5 ms·
It's really hard to say, but probably not good (there was an Atlantic article about this last week). Part of the dynamic here is the idea that the SL can't back
by tptacek 1y ago
It's really hard to say, but probably not good (there was an Atlantic article about this last week). Part of the dynamic here is the idea that the SL can't back down without losing so much domestic credibility that he puts the regime at risk; being in a shooting war with the West probably reinforces the regime's position. The flip side of this is that I don't think there were many signs that the opposition was in position to challenge the SL any time soon.
- awongh 1y agoafaik Iran is a very very different case demographically from Iraq and Afghanistan- in terms of being bigger, more modern and secular. It seems like those are dynamics that make it harder to go to war/stay in war.
- ummonk 1y agoQuite the contrary, the religious populace is more likely to fall in line and decide the government knows best; it’s the secular populace that is demanding retaliation and critical of the government for not pursuing nuclearization already.
- awongh 1y agoIf you're in Iran it makes sense that you would want that if you feel that Israel is a threat. (But it doesn't make it a good idea). I meant that demographically, if your populace isn't as poor, battle hardened and religious (like Afghanistan) maybe going into a long ground war is less politically feasible? In Afghanistan they had basically just been fighting a war, where the last war in Iran was 30 years ago?
- sealeck 1y ago> I meant that demographically, if your populace isn't as poor, battle hardened and religious (like Afghanistan) maybe going into a long ground war is less politically feasible? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_War Excerpts: > 95,000 Iranian child soldiers were casualties during the Iran–Iraq War, mostly between the ages of 16 and 17, with a few younger > The conflict has been compared to World War I: 171 in terms of the tactics used, including large-scale trench warfare with barbed wire stretched across trenches, manned machine gun posts, bayonet charges, human wave attacks across a no man's land, and extensive use of chemical weapons such as sulfur mustard by the Iraqi government against Iranian troops, civilians, and Kurds. The world powers United States and the Soviet Union, together with many Western and Arab countries, provided military, intelligence, economic, and political support for Iraq. On average, Iraq imported about $7 billion in weapons during every year of the war, accounting for fully 12% of global arms sales in the period.
- awongh 1y agoThat was 40 years ago though. So no one fighting on the ground in that war would be fighting on the ground in a war that starts today.
- jjk166 1y agoNo, but they're the ones making the decisions about fighting such a war. The child soldiers in the 1980s are the politicians, the diplomats, and the generals in the 2020s.
- Forgeties79 1y ago“…and we turned out just fine!”
- awongh 1y agoThey say that for WWI that it was one of the aspects that kept it "more civilized" (whatever that means in the context of war).
- ummonk 1y agoAh I see what you mean. Yes they don’t have the birth rate (or the suicidal fanaticism) to sustain a decades long attritional war against an occupation like Afghanistan or Yemen can. But given the size of the existing Iranian population and geography, and the lack of any significantly sized pre-existing anti-government military faction, I’m not sure the US military is large enough to even occupy Iran in the first place, absent a draft.
- awongh 1y agoIt would be reaaalllly stupid for the USA to invade Iran. Hopefully Iran is the one that blinks for the reasons above.
- MichaelZuo 1y agoWhy would they blink when they know they are safe from a boots on the ground invasion for the forseeable future?
- jt_b 1y agoI think they probably like having an GDP 25x larger than North Korea's. Gets a lot harder to export your products around the world when you're squared off against the US.
- MichaelZuo 1y agoHow does that follow?
- gregoryl 1y ago> if you feel that Israel is a threat Israel is very clearly, without any question or doubt, a serious threat to every one of its neighbors.
- Ancapistani 1y agoJordan seems pretty safe and happy to me.
- nebula8804 1y agoLike the Pager attack thats just another long game it seems: https://old.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/14tcxgq/zionist_version_of_greater_israel/ https://old.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/14tcxgq/zionist_ve... EDIT, clearer map: https://www.islam21c.com/wp-content/uploads/The-alarming-details-of-Israels-future-ambitions.jpg https://www.islam21c.com/wp-content/uploads/The-alarming-det...
- throwaway2037 1y agoIt has a peace treaty with Jordan and Egypt. Also, they signed the Abraham Accords with UAE and Bahrain. As far I know, there is no risk of conflict with Saudi Arabia, Qatar, nor Oman. Who else am I missing? Half joking: (ignoring Trump's recent "threats") Is the US a threat to Canada or Mexico?
- firesteelrain 1y agoMexico is more of a threat. So many drugs flow North. It’s slowly killing generations of people for decades.
- sebmellen 1y agoEgypt, Jordan, Cyprus? Really?
- golol 1y ago[flagged]
- YZF 1y agoThis doesn't sound right to me. Sources? One data point I heard recently was 80% of Iranians oppose the current regime. That said I've also heard there is wide support for Iran to have a nuclear program. Presumably as a matter of national pride. I would still imagine the secular population to be less inclined to go to war with Israel in general. The only Iranians I've personally talked to are ones that live in the west. They generally want to have peace with Israel and want to see the regime removed. Again very anecdotally they are still not happy about Israel bombing Iran but if the regime is actually somehow magically removed I don't think attacking Israel would be a high priority for a hypothetical secular or democratic regime.
