4 ms·
I hope he will give us an actual example from his work. But meanwhile, here's a classic example: The Donau is a river. On this river is a steamship (Dampfshiff
by bradley13 1y ago
I hope he will give us an actual example from his work. But meanwhile, here's a classic example:
The Donau is a river. On this river is a steamship (Dampfshiff): Donaudampfschiff
This ship is part of an organisation (Gesellschaft) that manages cruises (Fahrt): Donaudampfschifffahrtsgesellschaft
The ship has a captain (Kapitän) who has a cap (Mütze): Donaudampfschifffahrtsgesellschaftskapitänsmütze
On this cap is a button (Knopf): Donaudampfschifffahrtsgesellschaftskapitänsmützenknopf
You could extend this example: The button is colored with a special paint (Farbe), which is produced in a factory (Fabrik): Donaudampfschifffahrtsgesellschaftskapitänsmützenknopffarbenfabrik
And the factory has an entry gate (Eingangstor): Donaudampfschifffahrtsgesellschaftskapitänsmützenknopffarbenfabrikeingangstor
In English, this would be a huge sentence, all in reverse order: The entry gate of the factory that produces the color for the button on the captain's cap of the ship belonging to the cruise organization on the Donau.
The German is a lot more compact, if sometimes hard to parse :-)
- praptak 1y agoI don't remember many events from 1996 but my German boss walking into the office excited about the spelling reform of "Schiffahrt" certainly stood out as a memorable event. (They added the third f or maybe re-added it)
- Skeime 1y agoContext, maybe just for others: Schiff is ship and Fahrt is ride, so eine Schifffahrt is a cruise (and without the article, it is also the term for seafaring in general). Anyway, you can see that Schiff ends with two Fs and Fahrt starts with one, so if you put them together to form a compound word, you get three Fs in a row, Schifffahrt. In pre-reform German spelling, this was deemed excessive, so one would write Schiffahrt, instead. The German spelling reform in the mid-90s changed this, so now you do the logical thing. (Whether the old way really was confusing and which way is more aesthetic are separate questions.)
- bashkiddie 1y agoYeah, there has been a changeset in spelling rules https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reform_der_deutschen_Rechtschreibung_von_1996 https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reform_der_deutschen_Rechtschr... ... several times: 1996,2004,2006,2011,2017. The current correct spelling is either Schiff-Fahrt or Schifffahrt.
- lucb1e 1y agoImpartial foreigner here who has no stake in the old or new spelling. If you're combining ship and port, you can't just write shiport. Of course it's shiff-fahrt / shifffahrt? By what logic does anyone argue anything else?
- praptak 1y agoFirst of all, it was probably a descriptivist move. What I think happened is that people wrote 'ff' because 'fff' looked like a typo or was less convenient to write, so the linguistics codified that. Also, there are portmanteau words where the middle letters overlap, e.g. bro+romance=bromance.
- lucb1e 1y agoBromance does not sound like broromance in speech
- kazinator 1y agoI found a word like this in English. https://www.etymonline.com/word/chaffinch https://www.etymonline.com/word/chaffinch There may be others. When we turn to the letter 'l', we have the word skill-less which is not always written with a hyphen, in which case the three l's remain intact.
- bashkiddie 1y agoI can only guess: Once upon a time we used to write by hand. It was considered time consuming. Once upon a time we used to set books in lead letters. There were ligatures, where two consecutive letters hat a special spacing - like "fi" or "sz". If we allowed three consecutive letters, we would need to invent new ligatures. It is probably easier/cheaper to just forbid the spelling.
- andoando 1y agoI mean is this really one word though, or a bunch of words just spelled with no spacing?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- watwut 1y agoIt is one word in German. It has one article, Germans talk about it as about a single word and treat it as a single word for grammar purposes. You can use it as a single noun in any sentence. But it also odd example for this, because it is long as hell anyway already and additional spacing that English equivalent would require is just opportunity to wrap. It is just harder to read, but English equivalent would be easier to layout.
- mejutoco 1y ago> It is one word in German Is it in the dictionary?
- plz_throw 1y agoIt really is one "new" word consisting of a bunch of words spelled without spaces. It is a compound, where every word adds additinal information to the last component. An easier example is sth like "Altbauwohnung" which would be an apartment (Wohnung) in an old (alt) building (Bau) where "Altbau" is also a compound. This way of compunding enables you to build new words everyone can understand the first time they encounter them, but also to build those stupidly long words.
