4 ms·
Driverless Semi Trucks Are Here, with Little Regulation and Big Promises
- bookofjoe 1y agohttps://archive.ph/cfa04 https://archive.ph/cfa04
- djoldman 1y ago> These new trucks won’t need sleep, they won’t speed, and they won’t get road rage. They won’t ride the brakes or make unnecessary lane changes, wasting fuel. And they won’t need to abide by the 11-hour daily driving maximum imposed on long-haul truckers for safety reasons. Exactly. Even if a robot vehicle could "just" match the performance of a human, we would still vastly prefer them because we want people to do higher complexity tasks than operate motor vehicles.
- harimau777 1y agoEven if people want to do higher complexity tasks, that doesn't mean they will have the opportunity to. Much more likely is that people just become poorer and/or switch to more demeaning jobs.
- trollbridge 1y agoThere also won't be a truck driver to under pay or not pay at all to load and unload the truck nor be a sham owner-operator who is being leased the truck by the trucking company and can barely eke out a living. Same challenge Uber at al face with autonomous vehicles - when you can underpay a driver 50 cents a mile to drive their own car, it doesn't make much sense to have an autonomous vehicle that costs you closer to 70 cents a mile to operate.
- _heimdall 1y ago> we want people to do higher complexity tasks than operate motor vehicles. Why? And who is the "we" here? I really could care less what kind of job someone else enjoys doing. They don't owe me anything and I don't want to tell them what kind of job to have any more than I want someone telling me what job to have.
- infecto 1y agoEhh, the point is not to tell others what to do but to not stop innovation by government regulation pandering to trade or labor groups. Look at the latest dock workers agreement that includes language to prevent automation. Dockwork is one of the best examples of something that can be automated quite well.
- soco 1y agoAnd my point is, I don't want to make people lose their living. Period.
- infecto 1y agoIf it’s going to happen anyway why pander to that group? It’s like how politicians in the US keep promising coal is coming back. No it’s not. I don’t want to actively “make” people lose jobs but I also don’t want to limit innovation. The relatively free movement of labor is a benefit for all including workers. I guess if someone really wants that Amazon warehouse picker job great but I am not sure that’s true.
- fragmede 1y agoYou don't? By paying your taxes, some of which goes to the police, you're forcing criminals, with their ill gotten gains into jail. An absurd thing to point out, other than that fact that there are some people who you do want to lose their living. Because those jobs harm you or society. Then we're just left to debate what harms society and what lets everyone in a society thrive.
- SonOfKyuss 1y agoI mostly disagree with regulations that specifically limit progress, but I can also see the benefit of phasing changes in at a regulated pace in order to give the real humans who depend on those jobs with very little social safety net time to adjust
- intrasight 1y ago
- 1over137 1y agoI’ve got news for you: not all humans want, or even can, do high complexity tasks.
- trollbridge 1y agoYep. And there's human dignity in doing work that involves low complexity tasks.
- cr125rider 1y agoI knew a guy many years ago, super nice guy, who was an over the road trucker. I don’t think he had it in him to do more complex tasks. Hard worker, nice, just the way God made him. I think the task complexity stopped at driving.
- close04 1y ago> we want people to do higher complexity tasks than operate motor vehicles Does it look like the market is sitting today on a pool of hundreds of thousands of higher complexity jobs that just go unfilled because people choose to "just" operate motor vehicles? Do those jobs look like a realistic fit for today's truck drivers? There are 3 million truck drivers in the US today. Do "we" understand what's the impact of "our" preference towards what other people should do? Or is what "we" want coming from a place of "I'm safe from all of this so I can afford to have lofty ideals for others"?
- djoldman 1y agoWell there are 7.2 million job openings: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/jolts.nr0.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/jolts.nr0.htm I'm not sure how many of them are more complex than truck driving but it's safe to say that there are plenty of employers looking for workers.
- close04 1y ago> I'm not sure You started with a number you don't understand as the answer to a question I certainly did understand when asking. You went from "increased skills jobs are so much better for people" to "maybe they'll find some job, I'm not sure". But the average trucker won't find good job in finance, IT, or health. The jobs either aren't better (better work, better pay), or they're not realistically reachable by a normal trucker (easy enough to upskill to make it likely). Employers aren't usually looking to hire old and inexperienced former truckers when the competition is either people with experience on that job or youngsters willing to take lower pay because they don't have a family to support.
- noworld 1y agoCan they not ride next to each other on two lane roads? That would be great.
- Molitor5901 1y agoAnd diminishing cost of returns. If it just gets 60% of human performance the industry will use them, and push to advance the technology to the point of no human interaction.
