly Maybe if you're referring to iPhones and iPads. The Intel Macbooks were always super easy to open for cleanup or replacing parts. I did it for years and never broke anything.
- diggan 1y ago> Maybe if you're referring to iPhones and iPads. Or the new laptops ;) They're no longer Intel Macbooks, and compared to laptops from other brands, the new Apple hardware seems way harder (although I'd confess to not having the experience of picking any of the M* models apart personally). https://www.ifixit.com/repairability/laptop-repairability-scores https://www.ifixit.com/repairability/laptop-repairability-sc... Didn't the latest iPhones have some sort of "repairability" push or something? Don't remember exactly, but seems to have given me the idea that Apple is moving towards making it easier to repair the iPhones specifically.
- pier25 1y ago> Or the new laptops ;) Yeah that was obvious from the OP :)
- fckgw 1y agoYes, they moved all their batteries away from glued adhesives to "Command Strips" pull-tab style adhesive pads. Same pads have been on the laptops for a bit as well. The latest iPhone also rotated the guts to where the battery is easier to get to and does not require removal of the logic board. https://www.ifixit.com/News/100693/more-modular-than-ever-before-iphone-16-pro-and-pro-max-teardown https://www.ifixit.com/News/100693/more-modular-than-ever-be...
- jeron 1y agothis read more like "Do Not Repaste Your MacBook". There's no way this was worth 5 degrees and 100 points in cinbench (sic)
- saurik 1y agoI mean, even the title very clearly says "(but don't)".
- meatmanek 1y agoFor some reason, the HN title has had that part removed. I think it used to contain it, so I guess the mods edited the title after the fact? Or maybe I'm misremembering.
- tiagod 1y ago5 degrees with much lower RPM.
- raihansaputra 1y agoi think it's worth it to know for MacBook Air users instead (like me). I think mine is wearing out and what's annoying is it throttles on some web pages because the temp would spike to 106c. But not on (admittedly light) gaming or Lightroom editinf.
- rglullis 1y ago[flagged]
- kstrauser 1y agoAlso, the sarcasm.
- t1234s 1y ago[flagged]
- speedgoose 1y agoBy the way, the Stockholm syndrome isn’t scientifically a thing.
- bowsamic 1y agoWhat makes something “scientifically” a thing?
- speedgoose 1y agoYou can observe, document it well, and it can be reproduced.
- xandrius 1y agoStill drive across a point.
- carlosjobim 1y agoIt is a particular and well documented event, which happened in physical reality on this planet. You can easily find all the evidence you could ever ask for.
- moi2388 1y agoDid you actually read about it? Because the entire story is more a warning for malpractice of the psychiatrist in question than an actual effect. The government told the woman to find solace in dying on the job. The woman was critical of this so the psychiatrist claimed she had sexual attraction to the hostage taker
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- maz1b 1y agoWhile I can appreciate the intent of this blog post.. I don't see how the title should be "repaste your Macbook" when touch ID breaks and the button stops working. Doesn't Apple offer this service if you have AppleCare+? or even if you dont? that way its on them?
- jillesvangurp 1y agoI think if you use your laptop beyond three years, you might want to worry about shit like that. But you really should consider getting something decent instead. I use leased laptops for work and I generally replace them after three years with whatever is new and shiny. I recently upgraded from the M1 macbook pro to a shiny new M4 Max. And damn this thing is fast. My build speeds massively improved. This is cutting hours of time in a week. Which is an unbelievable upgrade of my quality of life. And it also means I run tests more often and pro-actively instead of going "I could do it but it's going to take five minutes". My build speeds are now routinely below 1 minute. Ram throughput and having more CPUs are making the difference here. I was expecting my builds to be faster with a new laptop. But not by 4-5x. So, I don't think I'll ever be faffing about with thermal paste. Because that would mean I'm penny pinching instead of getting a massively faster laptop. It's a judgment call of course and a bit personal. Not everyone needs a fast laptop. But I gladly spend a bit extra for this stuff. On the current contract, my new laptop is costing 100 euro per month. That include apple care coverage. And it's a 48GB M4 Max. Worth every penny. I'm not going to worry about thermal paste because I'll upgrade before that becomes an issue.
- spaqin 1y agoI don't think creating more e-waste is the answer, especially for things that still work properly with marginal improvement over time. Neither it is the option for most of the population. Use it as long as you can and squeeze the most of the things you already have.
- maz1b 1y agoYou're right, but the ultra-overwhelming-majority of people are not like us who can maximize off each new silicon generation.
- pram 1y agoA nice and unexpected thing about the current MBPs is they usually have their fan completely turned off. There was barely any dust in my M1 Max MBP when I looked.
- moribvndvs 1y ago> The fan was incredibly easy to swap out (hats off there, Apple!) After reading this, an Apple middle manager is gathering an emergency meeting to figure out who fucked up
- smallpipe 1y agoI remember doing it on a thinkpad. I didn't break any cables, I didn't need a guide, and it got significantly quieter afterwards. Macbooks are pretty, they've got a great CPU, but the repairability is just rubbish
- thewebguyd 1y agoSame with most dell laptops I've owned. Pop off the back panel and everything is there, easily accessible, standard screws. Just did this on an Inspiron I have, just about 8 screws, pop the heat sync off, repaste, reassemble and done. Took like 15 minutes. Plus the RAM and SSD are also easily accessible and replaceable, as is the battery in a matter of minutes.
