10 ms·
Spain and Brazil push global action to tax the super-rich and curb inequality
- ymgch 1y agoBrazil lacks the moral authority to promote any global action. End.
- rebanevapustus 1y ago> Brazil One of the most violently unequal countries on the planet. Very proficient however in virtue signalling.
- mvid 1y ago“The problem isn’t solved, so how dare they try to solve it”
- pennaMan 1y agoThey are not trying to solve it. They are pretending to solve it by masking the underlying issue and making things worse in the proccess.
- exe34 1y agoWorse for whom? If it's for people richer than me, I'm okay with it.
- octo888 1y agoThat is completely obviously not what they meant
- carlosjobim 1y agoEverybody who is richer than me are bourgeois scum and should have all their property confiscated. Everybody who is poorer than me are lazy bums and shouldn't get any more help.
- actionfromafar 1y agoI don't have high hopes it will solve anything, but I'm also not sold on it making anything significantly worse.
- octo888 1y agoAlso let's not forget Spain's endless corruption scandals. You aren't going to tax the people giving you money
- diggan 1y ago> You aren't going to tax the people giving you money Lol, why are we still being taxed then? We do have endless corruption scandals though, that part is pretty accurate, but they still tax us like there is no tomorrow. At least we have pretty good healthcare, so it isn't all doom and gloom like the "news" want us to believe.
- skirge 1y agohealth insurance contribution is considered as tax in Spain?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- octo888 1y agoI meant: you're not going to tax the people giving you bribes. Are you bribing politicians LOL? I hope not
- diggan 1y agoNo, at least not as far as I know :) But we are indeed paying their salaries ("giving you money") via our taxes, I guess that's what I thought when you wrote that. No foul :)
- Propelloni 1y agoLike I said elsewhere, virtue signaling is moving the Overton window. It works pretty well for the alt-right, so we know it is working. Reading the press release shows me that Spain and Brazil are aware that this is a hard problem. They are especially aware that a nation, or two nations, alone cannot solve it, thus they suggest a "global registry", which is basically a "abolish tax havens" again. Let's see how far we get this time, I wish them all the best.
- owebmaster 1y agoTaxing wealth-extracting foreign corporations is a way to have resources to fix the inequality.
- eclecticfrank 1y agoGermany technically has a wealth tax. However, it is supended since 1997, because the methods of how real estate wealth was calculated were outdated and thus considered unconsittutional. Tax is not collected, but the supporting law has never been revoked. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verm%C3%B6gensteuer_(Deutschland) https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verm%C3%B6gensteuer_(Deutschla... (Sorry, no translation available)
- kleiba 1y agoInterestingly, the court order in question demanded that real estate should be taxed higher than the status quo - instead, the conservative government decided not to collect that tax at all any more. Wikipedia claims that this decision was partly due to the max tax rate being at 53% at the time. Today, it has dropped to 42%, but for some strange reason, the wealth tax has never been reinstated.
- rckt 1y agoConsidering how everything is rigged in favor for the rich I don't have high hopes for this. But it would be great if they really come up with a system that makes sense and offers equal tax regimes for everybody. Right now if I'm not mistaken in Spain the most taxed people (in terms of ratio) are those who earn < ~300K per year.
- diggan 1y ago> Right now if I'm not mistaken in Spain the most taxed people (in terms of ratio) are those who earn < ~300K per year. You are mistaken. Currently, the higher income you have here, the higher tax rate you have, where the highest tax rate on income sits at 47%, which you get hit by when your income is above 300K/year. People between 60K and 300K sits at 45%. And then there are regional differences, someone in Andalucía don't pay the same amount of taxes as someone who lives in Catalunya for example, where the top tax rate is 50%. Even taking into account other taxes we have, you still end up paying more in taxes the more you earn, unless you start engaging in schemes to lessen your tax burden, obviously. Although the social security is capped, so it does increase slower once you go beyond the cap, but it doesn't start regressing which your comment hinted at. Edit: important to note that the tax rates are all marginal tax rates, maybe that was a bit unclear.
- foota 1y agoWow, a 45% tax starting at 60k is kinda unreal.
