3 ms·
> No question that Ive is a legend Not sure why he deserves to be a legend, to be honest, but yes, he is a legend. He did a good job, but those small and mini
by amelius 1y ago
> No question that Ive is a legend
Not sure why he deserves to be a legend, to be honest, but yes, he is a legend.
He did a good job, but those small and minimalistic designs were only possible because of the efforts of entire teams of engineers, of which the public never heard anything.
- bigyabai 1y agoAnd many of those designs were made at Ive's behest, against the wishes of entire teams of engineers. I feel like we have his "courage" to blame for the Butterfly keyboard, terrible Mac thermals and the lack of ports on "Pro" computers.
- trane_project 1y agoThe thermals were all Intel’s fault. My 2019 MacBook from work is an oven. I can’t tell whether my smaller m4 max is turned on by touching it.
- bigyabai 1y agoYour 2019 Macbook also uses a different chassis, designed by Jony Ive. Apple knew it throttled the chips they used but shipped it anyways, presumably because Ive liked his thinness even when it results in a bendgate. You'll note that Macbooks don't quite look the same after Ive left and his influence went away.
- PantaloonFlames 1y agoI don’t actually know. Last MBP I had was circa 2017 or so. How are they different ?
- kshacker 1y agoBeefier. Bulkier. Quick google search says Intel 16" was 4.3 lbs whereas M4 16" is 4.7 lbs. Not a big difference you say but 1) it is going in the opposite direction where the newer product is bulkier and 2) imagine the years of thin-ness that would have been forced under a different regime.
- hinkley 1y agoI wonder how much of that is battery.
- jltsiren 1y agoBlaming Intel is a poor excuse. Apple could have done some actual design and built a laptop around the hardware they had. But they didn't want to. Instead, they ignored the reality, stuck to the flawed design, and shipped mediocre laptops several years in a row.
- mrweasel 1y agoApple had the design ready for an Intel chips that didn't arrive. Rather than revisiting their design they opted to just chuck the chip into a design that couldn't accommodate it's thermal characteristics.
- apt-apt-apt-apt 1y agoI spent way too much time figuring out that around 53W is the maximum that the last Intel MBP can sustain over longer periods before the VRM (converts power for the CPU) poops out and throttles you.
- microtonal 1y agoI agree, but I think they didn't care. For some years, some Apple execs believed that the iPad was going to replace the Mac. After that they knew that the Apple Silicon Mac was nearby, so they probably didn't want to make an investment in a 'legacy' platform. Did suck for all the people who bought one.
- trane_project 1y agoI've never had an Intel laptop work well in the efficiency and thermal department, Apple or not. I used to blame Apple too, but seeing the difference, it's hard to argue who the main culprit was. Can't design around a bad foundation.
- ginko 1y agoPentium M's were magical when they came out.
- cameronh90 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- brulard 1y agoI had the butterfly keyboard for 5 years yet I didn't have a single problem with it. And I'm a long time mechanical keyboards user. What is all the hate about?
- buzzerbetrayed 1y agoJust look it up. It was a thing for years, to the point that Apple was basically forced to revert it.
- kshacker 1y agoI was like you ... until one day.
- Octoth0rpe 1y agoThat's luck on your side. I too own a butterfly keyboard, trouble free. But there were 50 other macs in the office I worked in that regularly had issues. They were unreliable as hell, and beyond the reliability issue, many people did not like the shorter travel distance (I didn't mind this at all myself).
- vessenes 1y agoI felt the same way when I used it. But recently I booted up an old laptop with the butterfly keys and I was like "ewwww" as soon as I started typing on them. They worked. But what we have now is more comfortable.
- ilikepi 1y agoMany people (more than the average rate for the prior generations) _did_ have problems. Perhaps more importantly, the only way to address those problems when they arose was to replace not only the keyboard itself but the entire top case of the machine due to the way the parts were integrated. This process costed many hundreds of dollars when the machines were out of warranty, and the company eventually acquiesced to social pressure and lawsuits by creating an extended warranty program. That's not to say your situation is unique...there are probably many machines out there that have not had problems, including one owned by my wife. But there are also an unusually high number of machines that did.
- detectd 1y agoDon't forget the Apple Mouse with the lightning port under the mouse so you can't use it while it charges. It's still the only Apple product with a design that makes me physically cringe. I also find it awkward and uncomfortable to use, but that might just be me.
- bazmattaz 1y agoI love the Apple mouse. Been using it for 10ish years. But yeh it’s an absolute ball ache when it loses battery and you reallly need a mouse
- ryandrake 1y agoWhen I had that Apple mouse, I kept around a separate wired mouse to use when it inevitably ran out of charge while I was in the middle of work. I won't just stop what I am doing just because Apple wants me to not use a mouse with the cord plugged in.
- stuckkeys 1y agoI was just going to say…the mouse has to go on its back to be charged lmao.
- TiredOfLife 1y agoSo the power button on the bottom of Mac Mini is fine?
- detectd 1y agoI'm not familiar with the Mac Mini. I didn't know about that.
- microtonal 1y agoThe almost two decades before he made great designs. I have always felt it went downhill after Jobs was not there anymore to provide a counter force to Ive's design tendencies. It's like taking one of John or Paul away.
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y agoIve did good designs when Jobs kept him in check. Once Jobs was gone he messed up a whole generation of MacBooks. Things got much better after his departure.
- fakedang 1y agoI think after Jobs, Ive did all sorts of things just to justify his presence at Apple. Hence trying to make an already well-designed product even more "well-designed", but to his terms. And that's when it started turning to shit.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- turtlebits 1y agoOther than reliability issues (which I never ran into), the butterfly keyboard is the best laptop keyboard I've ever used.
- bobxmax 1y agoI absolutely despise comments like these, and you only see them on HN. It's like saying great architects aren't great, it's the construction workers who should get the credit.
- bcrosby95 1y agoHN isn't special here. There's conflict between people whose job is to make something look pretty and people whose job is to make it work in every industry.
- davidivadavid 1y agoRepeat after me: design isn't about making things pretty.
- wizzwizz4 1y agoCertain people who call themselves designers could do with learning this. Bring back brutalism, I say!
- asadotzler 1y agoFor Ive, it often was. Ever thinner MBPs? Why, if not for appearance given the weight didn't change. No ports on PRO computers? Why, if they didn't bother his aesthetic sensibilities. Charging your mouse disables its use because the ports on the bottom? Why if not to hide the port for looks? He spent most of his time at Apple trying to make things pretty. Your comment may be true for "design" in the abstract, but as someone who spent plenty of time studying design and architecture, let me assure you, many of the people I studied with who are now industry veterans never cared about much more than aesthetics, even in architecture where engineering and building science are major factors. Again, sure, theoretically true for "design" but hardly true for Ive.
- bobxmax 1y agoJust because you don't know the reasons doesn't mean there weren't any.