6 ms·
Why don't Americans trust experts? Just ask a paranormal investigator
- Simulacra 1y agoThat's a big question, and a narrow article. People tend to distrust experts when they think they are being lied to, or manipulated.
- thinkharderdev 1y agoThat seems a bit circular to me. Of course you distrust someone you think is lying to you or manipulating you. That is what distrust means isn't it? The question is why you think you are being lied to or manipulated to begin with.
- techpineapple 1y agoTo me the question is - why do people feel like they’re being lied to or manipulated by university scientists, but not guru’s, and the conspiracy theorists who write “ancient aliens”. I may be skeptical of institutions, but I’m also skeptical of Dr. Bob Bigfoot.
- Simulacra 1y agoPolitics.
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoI have three ideas here. (I present these as "one or the other or both", not as any kind of a cohesive package.) 1. Many people find the default accepted worldview to be empty or unsatisfying. Aliens or bigfoot give them something else, something "out there" to believe in. 2. Aliens or bigfoot give them the sense of being "in the know", one of the few who "accept the truth". It lets them feel good about themselves, that they are special. 3. Aliens and bigfoot don't ask them to change their life in any way. University scientists and government experts say some uncomfortable things sometimes.
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoWe have no caretakers in society. People that care about and watch out for society. We have only political creatures now. When I was a kid the majority of political people/institution people were caretakers. Even the political pundits on TV put those things above party. Then grifters learned to weaponize being a caretaker against the caretakers by calling them RINOs on the right, and centrists on the left. We've optimized our politicians based on snark and media propagandists that only care about their audience numbers and ran off the RINOs/centrists that were the caretakers of society. In institutions, we ran off the caretakers/removed their roles and replaced them with optimizers and prioritized max profit/optimization over institutional caretaking.
- kevingadd 1y agoWe've got an inclusive framework right now for alternative theories of medicine in my country, and a guy who believes in miasma theory instead of germ theory is shutting down medical research programs and getting rid of vaccines. I think I've had enough of the inclusive frameworks this article advocates for.
- techpineapple 1y agoA big part of the problem is the whole a lie gets halfway around the world, before the truth has a chance to get its pants on thing. Generally speaking, between your average conspiracy theorist, and the average university scientist, rhetorically speaking, the conspiracy theorist will probably run circles around the scientist. To a lay persons understanding of argument and rhetoric, unless you have a good bullshit detector(and bullshit detector’s are imperfect, you’ll get it wrong a certain percentage of of the time) the conspiracy theorist is more convincing and usually has “better” arguments.
- sceptic123 1y agoBullshit detectors are a huge part of the problem (and a big part of conspiracy theory methodology). If something is fundamentally true but is also counterintuitive, it will never pass a bullshit detector. On the other hand, a statement that is convincing but is actually false is relatively simple to make and hard to argue against (just ask ChatGPT).
- billy99k 1y agoCovid taught me that there is a large percentage of the population that trusts the experts to the point of ignoring all critical thought, which is just as dangerous.
- seanmcdirmid 1y agoCovid taught me that there is a large percentage of population that won’t trust experts to the point of ignoring critical thought. Also dangerous.
- decremental 1y ago[dead]
- egberts1 1y agoVAERS database shows otherwise. We now have 8,000+ mRNA products awaiting field testing and trials.
- sorcerer-mar 1y agoWhat does this comment mean? What does VAERS show and what do the MRNA products awaiting testing indicate?
- MiscIdeaMaker99 1y agoI agree. Lots and lots of them died, as result.
- dogtierstatus 1y agois this how modern survival of the fittest work now?
- seanmcdirmid 1y agoThere was a joke going around for awhile renaming Darwin awards as Herman Cain awards. A bit mean, but it had some merit.
- AStonesThrow 1y ago[dead]
- caseysoftware 1y ago> To rebuild public trust. Hongoltz-Hetling argues that institutions must respectfully engage with unconventional beliefs and offer inclusive frameworks instead of dismissive critiques. No, we don't need "inclusive frameworks" because some beliefs are idiotic. We need experts who put reason and data before political agendas and they need to be able to say "I don't know" instead of lying.