- diggan 1y agoWhy is that? Sure, not all of it goes directly to people who need it, but I generally feel fine paying that amount of taxes, because I myself got helped by others paying taxes when I was dirt-poor but still needed to go to the hospital. If/once you reach that point (+60K/year), you already live a above-average life, why not share some of that with others who aren't as good/lucky as yourself? Seems like a no-brainer to me, but I might be too European to really grasp the problem.
- v5v3 1y agoIf Spain can get support from across the EU. And Brazil the same from BRICS then we could see change. Best not to hold your breath though...
- raverbashing 1y agoBRICS is just an acronym, it is void of any meaningful significance other than that. Edit: "oh but it's an actual organization" yeah with still very little significance between pretending it's anything but a convenient proxy for the bigger members
- diggan 1y ago> BRICS is just an acronym, it is void of any meaningful significance other than that. I think your understanding of BRICS might be slightly outdated, did you read about the last time in the late 90s or something? It's beyond just an acronym today, with institutions actively involved, new initiatives and more.
- impossiblefork 1y agoI don't think, just an acronym, but my impression is that the only thing BRICS or BRICS+ agree on and are actively co-operating to achieve is collectively getting off the dollar and ending the effects of the so-called exorbitant privilege on themselves.
- owebmaster 1y agoIf that is the "only" thing, it is quite the ambitious goal
- impossiblefork 1y agoMaybe, but should it really be hard? Either one gets rid of the oil trade-- which I think is quite feasible, then the need to acquire dollars to buy these products goes away, so there's nothing more needed, or one negotiates something with one of the many countries which either have or could acquire the ability to produce oil where one bypasses the dollar trade. Maybe, if they didn't have Russia in the group and had talked to more people about the sanctions, something like 'we need this, and the alternative is Russia-- can't you be flexible and not sanction Venezuela', they could have even used Venezuela.
- GardenLetter27 1y agoThis is the wrong way to look at the issue. The super-rich don't stay rich by just sitting on their money, they invest it. These countries should focus on encouraging investment there - by getting rid of bureaucracy and red tape, make it possible to hire across the whole EU a lot easier, without needing separate tax registration in every country, etc. Lower the barriers to entry wherever possible - no long application processes for developments with endless consultations, no arbitrary minority language or qualification requirements, etc. Income inequality is a good thing, but there needs to be equal access to education and opportunities and the lowest barriers to entry possible.
- bestouff 1y ago> Income inequality is a good thing That's your opinion. I fail to see how the differences were have today make sense and could be good for the society.
- newsclues 1y agoTake the global wealth, divide it by the population, and redistribute it evenly. Suddenly a lot of productive assets are no longer working. Do you think capital allocation will be better when it's being done by everyone?
- johnecheck 1y agoBad take. Obviously if you you cut a factory into a million pieces and hand them out, you've lost value. Investment tools cover all your concerns here. (Hopefully paired with a regulatory framework that prevents scams (looking at you, crypto))
- Jensson 1y ago> Investment tools cover all your concerns here. Nope, since you decided that investments can't make you richer investment tools no longer works. And if investments are allowed to make you richer you didn't solve wealth inequality, because most people will just spend and consume rather than invest in anything.
- myrmidon 1y agoI think increased automation and now AI are making wealth inequality problems inherently worse. The existence (and prevalence) of food delivery work alone is a depressing portent in my view: If delivering food for objectively shitty pay is still a viable option for a lot of people, that signals to me that human labor has become borderline worthless (even in a wealthy/developed environment). That makes the "american dream" (=> start from nothing, do a good job, become wealthy) increasingly less realistic. I'm also afraid that this (preventing wealth inequality from getting out-of-control) might be a "practically unsolvable" problem for democracies in general (just like managing housing and public pensions): It is too easy to "sabotage" democratic progress for the negatively affected minority (and that minority is exceedingly powerful/well-positioned, too).
- barney54 1y agoAI hasn't had an impact yet. Automation is great and has made things undeniably better. In the 1800s, 30% of the US GDP was tree cutting. https://x.com/AlecStapp/status/1939912893102760063 https://x.com/AlecStapp/status/1939912893102760063 Before automation, nearly everyone was involved with agriculture. Today is much better.
