14 ms·
The FTC puts off enforcing its 'click-to-cancel' rule
- lenerdenator 2y ago[flagged]
- jfengel 2y agoI remember everyone celebrating a regulation from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau back in November. As I said at the time, it was nice to have one of those.
- micromacrofoot 2y agoWe have quite a number of them, and they're all pretty good. Here's a sample of what the CFPB has created and/or enforces: * Truth in Lending Act * Fair Credit Reporting Act * Fair Debt Collection Practices Act * Equal Credit Opportunity Act * Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act * Home Mortgage Disclosure Act * Consumer Financial Protection Act The CFPB was one of the most effective agencies for consumers
- triceratops 2y agoBy "have one" I think they meant a bureau to protect consumers financially.
- ars 2y agoFor the most part all that those things accomplished was lots of paper.
- micromacrofoot 2y agoPaper as in money? I can point to how multiple of these have saved me money directly. Cash dollars. Overdraft savings alone have numbered in billions back in the consumers' pockets... and that's just one piece of legislation that is easy to measure. A lot of people don't realize how many current credit card regulations didn't exist 20 years ago. For example: you'd have to manually figure out how much interest was costing you and now they have to print it right on the statements. They've helped rein in some of the most predatory industries out there in numerous ways.
- ars 2y agoI don't feel like going through each one specifically, and I'm sure some of them actually reined in some practices, but the vast majority are just disclosures, i.e. some paper for the consumer to sign without reading.
- micromacrofoot 2y agoWhy comment at all if you're going to make an incorrect claim with the evidence of "I don't feel like it"
- buzzerbetrayed 2y agoDelaying the enforcement to July makes you right?
- MOARDONGZPLZ 2y agoPlease please please call me out in August if I am wrong, but I can absolutely guarantee this is like step 10 in further erosion of protections for consumers and this will never be enforced, certainly not in July. This is like rolling back overdraft fee caps, which has no benefit to consumers.
- gosub100 2y agoStopping the hemorrhaging of money is more important. Were you aware of all the ridiculous ways money was being spent under Biden? It's why Democrats lost the election.
- RankingMember 2y agoThat symmetrical registration/cancellation is being slow-walked like this is absurd (but under this admin, certainly not surprising).
- lenerdenator 2y agoIt's absurd if you believe the point of government is to be by, for, and of the people. If you see government as a way to enhance the ability of the owner class to enrich themselves, it makes perfect sense.
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoThen explain why the rule was created in the first place?
- mjcl 2y agoDemocrats see government differently than Republicans.
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoWell yes, I agree. But GP was saying "government" writ large behaves XYZ.
- collingreen 2y agoWhich absolutely does not imply a monolith of people all working in perfect lock step. It seems like you're looking to fight on the internet - would you consider a different activity instead?
- sorcerer-mar 2y ago> It's absurd if you believe the point of government is to be by, for, and of the people. > If you see government as a way to enhance the ability of the owner class to enrich themselves, it makes perfect sense. No I actually think it's important for people to square views like "government is a way to enrich the owner class" with actual reality, such as the fact that the government when administered by a different party did the exact opposite.
- sillystu04 2y agoVisa/Mastercard have enough power to enforce this on their own. Although obviously regulation would've been better. If a bunch of elected officials wrote letters to execs and a couple of NYT articles were written about the issue, Visa/Mastercard might be motivated to help.
- drdec 2y agoI, for one, do not want to encourage Visa/Mastercard to use their market position to enforce policies. What they have already done is damage enough.
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoWhy? They get revenue from unwanted transactions too.
- doctoboggan 2y agoThose transactions might have a higher than normal chargeback rate which could motivate them to get rid of them. It could also be a perk of the card, they could provide a subscription cancellation portal on their website.
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoThat would definitely be a huge perk to me!
- dspillett 2y agoChargebacks might upset that being a big benefit, and being the firm that takes a stance for customer care could be good advertising fodder. Though I don't see it working unless they both do it in step which minimises the useful effect of that against each other. It could still be a benefit vs other payment methods, what is PayPal's policy on such things?
- n_ary 2y agoNumber of people afraid to pickup the phone and talk to another human being instead of letting few hundred in forgotten subscription is larger than I previously thought. By that sense, without any data, I suspect that chargeback amount is wayyyy smaller headache compared to txn fees from forgotten uncancelled subscriptions.
