5 ms·
Feasibility study of a mission to Sedna – Nuclear propulsion and solar sailing
- stevenAthompson 1y agoWhy dont they just launch a string of hundreds or thousands of tiny mesh probes out of a canon over a longer period of months or years? They dont need to be powerful if you have a big mesh network and each probe would only need to cost about what a cell phone does.
- walrus01 1y agoCheck out the antenna size, path loss, link budget and modulation and FEC that were required for new horizons to send back data at the equivalent of about 2400 bps. Tiny cubesat size things have no hope of sensing useful data to earth.
- stevenAthompson 1y agoI'm not talking about launching a cubesat, I'm talking about launching a mesh network of thousands or millions of mass produced devices half or a quarter the size of a cubesat. New Horizons, to use your example, weighed a thousand pounds and used a 2 meter dish transmitting at something like 12 watts to compensate for the fact that the receivers are billions of miles from earth and hidden beneath a blanket of RF noise. The inverse square law can't really be beaten at that kind of distance so everything becomes inefficient by design. If we can pick up that tiny 12 watt whisper of a signal from billions of miles away, surely we we could design much lower power omnidirectional signals that relay between mesh nodes closer together using far less power? Imagine a string of probes that are all within a few thousand miles of each other with clear line of sight. Yes, we might need six million of them to cover that same distance, but if they were cell phone sized devices produced using what we've learned about consumer electronics it should be feasible to just keep launching them forever, for a few hundred bucks apiece, until we eventually build a large network that could assemble high resolution data by combining multiple sources. We keep trying to fight the rocket equation, but that's not a battle that can be won. Mass is always going to be the limiting factor for space exploration, so maybe we can just start launching lots of intelligent low mass things regularly instead of the occasional big dumb thousand pound lump of metal.
- grues-dinner 1y agoThe general principle is sound but the engineering is rather a problem. Assuming the launcher is solved (railgun, light gas gun, whatever), and a giant dish to pick up the even tinier then usual signals (maybe the DSN is already enough even, but the US already knows how to build an Orion satellite, so a giant space-based dish isn't impossible), what I would guess to be the sticking points would be the probes themselves. Each one needs whatever sensors, but more importantly, the auxiliary stuff to last years or decades in transit: in particular power supplies, heaters (=power!) if you can't make your electronics survive constant cryogenic temperatures, as well as comms amongst themselves to organise the mesh and high-gain comms back to Earth. Maybe the worst of that could be solved with a nuclear power supply and then it's basically "just" radio and software design. I also don't think you'd use onmidirectional mesh comms, you can get a lot of milage (literally) out of a phased array that can steer the beam at each target, plus it also becomes a bonus multistatic radar network.
- stevenAthompson 1y ago>the engineering is rather a problem I suppose that's my point. It's really just a series of maybe-not-that-easily solvable engineering problems, and it would allow us to not only explore further but to do it at a relatively low cost and with the ability to "upgrade" the network gradually as each generation of probe improves. More importantly, it would allow us to finally get around that pesky rocket equation and do it cheaply enough that we might actually get political buy-in. > nuclear power supply This was my exact thought, a small RTG power supply in each could provide enough power for hundreds of years with no moving parts. Not enough for billion mile transmitters anymore, but now they don't have to be. > phased array that can steer the beam at each target That's a great idea, and like most of the individual pieces of the plan it's kind of a thing we already know how to do. Sure, you could dedicate the next decade to solving it well, but you COULD solve it today with variations on off the shelf systems. Really, the power source and antenna design are just a few of several hundred (thousands?) of engineering problems that would need to be solved, but all of the engineering challenges I can think of are solvable with variations on current tech. The only reason it isn't being done is that nobody is doing it.
- pdabbadabba 1y ago> Why dont they just launch a string of hundreds or thousands of tiny mesh probes out of a canon over a longer period of months or years? The word 'just' is doing a whole lot of work in that sentence!
