5 ms·
> One fights the enemies of the state "At stake is a fundamental component of the framework of US constitutional democracy. It begins with the principle, enshr
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> One fights the enemies of the state
"At stake is a fundamental component of the framework of US constitutional democracy. It begins with the principle, enshrined in law, that military forces exist to protect the country from existential threats — such as an invasion or rebellion — not to enforce the law.
Most fundamentally, the founders of the American republic understood very clearly that concentrated military power, loyal to a single man, could be used to achieve total control by that person. And they had a historical example in mind: Rome — a republic governed by the people and the Senate — was transformed into an empire ruled by an emperor as a result of the Roman army being turned against its citizens."
https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2025-06-09/trump-s-national-guard-deployment-is-a-threat-to-democracy https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2025-06-09/trump-...
- kpw94 1y ago> military forces exist to protect the country from existential threats — such as an invasion or rebellion — not to enforce the law. serious question: are Countries such as Italy, France etc not a democracy? All of them are, verbatim from wikipedia, "a military force with law enforcement duties among the civilian population.". Ditto for spain Guardia Civil, and many of the countries listed in that same wiki page: Algeria, Netherlands, Poland, Argentina, Romania, Turkey, Ukraine, Chile, France, Italy, Portugal, Spain, ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gendarmerie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gendarmerie
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> serious question: are Countries such as Italy, France etc not a democracy? They are, but not in the the "framework of US constitutional democracy." A system for which we have more evidence of stability than either of Italy or France's modern republics. (Note, too, les gendarmes' heritage: imperial France. Also, gendarmes aren't usually deployed overseas. They are, in a sense, more similar to the FBI than the U.S. Marines.)
- gabaix 1y agoI have always found confusing the existence of the gendarmes. They are indeed a vestigial force of the XIXth century, and should be transformed into a regular police force.
- aredox 1y agoOn the contrary, they are more relevant than ever in today's era of peacekeeping and anti-terrorism activities. They are fundamental to the stabilisation of the Balkans, for example. They fill the gap between full war and "normal" (punctual) criminality.
- gabaix 1y agoThe issues are two-fold 1- the territorial split between gendarmerie/police within the French territory 2- the fact the gendarmes for police work report to the Ministry of Defense. If one had to design the police system from crash, they would likely merge police and gendarmes for police work.
- BrandoElFollito 1y agoYou forgot 3: a hatred between the organizations for ego reasons (not everyone, not everywhere). The split is nonsense today.
- forty 1y agoGendarmerie are simply policemen with a military status which give them some duty (like I think they cannot strike) and some benefits (earlier retirement) but they are still really a police force in reality. I don't think it would look good to send actual army to fight citizens, and I don't think the army would appreciate it either (it might have been done already, no idea)
- closewith 1y agoThat is not universally true. A Gendarmerie is literally a military force with law enforcement duties and many are exactly that. In the Netherlands, the Royal Marechaussee are literal soldiers who perform military police duties and also many civilian policing duties, but all of them are soldiers first.
- close04 1y ago> A Gendarmerie is literally a military force with law enforcement duties The second part is a huge differentiator from "normal" military. A police force even if administratively under the military has one crucial differentiator: their daily duties and training revolve almost exclusively around policing civilians from the same country. Military training and tactics are overwhelmingly aimed at dealing with foreign enemy combatants, mainly other military forces. The methods give away the intentions and expected outcome. The US already has a very "militarized" police force. You send actual military only if you want to inflict the maximum amount of damage, and with that threat overwhelmingly scare the country into compliance.
- closewith 1y ago> their daily duties and training revolve almost exclusively around policing mainly civilians, citizens of the same country. That is the part that is not universally true. There are plenty of Gendarmeries who are soldiers first, with combat training and ethos, who also perform policing duties, the Marechaussee included.
- 1y ago
- eldgfipo 1y agoAs a French, I'd argue we're a flawed democracy. Shame on us when we compare ourselves to Scandinavian countries.
- hotmeals 1y agoSome of the cases you mention involve "military" police who are under the authority of the Ministry of the Interior, instead of the Ministry of Defense. Many also are not the only police force, in Chile the investigative duties fall to the non-military PDI. IMO as Chilean, it's a pretty bad thing democratically, for both historical (dictatorship) and more recent reasons. Still, there is a clear difference between when the police with deep ties to the army enforce the law and when actual troops do it. While copper Gutiérrez and grunt Herrera both technically have the rank of corporal, one mostly writes tickets, deals with noise complaints, and has riot training, while the other only knows how to march and shoot an assault rifle. The actually important thing is that this is testing the waters. Trump will use the troops for flimsier and flimsier reasons. NOTE: Chilean police are semi-routinely brutal; this is not an endorsement.
- aredox 1y agoSuperficial argument. The "gendarmerie" is exclusively trained in law enforcement. The military aspect is only relative to organisational aspects.