- tantalor 2y ago> the burdens that forcing compliance by this date would impose With no consideration given to how consumers may be harmed by non-enforcement meanwhile.
- notfromhere 2y ago[flagged]
- chillingeffect 2y agoAnd increasing amt banks are allowed to charge for bounced checks... :/
- mtoner23 2y ago[flagged]
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoOr, alternatively, don’t punish people overly for writing blank checks?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nick238 2y agoOne of the anti-consumer behaviors that banks figured out was reordering transactions to increase overdraft fees [0]. For instance, say you made 5 purchases in a given day for ~$20 each, and your account had $500 in it. Then, you need to make an emergency $600 payment because something on your car broke. Banks used to have (maybe have again, as the CFPB is now a husk) broad latitude to resequence transactions posted to your account, so instead of you thinking you'd have one overdraft in the example, $500 down to $400, then once into the negative, -$200, and one overdraft fee, the bank could post them so it was $500 to -$100, an overdraft, then all 5 small transactions were also overdrafts, allowing them to charge 6 overdraft fees. In December 2024, the CFPB announced a proposed rule to cap overdraft fees for banks with over $10B in assets at $5 (OR treat the fee like a loan) and add additional regulations to avoid resequencing. On May 9th, last Friday, the president signed the resolution [1] to overturn the pending CFPB regulations, saving us from "unlawful government price caps" (ABA President Rob Nichols) and "harmed the very consumers the CFPB is supposed to protect" (Sen. Tim Scott, R, Banking Committee Chair). Comparing it to a loan, e.g. a credit card, usual effective overdraft fees are something like 16,000% APY [2] ($35 charged to the average $26 overdraft, repaid in a few days). Those with poor finances often might use a debit card instead of a credit card, which they might not have access to. It's a cruel joke that those with a bit more financial privilege can pay for things via CC without having the money for ~30+ days (statement close + payment due date) for 0%, or if they let the debt ride, "only" 40% APY. Not 16,000% APY. [0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/12/your-money/customers-can-lose-when-banks-shuffle-payments.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/12/your-money/customers-can-... [1]: https://bankingjournal.aba.com/2025/05/with-trump-signing-repeal-of-cfpb-overdraft-rule-aba-to-drop-lawsuit/ https://bankingjournal.aba.com/2025/05/with-trump-signing-re... [2]: https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_overdraft-credit-very-large-financial-institutions_fact-sheet_2024-01.pdf https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_overdraft...
- bee_rider 2y agoWith all the dark patterns and bullshit in every service, it has become too difficult to pay for things. Even services I like, and I think are run by ethical people—you never know who’ll get bought. Of course, like everybody else, I block ads. Although, when I didn’t I didn’t click on the things anyway. I dunno. For a while I felt bad consuming stuff without paying. But in the end, the internet has become so hostile and manipulative, I guess… I’m just going to wait it out. Eventually hopefully it will all collapse and a viable business model will be discovered.
- brador 2y agoA better system idea - every data point of user data needs a datetime stamp and source. Any request for your own private data will then come with datetime stamps and source origins for every piece of data they have of you. Thereby allowing you to cut off at the source and request deletion, which they must then propagate upstream or risk a fine per data point.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoOfficial release: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/05/ftc-votes-negative-option-rule-deadline https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/05/...
- SoftTalker 2y ago"If you can sign up online, you must be able to cancel online, too." That leaves a lot of room for the "Cancel" option to be buried in an obscure hard to find part of the website. I'd have hoped there was a requirement for it to be as prominent and as easy to find as the "Subscribe" option (and maybe there is, just not mentioned in this piece?)
- fastball 2y agoDo you actually want there to be a big "Cancel" button in the top right corner of every subscribed service? I personally don't want that. Click to cancel? Sure. But perfectly symmetrical is not something I need and in many cases not something I want.
- consp 2y ago> Do you actually want there to be a big "Cancel" button in the top right corner of every subscribed service? Yes, since the alternative is what you have now: impossible to find and if you find it highly annoying. Even if you have the law which says "canceling must be as easy as subscribing" like where I live it still isn't even close due to efforts of government creating a law but failing (by design) to fund the agency tasked with keeping the companies in check.