- myrmidon 1y agoI'm not saying that things are necessarily gonna get worse-- just that human work decreasing in relative value creates huge (new!) problems for our current wealth distribution mechanisms. Maybe there is an easy way to have our cake and eat it, too (like consistent wealth taxation like the article suggests), but I'm doubtful. In the past, basically every form of investment used to involve human labor to some degree-- meaning that every rich industrial magnate also automatically created opportunities for zero-net-worth workers/builders/employees. But when your big investments just become server racks and industrial robots, then you no longer have this balancing mechanism, and you probably need to do something to prevent wealth concentration without bounds (and to guarantee opportunities for "worthless" individuals).
- ta1243 1y agoIn the US, over the last 45 years, work has increased in value about 3.5% a year, and the S&P about 9.5% a year. Work is not valued, wealth is.
- thisIsAtest25 1y agoHow are they going to do this? If they increase the tax burden on people's salaries, they'll start working informally (I live in Brazil and currently see that people look for various ways to escape income tax, whether by opening a company or choosing not to register formally (and they're not rich, but the state considers them rich, even earning ~$32k per year)). If they force companies to pay, the tax burden will be diluted into products/services, falling on the poorest. The right path is to reduce the size of the state - these policies will only make life worse for the poor. In a world with scarce resources, this problem has no solution.
- tsimionescu 1y agoThe state is the solution to this type of problem. Reducing the size of the state only serves to take resources away from democratic control and into the hands of private entities.
- thisIsAtest25 1y agoIn a perfect world without greed and corruption, I would agree with you. However, I live in Brazil, where the state is constitutionally mandated to provide all basic necessities (healthcare, education, etc.) and we have one of the highest tax rates in the world. Additionally, corruption here is absurd. Despite having enormous budgets, the services the state provides are inadequate. Many people choose to sacrifice an additional portion of their income (on top of what they already pay in taxes) to access these services privately. Even with extensive social policies and taxes on virtually everything you do — salary, consumption, transfers, inheritance, literally everything — quality of life remains poor. High tax rates actually breaks development. We must be cautious about supporting policies that tax the wealthy more heavily, because when the state considers someone earning $2,000 per month to be 'rich'—which already happens, as evidenced by the current income tax brackets (IRPF)—these measures won't improve anyone's life.
- alpaccount 1y agoAbsolutely spot on: > Many people choose to sacrifice an additional portion of their income (on top of what they already pay in taxes) to access these services privately. In Brazil you pay taxes which are supposed to grant you health care, education, safety. None of that happens, so you pay (again) for private school, healthcare, insurance and so on. Anyone that lives/lived there knows this.
- newsclues 1y agoA billionaire is 1000x wealth of a millionaire. A millionaire is 1000x the wealth as someone with a thousand bucks. As someone closer to a net worth closer to $1000, it sure is funny watching the rich millionaires complain about the rich billionaires. I bet the millionaires don't think the wealth transfers and confiscation they support for the billionaires, will ever be applied to them.
- guappa 1y ago> A millionaire is 100x the wealth as someone with a thousand bucks. You're off by an order of magnitude.
- newsclues 1y agono, it was a typing error
- s_dev 1y ago>A millionaire is 100x the wealth as someone with a thousand bucks. Run your math again through a calculator.
- newsclues 1y agonot hitting a key on the keyboard isn't an error in calculating. Did you not understand the point being communicated?
- s_dev 1y ago>not hitting a key on the keyboard isn't an error in calculating. It really is an error in calculating. That's the great thing about math, it doesn't care how you 'feel' or what you 'wanted to express'. You need to update your comment and the error will be gone and not try to argue semantics.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bluecalm 1y agoInstead of calling for more surveillance, government overreach, and other communist wet dream fantasies like a global registry of wealth they could have started by fixing things in their own countries. One good way would be to start taxing assets they control like land. Tax land value and suddenly there will be incentives to build more. Tax land value under big touristic resorts and use that revenue to fund local services instead of killing middle class with taxes on their productivity as they are currently doing. Instead of complaining about rich people buying big houses and a lot of land around just tax that - that aligns incentives and makes presence of rich people profitable for local communities. What they want to do instead though is first tax assets people have in other countries which don't influence them what so over and then if those people want to leave they cry foul as well - you will stay and you will like it - exactly as in communist Cuba. >>There’s a real need to know who the beneficial owners are behind companies and legal structures used to conceal wealth,” said Mr. Gascón Maybe there is, maybe there isn't. If you tax assets and get rid of corporate income tax replacing it with revenue based taxes (like a new digital tax idea or a tax on big super market chains) and a land value tax then it doesn't matter who is behind what as the local entity has to pay anyway. If you build an attractive country companies and people will pay you to live and do business there. Why are you so obsessed on their total wealth? Is it maybe more about control and power than paying your "fair share"? The thing is they don't want fair taxation. They want to take wealth of productive people and give to their ever increasing number of cronies. This kind of toxic thinking geared towards punishing productivity and making sure no one gets ahead too far is a cancer in Europe and imo major reason old EU countries stagnate instead of growing.
