4 ms·
GE [1]? Boeing [2] [3]? The stocks go up because management and shareholders pull forward the gains as financialization destroys the long term value of the ente
by toomuchtodo 1y ago
GE [1]? Boeing [2] [3]? The stocks go up because management and shareholders pull forward the gains as financialization destroys the long term value of the enterprises. Works until it doesn't.
[1] Power Failure: The downfall of General Electric - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44102034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44102034 - May 2025
[2] Fatal Recklessness at Boeing Traces Back to Long-Standing C-Suite Greed - https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/boeing-corporate-greed-airline-safety/ https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/boeing-corporate-... - April 9th, 2024
[3] HN Search: Boeing - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=boeing&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- WalterBright 1y agoBoeing consistently went up for many decades prior to the MAX crisis. So did GE. Companies have life cycles. They grow until they become unable to function efficiently anymore, then they go down. It's not about prioritizing short term results.
- palmotea 1y ago>> GE [1]? Boeing [2] [3]? The stocks go up because management and shareholders pull forward the gains as financialization destroys the long term value of the enterprises. Works until it doesn't. > Boeing consistently went up for many decades prior to the MAX crisis. So did GE. The point is they could have probably kept going up if they hadn't done that. It's like how if you choose to eat your seed corn, you'll be fat and happy for a season, then you and your family will certainly starve to death next year. You'd most likely had lived if you hadn't made that short-term decision. > Companies have life cycles. They grow until they become unable to function efficiently anymore, then they go down. And how often are the "life cycles" really just the accumulation of bad short-term decisions catching up with the company? You can kludge and kludge and kludge, but eventually that makes the app unmaintainable. Then you're in "total rewrite" or go under territory.
- WalterBright 1y ago> The point is they could have probably kept going up if they hadn't done that. No company goes up forever. They all eventually strangle themselves with bureaucratic inefficiency.
- palmotea 1y ago> No company goes up forever. They all eventually strangle themselves with bureaucratic inefficiency. So they should act to strangle themselves faster? It feels like your reasoning is equivalent to, "Eventually you'll die, so there's no point taking care of your health. Go save money by avoiding the doctor, take up smoking, and eat junk food all the time."
- WalterBright 1y ago> So they should act to strangle themselves faster? Come on.
- palmotea 1y agoBeing relentlessly focused on the short term will do that, eventually. You seem to think the assumption "all companies die" means you can simplify away their journey, but it matters if they get there faster or slower (at least to society, if not the decision-makers to maximize their personal profit while hoping to not being the ones left holding the bag).
- nradov 1y agoOld companies die and new ones take their place. This is not a problem for society. In most cases creative destruction is a net positive.
- palmotea 1y ago> Old companies die and new ones take their place. This is not a problem for society. In most cases creative destruction is a net positive. That's what they say, but I don't think it's true (at the high end, at least). For instance: if Boeing dies, the market will not replace it. It'll be an Airbus monopoly for large jets, and maybe the the communists will eventually build a competitor (Comac). IIRC, it's too expesnive for Embraer to make the jump into that market.
- grumpy_coder 1y agoBoeing has consistently underperformed the market massively since the MD merger. Making maybe 3% after inflation
- WalterBright 1y agoThe vast bulk of Boeing's history was before that.
- CamperBob2 1y agoRight, and isn't that everyone's point? When their focus was on the product, they excelled.
- bumby 1y ago>It’s not about prioritizing short term results Boeing was forced by courts bolster safety, compliance, and quality programs as well as admitting to conspiracy to thwart FAA oversight. I don’t know about you, but my experience is that when companies undermine those types of oversight, it’s almost always due to schedule and price pressure (ie short term results). (Not to mention, the whole impetus for MCAS was to rush the design to market so they wouldn’t lose out on AA as a customer).
- WalterBright 1y agoAgain, the vast bulk of Boeing's history was before that. > the whole impetus for MCAS was to rush the design to market so they wouldn’t lose out on AA as a customer The impetus for MCAS was to make the MAX behave like the previous 737 model to reduce the expense of retraining the pilots. In general, flying is safer when pilots do not need to "code switch" when switching airplane models. Many crashes result from a pilot reflexively doing the right thing for the previous airplane they flew, rather than the one they are flying at the moment.
- bumby 1y ago>Again, the vast bulk of Boeing's history was before that. I’m not sure what you intend to convey with this statement. If price reflects reality, the current price should reflect the current reality, no? Whether the White Sox were the best team 100 years ago has little bearing on my prediction about their chances this year. I fail to see how Boeing’s prior culture prevents them from succumbing to short term incentives. I know your point is the downfall is a bureaucratic one, but the evidence does not point to that (they actually cut corners on bureaucratic requirements). >The impetus for MCAS was to make the MAX behave like the previous 737 model to reduce the expense of retraining the pilots. Go deeper. Why was this considered necessary? (Hint: it’s because they wanted to rush the design to market with a less expensive (and lower quality) product. Ie cost and schedule pressure. You stopped at the proximate cause.)
