5 ms·
(1) Assuming Starship makes it to orbit, it enables a range of structures larger than the ISS but smaller than the O'Neill colonies. A mission to Luna or Mars
by PaulHoule 1y ago
(1) Assuming Starship makes it to orbit, it enables a range of structures larger than the ISS but smaller than the O'Neill colonies. A mission to Luna or Mars involves 12-20 launches of fuel tankers, for the same cost you can put up a lot of mass to LEO. A really flashy space hotel seems practical, as would simulation environments for Lunar, Mars and Asteroidal technology development.
(2) O'Neill colonies with large airspaces seem impractical because you'd need large amounts of nitrogen or some other inert gas: you can find oxide rocks everywhere in space but pure oxygen environments aren't safe. On the other hand, the atmosphere for an LEO baby Bernal sphere would be about 15 Starship loads and probably worth it for the visual appeal.
(3) The later work of O'Neill's students focused a lot on manufacturing. The proposal to build large structures by vapor deposition of metals onto a balloon still looks feasible. The solar power satellites shrank considerably in mass and it seemed that they could be built more practically from terrestrial materials.
(4) Any space colonization effort runs into the problem that it needs to be self-sufficient in terms of manufacturing (especially Mars) which led Eric Drexler to go off and develop his vision of molecular assemblers. Drexler's proposals haven't aged well but something equivalent that combines 3-d printing with flow chemistry, synthetic biology, fermentation and other technologies is probably possible -- and I think is the critical path. That flashy space hotel, however, really is about rocketry and space assembly of large structures which really is the unique application of space manufacturing; I don't think space manufacturing can ever be competitive for the terrestrial market but it can be competitive for things that can only be made in space.
(5) Colonization of Ceres dominates all other space colonization opportunities in the solar system because there is no shortage of water and no shortage of nitrogen. It seems possible to take the whole thing apart and build a colony with more floor space and a larger population than Earth. You don't get the 0.2 cubic kilometers of ocean that we get, but I think you can culture all the fish you can eat anyway.
- TMEHpodcast 1y agoStarship feels like the ultimate engineering gamble, so many moving parts (literally) that getting it right might be as hard as building the habitats it’s meant to launch. On nitrogen, I keep wondering: if in-space manufacturing matured, couldn’t we generate atmosphere by cracking water for oxygen and synthesizing nitrogen analogues through hydrogen-based pathways? Or is Earth’s air mix so specific that importing nitrogen stays unavoidable?
- bryanlarsen 1y ago> the ultimate engineering gamble It's a no-lose gamble though. If they fail we still end up with SuperHeavy as a massive, cheaper Falcon like architecture. If it succeeds, finally our space dreams can start to be realized.
- jitl 1y agoWhere are you going to get the water? What makes water mass cheaper to orbit compared to nitrogen mass?
- TMEHpodcast 1y agoClosed-loop systems like on the ISS already reclaim water from humidity, sweat, and urine, and could be scaled up for larger habitats. Air works similarly: CO₂ is scrubbed, oxygen is regenerated from electrolysis, and trace gases are filtered. I realize you still need an initial stock of oxygen and nitrogen, but isn’t this a problem that could be solved eventually with science?
- jitl 1y agoThis is like saying “once we solve the problem, the problem will be solved”
- TMEHpodcast 1y agoNow you’re speaking my language! Let’s get started shall we?
- econ 1y agoAfter we solve it the problem won't exist anymore. No more deals.
- dylan604 1y agoHang out a big butterfly net and capture the dirty snowballs that float past. There have been lots of new releases of frozen water discoveries on various bodies. Typically in craters that pretty much stay in shadow. Water doesn't seem to be that scarce. It's just not as abundant as on Earth
- lukan 1y ago"(5) Colonization of Ceres dominates all other space colonization opportunities in the solar system because there is no shortage of water and no shortage of nitrogen." What about gravity?
