7 ms·
Largest Wildlife Bridge Spanning 10 Lanes of CA 101 Is Nearly Complete
- netsharc 1y agoHuh, why does the embedded video look like someone played it over a Zoom screen-sharing session, and another participant of that Zoom meeting did a screen record?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jonstewart 1y agoIntroducing wolves back to a relatively small part of Wisconsin has had a positive economic impact from reduced car crashes with deer. This crossing will no doubt help the cougars, and that’ll help the humans who have to drive on this terrifying part of the 101. https://wolf.org/media-releases/new-study-shows-wolves-save-wisconsin-residents-10-9-million-annually-because-of-reduction-in-deer-vehicle-crashes/ https://wolf.org/media-releases/new-study-shows-wolves-save-...
- rurp 1y agoOne of my favorite wildlife stats is that you're hundreds of times more likely to be killed by a deer than a mountain lion. Protecting apex predators like wolves and lions significantly reduces deer caused deaths and injuries. It's nice to see public opinion steadily changing in this area for the better, past predator management has been extremely stupid and harmful.
- downvotetruth 1y ago> having required 26 million pounds of concrete the height restriction alone should have been reason enough to go with a tunnel, but how could CA miss an opportunity for construction waste /s
- jeremyjacob 1y agoI believe they chose a bridge to create a more uniform natural path across the freeway so that the animals will be more likely to utilize it. There’s already an overpass a half mile to the south that would allow a crossing over frontage roads but because it’s not obvious and wild enough, animals still cross on the freeway.
- downvotetruth 1y agoThe first sentence is almost completely subjective, and the leading fact in second sentence gives the best evidence against an overpass in this thread. The only thing that is going to make this more obvious to the mountain lions would be a few more dead deer carcasses as a result of the car lights! lets jump off the side into oncoming hidden traffic behavior.
- jmye 1y agoYou’d think the right thing to do would be to pick the option wildlife is most likely to use, and that there was research and decision-making that went into that above and beyond “tons of concrete”. Do you think that didn’t happen, that you’re significantly smarter about wildlife bridges than the folks who planned this one (who were, apparently, too dumb to ask a question you thought of sixty seconds after reading about the amount of concrete used), or just deeply into throwing shade, deserved or not, at CA at every half-imagined opportunity?
- downvotetruth 1y agoNo, I do think that happened and that the underpass was the more reasonable solution; why Caltrans required due to the bridge’s size and cost to have its completion be reliant on donations from the public.
- jmye 1y ago> and that the underpass was the more reasonable solution […] bridge’s size and cost Emphasis mine. So still just about the amount of concrete. Ok. Good talk.
- ksec 1y agoI had to google and double check there isn't another place in Europe called Santa Monica Mountains. Because building bridge for Wildlife seems very European rather than American, or at least modern American. I remember a lot of them in Holland and other places. Let's hope more of these get built in US. ( While not being crazy expensive )
- vondur 1y agoHa, this is California and it cost 92 million US dollars
- bruce511 1y agoMore interestingly is the timeline. Broke ground in 2022, finished in 2025, and likely operational before the end of the year. Now sure, it likely took some years in the planning as well, but it shows that infrastructure can be built in reasonable time lines when politics and nimbyism don't get in the way. And this isn't a simple bit of construction- it spans a serious bit of active highway.
- bhaney 1y ago> shows that infrastructure can be built in reasonable time lines This bridge for deer took 3 times longer to build than the Empire State Building.
- maxbond 1y agoA bridge for deer isn't any easier to build than a bridge for pedestrians, even if you don't care about deer being on a bridge that collapses there's a highway underneath. Cars would be crushed and traffic disrupted. So we're just talking about a bridge. It's built to the same standard as any other bridge. (Also it's more like a bridge for mountain lions but whatever.) If the Empire State Building had been built across a highway, and had to schedule construction around avoiding disruptions to traffic, than it would've taken three years too.
- api 1y agoThis is not a bad thing, but my first thought was: anything but housing.
- aaron695 1y ago[dead]
- michaelrmmiller 1y agoI live nearby and drive past it nearly every day. It’s been fascinating watching its construction. They’ve done a very good job not impacting traffic and only closed down the highway late at night for a week or two.
- conradev 1y agoYeah! The first time seeing it was funny, a bridge with no roads. Excited for it to open. It’s a bummer that it cost $100m
- WalterBright 1y agoAt those costs, very very few will be built. More modest projects should be considered. Like simple bridges, or large culverts running underneath the highway.
- bartvk 1y agoI wonder why they didn't opt for your suggestion for multiple modest projects. The article doesn't mention it, it only says: > National Park Service began a decades-long study of the region’s mountain lion population that the 101 freeway was deemed “the most significant barrier to the ecological health of the region.”
