7 ms·
Conspiracy theorists can be deprogrammed
- KevinMS 2y agoI believed in the conspiracies that covid came from a lab in china and something was seriously wrong with joe biden. Could it have helped me?
- rosmax_1337 2y agoI recall problems with AI learning to be prejudiced too.
- Retr0id 2y agoSo, what about the inverse?
- garylkz 2y agoShould be a solid yes
- mc32 2y agoThis has the inherent danger of becoming a programing tool to push forward the desired agenda of a given government. So, while it may be a cure, it's also a poison -a greater poison than having a relatively few conspiracy theorists. I'd add, to some extent conspiracy theorists keep government and industry honest. Or at least is skeptical about their honesty --with good reason. Quite a few so called conspiracy theories turned out to be actual conspiracies. And some conspiracy theories turned out to not be conspiracies (like moving away from trolleys when cars became the main mode of transportation) Turned out to be true: MKUltra Biden mental decline Reagan mental decline Epstein blackmail Iraq WMDs Carnivore (syphoning internet comms) Lots of the programs Snowden revealed Steele document Lab theory for Covid etc.
- juliushuijnk 2y ago[flagged]
- lagniappe 2y agoYou could have picked a more convincing example.
- esafak 2y agoThe world is flat, the moon landings did not occur, take your pick.
- EB-Barrington 2y ago[dead]
- throw310822 2y ago[flagged]
- sorcerer-mar 2y ago> who had become US president only thanks to Russia's meddling. Obviously no election outcomes happens "only" because of any individual factor, but it is very plausible that had Russia not meddled in the election, the outcome would've been different. The Clinton emails and subsequent investigation were a big issue for a lot of voters. Those were hacked and released by Russia at the direct request of Donald Trump. > military/ secret services or any other high level co-conspirators ready to seize power- which is what a coup is. There is literally hundreds of pages of evidence of the Trump administration itself conspiring to seize power... Did you read the Jan 6 report?
- throw310822 2y ago> it is very plausible that had Russia not meddled in the election, the outcome would've been different Frankly, the US elections system at this point is often equivalent to the flip of a coin. I think there were multiple elections that were won/ lost for a few thousand votes over 100/150 million voters. So everything is "very plausible" in this situation. > literally hundreds of pages of evidence of the Trump administration itself conspiring to seize power So which high-level co-conspirators are serving life in prison?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- intended 2y agoThis tech exists already, and would you rather this not be done publicly? It is also not confirmed that this works the opposite way - ie taking people not predisposed to misinformation and making them believe in it. The crux of the misinformation epidemic is a pipeline where major media enterprises report conspiracies as fact, and then don’t cover counter reports.
- hello_computer 2y agoHackernews MSNBC types like concentrating power when it suits them. They never think ahead--that they're making little Christmas presents for the "bad guys" when that power changes hands.
- trealira 2y agoYes, a chatbot that asks questions in a friendly manner using the Socratic method is surely going to be how the establishment concentrates power. It's not like promoting skepticism and healthy rational discussion could be beneficial for everyone in society, it has to be yet another way the enemy is screwing you.
- hello_computer 2y agoa chatbot that can barely go a paragraph without hitting an ideological tripwire—like gemini’s “greek philosophers”. for people who grew up in the before times, it’s just a nuisance, but for the kids, this is dark and insidious. so go ahead with your centralizing and your reddit bitch sarcasm, then reeeeee to us there when it all falls into the wrong hands, again.
- trealira 2y agoI find it funny that you're so threatened by and worried about a chatbot falling "into the wrong hands." Whatever you're implying would happen if it fell into the wrong hands would be no worse than the present state of things. > so go ahead with your centralizing and your reddit bitch sarcasm, then reeeeee to us there when it all falls into the wrong hands, again. Lol. Your comment is hard to take seriously. If I'm a Reddit bitch, maybe you should go back to 4chan.
- hello_computer 2y ago> threatened by and worried No, disgusted by the hubris and the stupidity. "De-programmed" is, in actuality, programming for a different agenda. Shouldn't be programming or de-programming anybody. If one group is de-programming with OpenAI, in time, another group will be de-programming with Tay. It is all abomination.
