3 ms·
Driving is becoming a hobby for the rich. A more fair approach would be rationing, not just for driving but for every naturally scarce resource. https://en.wi
by amelius 1y ago
Driving is becoming a hobby for the rich.
A more fair approach would be rationing, not just for driving but for every naturally scarce resource.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationing
- gonzalohm 1y agoAt least the fees are invested back into public transport (for non rich people)
- gruez 1y ago>A more fair approach would be rationing, not just for driving but for every naturally scarce resource. How would that even work? If there's only enough road for 10% of the cars in Manhattan, does everyone just get "hall passes" for driving 36 days a year? Ironically that'd make driving even more "a hobby for the rich", because nobody but the rich are going to spend $30k+ on a car, for the privilege of driving it for 36 days a year. Even if the ratio was closer to 50% (which is doubtful, given how congested Manhattan is), only the well off can afford a car that's sitting idle half the year. If you make the passes tradable, you basically reinvented congestion pricing.
- rainsford 1y agoIt's even worse than that, because rationing makes driving an unreliable solution at any price point. Sure, a rich person can afford a car they only use part of the time. But if they regularly have a need to go into the city, they still need an alternative solution the rest of the time when they can't drive into the city for any amount of money. And having the ability to drive only some of the time is even more unhelpful for non-rich folks for exactly the reason you outlined. The idea of rich people commuting by driving into Manhattan from their mansions in Connecticut while average people live closer and take public transit might bother some egalitarian sensibilities, but it's probably a better outcome than driving being so unavailable to everyone that the only people who really benefit from it are tourists or those who otherwise don't really need to drive into the city at all.
- donohoe 1y agoYou’re jumping to an extreme conclusion. A ~10% reduction in cars due to congestion pricing doesn’t support the idea that driving is becoming a hobby for the rich. That’s a modest shift, not a wholesale class divide. Let’s keep the debate grounded in actual outcomes, not sweeping generalizations.
- amelius 1y agoRight now it is maybe an extreme stance, but with many resources becoming scarcer we're on a slippery slope here. The free market is nice in many ways but near resource scarcity it breaks down. It's good to think of fair solutions early on because we'll have to deal with this eventually.
- rainsford 1y agoNot only does it not break down, but situations with scarce resources are actually when the free market is most useful. It creates an efficient way to allocate those resources while avoiding shortages and creating incentives to develop alternatives. It's not perfect, as it can result in scarce resources going to those with the most money rather than those with the most need, but the track record compared to alternatives is pretty good.
- amelius 1y agoOk, perhaps I should have said scarce __and__ essential. We've grown so accustomed to many things that they are now considered essential to a large degree.
- yurishimo 1y agoMany large European cities have congestion pricing and it's fine. The very poor can't afford a car anyway and the price conscious drivers were already using a "Park & Ride" type of service to get to the city center because parking is expensive on top of the congestion charges. If you need to drive into the center for some reason, you should be able to get the fee reimbursed (like validated parking) or it's so rare that you find yourself in that situation, you can eat the €10 cost twice a year.