- triceratops 1y ago> They grow until they become unable to function efficiently anymore, then they go down But why?
- dsr_ 1y agoThe book on GE is specifically about how they lied, cheated, and committed fraud -- er, accounting irregularities -- for decades, in order to maintain the illusion of number goes up predictably. In retrospect, it was exactly as unlikely as Madoff's numbers.
- spwa4 1y agoBut ALL of the FANGs pride themselves on predictably rising numbers. They all have a semi-believable story, and in fact only Amazon has a unique tactic (which is cheating taxes entirely by having zero profit, hence their revenue goes up predictably instead of profit. The others have steadily rising profit with slight variation in the rise of their revenue) But all of them do it. Facebook/Meta, Amazon, Netflix, Google, Apple. Even the non-FANG fangs like Tesla, Twitter, ... and all have stories about faking it. Most are advertising and that's easy to fake on both sides (buy your own adertising, and of course fake engagement), Amazon has zero profit so they proudly declare they're faking it for the government (but, of course, they're not cheating you), Netflix has steadily rising subscriber numbers where everyone else has failed, even Apple's growth has switched to subscriber growth, the part of their business that would be the easiest to fake. In fact this is quite common in the whole S&P 500, including outside of the US, with numbers not quite as dramatic as the FANGs, but still going up.
- saghm 1y ago> Companies have life cycles. They grow until they become unable to function efficiently anymore, then they go down. > It's not about prioritizing short term results. Why did they need to grow in the first place though? If a company is already profitable, and growing will end up making them less functional and eventually erode profits, that sounds like it's due to prioritizing short-term results over long-term stable profits.
- Aunche 1y ago> Fatal Recklessness at Boeing Traces Back to Long-Standing C-Suite Greed I suspect this is true to a certain extent, but IMO this narrative has been exaggerated to the point where it is completely useless. If Boeing execs were only focused on "short term profits," how did commercial aviation deaths decrease despite there being significantly more flights? https://www.statista.com/chart/4854/commercial-aviation-deaths-since-1942/ https://www.statista.com/chart/4854/commercial-aviation-deat...
- toomuchtodo 1y ago> Works until it doesn't. Boeing 737 Max: The troubled history of fatal crashes and 346 deaths in 7 years - https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/business/boeing-737-max-the-troubled-history-of-fatal-crashes-and-346-deaths-in-7-years/articleshow/111566888.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/busi... - July 8th, 2024 As Boeing looks to buy a key 737 supplier [Spirit AeroSystems], a whistleblower says the problems run deep - https://www.npr.org/2024/06/16/nx-s1-4998520/boeing-737-spirit-aerosystems-whistleblower https://www.npr.org/2024/06/16/nx-s1-4998520/boeing-737-spir... - June 16th, 2024 Boeing’s Decline Traced to Decades of Catering to Shareholders Above All Others - https://bhr.stern.nyu.edu/quick-take/boeings-decline-traced-to-decades-of-catering-to-shareholders-above-all-others/ https://bhr.stern.nyu.edu/quick-take/boeings-decline-traced-... - April 8th, 2024 Boeing’s long fall, and how it might recover - https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boeings-long-fall-and-how-it-might-recover/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boein... - April 7th, 2024
- Aunche 1y agoAre there actually more issues or are people just more aware of them? Like I said, commercial airline flights are significantly safer than they were in Boeing's supposed golden era despite these publicized scandals.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoIf your position is "well, it lasted this long and the organizational rot only killed a few hundred people" we may be unable to meet on this topic. How many deaths would be sufficient? I argue the decline in fatalities over time is due to commercial air traffic regulations and systems. https://news.mit.edu/2024/study-flying-keeps-getting-safer-0807 https://news.mit.edu/2024/study-flying-keeps-getting-safer-0...
- badpun 1y agoBoeing stock price still almost doubled in the past 10 years. Went up by hundreds of percent in the past two decades. GE stock is worth 40x what it was worth 40 years ago, when Jack Welsh took over management! These two seem like two very successful companies, led by succesful strategies.
- immibis 1y agoA lot of things did. Seems like prices much tend to rise faster than inflation.
- badpun 1y agoA lot of badly managed companies (or just companies in stagnant industries) saw their stock prices stagnate or fall. Boeing and GE had large rises though (meteoric in case of GE).
- int_19h 1y agoDo stock prices even meaningfully represent anything anymore? Looking at some valuations makes me feel like it has all devolved entirely into gambling.