- PaulHoule 1y agoRotation. You don’t live on the surface but you build a beanstalk and build a big framework of small O’Neill’s cylinders. See https://arxiv.org/abs/2011.07487 https://arxiv.org/abs/2011.07487 I’d say this paper thoroughly debunks all other space colonization plans in comparison. For instance it is not sustainable to use rockets for routine transformation. The moon doesn't have enough volatiles. Who knows if gravity on the Martian surface is enough to be healthy. Even if you could take, say, Mercury, apart it would be silly to build a ‘Dyson swarm’ but rather you would build a big framework like that or a ‘Dyson foam’ (e.g. if you took Mercury apart and turned it into a solar collecting structure 1m thick you could capture enough energy to make a few tons of antimatter a second for interstellar travel)
- perihelions 1y agoCeres is very far away orbitally. It's three times further than Mars, but also has no braking atmosphere or gravity. If you send a payload to Ceres, that payload has 5 km/s of relative velocity that can only be zeroed out with rocket propulsion. (That's a lot). It's not coincidence the first Ceres orbiter was also a flagship prototype for advanced electric propulsion. It's a deceptively remote target.
- PaulHoule 1y agoGranted. I don't see it as a Muskian "send 10,000,000 people and keep sending them supplies" kind of thing but rather "send 100 people, 1,000,000 eggs and the closest thing to a Drexler machine that we can make" kind of thing. The latter is what I think the BoM for a successful Mars colony looks like too.
- tim333 1y agoI'd imagine, given the rate of progress with AI and robots, the most practical would be to send robots ahead and have them build the infrastructure for some people to maybe visit later?
- PaulHoule 1y agoI did an analysis of sending a factory sent to a carbonaceous chondrite asteroid that builds a factory factory which builds a solar sail factory that sends solar sails back to Earth-Sun L1 to counter climate change. The first thing in the decision tree is "do you send a crew?" and you're trading off the hard problem of teleoperating the thing (need a big advanced in autonomy) vs the hard problem of providing a habitat and liklihood that the crew doesn't come home. So yeah, sending bots ahead to build an environment is an option even on Mars. I think Wall-E. If you're going that far though you might consider not sending intact humans at all and just sending the eggs and growing them out either artificially or in some other animal. (I see the Ceres thing as being on the line to interstellar colonization whereas I don't see Mars as such. A likely intermediate step past that is doing something similar on an outer solar system or interstellar body, say, Titan or Pluto, powered by D-D fusion.)
- jandrese 1y agoI had a back of the napkin design that was basically a sleeve that fitted over Starship and could be launched into orbit. Those sleeves had angled ends that could then be bolted together in orbit to make a station with an octagon shape that could be spun at 2 or 3 rpm to get 1/2 Earth gravity. Obviously still an enormous engineering challenge, but one that I think is solvable using today's tech. Well, tomorrows tech, but nothing that requires a breakthrough in materials science or basic physics or anything like that. My plan was to fit the inside with huge water bags that would help to reduce cosmic radiation, provide thermal mass, and slow any micrometeorites that puncture the hull. The water could be launched on cheaper rockets and transferred in orbit. The water could also be pumped between sections to keep the wheel balanced. The central hub area would be more of a challenge, probably having to be assembled (or at least unfolded) in orbit. Probably the biggest downside is that you wouldn't be able to spin it up until the entire structure was somewhat balanced, which means installing things like solar panels and radiators in pairs and the docking bit of the central hub would probably need to be on bearings so it can counter rotate to be effectively stationary or you wouldn't be able to dock more than 2 spacecraft at a time. The ISS was built in sections over the course of decades, this would need to be built all in one go, which is a huge commitment. NASA's plans for two tethered stations (or one station and a counterweight) are probably more feasible, but much less cool.
- mr_toad 1y ago> large amounts of nitrogen or some other inert gas You could ship liquid ammonia and then burn it to produce nitrogen and water.
- kristianp 1y agoI vaguely remember O'Neil's book talking about zero g manufacturing by welding together plates of Aluminium. Although I may be remembering some other work. Could we use an inflatable workshop to weld together cylindrical sections of a torus? I can imagine sealing the end of the torus secrion and extruding it out the side of the inflatable. Very hazardous for the workers, I imagine.
- pfdietz 1y agoO'Neill colonies are impractical because they involve large wasted air spaces. The mass needed to resist pressure loads is proportional to (volume) x (pressure), so it's best to stack floors so all that volume can be put to use.