- prewett 1y agoCannon, not canon (the official texts, e.g. biblical canon, or Star Wars canon). They don't launch space probes out of cannons because they don't make it out of the atmosphere. According to [1], muzzle velocity of a cannon is about 1685 ft/sec, which is 0.51 km/s. Delta-v to orbit is around 10 km/s. This is a feature, though, because launching your cannon shell into orbit means it isn't hitting it's target. But let's suppose you have some propellant that is 20 times more potent. A cannon imparts all the energy at the beginning, with the acceleration happening as the expanding gasses push the projectile out of the tube. Assuming that the probe survives the initial explosion (unlikely), it is going to accelerate to 10 km/s very rapidly. Once calculation [2] put the g-force on a cannon shell to be 15 g, but lets say 10 g to be conservative. So we need 20 times more acceleration, so 200 g. Even if your probe is not smooshed in the acceleration, it is unlikely to be functional. (Note that, in comparison to cannons, rockets avoid this problem by providing the acceleration over a long period of time) Now if you managed to engineer it for 200 g, air friction is going to burn it up. We know this because when spacecraft come down they have to lose all the velocity they got going up, and they tend to burn up. Heat shielding is almost certainly going to put you over the weight limit. What, you say? This is a space cannon? Okay, well leaving aside how this cannon is going to burn the propellant without oxygen, the delta-v to Pluto from LEO is 8.2 km/s, so Sedna will be a little bit more. This is still an order of magnitude larger than the cannon, and still has acceleration problems. Plus, you had to use a rocket to get the payload to the cannon, so putting a second stage on the rocket. You still have the issue that it's going to take a couple of decades to get there, which is what this paper is trying to address. [1] https://www.arc.id.au/CannonBallistics.html https://www.arc.id.au/CannonBallistics.html [2] https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/3249185/calculate-g-force-on-cannon-payload https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/3249185/calculate-g...
- stevenAthompson 1y agoThose are valid points, and I appreciate you taking the time to make them. To clarify, when I misspelled "cannon" I just meant "big gun" rather than a literal piece of primitive weaponry. More importantly, I would like to point out that while all of your concerns are valid, many of those problems were already solved in the 1960's. Project HARP[1] was able to use a 400 lb projectile to launch a 185 lb payload to a height of 111 miles... in 1966. We don't need anything close to 185 lbs of payload. You'll note that 111 miles up is considered suborbital space. HARP was built mostly of 1950's era technology, and cost between $1000-$3000 per payload to fire. It had a 16" barrel and could be reloaded in about an hour. The payloads were encapsulated within a "sabot" to protect them, and the sabot seemed to do it's job, because primitive electronic instrument packages were deployed without being destroyed and weather balloons were deployed with success. The long term plan for that project was to add a second stage which would push the payload into orbit, or beyond. There is no reason to believe it wouldn't have worked, but the Vietnam war happened and people lost the taste for funding space exploration. It was shut down. The enormous gun is still there, rusting where it was abandoned after firing nearly 100 ballistic payloads into suborbital space Now, if we could fire ballistic payloads into suborbital space in 1966 what do you think we could achieve today? Honestly, the engineering isn't even that difficult, it's just a matter of figuring out how to pay for it. The rest is an incremental improvement over something we could already do in the 60's. Sure, I'm glossing over a ton of minor issues (like the entire second stage), but those problems are also basically solved and we've learned a few things in the last 60 years. I not only think it's possible, I think someone should give it a shot (pun intended). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_HARP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_HARP
- jmyeet 1y agoSo I'm a fan of space exploration but this one seems... a reach. First, you can't say that any of this propulsion tech is remotely mission-ready. It's all very speculative. There's been no real-world testing of any kind. You'd need to at least test-fire it in orbit and prove a solar sail in particular. Any kind of nuclear propulsion adds whole new levels of proof-of-solution (yes I know RTGs exist but those are technically quite simple being just radioactive decay rather than something utilizing fission or fusion). Second, it's not clear what kind of speed this could reach. At New Horizons speed, assuming you can find the right launch window, you're looking at 18-25 years transit. That's a long time for a probe to survive. If you do adopt a solar sail, what happens to it over 20+ years? What happens from long-term damage of hitting dust and micrometeors? Could you need to course corret if it gives uneven thrust? And all this for... a flyby. Obviously Sedna is too far and too slow for anything else. Just like Pluto. But if we're talking 2j0-30 year missions, I'd rather send an orbiter to Uranus. About 20 years is I believe the time frame for an orbital insertion to Uranus. IIRC Neptune is closer to 30.
- santaNorthPole 1y ago[flagged]
- prewett 1y agoCentauri Dreams (https://www.centauri-dreams.org/ https://www.centauri-dreams.org/) has a nice summary (as well as regular fare of this sort).
- pavel_lishin 1y ago> Sedna is expected to pass through the perihelion of its orbit in 2075--2076 and then move again away from the Sun. Considering the distances involved, a mission targeting the object would need to be launched "relatively" soon, especially if using conventional propulsion systems, which could require up to 30 years of deep-space travel. Sedna's perihelion is ~76 AU - more than twice as far as Pluto, which took New Horizons nearly a decade to reach. Sedna's apehelion is over 500 AU. > The Direct Fusion Drive rocket engine is under development at Princeton University Plasma Physics Laboratory Is it ... is it actually working? How close are they? And even if they get it to work next year, will it be something well-engineered & reliable enough to send it into space for 10 years and expect it to work?