- wing-_-nuts 2y ago>Do you actually want there to be a big "Cancel" button in the top right corner of every subscribed service? ABSOLUTELY YES
- accrual 2y agoEven better would be a little field showing the rate and due date: [Cancel] [USD 12.99/mo billed on the 20th]
- fastball 2y agoFair enough. I'm going off my experience with cookie banners, and how that whole thing seemed like a great idea at the time but turned out to mostly be an incredible annoyance. In the same way, I don't think I'd enjoy a cancel button being front-and-center and cluttering up an interface at all times, given that I don't want to perform a cancellation action the vast, vast majority of the time when I am using a subscription service. 95% of the services I use already stick a cancellation button in either a "billing" section or a "user" section, which is generally quite easy to find and use in the rare instances I need it.
- bilsbie 2y agoI wish businesses would realize this actually hurts their sales. I’ve put off joining a gym for years because I don’t want the hassle of I want to cancel. Also I never do free trials assuming they’ll be hard to cancel.
- yoyohello13 2y agoIt doesn’t though. They’ve done the math and the profit gained by adding friction to cancel outweighs the loss of business
- gizzlon 2y agoHow do you measure those you never see? Qualitative? I'm definitely in the newer-touch-something-if-it-seems-hard-to-cancel camp. How do you measure that I didn't sign up?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vasusen 2y agoI have seen the results of these A/B tests closely on a major consumer site and I can tell you it definitely hurts the business to make cancelation really easy.
- TheCoelacanth 2y agoHow do you A/B test your company's reputation as being difficult to cancel? You can't exactly serve up different word-of-mouth to different users.
- mrguyorama 2y agoBelieving that "reputation" actually matters for American businesses is laughable. Craftsman tools are STILL riding the reputation they had half a century ago, despite being made out of the cheapest chinesium and losing their impressive warranty stance. The American consumer has demonstrated an absurd inability to consider past events as useful information to predict future results. Things continue to enshittify because the 3 consumers who recognize that quality is going down are vastly outweighed by the increase in consumption by the rest of your market. Kitchenaid still sells plenty of mixers that die after a year. Hell, American car brands are still successful businesses even though they have made only a few reasonably competitive vehicles since the 50s. Disney and Netflix are still making plenty of money despite making it difficult to share accounts.
- arwhatever 2y agoIt seems like delaying enforcement of anti-scam(ish) behaviors like this increases the average profitability of scam(ish) behaviors, and therefore creates an incentive to engage in scam(ish) behaviors in the first place. It seems (to me) as if such behaviors were stamped out more rapidly not only would fewer customers be affected, there would be less incentive to try the scam(ish) behaviors in the first place.
- tlogan 2y agoThis is something that should be governed by legislation (law) —passed by lawmakers, as we've seen in California - not by executive agencies. The FTC, as part of the executive branch (kinda independent but heavily influenced by the administration in power), shouldn't be in the business of creating new laws. But I get it now: when Biden directs the FTC to act, it's considered legitimate use of executive power. When Trump directs an agency not to act, it's authoritarian overreach.
- sapphicsnail 2y agoDo you not think the Trump administration is more authoritarian?
- tlogan 2y agoThe Trump administration can arguably be seen as less authoritarian, given its efforts to reduce the size of the federal government and its agencies. His style is certainly authoritarian, but that’s not the same as the actual impact on me, my family, and my community.
- computerthings 2y ago[dead]
- arwhatever 2y agoI'm listening to hold music right now, 30 minutes into my attempt at cancelling 3mbps home DSL service (not a typo), for which the price has crept up to $71 USD/mo. I first spoke with a customer service agent whose accent I couldn't understand very well. I have him ALL my account information. He mumbled something about being unable to forward me to the actual customer service agent (then what is your role, dude?), then came back on and said he couldn't forward me and so I would have to call them myself. He gave me the same number I had already called. I pointed this out to him and he gave me some other number, which is where I'm listening to on-hold music now. Right now the on-hold music is interrupted to sell me shit.
- shlomo_z 2y agoI feel your pain. This is extremely annoying. I wish you the best of luck!
- arwhatever 2y agoDone, and done. 14 + 44 minute phone calls, gave all of my information to 3 redundant people, including explaining to confused agents that I don't recall the account pin, well you have to have the account pin, well actually the previous person accepted my answer to my personal security question and the person before that texted me a temporary pin but now for some reason those alternate methods don't work for you?
- accrual 2y agoI wonder what would happen if one sent a cancellation letter via certified mail, then just stopped paying. If they come after you, well - you canceled.
