8 ms·
The cult of doing business
- carlosjobim 2y ago[flagged]
- pas 2y ago> There's a fundamental spiritual divide between people. One side hates being alive from the moment they are born, so everything is suffering, especially work. The other side loves life and loves doing things. [citation needed] :) So even if people end up in these very black-and-white groups it's doubtful that they are predetermined. But it's more like it's a spectrum, and some people start from a very good place some from a very hard one. And there are many important and distinct factors affecting one's relationship with work, success, motivation, diligence. Not to mention that luckily people's life (and relationship with work) can get better.
- carlosjobim 2y agoYou just cited it.
- carlosjobim 2y agoIt is a spectrum for a while, until people generally fall into one of the poles. And starting in a hard place or an easy place has no influence to this attitude, in my experience.
- pirgidb 2y agoThat's a story you tell yourself about the internal lives of others, but it is not knowledge. You don't actually know what's inside other people's minds. All we ever catch are glimpses of each other. It's tempting to make sweeping generalizations about others to explain the ways they confound and frustrate us. But it's essential to hew to the truth and accept that life is ambiguous, people are baffling, and simplistic narratives do more to give us comfort and reinforce our biases than they do explain the world around us.
- ordinaryradical 2y agoI’m not sure this claim has any more validity than his. Calling people unknowable flies in the face of a bunch of modern disciplines. We can see people behave very predictably with Game Theory, for example. Still, I respect the view that the individual is private unto themselves in a profound way. But I would also say people tend to show you what they believe in how they act. If you pay attention you will begin to notice when someone has put their hopes in power, finances, achievement, or ideology, to give a few popular examples. And it’s not about what people say animates them, or even about what they believe about themselves—it’s how they act.
- pirgidb 2y ago"People respond to incentives and we can model this with game theory" is a model that notably does not assume anything about the content of people's character or mind. And it frequently fails to explain the behavior of individuals, because you may not understand the incentive landscape they're in. You may offer to pay someone to do something, and it sucks the joy out of it for them, or they feel offended by your offer, and they become less likely to do it. There's light-years of difference between observing an individual person's actions and drawing conclusions about what they believe (this is in line with what I was referring to with "catching glimpses") and generalizing to conclude that everyone is predestined to be either enthusiastic and lively or a miserable wretch. It's far more likely you caught someone on a good or bad day, to pick just one alternative hypothesis. People contain multitudes. I also pay attention to the difference between what people say and what they do, and I agree it is meaningful and would even says it's a critical part of being around people. But it's easy to get carried away and pretend we know more than we really do, simplistic stories that explains everyone's behavior is very seductive. A model's ability to generalize is inversely proportional to how powerful it's predictions are. Stories like this that take people and bin them into two groups that control their destiny have huge predictive power - and apply to almost nobody. Whereas to return to game theory, assuming people are black boxes that optimize some unknown and idiosyncratic utility function which we infer based on their revealed preferences can apply to nearly everyone and everything. But it's predictions are very narrow in scope. You can use an A/B test to optimize any change to any UI flow, and it'll tell you which one converts better. But it won't tell you why.
- steveBK123 2y agoThe problem is that "everything is suffering, especially work" is a mindset at the end of the day. Most of us live in free enough countries where we are not assigned a class/vocation from birth. If your job is so unrewarding or unfulfilling, try something else! You are not married to a job, you won't be court marshaled for leaving, and you likely won't be rewarded for trying to keep a "job for life" like our parents generation might have been. Maybe you burned out and simply changing scenery will improve your life. Maybe you are in the wrong type of role and trying something new helps. Doing nothing certainly won't help!
- FredPret 2y agoSome suffer from learned helplessness. This turbocharges their resentment towards their boss, their company, and all of capitalism. Appreciating the magic of living in a thriving economy (true for most of the world for decades now) is partly attitude.
- steveBK123 2y ago> Appreciating the magic of living in a thriving economy (true for most of the world for decades now) is partly attitude. Yes. Louis CK did a bit ~15 years back about someone throwing a tantrum on a plane when the (then brand new tech) WiFi broke down. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=me4BZBsHwZs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=me4BZBsHwZs
- FredPret 2y agoExactly. Each of us is standing on the shoulders of giants - technological, scientific, commercial, political, and many other kinds of contributions. Life may not be perfect, but we all live downstream from Ugh the Caveman who once held a blunt rock in each hand, decided to whack them together, and bootstrapped the entire human tech tree, all while facing lions, sabre-toothed tigers, mammoths, ice ages, terrible diseases, and hunger.
