7 ms·
It's lead. Lead concentration in America "rapidly increased in the 1950s and then declined in the 1980s" [1]. There is a non-linear discontinuity among kids bo
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
It's lead.
Lead concentration in America "rapidly increased in the 1950s and then declined in the 1980s" [1]. There is a non-linear discontinuity among kids born in the mid 80s, with linear improvements through to those born in the late 2000s [2].
Arrest rates for violent crimes are highest from 15 to 29 years old (particularly 17 to 23-year olds) [3]. They're particularly low for adults after 50 years old.
We're around 40 years from the last of the high-lead children. 17 years ago is the late 2000s.
[1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1040618223002951 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S10406...
[2] https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/10.1289/EHP7932 https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/10.1289/EHP7932
[3] https://kagi.com/assistant/d2c6fdd5-73dd-4952-ae40-1f36aef1e268 https://kagi.com/assistant/d2c6fdd5-73dd-4952-ae40-1f36aef1e...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- PartiallyTyped 1y agoCan we blame lead for the US’ electoral landscape too?
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Can we blame lead for the US’ electoral landscape too? More of a pet theory, but voters born between 1950 and 1980, boomers and Gen X, have had a well-documented set of policy preferences.
- ivape 1y agoWhat if I told you voters born between nnnn-yyyy had a set of policy preferences?
- kayodelycaon 1y agoThere’s supposedly a cycle of attitude between generations. If your parents are X, you want to be Y. If your parents are Y, you want to be Z. If your parents are Z, you want to be X
- jdminhbg 1y agoBoomers were essentially statistically indistinguishable from Millennials in the 2024 presidential election: https://www.businessinsider.com/how-generations-voted-trump-harris-gen-z-gen-x-boomers-2024-11 https://www.businessinsider.com/how-generations-voted-trump-...
- kayodelycaon 1y agoNo. You can’t blame lead. There is zero justification for making the average person less responsible for their own worldview and choices in leadership.
- lazyasciiart 1y agoWell, that’s the first time I’ve heard anyone explicitly say they don’t want to understand causal factors because it would reduce the ability to tell people they should bootstrap themselves.
- potato3732842 1y agoI don't think it shifts the red blue much which is probably what you're getting at. I think it absolutely affects the quality of politicians we get though. The best that a given generation can offer is probably lower if that generation huffed a lot of lead gas. So as they age out and younger people hit peak career and fill those roles things will probably improve a bit.
- PartiallyTyped 1y agoI was mostly thinking that the politicians all look so incompetent — with some exceptions of course — that if it wasn't real, it'd be a very unfunny joke exactly because of how much caricature-like and exaggerated personalities the politicians have.
- krapp 1y agoNo. Much of the American electoral landscape is still shaped by the systemic remnants of slavery, reconstruction and segregation, and the post-Trump landscape by the cultural trauma of having elected a black president.
- krapp 1y agoNo. Much of the American electoral landscape is still shaped by the systemic remnants of slavery, reconstruction and segregation, and the post-Trump landscape by the cultural trauma of having elected a black president. Although I'm sure all of the lead poisoning didn't help.
- krapp 1y agoi don't know why there are two copies of this comment now, I didn't post it twice.
- vkou 1y agoYou could, if you wanted to misdiagnose the problem. You'd have more success blaming COVID inflation and the general public's poor education in economics and lack of understanding why eggs were $3.50/dozen. (Today they are $6.00/dozen)
- aaomidi 1y agoAnd abortion access.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoProbably not. That played out in the last wave of crime reduction.
- throwaway_2121 1y agoLack of boredom is also a factor. Social media and modern games are keeping them occupied.
- mymythisisthis 1y agoPeople also have fewer possessions worth stealing and trying to hock? It's not like TVs and radios cost that much anymore. People wear less jewelry. Though this is not a significant factor, it might be worth putting on the list still.
- bobthepanda 1y agoThe most valuable things on a person these days (credit cards, phone) are also incredibly easy to lock down and make worthless. Many of the things like jewelry, are also now rendered essentially worthless because a lot of jewelry now is cheaply sourced; pawning off crap from fast fashion is not going to be worth it.
- hn_throwaway_99 1y agoI was thinking that as I was getting ready to sell my house. I'm not a particularly materialistic person to start with, but there are hardly any physical objects in my home that I value that much besides (a) some photo albums/pictures and yearbooks - and for newer generations these are mostly digital I guess, (b) my violin and (c) my espresso machine and grinder. I guess you could throw my cellphone in there as well - easy to replace but would be a PITA, like losing my wallet. It'd be a pain to replace all my furniture and other stuff but I certainly don't feel any attachment to those things.
- matwood 1y agoI feel you. I’m selling my house and I joke that I’ll give someone a better deal if they just take everything in it as part of the sale. A suitcase for my clothes, my computer, and some physical mementos is all I need to keep. Even the clothes are optional, but I don’t feel like buying a new wardrobe. My coffee grinder may have been on my list, but I moved countries and the power is incompatible hah.