- sethhochberg 1y agoThe part I have a hard time with as a corporate purchaser is that the failure/repair/replacement rate on our small number of Dell machines is upwards of 50%. We've only got about a dozen in use, and less then half of them have just worked reliably. At a certain point I don't really care how repairable the Macbooks we buy for almost everyone else are/aren't because the failure rate on those is so low by comparison. I'm glad the Dell repair guy who gets sent out has a pleasant experience when he replaces the guts of a machine but my team still has to spend time and money shipping around replacements and dealing with warranty repair at a rate we just don't see with the Apple gear. Once upon a time our entire corporate fleet was all Macbooks but the only thing we had worse luck with than these Dells was training nontechnical users on how to get to their Excel or specialized actuarial/compliance software through virtualization
- thewebguyd 1y agoNo argument there. Where I work (I'm in infrastructure, not a dev) we've switched almost entirely to MacBooks and experienced the same when were a Dell shop. Horrible reliability. We've been on Macs since ~2023 and I've yet to need to send one off for repair or RMA. I keep them for use at home as Linux machines because of the repairability and ease of upgrading, but my main machine is still a Mac. I'd love MacBook level of hardware quality combined with easy access to repair and swap parts.
- thimabi 1y agoI wonder if Apple itself offers repasting services via AppleCare. For someone like me, with little experience in handling electronics, it might be better than trying to fiddle with the MacBook’s internals.
- leakycap 1y agoI don't know if it is different with Apple silicon, but I had a 2018 MBP that overheated and the Apple Store replaced the logic board and upper case assembly rather than try any sort of repair of the existing board with heat issues.
- reddalo 1y agoOffering such a service would be an admission by Apple that their products are not God-tier.
- notpushkin 1y agoGo for an independent repair shop instead.
- t1234s 1y agoI had to do this to my 2012 MBP (along with fixing the gpu solder problem) and I found it wasn't that hard to disassemble / reassemble. Also replacing the battery, upgrading the ram/storage was very easy to do. Contrast this to my 2017 MBP which has to score on the top 10 list of worst apple products of all time as far as quality and ease of repair go. Have these new M3/4 MPBs gone back at all to being easy to dismantle or change the battery in? The OP with their M1 mentioned tearing overly thin ribbon cables.
- mhuffman 1y agoI had to replace the fans on a 2013 MBP that I use as a linux laptop and the experience was one of the most nerve-wracking in my whole life! It really is put together to dissuade people from tweaking anything inside of it.
- jpalomaki 1y agoI replaced battery and did repaste on Intel MacBook Pro (with Touch Bar). Quite tedious process. So many extremely tiny screws with different sizes and all those small connectors. Having been mostly opening ThinkPads before I wasn't really prepared for it. Also did the mistake of not reading the full instructions before starting. The process took way longer than I expected and with zillion teeny tiny half millimeter screws on table I was afraid to take a break.
- hengheng 1y agoI was tempted to do that with my first-gen Intel MacBook because it just wouldn't run quiet when idle, that is until I discovered by how much I could undervolt that chip with a random tool that I could just download. I believe I went from 1.26V to 1.03V, or at least these are the numbers still etched into my brain. Ratio of the squares of those numbers is 2/3, and so the laptop was certainly quiet without having to open it up. But I was surprised at Intel's product back then.
- lisnake 1y agoI fixed the eGPU disconnecting issue on my 2012 MacBook Pro by placing the entire motherboard inside an oven for 10 minutes (a rather unconventional solution for reballing). So, yes, MacBooks from that era were not as fragile as they are now. By the way, that laptop still works.
- haiku2077 1y agoDon't use regular thermal paste or pads in a Mac. They're not suitable for non-pressure mounted applications. You can buy TCRS Carbon Black if you really need to repaste a Mac part instead of swapping a new part that was pasted at the factory.
- Lalabadie 1y agoThis. Its not a case of Carbon Black being better over other acceptable options. The thermal paste applied in this article needs pressure on the two surfaces making contact to function at all, and to remain functional. The laptop isn't built like a desktop cooler setup.
- dmsnell 1y agoSeveral years ago I replaced the thermal paste in my MacBook Pro and I did it in two steps: first to high-end paste; and second to liquid metal. The results were impressive, and I think it’s a bit veiled how paste degradation over time impacts perceived laptop speeds. I’ve been tempted to replace the paste on new devices but haven’t taken that plunge. https://fluffyandflakey.blog/2019/04/13/increasing-thermal-headroom/ https://fluffyandflakey.blog/2019/04/13/increasing-thermal-h...
- Havoc 1y agoNeed to repaste and replace pads on my 3090 (appears to be overheating) and dreading the process, especially the pads. >[After] Max CPU temperature: 96°C What? Is that normal for macs? Vaguely unrelated I'm only buying thermal grizzly paste in future...that factory tour they did was super impressive. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HsIk_mMrt2w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HsIk_mMrt2w
- dwood_dev 1y agoGPUs are quite easy to repaste. Just order the correct replacement thermal pads in advance and the whole thing is easy.
