4 ms·
> But the core of my contention is that: if you make the platform that others run on and which creates entirely new economies and allows businesses to thrive, d
by amelius 1y ago
> But the core of my contention is that: if you make the platform that others run on and which creates entirely new economies and allows businesses to thrive, don’t you get to define the constraints that you want since it’s _your_ platform? What’s effectively happening here is that companies are using the courts to force the design of OSes in a certain way: That only open OSes can ever be made, not closed ones.
Huh, the __user__ paid for the product, so they own it. After the user handed over their money, Apple has nothing to say about who I do business with on that product, or what the conditions are.
You can say "platform" as much as you like, but that's just Apple's way of forcing their way into the argument.
Someone has to make the platform. If they want recognition for that or compensation, maybe they should apply for government funding. Don't bother the consumer with it.
And if you don't like a government regulating a market, then you haven't seen a company regulate one.
- zaphar 1y agoThe user can hack the product, install a different OS, Strike it with a hammer, or throw it away. Apple hasn't violated their rights in any way. Sure hacking it or installing a different OS are hard but rights are not meant to guarantee something is easy. I never bought the argument that user rights should dictate how a product hardware or software should be manufactured.
- ivell 1y ago> I never bought the argument that user rights should dictate how a product hardware or software should be manufactured Probably you meant it differently, but guaranties and warranties exist exactly due to this. Users have right to expect their device performs as advertised and in a reasonable manner.
- zaphar 1y agoI think those are more about ensuring that the user is buying what they think they are buying. They don't dictate exactly what is sold they merely offer protection to the user that what they bought is what was on the tin.
- wilsonnb3 1y agoIn some philosophical views, rights are meant to guarantee that things are easy. You can see that exact dynamic play out in US states regarding voter ID laws.
- zaphar 1y agoPerhaps, but I disagree with those views.
- aspenmayer 1y ago> I never bought the argument that user rights should dictate how a product hardware or software should be manufactured. How do you feel about user rights (of wheelchair users) dictating how a product hardware (such as public property and public and private spaces and structures open to the general public) should be manufactured (to include wheelchair ramps and and other amenities such as elevators and accessible restrooms)?
- _benton 1y ago> Huh, the __user__ paid for the product, so they own it. After the user handed over their money, Apple has nothing to say about who I do business with on that product, or what the conditions are. But this is already the case. You own the device, you can do whatever you want with it (legally ofc). If I buy a fridge without a freezer, the fact that I can't freeze food with it doesn't mean I don't own the fridge. Furthermore I don't appreciate other companies using the legal system to profit by forcing Apple to design their products in a specific way.
- bitpush 1y ago[flagged]
- _benton 1y agoIt does hurt when I can no longer purchase a product that I want because other corporations wish to use the legal system to make more money, yes.
- bitpush 1y ago[flagged]
- _benton 1y agoThis seems like a bad faith argument. But if you're being serious, I can buy non-nike shoes in the same way you can buy non-Apple phones. If anything, the people complaining about Apple would be upset by the lawsuit because they want to buy an iPhone despite other options being available. And in that case, the alternatives are cheaper not more expensive in the case of ethically made shoes.
- aspenmayer 1y agoWhen the analogy obscures more than it reveals, it ceases to be a reasoning aid, and becomes a red herring.