- bell-cot 1y ago> Even if a robot vehicle could "just" match the performance of a human, we would still vastly prefer them because we want people to do higher complexity tasks than operate motor vehicles. Sadly, this sounds like an anodyne ideal, tuned to rationalize "don't worry, feel happy" indifference in well-to-do people - who are conveniently far away from the affected workers, and the grim realities of how the change will actually play out in their lives and communities.
- threatofrain 1y agoI could imagine we create dedicated infrastructure lanes which aren't meant for ordinary people. That would make the self-driving problems a lot more manageable.
- trollbridge 1y agoSuch dedicated infrastructure lanes would cost an enormous amount of money, which the operators of such autonomous vehicles are not going to want to pay.
- nmeofthestate 1y agoThe whole point of self-driving vehicles is that they can can run on existing infrastructure, so that's a non-starter.
- pdoege 1y agoIf we had dedicated infrastructure we could make the roadways out of wear resistant material. Maybe a metal or something
- Moomoomoo309 1y agoAnd if it's not the same infrastructure, we can lower the fuel cost by reducing rolling resistance by switching to steel wheels on steel tracks, and then since no other vehicles will be on this infrastructure, we can chain multiple of the trailers together, aaaand we've invented trains. All transportation alternatives converge into trains over time, it's like carcinization but for transport.
- gwbas1c 1y agoFrankly, I think we could electrify the rails and then move single cars along like packets on a network.
- cassiogo 1y agoSo... train tracks?
- Symbiote 1y ago> Ms. Griffin recalled a particularly difficult episode: [...] She slammed on the brakes and yelled. Her truck pulled up just in time. > “I thought for sure I was going to kill those people,” she said. I hope at least the autonomous truck won't be driving at the very limit of the available stopping distance. She seems to have been driving too fast around a bend in a signed construction zone. This driver seems like a perfect example of where the autonomous truck doesn't need to be perfect to improve upon human drivers.
- intrasight 1y agoI had the same reaction to reading this I also had the reaction that the truck would "know" way before seeing the blockage - because the cloud AI will know everything everywhere all at once.
- bgwalter 1y agoThese trucks will also not form unions or start trucker protests like in Canada. They'll centralize and monopolize yet another middleman's dream and create the physical Internet, with vast opportunities for rent seeking and wealth extraction. You will not own the trucks: They'll be rented to you, you won't be able to repair them. If they malfunction, you'll have to talk to some centralized Email or "AI" based customer "service". Somehow, the monopolists will extract as much money as you previously spent on a driver. It may not be a monopoly in the beginning, but it will consolidate to at least an oligopoly soon.
- noworld 1y ago[flagged]
- ralfd 1y agoThis is muddled thinking. Automated trucks will lower costs for everyone. https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/10/10/spoons-shovels/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/10/10/spoons-shovels/ > If that digging would give work to a hundred men with shovels and picks, why not get a thousand men and give them teaspoons with which to dig up the dirt?”
- Braxton1980 1y agoDo you have evidence that's specific to the automated truck situation?
- bgwalter 1y agoStereotypical anti-luddite quotes are not thinking. Automation in construction has not led to lower prices, on the contrary, prices are exploding. Automation in car manufacturing has not led to lower prices, cars are still expensive. Automation in health care didn't prevent prices from exploding. If a monopoly emerges, by definition control and prices are centralized. And I really don't want broligarchs that follow the agenda 2025 to control the food chain.
- FirmwareBurner 1y ago
- nmeofthestate 1y agoWorking on self-driving truck software has to be one of the most high-stress jobs in software development - I'd have trouble sleeping at night, given the carnage that could potentially result from my mistakes.
- Molitor5901 1y agoIt is only a matter of time before the bulk of truck transport is autonomous. Some can say it won't happen, or it won't happen anytime soon, but that is to be extraordinarily short sighted into what is the goal of the shippers: to remove the human. Truck driving is not an industry I would recommend anyone getting into, but truck maintenance, yes.
- ryanmcgarvey 1y agoI don't think it will come all at once. By far the part no one wants to do and is also easiest for AI to tackle is long hauling. Humans will still be required for the last mile and delivery. I can envision a world in which we have "more" drivers because of AI not fewer.
- ty6853 1y agoThis sounds right, but I'd be interested in hearing from a trucker. Most of them get paid $0.X per mile, I imagine the interstate miles are the easy money and the last mile through Manhattan is the hell money.
- rascul 1y agoA lot of the last mile truck drivers are paid hourly or per stop instead of per mile. I don't have any numbers to say how many, though.