- zamadatix 1y agoIt was ~15 years between the V-2 rocket crossing the Karman line to a human walking on the moon. 15 years from now we will have time for a 10 year break followed by another 15 years before we'd need to launch such a 10 year mission to be there by 2075-2076. The real question "is there actually fund this engine and mission to bring that to completion in the next 40 years" than whatever the completion and reliability is today.
- SJC_Hacker 1y agoIt was 25 years from V2 to Apollo 11. 55 years from Apollo 11 to Katy Perry
- pfdietz 1y agoIt's a scheme based on rotating magnetic field drive (RMF) of field reversed configurations. The claim is that they can preferentially accelerate and recover energy from 3He ions, greatly reducing DD fusion and associated neutrons. I question the recovery part (how is the entropy that is introduced by ion-ion collisions removed?), but do not have the expertise to fully evaluate the claim. In any case, it certainly cannot be ready next year, and would require large amounts of 3He.
- nicktelford 1y ago
- chuckledog 1y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedna_(dwarf_planet) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedna_(dwarf_planet)
- imglorp 1y agoThey know its radius is ~1000km but interestingly, there is no way to determine its mass without a flyby or other gravitational interaction. I guess you could swag it by using the lunar density, which gives ~~~ 10^22 kg. https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=4.189%C3%9710%5E9+km%5E3++*+3.344+g%2Fcm%5E3+ https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=4.189%C3%9710%5E9+km%5E...
- unwind 1y agoIt's actually the diameter that is 1,000 km, so I guess that changes the mass if assuming Lunar density to around 1.74×10^21 kg.
- _joel 1y agoWouldn't it's composition be of more ice and rock (like pluto), therefore lower density than the moon?
- sapiogram 1y agoThat's a reasonable assumption, but given Sedna's unusual orbit, its origin could also be quite different from Pluto's.
- benbayard 1y agoIn the wikipedia post you are replying to has the chemical composition of the surface of the planet, obviously we can't know what is beneath that, but to me, indicates this is closer to Pluto than it is to our Moon. > Detailed spectroscopic analysis has revealed Sedna's surface to be a mixture of the solid ices of water (H2O),[15] carbon dioxide (CO2), and ethane (C2H6), along with occasional sedimentary deposits of methane (CH4)-derived,[16] vividly reddish-colored organic tholins,[15] a surface chemical makeup somewhat similar to those of other trans-Neptunian objects.[17]
- myrmidon 1y agoThis direct fusion drive is a really interesting concept. Maybe something like this could be used for interstellar travel in a century (or five), it is very encouraging that there is active research on it. ~5kg of thrust is not a lot, but over time... This sounds significantly more feasible than nuclear pulse propulsion ("project orion" style) which I used to think was the only feasible approach to get to another star. One thing that was unclear from the paper to me: How does the fusion drive "pick" D/He3 fusion over D/D? Can this be "forced" by just cranking the plasma temperature way up? Or do you still just have to deal with a bunch of neutrons from undesired D/D fusion?
- floxy 1y agoRoundtrip Interstellar Travel Using Laser-Pushed Lightsails https://ia800108.us.archive.org/view_archive.php?archive=/24/items/wikipedia-scholarly-sources-corpus/10.2514.zip&file=10.2514%252F3.8632.pdf https://ia800108.us.archive.org/view_archive.php?archive=/24...
- myrmidon 1y agoThis is very interesting. Apparently beam collimation is much less of a show-stopper than I would have assumed. But I don't see us putting a a 1000 kilometer lens into orbit anytime soon, and that multi-terawatt (sustained!) laser system sounds like a bit of a headache, too...
- cnity 1y agoSee: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakthrough_Starshot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakthrough_Starshot
- pavel_lishin 1y ago> This paper discusses the use of solar system-based lasers to push large lightsail spacecraft over interstellar distances. The laser power system uses a 1000-km-diam. lightweight Fresnel zone lens that is capable of focusing laser light over interstellar distances. A one-way interstellar flyby probe mission uses a 1000 kg (1-metric-ton), 3.6-km-diam. lightsail accelerated at 0.36 m/s2 by a 65-GW laser system to 11% of the speed of light (0.11 c), flying by a Centauri after 40 years of travel. A rendezvous mission uses a 71-metric-ton, 30-km diam. payload sail surrounded by a 710-metric-ton, ring-shaped decelerator sail with a 100-km outer diam. The two are launched together at an acceleration of 0.05 m/s2 by a 7.2-TW laser system until they reach a coast velocity of 0.21 c. As they approach a Centauri, the inner payload sail detaches from the ring sail and turns its reflective surface to face the ring sail. A 26-TW laser beam from the solar system, focused by the Fresnel lens, strikes the heavier ring sail, accelerating it past a Centauri. The curved surface of the ring sail focuses the laser light back onto the payload sail, slowing it to a halt in the a Centauri system after a mission time of 41 years. The third mission uses a three-stage sail for a roundtrip manned exploration of e Eridani at 10.8 light years distance. Very cool.