- eszed 1y agoA big reason (this is from the project site): > NEPA Completed 04/12/2018: Finding of No Significant Impact (FONSI), Liberty Canyon Wildlife Habitat Connectivity Project > In compliance with CEQA, Caltrans held a 47-day public scoping period to allow the public and regulatory agencies an opportunity to comment on the scope of the IS/EA and to identify issues that should be addressed in the environmental document. A scoping report documents the issues and concerns expressed during the public scoping meetings held on January 14, 2016 and the written comments received from the public, community organizations, and governmental agencies during the public scoping period from December 14, 2015 through January 29, 2016. The release of the Final Environmental Document with responses to comments included was completed in the summer of 2016. NEPA/CEQA was completed in April 2018. A total of 8,859 comments were received in response to the draft Environmental Document, with only 15 opposed. When any infrastructure project requires nearly a decade of preliminary work before shovels hit ground, said work becomes impossible to accomplish for smaller-scale builds. Even if ten smaller bridges would be a better solution, 10x-ing the review process would likely be impossible at current staffing / budget levels. It's a big problem.
- ourmandave 1y agoI would pay stupid money to have America change the lyrics to Ventura Highway to include the overpass and then perform it at the ribbon cutting. Like Elton did for Diana with Candle in the Wind.
- thaumasiotes 1y agoDon't tell us, tell them.
- labster 1y agoThe hardest part might be getting them to wake up early enough for the ribbon cutting. I saw America perform at the Ventura County Fair around noon, and they complained it was the earliest gig they had all year. But it was Ventura Highway in the sunshine, which was its own kind of awesome.
- sameline 1y agoFor those interested in learning more about road ecology, Crossings is an interesting read. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/123627807-crossings https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/123627807-crossings
- komali2 1y agoGigantic roads like that make me crazy! I can't understand how people subject themselves to living near these giant impassible rivers of concrete! Even a city road that's not a freeway - on a visit to sf I needed to walk across Harrison and then 6th street. 12 lanes to walk across, two lights to wait for! I felt like tearing my hair out. At least they finally built a way for the animals to cross again. I can't imagine how long it would take to walk across that eco bridge thing.
- jedberg 1y agoI grew up in Agoura Hills, it's funny to see this on HN of all places. And in another amusing twist, I just drove under this two days ago because I am visiting my parents this weekend. It's something the locals have known was needed for a long time, I'm glad they were finally able to get it built.
- WD-42 1y ago[flagged]
- wwweston 1y agoThere’s still plenty of great landscape to preserve and wander around the metro area ( at least as long as it doesn’t get sold off by venal hacks like Mike Lee).
- superdude12 1y agoConsidering it doesn’t have to carry much weight, why couldn’t they make it out of wood to cut costs?
- mulmen 1y agoI would be shocked if material costs are within an order of magnitude of the labor and design costs.
- mrj 1y agoDirt is pretty heavy. As the article said, the next step is to add native plants to the top.
- quickthrowman 1y agoThere are (at least) thousands of tons of soil on top of the reinforced concrete.
- randmeerkat 1y agoAmazing, California can build a wildlife bridge, but god forbid they build higher density housing.
- daedrdev 1y agoIs this not also a wildfire bridge? I know freeways are usually important wildfire breaks but I guess its easier to know thus is here ahead of a fire
- bartvk 1y agoWeird how you're downvoted. IMHO, it should not stop its construction, but it's an interesting question. Undoubtedly, after dumping soil on the bridge, shrubbery and even trees will grow, so yes, it could act as a wildfire bridge. Note that the article also says it offers an escape route from wildfires, so it goes both ways.
- libraryatnight 1y agoIf had to guess about the downvotes: the note about the article you point out (that's the big reason), plus (and this was just the first thing of a handful of relevant information) the easy answers with a quick search https://valleynewsgroup.com/wildlife-bridge-wont-become-a-wildfire-bridge/ https://valleynewsgroup.com/wildlife-bridge-wont-become-a-wi... Which took less typing to find than making the comment.
- suzzer99 1y agoIt's pretty easy to protect one bridge if the fire gets close from either side.
- mrlonglong 1y agoOver in the UK we're just finished building one on the M25, the world's biggest car park during rush hour. https://www.theconstructionindex.co.uk/news/view/wisley-scheme-to-get-garden-bridge https://www.theconstructionindex.co.uk/news/view/wisley-sche...
- swhitf 1y agoNot your fault but holy shit that site is awful on mobile!
- gamblor956 1y agoThere's a lot of people in this forum that greatly underestimate how hard and expensive it is to build things in the real world when you need to get things right the first time (because it can't just patch it later).
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- blks 1y agoLooks like a bandaid. Main issue here is this crazy 10 lanes highway. This should not exist.
- erulabs 1y agoThe book “the lion in the living room” documents P-22 and LAs love for the cat very well, it’s a great read and I recommend it. As much as I’m happy about this I find myself skeptical that wildlife will learn to use it. Do animals walk along the side of the highway looking for openings? Have there been any studies on the efficacy of these wildlife bridges?
- ahoef 1y agoThese are all over The Netherlands and widely used by animals.
- xnx 1y ago> Do animals walk along the side of the highway looking for openings? There's precedence in the natural world. A single log can get a lot of use by all types of critters: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qsDU_tTgsFw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qsDU_tTgsFw
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- kjkjadksj 1y agoThey will use it but they also use bog standard cheap bridges too. Imo making it look like natural landscape for $$$$ is kind of stupid.
- gregfjohnson 1y agoI wonder if there are any plans to place meat along the bridge to attract mountain lions. Will ecologists try to "train" the wildlife to use the bridge, or just let nature take its course?
- Rebelgecko 1y agoI don't think they'll "bait" it but there are some design choices made to funnel animals into it
- dragonwriter 1y ago