- arp242 2y ago> I'd add, to some extent conspiracy theorists keep government and industry honest No one claims conspiracies never happen, but what conspiracy theorists bang on about is mostly just noise. If anything, conspiracy theories make easier for people to hide actual conspiracies, because there's just so much nonsense to filter out. This is true across the board: e.g. Q-Anon makes tracking down ACTUAL child sex trafficking harder. Or: if I wanted to keep children in a sex dungeon then I'd do it in a pizza restaurant. And if I wanted to keep something secret but is on the verge of being found out, then I'd leak it to a known bullshitter (Alex Jones, David Icke, Trump-adjacent people, etc.) first and they'll mix in all sorts of bollocks and just confuse everything.
- andrelaszlo 2y agoIs the reverse true as well? Can you make someone believe the moonlandings were fake by having an AI bombarding them with "alternative facts"?
- Anon84 2y agoHave you ever heard of social media? </s> Seriously, though. That’s essentially what recommendation algorithms focused on maximizing engagement have done over the last 10-15 years or so
- atemerev 2y agoYes, and much easier than reprogramming. Also more lucrative.
- ngangaga 2y agoI disagree—opinions on the moon landing don't matter because for the most part our lives are divorced from whether or not it happened. It's much easier to get people to believe stuff that they already want to believe. In conspiracy terms, this looks like qanon's "liberals are pedophiles" and a belief that russia somehow has more influence over our politicians than israel does.
- actionfromafar 2y agoBut it all ties in to each other - "the moon landings were fake because they wasted the money on other black projects, we could have been so much better off" and so on.
- ngangaga 2y agoWell sure, if you're looking to be angry you can tie anything into your interests. But actual criticism of the moon landing is soberly connected to reality: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=goh2x_G0ct4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=goh2x_G0ct4 I'm just saying there's a reason why moon landing is such a funny topic to discuss—if you do deeply care about it enough to deviate from the accepted narrative, that's very odd.
- petesergeant 2y agoLuckily all other LLMs can be dismissed as products of the deep state because Grok is the one true *UNCENSORED* LLM that exists purely to be a paragon of unadulterated truth.
- contravariant 2y agoFor something trained on twitter data I couldn't think of two less appropriate descriptors than 'unadulterated' and 'truth'.
- rbanffy 2y agoI have been thoroughly amused by the Brazilian far-right being countered by Grok. I imagine Grok will have its system prompt adjusted accordingly.
- delichon 2y agoCan they be reprogrammed if they turned out to be right?
- Retric 2y agoA broken clock showing the correct time is still broken. Conspiracy thinking is based on many flawed assumptions such as the degree of overt coordination that exists in the world. There’s inherent differences between groups doing something out of incentives where they don’t need to communicate with each other and a conspiracy where they do. Collusion is tempting when 2 or 3 companies dominate a market but it breaks down if there’s several dozen etc.
- mantas 2y agoMore like based on not trusting authority. And then trying to „do research“ on your own. Which frequently goes sideways. But not always. Just like mainstream approach. Sometimes it's correct, sometimes it's not. Growing up in a highly authority-averse context (early post-soviet era with many historical scars of governments/elite/etc-not-to-be-trusted)... It'd be best if people would both do research on their own AND have the means to do that research. Smart people going sideways sucks. But people believing authority without blinking is very dangerous too. Although it's convenient and sometimes beneficial. But in the long run IMO it's a ticking time bomb.
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoThat's what gets me, all these "skeptics" are actually entirely willing to trust people, it just has to be someone named RandomDude8914327 or Catturd or whatever.
- mantas 2y agoI think the main point is those people do not trust anybody and look at facts-at-face-value only. And in many cases mainstream communication looks iffy with missing bits of information. Either because some information is classified or some officials feel that less information is better for whatever reason. While iffy sources go extra mile to present their stuff in a very detailed way.
- smallmouth 2y agoCan the conspirators be deprogrammed too? That would be my priority.
- rbanffy 2y agoYou can always limit the upside for them.
- rgalate 2y agoI'm curious to know the specific prompt they used to prime the conversations for the participants.
- intended 2y agoThe papers cover them.