- accrual 1y agoVery fascinating mission idea. Given how Sedna reaches so far away (>500AU), I wonder if the flyby would also reveal some details about conditions that distant. Maybe the surface contains some unexpected molecules that could shed light on its origin and what it's like that far out.
- pier25 1y ago> relatively soon If the DFD takes 10 years to get there it means it would need to be launched in 40 years. That's quite a timeline. Amazing that an organization can keep budgeting and planning for such a long project.
- ananddtyagi 1y agoSound like something out of 3 Body Problem
- mikewarot 1y agoAlready in orbit is OTP-2, which has 2 novel drive systems, one based on non-Newtonian thrusters, and the other based on an ION drive.[1] Edit: The latter is "Fusion enhanced"[3] The company’s the FireStar Drive uses is a water-fueled pulsed plasma thruster that uses a form of aneutronic nuclear fusion to boost its performance. I watch the orbital observations closely to see if any altitude is being gained.[2] This is their second satellite in orbit, the first one had high voltage power supply issues so they never got to try the thruster. [1] https://www.nanosats.eu/sat/otp-2 https://www.nanosats.eu/sat/otp-2 [2] https://celestrak.org/NORAD/elements/graph-orbit-data.php?CATNR=63235 https://celestrak.org/NORAD/elements/graph-orbit-data.php?CA... [3] https://www.aerospacetestinginternational.com/news/space/rocketstar-tests-fusion-enhanced-in-space-propulsion-process.html https://www.aerospacetestinginternational.com/news/space/roc...
- WaxProlix 1y agoAlready in orbit around Earth, notably. Not Sedna.
- mikewarot 1y agoNon-Newtonian drives have to prove they work outside the influences of a laboratory, if they work in low earth orbit, they should work anywhere. The Semi-Major Axis Altitude (SMAA) is a great proxy for orbital energy, and if they can make that number go way up, we should all take note, and start looking for new physics.
- codesnik 1y agosome measured effects in such experiments happen because of, for example, magnetic interference with the lab equipment. Well, on LEO there still present the Earth magnetic field, unlike in any usable interplanetary space. Interaction with the Earth magnetic field is already used by some satellites for orientation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetorquer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetorquer
- lgats 1y ago*IVO – Quantum Drive Propellantless Thruster - *The objective of the IVO Quantum Drive is to test the system in the LEO environment and qualify the drive’s ability to provide thrust utilizing proprietary quantum technology with no required propellant. Estimated Thrust: 1.75mN.
- mikewarot 1y agoI was surprised there were no references to past nuclear (fission) efforts, including a long test (more than 12.5 minutes) at 4000 megawatts of Pheobus 2A.[1] Perhaps there are some solid or non-cryogenic liquid fuels that could take place of the liquid hydrogen and make fission based systems far more feasible in the near term. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Rover#Phoebus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Rover#Phoebus
- jjk166 1y agoHydrogen is really the only propellant that makes sense for a nuclear thermal rocket. A nuclear reactor can't get substantially hotter or higher pressure than a chemical rocket engine, the reason it offers high specific impulse (basically efficiency) is because since you don't need chemical energy from the propellant to heat the propellant, 100% of your thrust can come from low molecular weight propellants (ie hydrogen). Helium will also give you better performance than chemical rockets, but substantially worse than hydrogen, and it's even more deeply cryogenic. Anything heavier than helium is going to provide little to no advantage over a chemical rocket, certainly nothing to justify the atrocious thrust to weight ratio and the extreme engineering challenges.
- fusionadvocate 1y agoBased on my experiences with Kerbal Space Program, this object seem to be almost being pushed off from solar orbit. Given its 'small' size, how much energy would be required to push it off the solar system?
- myrmidon 1y agoStill a no-can-do for our species currently, and it's not close. Would need around 1km/s on top of its average orbital velocity to escape, but the mass is probably roughly in the 10^22kg range, so thats like 10^28 Joule. Significantly more than a billion of the biggest nuclear bombs we built.