- andoando 1y agoWhat if I said in English, you can "compound" words with adjectives so for example if you have a book, you can add red and say redbook, and you can keep going and do stuff like uselessoldreddirtyneverusedbook. You can even add possessives which have their own adjectives, like if the book was owned by a redbearded german army vet you'd say The redbeardedgermanarmyvet'suselessoldreddirtyneverusedbook
- throw310822 1y agoIn fact, with added spaces, works fine in English too (since English is also a Germanic language): the Donau steamship cruise organization's captain's cap button. And extended: the Donau steamship cruise organization's captain's cap button's colour factory's entry gate. EDIT: Let's not forget to mention its Java implementation, which goes full German: DonauSteamshipCruiseOrganizationCaptainButtonsColorFactory
- ggm 1y agoThe German is only worse because we want to treat it worse, the sentence isn't much longer and they're broadly equal in conceptual cost. Which isn't surprising since Anglo Saxon is at the heart of the non French bits of English.
- marcosscriven 1y agoExactly. It’s not like you can even hear the absence of spaces in one or the other. It’s purely a writing choice.
- ggm 1y agoAustralian ad of 30+ years ago: avagoodweekend and dontforgetaboutheaeroguard
- cmrdporcupine 1y agoAnd I think the use of spaces between pieces of nouns in English has more to do with the fact that -- in comparison to German -- the pronounciation is so unpredictable from the spelling that not having the visual indicator between pieces could leave you completely lost -- "what word is this?" Whereas German has very regular and consistent rules of pronounciation that map closely to spellings, so once habituated you can scan it from the page and spit it out more reliably. Still, having grown up with English as my first language and (partially) learned German as a young man, learning German gave me more appreciation for English. Which only grew once I studied a bit of Anglo-Saxon. I love our language, there's just something about its character. A spelling reform would be nice (though entirely impractical) though.
- 3036e4 1y agoSwedish works the same (unsurprisingly), but note that programming languages also kind of do that. If you had to use a word like that in Java you would just mash all the words together in CamelCase and it would be pretty much the same as using the long German word (and almost exactly as difficult to read) even if technically it moved from being a single word to being a long list of words. It can still be a single identifier without spaces even if you translate to a language where it can not be a single word.
- gloxkiqcza 1y agoGerman is a prime candidate to implement PascalCase in a natural language.
- Skeime 1y agoThis is not necessary. Practiced German speakers generally do not struggle with splitting words into their components because syllables follow relatively predictable patterns. You will run into ambiguities from time to time, of course, but the same applies to tons of other features of natural languages as well. (Do you want to outlaw homophones in English?) Anyway, there is also a perfectly acceptable and established way of making German words easier to parse if need be: hyphens. So Hyphen-Case instead of PascalCase.
- gloxkiqcza 1y agoInteresting insight, thanks! Linguistics is fascinating, especially in the wider cognitive science context.
- School-Cotton 1y agoWhen I was learning to read German, for the longest time I thought the word “letztendlich” was “letz-tendlich” (which is meaningless but at least theoretically pronounceable) rather than “letzt-endlich” (which is what it actually is). I’m sure a native German speaker wouldn’t make the same mistake, though.
- hengheng 1y agoThe century old tradition has set up a couple rakes for native speakers to step into. "Selbständig" (freelancing) is obviously derived like self-standing, but "selb" is archaic and completely unused, prompting native learners to write 'selbstständig, which is wrong. Couple more ones like this. Ask a native speaker about hinüber vs herüber, they will be perplexed, because it feels so dialectal. And nobody even knows about imperfect tense vs perfect tense, it's just stylistics to most.
- 1y ago
- hoseyor 1y agoThis is not an accurate or precise example. You surely know you are misleading people. German does not simply just concatenate words ad infinitum across logical classification, a concatenated, compound word is generally logically limited by classification. The concatenation generally only tends to be used in relevant (operative word being “relevant”), increasing smaller/lower logical classification. You generally will not rise and fall in that classification, let alone jump horizontally as you concatenate. It is really just a logic tree, you don’t all the sudden jump trunks or branches. It has to be a logically precise unit. You’re essentially just saying ManBearPig. It’s not an actual thing. So the entry gate of the factory that produces paint that happens to maybe also be used on the button of the cap of the captain of the ship on the Danube and is also part of a union, is not… Donaudampfschifffahrtsgesellschaftskapitänsmütze nknopffarbenfabrikeingangstor