3 ms·
The C suite may make some dumb short-term mistakes - just like twenty years ago when they tried to outsource all software development to cheaper countries - but
by simonw 1y ago
The C suite may make some dumb short-term mistakes - just like twenty years ago when they tried to
outsource all software development to cheaper countries - but they'll either course-correct when they spot those mistakes or will be out-competed by other, smarter companies.
- reactordev 1y agoThe market will always respond. When it happened before, younger - smarter - more efficient competitors emerged.
- ringeryless 1y agothis. i mean, look at xerox or big blue
- jimbob45 1y agoHR can remain irrational longer than I can remain solvent.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- shikon7 1y agoUntil someone makes the idea fashionable to replace HR with AI.
- owebmaster 1y agoThen it will be forever irrational.
- pseudocomposer 1y agoHR isn’t irrational; you’re just making the mistake of thinking their role is to serve you, the employee, as opposed to the C-suite and shareholders.
- fakedang 1y agoExcept it makes sense in a lot of recent off-shoring cases. While there are still your usual stupid companies outsourcing to Indian WITCH, a lot of midsize companies are also doing alright with nearshoring to either LatAm or even just out of SF/Seattle/NY (in the case of US companies), and Eastern Europe (in the case of EU companies). Even in biotech for instance, preliminary research has been successfully outsourced to either academia or to Indian and Chinese CROs. The latter have done exceptionally well, even innovating new products on their own and licensing them to the US market. The myth of onsite worker efficiency was practically shattered with Covid. Where the Western worker can really only shine is in advancing on the tech forefront and helping keep that tech within Western borders. Stuff like defence or cybersecurity or some advanced new product/tool development. Anything else is free to be arbitraged away.
- simonh 1y agoIt's getting there, slowly, because a lot of the initial bootstrapping problems have been worked through. Lets say there are 1,000 decent engineers in a country and they get hired by various western companies and it's all a great success. They're very happy, obviously offshoring there works well, other companies pile in and hire 10,000 engineers. Ok, are there another 10,000 decent engineers in the country? Probably not, but maybe you can poach some of the 1,000 and use them to train up the other 10,000. But soon there are openings for 100,000 offshored jobs, then 500,000. How many well trained engineers are there again? That ramp up takes time, and it's not just a matter of smart people, it's relevant experience. If you have two countries with the same number of competent trained people, but in one of them 5% have directly relevant experience, and in the other 50% of them do, that's a massive advantage that cannot even be solved with money. Then there's the fact the the most talented and experienced people move out of the country. So for every 10 engineers that get to top tier, 3-4 of them move to Europe or the US. So, not only are these countries losing those people, but also they're losing out on all the juniors they could lead and train up. Hiring there is like trying to fill a leaky bucket. None of which is to say this is impossible, or that it isn't worth doing, or that it won't work. I've seen it work, and the company I'm at now has reaped huge benefits from offshoring. You just need to go into it clear eyed and with the understanding that it has to work for the people you're offshoring to, and that country as well, and you need to be adaptable as the situation changes.
- cardanome 1y agoThat assumes a free and efficient market. Good luck with that. The big tech monopolists can literally buy off any emerging competition. They have massive political influence that they can leverage to shape the market based on their needs. Not that there would be any political appetite to challenge national "champions" in times of rising international tension anyway. They are too big to fail.
- ringeryless 1y agountil they aren't. don't discount the possibility of a total rout for those who put all eggs in such a shoddy basket. interesting to note the limits of political influence now that the megabill stripped the ai moratorium nonsense. i suspect that the brick and mortar politicos are a bit like "thanks for the money, now bugg off, kid, before i beat you up" it will be interesting to see what sort of revenge the worlds richest man is cooking for his uppity fixer dude.
- marcosdumay 1y agoOr, if a government tries to protect them, the entire country will be outcompeted in an ugly, bloody process that can take the best part of a century and leave millions of people behind. Yes, markets work. But people insist on ignoring attrition against all the evidence. It's an almost religious belief.
- dyauspitr 1y agoThey’re still doing that. All the tens are of thousands of layoffs you’re hearing about are still going to India.