- tdeck 1y agoThe fact that someone dislikes their government's current ruling regime doesn't mean they want the US to invade and install a puppet government instead. It's a false dichotomy. > if the regime is actually somehow magically removed I don't think attacking Israel would be a high priority Attacking Israel hasn't been a high priority for Iran. When Israel bombed an Iranian consulate, Iran referred it to the security council and waited, but the security council took no action. When Israel carries out an assassination within Iran, Iran did the same thing. Only after the UN refused to do anything to hold Israel to account did Iran retaliate. Then recently Israel launched a massive series of strikes against Iran, assassinating top members of its military and blowing up apartment buildings. It seems clear that the Iranian government didn't want to go to war with Israel, but at a certain point they ran out of options. First letter: https://digitallibrary.un.org/nanna/record/4043282/files/A_78_838--S_2024_281-EN.pdf?withWatermark=0&withMetadata=0®isterDownload=1&version=1 https://digitallibrary.un.org/nanna/record/4043282/files/A_7... Second letter: https://digitallibrary.un.org/nanna/record/4055716/files/S_2024_584-EN.pdf?withWatermark=0&withMetadata=0®isterDownload=1&version=1 https://digitallibrary.un.org/nanna/record/4055716/files/S_2...
- throwaway2037 1y ago> Attacking Israel hasn't been a high priority for Iran. Really? It is interesting that you made no mention of Hezbollah in Lebanon, Hamas in Gaza, not Houthi in Yemen. All are well-known proxies for Iran to militarily harass Israel. They all receive direct funds and weapons from Iran.
- yencabulator 1y agoNot that secular. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonyad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonyad
- awongh 1y agoI don't know that much. But I have heard about how in terms of daily outlook a lot of Iranians aren't very religious. Esp. compared to other countries in the region.
- ronnier 1y agoWith all respect please type out SL. I and many others don’t know what that means. For us it’s just two random letters thrown into a sentence
- moosedev 1y agoI assume it's Supreme Leader.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- citizenkeen 1y agoSupreme Leader
- dralley 1y agoOn the other hand, the internal Cyber Police HQ got bombed today. If the institutions of internal suppression are sufficiently disrupted, maybe some form of resistance could be form. Who knows.
- anigbrowl 1y agoPeople keep wishcasting this idea, but just because many/most Iranian people don't like the regime does not mean they want to be bombed by Israel/the USA.
- throwup238 1y agoThe one thing we’ve learned over and over again since WWII: strategic bombing does not actually achieve any objective except temporarily disrupting logistics. If anything it strengthens the resolve of the people being bombed, giving the target regime more ammunition to carry on.
- dralley 1y agoThis is dumb. Strategic bombing did work in WWII, but it was never as effective as its advocates claimed at the time mostly because the bombs rarely hit anything important. They had to drop far more munitions than originally envisioned to actually do critical damage to infrastructure. You can't really compare WWII dumb bombs dropped from 25,000 feet to modern precision weapons that can hit precisely the weakest point on a target, times thousands of targets, within the span of a few hours or days. I mean, we literally just watched a massively successful strategic bombing campaign over the last week! Desert Storm was massively successful, Iraqi Freedom (the actual invasion, pre-nationbuilding part) was massively successful, Israel's bombing of Hezbollah was massively successful. I don't know how anyone can argue that strategic bombing with precision munitions isn't successful.
- ivape 1y agoCambodia says hi. No one did it better than Kissinger.
- energy123 1y agoThey lack the capability to do much aside from disrupt shipping with SRBMs. They've taken down only one drone, which is one less than the Houthis. Their ballistic capability is heavily degraded. Their military leadership is gone. Their airforce is gone. Their air defense is gone. They're a paper tiger and I don't understand why people still think there's the prospect of some kind of grand retaliation. They're not holding back, they just can't do anything.
- Aloisius 1y agoAs if conventional responses are the only way to retaliate. We are talking about Iran here. They're all about asymmetric warfare.
- energy123 1y agoTheir intelligence heads are also all gone. What kind of response do you envisage?
- Aloisius 1y agoWell. Some guys with a tiny fraction of the funding Iran has managed to fly a few airliners into some buildings a few years back. So, I imagine there are perhaps unconventional options available to a country which is fully willing to fund terrorist groups for decades against a country with a very large amount of largely unprotected infrastructure. But who knows? It just seems a bit premature to argue Iran's defeat. Feels a bit... mission accomplished.
- firesteelrain 1y agoEven more reason for them to go. It’s not good enough to continue taking it from Iran.
- Aloisius 1y agoAhh, trying to bomb your way to regime change in the Middle East. This feels so familiar. What could possibly go wrong? If only those who advocated for war were forced to fight in them.