- steveBK123 2y ago
- steveBK123 2y agoYeah I think you've sort of touched on something there. Many of my hardworking friends also have interesting hobbies/interests outside work they pursue and are known for. Arts, literary, cuisine, gardening, sports, charity, whatever. Generally putting more out into the world in other non-work venues. However practically none of my more "slacker" friends have anything to show for their time outside of work. They define life more in terms of what they are avoiding. Hobbies are more consumptive - watching TV/film, dining out, travel, etc. Maybe at the end of the day being good at any one thing takes some intellectual ability, commitment and effort.. so once you've applied that in one area you are likely able to do so elsewhere.
- steveBK123 2y agoAnd before I'm accused of moralizing - I'm not. The older I get the more I look at this bifurcation in terms of - wtf am I going to do in retirement. You read a lot of early retirement experiences and the people that "retire to something" (a hobby/volunteer work/etc) do much better than those that "retire from something" (can't wait to stop working!).
- bradly 2y ago>I love working (...) it's rewarding and mentally developing Some work may be these things, but not all work. If your work is consistently both then there is a good chance your work involves some creation that is satisfying you. I do agree that taking the morality out of our everyday tasks can greatly affect our outlook on life.
- carlosjobim 2y agoIf your work is not mentally developing anymore, it's time to look for the next thing to do. You've already conquered it completely.
- bradly 2y agoThat is a privilege not all have.
- carlosjobim 2y agoDoes your comment have any other purpose than to try to shut down a conversation?
- pirgidb 2y agoIf you're not willing to engage with what they have to say charitably, maybe you should just leave it. Their comment is plainly relevant to yours, and "shutting down conversation" is not at all a good faith interpretation. It is a huge weakness in your argument that you say people should leave jobs that aren't stimulating to them, when we live in a world where people have to work to survive and frequently cannot make decisions on that basis. Imagine for a moment you are talking to someone who works a minimum wage job at McDonald's to provide for their children. How do you imagine they would respond to your suggestion they abandon their responsibility to their children to find a more mentally stimulating job? How would that be anything but patently absurd?
- carlosjobim 2y ago
- Trasmatta 2y agoOr maybe some people don't get the chance to work on things that are rewarding and mentally developing? Not all work is equal. Maybe have some gratitude that your work has given that to you, rather than assuming that other people who are drained by their work are somehow spiritually inferior.
- carlosjobim 2y agoWho should I be grateful to? These people are drained long before they enter the work force. And no matter what job they have they will be drained by it. You probably saw a good chunk of them in school.
- steveBK123 2y agoOne of the things that opened up my eyes to how much of life is mindset & purpose was, ironically, dealing with some of the very wealthy in NYC. Some of the most anxious, unhappy, complaining people I met were the underemployed spouses of the very well off. And this isn't a sexist statement because it was both women and men. And some good percent of them had no kids either. Truly no responsibilities. The kind of people who I'd bump into at the gym just after sunrise on the way to a long day of work, and they lament to me how their weekly in-home massage got cancelled due to a scheduling conflict, and they just don't know what to do with their day. LOL. One can be happy or unhappy at any objective income/wealth/stress level. You'd be very surprised.
- carlosjobim 2y agoCouldn't agree more.
- Trasmatta 2y agoSome of the people in this thread have apparently never had a truly shitty job.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- betterThanTexas 2y agoah, if only the rest of us had the willpower to simply choose to not suffer and to enjoy life instead. Seriously, who do you talk to that enables such viewpoints? I suspect not many people want to talk to you after their shift. Work isn't the problem; it's doing bullshit work that's undervalued so that morons who don't work can eat. This has held true at every part of the pay scale. It's just the compensation on the upper end helps you have hope you may find meaningful work that can feed you. I suspect we all WANT to work. We just need to eat, too.
- carlosjobim 2y ago> ah, if only the rest of us had the willpower to simply choose to not suffer and to enjoy life instead. Exactly! You have to find that path before it's too late. Each one of us have only 80 years at most. > Work isn't the problem; it's doing bullshit work that's undervalued so that morons who don't work can eat. Agree. Doing dishonest or unethical jobs is not real work and makes nobody happy. > I suspect we all WANT to work. We just need to eat, too. And within those two goals there is a great world of opportunities.