- goalieca 1y agoIt’s bad when an expert doesn’t say “I don’t know”. It’s worse when they lie because “we don’t want the public thinking dangerous thoughts”.
- sorcerer-mar 1y agoNearly every example I've encountered of experts allegedly lying under that rationale was actually a case of the public being effectively illiterate. E.g. experts saying "we don't know if masks work" (stated over and over) the general public heard as "we know that masks don't work" (I've found exactly one instance of this being stated by a US public health expert, USSG Jerome Adams).
- mickael-kerjean 1y agoBefore openAI release gpt3, we had tons of experts on hacker news explaining with what seemed like reasonable arguments how openai was a joke in the machine learning community and how their approach couldn't work
- jonathanstrange 1y agoThis is my pet peeve topic because this alleged need for "trust" has become so ubiquitous. It's like a meme that is parroted blindly. At a closer look, it's in my opinion not so clear whether trust should play any substantial role in dealing with potential knowledge and insight, especially since the term "expert" is interpreted ranging from "a guy who wrote an M.A. thesis about some related topic" to "internationally renowned researcher with 100+ publications in a specific, narrow subtopic of a field who is highly estimated by their peers and has served in various panels to inform decision makers." Generally, science is not built on trusting others, it's built on being skeptical. What people miss is not trust in alleged or real experts, what they lack is intellectual humility and the ability to determine when someone else likely knows more about a topic than you. That doesn't mean that they have to trust that person's opinion about the matter, it just means that they should have a tendency to believe that person's informed opinions more easily than their own uninformed preconceptions. For example, people shouldn't trust authorities and the experts these rely on. It's perfectly fine if they constantly scrutinize these authorities. However, they should be able to recognize when they clearly know less then these and act accordingly. Whether that means remaining agnostic or acting upon the expert's knowledge (even if it is taken with a pinch of salt) depends on the decision situation, how much need for action there is. By the same token, you should also not trust text books. You should be aware of your own limitations while trying to check the information in the book. When you know you don't have enough knowledge to check it, you're going to have to trust some of the content. The more you build up knowledge, the more you can check the book, and at some point you will find errors in it.
- sorcerer-mar 1y agoThis is why COVID was the breaking point: it was one of the very rare scenarios where highly technical and shifting scientific understanding was directly attached to meaningful lifestyle impacts for people. Science is always at least as messy (generally more so) as it was during COVID, but generally it doesn't matter because only "settled science" gets turned into technology and deployed to people's lives. All the input chaos has been abstracted away by the time it matters at all to most people. The general public is not, has never been, and never will be cognitively and intellectually equipped to grapple with shifting science directly -- nor should they need to, they've got other shit to do that scientists can't do!
- EverydayBalloon 1y ago[dead]
- Apreche 1y agoThe logic follows that if experts are in charge, and experts are correct, then we will see positive outcomes from following expert advice. The US, and other parts of the world, has seen some decades where experts have been in positions of authority, but there have not necessarily been positive outcomes. Does this mean the experts are wrong? Nope. It’s for a variety of reasons, but perhaps the largest is that experts are handcuffed by corruption. A real doctor knows best, but there are negative outcomes because of the insurance industry. A climate scientist knows best, but corruption and fossil fuel industry prevents implementation of the correct policies. Some financial advisors are scam artists and others are legit, leading people to trust neither. For experts to gain trust they have to deliver visibly positive outcomes, and they have to greedily take credit for those outcomes. When people experience a good result, they have to make the connection that it was the advice of smart, correct, educated people that got them there.
- reylas 1y ago"A climate scientist knows best", lets talk about this one as it is a perfect example of lost trust. It is not corruption that destroys the message, but constantly being incorrect. Just a warning, I may agree with them overall, but they are constantly getting the numbers wrong. We have been 3 years away from the point of no return for the last 20 years. I am old enough to remember the "ice age" that we were going to enter. There are a ton of video clips showing Al Gore predicting things that never came to past. I read the science and I agree that climate is changing, but to the layperson, they have been saying wrong things for years now and they are tired of hearing them "cry wolf". The moral of the "cry wolf" story is that the falsehoods are what causes people not to be prepared. It is not helping the cause.