- arwhatever 2y agoPerhaps the letter alone would be adequate. But frustratingly, the AT&T website appeared to allow you to replace your current (auto-pay) billing method with some other billing method, but I didn't see any way to remove all current billing methods, which makes just stopping paying nigh impossible. :-(
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoUgh, this is something the current admin's electorate could greatly benefit from. How significant of a revenue cut was this gonna cause businesses to justify immediately taking an anti-consumer stance?
- kevinventullo 2y agoCall me crazy, but it’s almost as if the administration is not acting in the interests of its electorate.
- nixpulvis 2y agoI want to see a candidate run largely on a consumer protection platform. We've been letting companies get away with more and more bullshit and it needs to stop.
- thomastjeffery 2y agoDo you mean Bernie Sanders or AOC?
- Gud 2y agoHi, European here. To hear these horror stories how hard it is to cancel a service in the US makes me wonder how the Americans put up with this.
- arwhatever 2y agoMy perception is that consumer protections are much weaker in the U.S. than in the E.U. It would be interesting if anyone has made any attempt at quantifying this. We all know that there are other countries where far, far worse abuses of power take place, but I've wondered if the U.S. might be at some really unfortunate nexus of strong contract law enforcement + particularly poor consumer protections that leads to these particularly madding subscription cancellation-type services discussed in this thread.
- nick238 2y agoOne of our defining American neuroses is an extreme aversion to anything remotely paternalistic.
- lostlogin 2y agoFellow non-American: Add in the random percentage increase in price when you try to buy something in a store from hidden taxes. Also add the culture of tipping, rather than paying staff.
- drdec 2y ago> Add in the random percentage increase in price when you try to buy something in a store from hidden taxes. It's not random. Those of us with a state tax are familiar with the rules and the rates. Those with a modicum of arithmetic ability have a pretty good idea what the total is coming to. Not saying "this is better" just that it is not as bad as you apparently think.
- lostlogin 2y agoI’ve only been to the US as a visitor, and found the percentages varied between shops and goods. I’m sure there is a pattern, but it really does seem crazy that it isn’t shown on the price tag.
- twoquestions 2y agoWhy do regular people like this? For real, is it all "Those People Have it Worse", or do they just like the government making things worse for it's own sake? There's people who like this who will never benefit at all, does anyone know why? I don't get it. Then again I don't get the appeal of tearing the wings off of flies either.
- lostlogin 2y ago> Why do regular people like this? For real, is it all "Those People Have it Worse", or do they just like the government making things worse for its own sake? Could you explain what you’re referring to? Isn’t the FTC trying to make it better (with key staff getting fired as they try)?
- twoquestions 2y agoPOTUS fired two Dem members of the FTC, and the remainder voted to delay enforcement. Some people like this, where companies get to effectively scam people by deliberately not enforcing rules preventing it. I don't know why people like this. I speculated that it was due to some dumb new bigotry of some sort, as a wild guess as to why people like it when the gov't harms people for no reason.
- typedef_struct 2y agoHow about 'click-to-bill'. If I don't touch your service you can't charge me.
- darknavi 2y agoKagi's policy is in the direction of that: https://help.kagi.com/kagi/plans/plan-types.html#fair-pricing https://help.kagi.com/kagi/plans/plan-types.html#fair-pricin...
- bdangubic 2y agoKagi is doing it the right way...
- Spivak 2y agoThe finger on the monkey's paw curls. Now every service will be spamming you notifications and emails even more desperately to bait you into "using" the service so they can bill you. More clickbait and scare tactics on news subscriptions. Also goodbye monthly subscriptions. It only works for Kagi because they're pretty decent folk.
- OptionOfT 2y agoMost, if not all of these service are billed before you get access. Ergo, if they cannot bill you, they can immediately revoke access. The system is built in such a way that they get a lot of information about you (e.g. SSN for internet access) subsequently used to ensure cancellation is extremely painful. If they didn't have this information, failure to bill would be immediate service pausing/termination, so it's not even that non-payment results in money lost for the company. For email accounts I create burners. I wish I could do the same in real life.
- Suppafly 2y agoOf course they did, everything pro-consumer gets canceled or put off during republican administrations.
- thrance 2y agoThis just in: consumer protection is "woke" and "cultural marxism". Americans elected the most corrupt president ever, that just received the largest bribe in history [1], and then act surprised when this administration fucks over consumers. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/may/11/trump-accept-luxury-plane-gift-qatar https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/may/11/trump-accept...