- ffsm8 1y agoTrump ain't gonna stand for that. No chance in hell this isn't getting derailed
- samiv 1y agoI hope this works. The only way to save the economy and the society is by taxing the rich. Think about it for a minute. The rich people hoard all the resources, financial assets, means of production and in the competition for resources they will (and are doing so) displace everyone else in the economy (and really from society also). This means that those who are displaced have no means to participate in the economy. And not only that but also they will be pushed to the fringes of the society and exists in slum conditions. This will stiff the economy and hollow it out. Let's say for arguments sake that the government taxes X hundred of millions of $ from the bezos/musks/gates/etc. and put that into the economy by - indirectly or directly hiring people - building infrastructure - providing services for the citizens (education, health care etc) - providing benefits to those who need. All that money will immediately go back into the economy stimulating all kinds of economic activity. And essentially two weeks later that same X hundred million is back in the bank account of bezos/musk/gates and it can be taxed again! By letting the uber rich hoard the wealth that wealth is essentially away from the economy providing very little economic activity. In economy this is known as the "high propensity to spend". The "poor" (i.e. working/middle class people) have high propensity to spend, the rich have low propensity to spend. Tax the wealth, not the work! This has been done before and it can be done again! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Deal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Deal
- tzekid 1y agoIn modern societies: top 1% of earners pay roughly 30% of taxes top 5% pay 65% of taxes top 10% pay 80% of taxes while bottom 50% usually barely make 2% of taxes. Heavy redistribution of wealth is already in place and it's not making things better.
- samiv 1y ago"Heavy redistribution of wealth is already in place and it's not making things better." You're right, because the distribution is removing large groups of people from the economy. Just for reference, this has been done before and it produced possibly one of the best economies (at the time) and it was very social democrat. This was the United States after the so called "New Deal". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Deal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Deal And just to make it crystal clear, we're not talking about taxing working people. We're talking about taxing the obscenely wealthy people who just sit on massive amounts of wealth, whether it's stocks or property or yachts or mansions or gold and jewelry. You know the > 10-1000x millionairs
- cucubeleza 1y agoBrazilian government is dumb as hell, just tax everything and waste money with idiot things and a lot of corruption, tax the rich will make then flee to another country like Arab Emirates or USA, so more money for then, less for the country, extremely common L of the Workers Party
- mafuy 1y agoSo what do you propose instead, since you seem to figured it all out?
- cucubeleza 1y agocut unnecessary spending (Brazil has TONS of it), cut taxes, cut bureaucracies and not hide inflation like they do it's a good start. And you, what's your propose? You also thing that tax rich people will make the other side richer?
- alpaccount 1y ago> cut taxes Yep, this is absolutely correct. I don't see how people don't realize this, the simplest way to make brazil less unequal is to REDUCE tax! From wiki: > The collection of federal taxes on the reserve base, shows that of the amount collected by the IRS of Brazil, the majority of the taxes are based on consumption, with approximately 53% on average of the funds raised by Revenue Federal Brazil and continue accounting for more than half of tax (52%) charged by the agency. This tax structure is even more perverse when we add the taxes collected at the state and municipal levels, which bring in the largest source of revenue. The tax burden on consumption is regressive. In Brazil those who earn up to twice the minimum wage spend 26% of their income to pay indirect taxes, while the tax burden for families with income higher than 30 times the minimum wage amounts to only 7%. Excessive taxation on consumption depresses demand directly affecting the economy, reducing the consumption of the middle and lower income families. Taxing the rich will solve nothing (and let's be honest, this government is not aiming nor has the capacity to enforce it). Something much simpler is just let people be able to consume things, by removing taxes and cutting spending (probably not even necessary given how much the state already takes from its people). Super simple, but, as usual, we love to overcomplicate it and play the popularity game.