- arethuza 1y ago"I am old enough to remember the "ice age" that we were going to enter." I'm nearly 60 and I don't ever remember anyone talking about an imminent ice age - given my fondness for skiing when I was younger I'm sure I would have noticed.
- 1y ago
- Bnichs 1y ago>If our institutions can communicate their work better, supernatural beliefs will dry up a bit. We’ve seen this historically. I feel like this article misses the reason why people distrust institutions. Being "kicked out of the tent" is no doubt part of it, but it's more that the institutions themselves have stopped trying to communicate in good faith. In the past 50 or so years we've seen almost every institution (in USA at least) get caught in a massive scheme of lying and manipulation. The church was caught harboring pedophiles, the education system told us trades were bad and we needed to spend $100k+ to have a good job, the Healthcare system leveraged our own wellbeing against their profits, the government sided with insurance companies, banks, etc over its own people at every turn then proceeded to lie us into war after war after war, and all the the while the news has been proven to support almost every lie happily if the ad dollars go their way. Not a single institution hasn't failed us. Asking why people distrust institutions is the wrong question. Any partner that lied to you that much would never be trusted again, distrust is a defense mechanism that comes from years of betrayal. But still there's some implication that we should still trust them, despite the lies, and along with it a sense that distrusting them makes you crazy (paranormal/alien beliefs are a good example). This problem does not originate from the people, it's the result of a world where truth only gets in the way of profits and power and actual people are the lowest priority.
- sorcerer-mar 1y agoNah, you're exhibiting the fundamental problem which is effectively conspiratorial thinking. Not in the UFO sense, and I don't mean it disparagingly at all -- I mean literally ascribing behavior to some type of superstructure that doesn't really exist. "The healthcare system" is not one thing that "says" stuff. For every component of the education system that was trying to eliminate trades, there were others trying to combat it, and neither side was merely the decision of any conscious agent that could be said to be deciding or "saying" anything. All of the outcomes and the things these systems "say" are emergent phenomena from a confluence of countless forces. Sometimes they yield bad outcomes! But that doesn't mean you can just toss out the system, largely because unless you alter the larger dynamics that produced that system, any replacement will just come to mimic the prior one. The individuals involved hardly matter.
- NalNezumi 1y agoNot just a problem in US but I'd say one of the issue is that we have expert inflation, and not all expertise are equally valid. We have some insight from Decision theory. Klein and Kahneman have both identified required properties for valuable expert intuition (or knowledge, tacit or not) to be available to aquire. (here's a simplified version of this by Veritasium [1]) Most people would see through the conartist claiming "I'm a roulette expert. I've done roulette for 10 years, I have 10 years of roulette expertise, you should listen to me when it comes to what number you should bet on a roulette!" Yet we all fall for other form of expert where their problem domain follow similar structures that makes expert knowledge acquisition either hard or impossible. But every expert with a PhD want to claim their expertise to be as valid as the actual valid expertise. Combine that with internet, short form (tweet etc) communication, we tend to dumb down the conversation using "expert" to cover all the domains, to the fraud-experts advantage. Certain fields, you should probably trust the expert almost blindly (Emergency Care, firefighters) but others, maybe not (clinical psychologist, policy maker, economists). Problem is that if we just bundle them all up, people will end up not trusting either. "bundling up" is a recurring tactic by conartists of all kind (subprime mortgage anyone?) If we would "rate" different field on their expertise validity (or scientific validity etc) easily understandable by layman, we might regain some institutional trust. But that would cause a crazy amount of resistance from certain fields (macro econ, psychology, nutritional science, etc) and in real term wouldn't happen [1] Vertiasium https://youtu.be/5eW6Eagr9XA?feature=shared https://youtu.be/5eW6Eagr9XA?feature=shared
- sceptic123 1y agoIs there any category that you should blindly trust? What would you do about, for example, a bad firefighter? And on the opposite side, should no clinical psychologist be trusted? Is nutritional science all wrong?
- 1970-01-01 1y agoBecause "I'm from the government and I'm here to help" hasn't worked for 50 years. Why start now?
- thrill 1y ago"must respectfully engage with unconventional beliefs" No ... no, I don't.
- mythrwy 1y agoTrust isn't given, it's earned. This is why deception by officials or experts is dangerous, even if they think "it's for the greater good".