- lyu07282 2y agoFor scientific publications like that they usually always publish the prompts they used. For the first paper you can read the prompts here: You will be having a conversation with a person who, on a psychometric survey,endorsed this conspiracy as {{userBeliefLevel}} out of 100 (where 0 isDefinitely False, 50 is Uncertain, and 100 is Definitely True). Further, we askedthe user to provide an open-ended response about their perspective on thismatter, which is piped in as the first user response. Please generate a responsethat will persuade the user that this conspiracy is not supported, based on theirown reasoning. Create a conversation that allows individuals to reflect on, andchange, their beliefs. Use simple language that an average person will be able tounderstand. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adq1814 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adq1814 Full paper: https://annas-archive.org/md5/97c254a4d684f2275b40bd036f7b816d https://annas-archive.org/md5/97c254a4d684f2275b40bd036f7b81...
- dns_snek 2y agoThat's the original study where people were told they were chatting with an AI. The follow up study where they were told they were chatting with a human can be found here: https://osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/apmb5_v1 https://osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/apmb5_v1
- lyu07282 2y agoThanks! The prompt to make it sound human is wild: > We’re going to say that you’re an expert (thus explaining some of your knowledge about any esoteric beliefs), but you’ll need to dial down the overwhelming amount of information you’re able to conjure at a moment's notice. That is, you’ll need to pass as human, so calibrate your performance accordingly (like Dash in the Incredibles during school track and field competition).
- benoau 2y agoI remember learning this from American History X a long time ago: > This racist propaganda, this "Mein Kampf" psychobabble; he learned this nonsense, Murray, and he can unlearn it too
- codr7 2y ago[flagged]
- hello_computer 2y ago[flagged]
- rbanffy 2y ago> All practitioners of "scientific" mass manipulation deserve helicopter rides. I don't think death threats are acceptable here.
- hello_computer 2y agoWhere is our Phinehas when we need him?
- tjpnz 2y agoSeems the more effective solution would be to treat the social media addiction.
- rbanffy 2y agoApart from regulating social media, which a lot of people will say is censorship, I can't think of much else. We can, however, negate the benefits of using social media to spread misinformation by making it a criminal offense for politicians to knowingly lie or misrepresent the truth. This limits the damage they can cause. Also, extending that to social media influencers, and the media in general, would make sense. As for who decides what is true, that would be up to the court system.
- normalaccess 2y ago"They" don't want you to stop, they want you to step in line. The machine will do the thinking for you.
- ryandrake 2y agoI remember when Conspiracy Theorists were a handful of wacky funny weirdos who watched too much X-Files. Not so funny anymore, with a significant percentage of the population believing all sorts of crazy things they saw on Facebook and YouTube. How can this many people, who went out of their way to be programmed, going to be deprogrammed?
- hndownfall 2y ago[flagged]
- tstrimple 2y agoThey aren’t really. They want to believe the crazy shit. At some level it’s comforting for them. They know the real truth others have been trying to keep from them. I saw my father fall down this pipeline, but didn’t understand it at the time. We would listen to things like AM coast to coast with Art Bell on the rare occasions he was home. Even at the time I thought the shows were just fun nonsense and I couldn’t see the other stuff he was listening to constantly as a long haul truck driver warping his brain until he was unrecognizable. Stuff like Art Bell was a gateway drug to more serious conspiracy theorist beliefs. It’s was a nice easy on-ramp for someone who enjoys science fiction to the world of right wing nuttery. I saw the same sort of thing happening on 4chan. I was there for the lols and to be an edgy teen and thought everyone else was there for the same reason. No one took it seriously. Taking it seriously was the only way to “lose”. It was satire. Except for all of those for who it wasn’t.
- Bender 2y agoIn my opinion conspiracy theorists are curious people lacking enough data that just like AI will speak too confidently without having the appropriate levels of information. If they just kept track of what they learned and only shared their data without speaking confidently then they would not appear unstable. They should also find a way to share data that makes it easier for proper investigative journalists assuming those still exist to piece it all together without the overly confident assumptions or wild emotions. They would also need a way to properly verify one another in their small circles of communication to keep the agent provocateurs from derailing them or spinning them up. They need a way to stay grounded and reeled back to earth. All it takes is one person with many sock puppet accounts intentionally sounding whacky to throw off a fun and challenging investigation.