- Havoc 1y agoYeah I'm optimistic. Just anxious cause paying for a new 24gb nvidia card is something I could do without in this GPU market Found a yt that for my precise card being repadded though so should be ok
- dontlaugh 1y agoIt’s normal for any CPU under load with correctly sized cooling to be just under its maximum temperature, which is often 100.
- Dylan16807 1y agoElectromigration is a real problem. "Barely enough" is not a synonym for "correctly sized". I might not hit problems within the lifetime of the device, but it's a pretty tight margin of error. If I can roughly roughly cut aging in half by dropping 10C, then I want to do that 2-4 times.
- ErrorNoBrain 1y agosomeone made a youtube video not too long ago (i think was that guy who made the 3rd party ssd upgrade kits?) he said that apple uses a special type of thermal paste... not that its some super awesome unique product, it's just that its not a paste in the typical sense, like you'd use on a GPU or CPU. It's more like a "putty".
- drewolbrich 1y agoI have a 2021 M1 Pro MacBook Pro that I use every day, and I don't hear the fans...at least not yet. I wonder how my situation differs from Christian's.
- mdasen 1y agoSame. One difference might be how much stress we put on the machine. I believe thermal paste does degrade faster with more heat and Christian says that he throws a lot at it: video editing, code compiling, CAD models. It might make a difference how much usage is being put on the machine leading to degradation of the original thermal paste faster or slower.
- wyclif 1y agoIs it possible to clean the dust out of the M1+ models without cracking them open?
- hhh 1y agoI use my M1 Max every day and still have only heard the fans once when it kernel panicked.
- mrexroad 1y agoI remember having to do this with the 2006 MBP, the first Intel books, when they were new.
- amatecha 1y agoI got the first intel Mac Mini (Core Solo), and it only survived a year or two before something on the logic board literally burned up. Not a good first impression on the switchover to the new architecture :(
- dclowd9901 1y ago>But where I also really notice it is in idling: just writing this blog post my CPU was right at 46°C the whole time, where previously my computer idled right aroud 60°C. The whole computer just feels a bit healthier. I get this same feeling whenever I change the fluids on my cars. I know from a practical perspective, it's very little changed, but I can't help feeling like the car just feels like it's in a better place. Which I guess it is? But I know it's entirely mental.
- leakycap 1y agoI don't think it is entirely mental - I had thought the same, but I recently had a very cheap rental car for months, so long they called it back to the shop for an oil change and then gave it back to me... that car drove SO much better after the oil change, the engine was quieter and smoother and the difference was obvious because the car had no vibration or sound insulation.
- dominick-cc 1y agoAll I can think is maybe they changed a clogged air filter at the same time. Otherwise it has to be placebo.
- leakycap 1y agoWhy would your go-to explanation be an air filter service that no one in this tangent has mentioned? This seems counterintuitive, but then you also say the only other option is placebo so I'm not sure I follow from the limited line of thinking explained here?
- mxfh 1y agoWeirdest disconnect of content to headline. In short: If your M1 is still working fine, don't do what I did.
- Eric_WVGG 1y agoI wouldn’t trade a modern Macbook for an old one by any stretch, but man, you could really have some fun with those older models. I gave my modded 17" 2009 "cafeteria tray" Macbook Pro to my father, and after using it for many more years, he brought it in for… something. I had replaced the internal optical drive with an SSD and reformatted it as a “Fusion Drive” (a kind of smart multi-drive partition that would put commonly-accessed things on an SSD and large rarely-used storage on an HD, identified as a single drive), apparently every Genius Bar employee crammed around the table because they had never seen any Apple computer like it :D
- ravetcofx 1y agoFusion was so terrible and unreliable in my experience. they were still selling fusion iMacs till 2020, and it honestly seemed faster to just disable the fusion and let it be HDD only. I saw so many failures and data loss with that.
- leakycap 1y agoIt is wild to me how much money Apple used to spend on ANYTYHING but a fast internal hard drive. The SSD-only days have at least got us out of the slooooww 5k rpm drive nightmare that was every consumer Apple device for decades.
- Eric_WVGG 1y agoI never had any issues with it, even my hacked together frankenfusion
- socalgal2 1y ago> My favorite memory of my M1 Pro MacBook Pro was the whole sensation of “holy crap, you never hear the fans in this thing”, which was very novel in 2021. I had that same "wow, no fan" when I got my M1 Mac (still have my 2014 Intel MBP and the fans come on almost immediately) > this dang thing still seems to just shrug at basically anything I throw at it. Unfortunately, this year I started playing with stable diffusion stuff, while it might be possible to optimize, what I have (automatic1111 and comfyui), is slow and my fans come on. Slow = 6x to 12x slower than friends with gaming PCs.
- mproud 1y agoAs someone who fixes these things, I rarely damage them. But you should be using nylon probe tools (a.k.a. “black sticks”) and tweezers, and properly practice electrostatic discharge safety. Or just have an Apple Authorized Service Provider handle this for you.