- strict9 1y agoNo it's not. Not entirely anyway. One thing I've learned in my decades on this planet is that just about never is one explanation for a human condition mostly correct. Lead is a convenient technical explanation that underestimates the impact of upbringing and community. It doesn't explain a lot of factors of juvenile delinquency that existed for generations before lead service lines or leaded gasoline.
- stubish 1y agoIndustry and highways and other high sources of lead pollution were built in the areas with higher juvenile delinquency. Not in rich, privileged areas. I think you can also correlate the rise in violent crime to amount of lead contamination in the soil, some articles claiming down to the city block level.
- pc86 1y agoWhich order did these things happen in? Maybe industry and highways increase lead exposure which leads to crime, or maybe areas already high in crime are cheaper so that's where industry and highways go?
- stubish 1y agoSpecifically violent crime. Poor areas had more violent crime. These areas got dumped with more lead pollution. The rise percentage wise correlates almost perfectly with lead levels, with poor (and now polluted) areas rising more than well off areas. And then the drop, where after lead was removed from petrol you get a significant drop, but still less of a drop in areas more lead soil contamination, such of those blocks next to a highway. We know the developmental effects on young brains from lead; it is why we banned it.
- ericmcer 1y agoIt is insane to just confidently assert that the only factor in the decrease in crime is Lead. Treating an insanely nuanced issue as an absolute doesn't make your argument more compelling, it is actually kind of baffling.
- YinglingHeavy 1y agoBut it's so satisfying to one's ego that a single cause is the issue. All complexity of societal changes in the last 50 years can be outmanuevered. Simplification is sexy.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- matthewdgreen 1y agoIt’s satisfying to know that we’ve eliminated a major environmental toxin with so many awful effects. It doesn’t mean that lead explains everything, but it is a lot better than the “we built enough prisons to lock up all the bad guys, maybe we should build more” alternative hypothesis/proposal I’ve heard.
- sien 1y agoThere was a crime decline in many rich countries from the 1990s as well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_drop#Decline_since_the_early_1990s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_drop#Decline_since_the_e... Maybe they were doing similar things with lead or something else is a big factor. Perhaps the rise of ever more cheap entertainment for young males who are most likely to commit crime. That's a global thing.
- kragen 1y agoYes, leaded gasoline was being banned in many rich countries at about the same time, and there's a positive correlation between the year it was banned and the year that violent street crime began to decline.
- ern 1y agoI think lead is nasty stuff, but if it was the single cause of high crime, surely we'd see a similar effect in other domains, like a rebound effect on IQs (another thing lead was blamed for)? Instead the Flynn Effect seems to have been strongest during the era of high lead, and it's tailing-off now.
- BobaFloutist 1y agoThe only reasonable conclusion is that lead causes crime by making people smarter.
- hellzbellz123 1y agoor maybe intelligence doesn't correlate with likeliness to commit crime? plenty of criminals are intelligent.
- hellzbellz123 1y agobelow study claims test score variances are mostly related too declarative knowledge side note, i wonder how internet had an effect on iq scores. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0160289620300908?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01602...
- hirvi74 1y agoI'm not convinced these tests measure what they claim to. Even assuming they do, IQ scores offer little practical value. The human body and mind are always adapting, however subtly, to changing environments. So I wonder -- are IQ tests assessing abilities that may no longer be optimal today? Homer likely had an exceptional memory, as did many ancient Greeks that participated in oral traditions. But how relevant is memorizing epics in the modern world?
- ivanjermakov 1y agoSeriously? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_causation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_c...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- treyd 1y agoI'll do you one better. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead%E2%80%93crime_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead%E2%80%93crime_hypothesis
- kryogen1c 1y agoWhat exactly are you claiming? Your points say old people have more lead, but then you say young people are more violent. That doesn't square with the articles point that incarceration rates are falling.
- Nopoint2 1y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44365162 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44365162
- Nopoint2 1y agoLet's add an example to illustrate the difference: Let's say that there is a correlation between the number of flights between London and New York, and the prices of sulfur. The correlation is near perfect. When your neocortex is working, you ignore it. You can't create any plausible scenario how this could work (it doesn't exist within your latent space) so you don't learn anything from it, it doesn't even register in your brain as anything worthy of notice. But everybody with the cerebellum only absolutely does learn it. And completely for real, not just as some fun factoid, but as a fact that they know the same way you know that airplanes have wings, and everybody knows it, only you don't. Then, one day out of nowhere people start buying sulfur. Your questions are met with laughter and mockery "dude, everybody's buying sulfur, are you autistic?". And you don't know, because you haven't even learned the pseudo facts that everybody else bases their reasoning on. This is only a made up example, but this is exactly how it works.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]