- WinstonSmith84 1y agoMaybe these economies shall try to attract the wealthy before trying to tax them ... Or is that so that because of past fiscal policies, the wealthy are gone and are now missing out to the economy? :-) The reality is that many (other) countries understand this and attract these wealthy people who contribute to their own economy - because wealthy people are more than people with a large bank account, it's usually entrepreneurs who will hire local workforce for their business, buy real estate, etc. If one knows Brazil and especially Spain, the other reality is that this initiative is certainly driven by a socialist-populist agenda, nothing to see here. Either way, this initiative is just a show, and sure to fail for many reasons.
- mg794613 1y agoWe can see a lot of knee-jerk responses from people with Stockholm syndrome. - No, the rich won't run away. - No, the rich are not carrying the country. - No, caring for another or a lesser fortunate, isn't communism. It's weird I have to say it, but some really need to hear it.
- HamsterDan 1y agoIf the rich won't run away, then Spain and Brazil don't need global action. They could just jack up taxes on the rich in their own countries. And since you've now pinky sworn that the rich will stay and pay the extra taxes, it won't have any adverse effects domestically.
- ozgrakkurt 1y agoWhy is it bad to tax based on wealth and not on income?
- throwawayb2025 1y agoForcing rich people to invest in low return area might be better strategy. If they know how to make money productive, they can make that area grow faster so that gdp can grow faster. This will ensure rich people money grows at higher rate only if gdp grows. Asking government to manage money is very in efficient.
- solstice 1y agoTrevor Noah had a good take on the absurdity of stocks and unrealised gains with their Schrödinger's-cat-like qualities: https://youtu.be/Gqlbn2nPO-A?t=84 https://youtu.be/Gqlbn2nPO-A?t=84
- LePetitPrince 1y ago[dead]
- alpaccount 1y agoI've replied to a comment with this but I'll leave it here. Reducing inequality in Brazil (even a tiny amount) is a DEAD SIMPLE problem that is not in any way related to the government taking more money from people (rich or poor), but, rather, in taking LESS money: > The collection of federal taxes on the reserve base, shows that of the amount collected by the IRS of Brazil, the majority of the taxes are based on consumption, with approximately 53% on average of the funds raised by Revenue Federal Brazil and continue accounting for more than half of tax (52%) charged by the agency. This tax structure is even more perverse when we add the taxes collected at the state and municipal levels, which bring in the largest source of revenue. The tax burden on consumption is regressive. In Brazil those who earn up to twice the minimum wage spend 26% of their income to pay indirect taxes, while the tax burden for families with income higher than 30 times the minimum wage amounts to only 7%. Excessive taxation on consumption depresses demand directly affecting the economy, reducing the consumption of the middle and lower income families. We're talking about a country where minimum wage is 260ish dollars a month, and a macbook costs TWICE what it costs in the US, where people make much more. We're structured in a way where only rich people have access to anything. You can tax said rich people more, but they'll just keep being the ones that can afford anything at all. source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_Brazil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_Brazil
- msgodel 1y agoYeah Brazil's issue isn't that it isn't taxing its people enough. As usual these things always just go after the middle class and sort people into destitute vs rich buckets. IE they exacerbate inequality.
- mathiaspoint 1y agoCrazy so many people jump to follow political ideas from Brazil given its track record with inequality.
- owenizzhr 1y agoYeah, socialism always works. Look how well the retribution of wealth did for the Soviet Union, Cuba, China, even Russia today. Socialism isn't the answer. If you take away the individual rewards of success you are awarded with "SUCK-N-EXCESS," Look at some successful societies: Japan, New Zealand, Germany. Not socialist. Success was rewarded and societies benefited.
- RweInNd2Dy4Us 1y agoAbsolutely? Wealthy Must Be Accountable Regardless Super Rich Lifestyle, Generosity Spreads Hopefully With Help!!! Mankind Needs Sensible Solutions Rich Or Poorer, Taxes Finance Programs For All People Needy?
- msgodel 1y agoYes Spain and Brazil are both countries we should try to emulate. Absolutely great places to live, especially if you're young. Bright futures.