- chneu 1y agoIt depends on the company. A lot of truckers are paid per trip, not by mile. But really it just depends. https://youtu.be/yIZRffLA294 https://youtu.be/yIZRffLA294
- danaris 1y agoI don't really see how the first part of your post leads to the last part. Right now, we have drivers for all of the miles the trucks go. Even if we posit that there may be more trucks on the road with self-driving long-haul routes, it's hard to imagine that it's enough more to make up for all the long-haul truckers who will no longer be needed. And at least for most purposes, it seems highly likely that the number of last-mile deliveries is primarily driven by demand, not the availability of long-haul truck routes. Even if they could increase slightly, there are limits to how many trucks the highways can fit without congesting pretty badly. (Anecdotally, the NYS Thruway is already approaching that limit at some times and in some areas.) So how would we end up with more drivers total than now?
- conartist6 1y agoA lot of people will die before this is done. Even the trucks will probably start experiencing mechanical failures more quickly than anyone expects (based on the passage of calendar time) due to the 100% duty cycle I would think
- incomingpain 1y agoAs long as they are insured. What's the problem? Driverless vehicles dont need to be perfect drivers, they need to be as good as the worst driver who can get insured. The 16 year old kid who doesnt know how to drive at all and didnt do drivers ed... Realistically the driverless vehicle AI is probably far better than the average driver already. All cars and trucks will eventually be driverless.
- danaris 1y ago> As long as they are insured. What's the problem? "Well, the truck plowed into a schoolbus full of middle schoolers, killing everyone, but at least all the families got a nice chunk of cash!"
- incomingpain 1y ago>"Well, the truck plowed into a schoolbus full of middle schoolers, killing everyone, but at least all the families got a nice chunk of cash!" The 16 year old kid driving the F250 on bald tires, whose driving experience is grand theft auto 4 could drive into that school bus as well. Whereas you cant source a single story of any driverless vehicle crashing into a school bus. Do you think we should hold drivers to a higher standard so that we can hold driverless vehicles to higher standard?
- danaris 1y ago> The 16 year old kid driving the F250 on bald tires, whose driving experience is grand theft auto 4 could drive into that school bus as well. Or that 16 year old kid could take his parents' cache of assault weapons and shoot up a mall. (They're preppers, you know.) Or he could research making chemical weapons online and release a nerve gas through his whole school. Humans have agency, and the kinds of things they can do and are likely to do are fairly well-known. Also, even the biggest, most lifted overcompensation pickup truck is unlikely to be a match for a full schoolbus in weight. A semi truck is a different story. Crash a pickup truck into a schoolbus, you might kill a kid who's right there; crash a semi truck into a schoolbus, you might send the schoolbus flying 200m spinning top over teakettle, bashing everyone in it around until they're hamburger. > Whereas you cant source a single story of any driverless vehicle crashing into a school bus. Humans have also been around for, well...all of human history. Driverless vehicles have, thus far, been around for just a few years, and only in very constrained circumstances. They have also, to the best of my knowledge, been exclusively passenger cars. Dangerous if misused, to be sure, but not on the same scale as a semi truck. If I invented a brand-new self-flying airplane, and you were (rightfully) concerned about its safety, and I said "you can't source a single story of my DanarisPlanes crashing into buildings!", I would be 100% correct—and it would still be bullshit, and the safety concerns would still be very real. Putting driverless semi trucks on public roads without extensive safety testing done to the satisfaction of third-party regulators with no vested interest in anything but the public's safety is a huge difference. The problem is not that there is a chance a driverless semi truck could cause a tragic accident. It's that I don't see any evidence that we have proper understanding of what the risks are—and with a Republican-dominated Congress willfully abdicating its responsibilities for years now, unfortunately we don't have any sane legislation or regulation to give us a common framework for handling this. The problem is also that just making sure they are insured is not a solution. First of all, the insurance companies also don't have enough information to properly assess the risk, because that information simply does not yet exist. Second of all, as I implied with my earlier snarky comment, when the negative consequences of the self-driving truck failing to behave properly could very, very easily include many dead people, money just doesn't make that better.
- creer 1y agoWhat's more surprising in there is that it's not Waymo doing this. It's hard to argue that Waymo isn't way ahead of the rest in self driving. And this outfit putting self driving semi trucks on the road is [checks notes] Aurora Innovation. Who? Further we learn they are proud of "360-degree sensors that can detect objects 1,000 feet away" and "already logged more than 1,000 driverless miles shuttling goods along Interstate 45 in Texas" - that's what? two days? "We have something like 2.7 million tests that we run the system through" and "two trucks without a driver". What in the world? Now, I will grant that some of this nonsense is probably the [checks notes] New York Times writer but still. This is absurd. The conclusion goes beyond that: "What Aurora’s doing is being much more careful than most,"
- creer 1y agoSpeaking of which, has Waymo / Google spoken recently of why they are not more visible on truck self-driving?