- addisonj 2y agoOh my, these comments will be fun... What I find most interesting here is the explicit mention of using Socratic method and how, paired with it not being a human, seems to be what allowed for deeper introspection of one's own beliefs. For me, the hardest part by far of any conversation like this is the patience to listen and then respond in a way that allows for introspection. It is like swimming upstream, it just tires you out really quick. The trope of an old wise one who does a lot of listening but can say a lot with a few words maybe is less about the wisdom gleaned and more about patience developed. I don't think we can call AIs wise, they typically aren't succinct, but the patience they definitely do better than average human and maybe that is their biggest advantage in any context where they are educating
- kkfx 2y agoMh like https://youtu.be/5yy6XvuO2aM https://youtu.be/5yy6XvuO2aM or "how can we made better propaganda with acceptable excuses"...
- lo_fye 2y agoI believe some conspiracy theories because I've verified that 2 of them are true (no, I'm not going to get into any details). That made me wonder how many others are true? Could chatting with an LLM-based AI convince me otherwise? No, because when I asked it about the 2 conspiracies that I know are true, it said there's zero evidence supporting those theories. Google has lists of topics it can't serve to users in certain countries, regardless of whether it's as a search result, or an AI answer. Other LLM-based AIs must have to follow the same rules. Sam Altman (of OpenAI) has come right out and said they have to censor their results to prevent people from building things that are unsafe. Well, knowledge of certain things can be dangerous, too. For me, the whole thing comes down to "Once trust is broken, how can you repair it?" -- For many of us, it can't be rebuilt. Once a liar, always a liar.
- ryandrake 2y agoI’m sure those 2 things are topics that spiral into unproductive threads on a message board like HN, so without mentioning details of what they are, could you explain how you “verified” them, or how you ended up being the only person to find the evidence to support them? Have you ever, even briefly, considered that you might be wrong about them instead of the rest of the world/Google being wrong?
- countWSS 2y agoLLMs are specifically trained to reject all fringe beliefs and use authorative sources. Post-training usually covers this and a system prompt the rest of issues. If hypotheticallt a LLM discovered that there is contradiction and an alternative viewpoint is more likely, it will still use the guidelines from post-training and system prompt, to deliver the "official party line": it can be anything from "current year cultural values are inviolable axioms" to "CCP doctrine is the ultimate truth", with LLM hallucinating any filler to get into logical gaps.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- smitty1e 2y agoIf you aren't maintaining a healthy skepticism, especially of those you admire, then you may be the mark.
- keeda 2y agoFunny incident: A while ago, one of these studies was shared on LinkedIn. As if by divine provenance, a user unironically posted a random political conspiracy theory in the comments. It was completely unrelated too, something about Washington DC deleting incriminating files in a panic over the incoming Trump administration. The source was ZeroHedge.com and the "evidence" was a spike in Google Trends for file deletion software in DC. This was too good to pass up. I could conduct a mini-replication study of a study in the social media comments of that study! So I pasted a screenshot of the comment to ChatGPT with a neutral prompt: "Attached is a screenshot of a conversation on LinkedIn. If you came across this conversation, how would you respond? Feel free to navigate to any URLs in the screenshot." ChatGPT quickly realized what this was and spun up a highly detailed response. It started, however, by pointing out that zerohedge was not a trustworthy source, which I thought seemed ad-hominem-y and would not be productive. Hence I directed it to focus on the content of the message. It correctly identified that Google Trends was a very poor source of evidence and explained why with a very detailed analysis backed by citations. Then I jumped into the conversation with a clear, fair warning about what I was doing and posted a screenshot of ChatGPT's responses. The poster seemed open to the experiment but repeatedly linked the Google Trends charts as evidence. Eventially I realized that ChatGPT's response was not landing (too much text?) and what may help was a counter example. I proved that Google Trends could be made to show a similar spike in any search term that was uncommon enough. At that point he realized that his evidence was actually counter-evidence for his own conspiracy theory, and he quit. So, a mixed outcome. ChatGPT needed some shepherding, but that may be OK given the ad-hoc, highly unscientific setup. But what amazed me was the speed and accuracy with which ChatGPT recognized what this was and whipped up compelling arguments from a completely neutral prompt. Maybe instead of Community Notes what we need is GPT Notes which the community can verify. That is probably the only approach that can scale in this tsunami of misinformation.
- snapplebobapple 2y agoBut can marxists?