- jxjnskkzxxhx 1y agoIn Portugal, the Guarda Civil are cops in rural areas. I have no special insight into their training or hierarchy, but I can tell you that in practice they interact with the population like cops, not like soldiers. E.g. you wouldn't report shoplifting to the army, but you can report to the Guarda Civil. So I don't think your comment makes any sense, at least in Portugal.
- tiagod 1y agoThere is no "Guarda Civil" in Portugal. It's called Guarda Nacional Republicana (GNR).
- jxjnskkzxxhx 1y agoI haven't lived there in almost 15 years. I stand corrected. In fact I'm closer in time to having lived in Spain than in Portugal, that must be the origin of my confusion. In any case, I hope you agree my description of the GNR was accurate in substance.
- tiagod 1y agoYes you are correct. They also patrol some highways (although I believe some are the jurisdiction of PSP)
- dontlaugh 1y agoThose are bad too. Anyone that grew up in a country with a gendarmerie knows they are the most violent, unpleasant and fascist (personally, not like "all cops are fascist") people you’ll ever meet.
- the_gipsy 1y agoHaving police not separated from military doesn't invalidate the democracy, it just makes it easier to subvert democracy at some point. The spanish Guardia Civil is a very good example of a police force tied too deeply with the military. In 1981 some parts of the force attempted an actual coup, with one guy entering the parliament and shooting in the air (or ceiling). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1981_Spanish_coup_attempt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1981_Spanish_coup_attempt The continuity of the Guardia Civil after Franco's dictatorship is one of many vestiges that has not been removed due to fears of creating an instability leading to some coup and a reversal to fascism. IMHO this may have been justified the years immediately after Franco's death, but should have been addressed at some point. See the 1981 coup as for why "appeasing" the oppressors usually doesn't work out, or even works out for the oppressors.
- anthk 1y agoThe Guardia Civil itself predates Franco, and to be fair some GC agents fought for the Republican side in the war.
- the_gipsy 1y agoTrue. But AFAIK they were a crucial element of the regime's oppression, especially in rural areas. Their logo even today still contains a fasces[1] shield, which as been added during the Franco regime. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fasces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fasces
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoIf the US has laws that forbid that, and other nations have laws that establish that, then the US military being used for police activities is threatening to democracy - or at least to the rule of law - in a way that it is not threatening in other countries. Other countries can do that if they want. It may or may not be a threat to them. But in the US, it's absolutely a threat to democracy, because it's already the executive deploying the military against the law.
- lordnacho 1y agoWell I hate to disparage a large group of people, but how often have you spoken to an American who understands this type of social-legal history of the country, and values it? Although I know quite a lot of (what I consider) well-educated Americans, it is also the only country from which I regularly meet the type of person who doesn't care at all about how society works (also, technology, history, art, etc). You'll probably find that HN-person is the kind of person who values this kind of argument, but HN-world is quite small. On multiple occasions, I've met Americans who simply care about might-makes-right. It's skin-deep, as soon as you ask them why they support this or that policy, it's because they are powerful and the rest of the world is not. I've literally met Americans who thought their tax money allowed them to summon troops, more than once. (This ended up backfiring as it turns out, they did not know how to get US Marines to arrive, big shocker.) The same kind of thinking seems to be prevalent internally. You can trample the law, because you can. You see it even in ordinary US-made popular media. What happens what a character gets in trouble with the law? Well, then of course it depends on who has the most money to hire the best lawyers. In the current case, I suspect the government will just do whatever it wants and there will be no legal reckoning.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Y_Y 1y ago> You'll probably find that HN-person is the kind of person who values this kind of argument, but HN-world is quite small. The nice thing about the HN Small World is that it can be efficiently searched. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hierarchical_navigable_small_world https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hierarchical_navigable_small_w...
- sebastiennight 1y agoWell, one would have guessed that the service powering HN search would know about HNSW: https://www.algolia.com/blog/ai/a-simple-guide-to-ai-search https://www.algolia.com/blog/ai/a-simple-guide-to-ai-search
- jampekka 1y ago
- socalgal2 1y ago[flagged]
- komali2 1y agoAmerica is a melting pot, many people are proud of their heritage. If seeing a Mexican flag triggers you, I'm wondering if you hold American values, or something else?
- aaronbaugher 1y agoHeard a rumor this morning that organizers have realized the bad optics in that, and have put out word to wave US flags today. It'll be interesting to see if they're obeyed.
- ryandrake 1y agoLOL, so if I travel to Australia and wave my American flag there, they should consider me to be part of an invasion force?
- kjkjadksj 1y agoSocal is majority latino today and was originally mexican land. There is no invasion. A reversion to historical norms if anything. People carrying flags to trigger conservative bigots does not an invasion make.
- msgodel 1y agoThen we should make it official by surrendering the territory to Mexico.