- brokegrammer 2y ago> I love working What if you needed to work for free?
- DanielVZ 2y agoI love working but, after two years of not taking vacations – due to several reasons that I should’ve anticipated – oh boy how much I’d like to take a rest. I counting the days until I can take a few weeks off.
- surgical_fire 2y ago> One side hates being alive > I love working You should stop hating being alive. There's so much more in the universe than work.
- carlosjobim 2y agoWork is part of the universe, it's not everything, but it is a key part. Exercising is hard work. Who lives life feeling better, the person who exercises or the person who just sits all day?
- const_cast 2y agoIt's not this simple. A lot of people revel in suffering because they have a faulty mindset that good things can only come from bad things. Meaning, success comes with blood, sweat, and tears. This is not true, generally. There is such a thing as free lunch. Not everything must be a battle, and not every battle has a winner. Some people lean into work because they believe that by sacrificing they will discover the key to happiness. So they sacrifice things that feel good, like spending time laughing with friends or maybe delicious food. In short, they shrink their lives, purposefully removing the good parts. Some go so far as to remove good parts for absolutely no gain. Maybe they're gluten-free, but they're not gluten intolerant. Some are even purposefully lonely in some extreme sacrifice of human nature. Almost like monks or cardinals - they believe if they sacrifice something so fundamental, like sex or love, that they will achieve something other's cannot. The truth is a lot of that sacrifice will be for nothing. Sometimes the right choice is doing something stupid, or doing something unproductive.
- carlosjobim 2y agoThat is a very deep truth that you're stating, and also very hard for many people to learn. I've tried asking these kind of people if they believe that Martin Luther or Vladimir Lenin is going to reward them after death for their faithfulness, but the thing most closely to an explanation that I've gotten is that they can throw it into the faces of the townspeople that they worked hard while the others didn't.
- bix6 2y agoGood read. I wish there was a bit more advice than the final sentence offers though.
- pas 2y agoZizek has a few pretty good tips! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLkweSiuG2E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLkweSiuG2E
- know-how 2y agoOnly an academic could write something like this; "But it’s even better to treat love itself as the most important work." Your mortgage servicer doesn't accept love as payment.
- QuantumGood 2y agoThe comment below yours mentions suicide. Your brain doesn't accept mortgage servicing as a reason to continue living. So I think the idea is that priorities should flow from fundamentals.
- dade_ 2y agoOr the Protestant work ethic? I didn’t think this needed a new explanation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protestant_work_ethic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protestant_work_ethic
- graemep 2y agoI think there are several weakneses in the Protestant work ethic as an explanation. 1. why is it directed at making money rather serving society? 2. Why does it glorify the rich rather than the "lowly workman" mentioned in the intro to your wikipedia link? 3. lots of evidence against it The first two of these are even less convincing given that background of a religion that condemns the accumulation of wealth ("eye of a needle" etc.) and literally worships a "lowly workman". As for evidence, this section of the wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protestant_work_ethic#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protestant_work_ethic#Criticis...
- betterThanTexas 2y ago> why is it directed at making money rather serving society i think this particular phenomenon is rooted in calvinism, particularly in North America, and calvinists hated humanity. It also wouldn't surprise me if the protestants coming over here normally prone to social responsibility (eg some lutherans) were less willing to show up for their community than those in the old world.
- valiant55 2y agoAs a former Christian coming of age in the early 2000s there was a popular IP called "Left Behind" about the Rapture. I always thought the concept of the anti-christ was ridiculously absurd. That someone could convince Christ's followers to basically believe the opposite of the Gospel. After witnessing the rise of 45/7 and the complete bamboozling of my deeply Christian extended family I no longer consider it ridiculous. All that to say I'm not sure it really matters what exactly was written in the Bible because clearly a lot of the supposed followers of Christ never read it.
- 2y ago
- foobarbecue 2y agoThis is a book review, right? I'm confused by this pattern of people reading book reviews and treating them as if they were the book itself, or an original article. Isn't the purpose to decide whether you want to buy the book?
- wslh 2y agoIf you are interested I always recommend to at least download the "sample" from Amazon Kindle before buying it.
- api 2y agoWhat’s wrong with finding meaning in work? Of course like all things the entrepreneurial ethos gets very silly and begins to incorporate a lot of very silly other ideas (think and grow rich!) when you dive deep into it, but as I’ve gotten older I’ve realized that most movements, philosophies, and ideologies get silly if you go deep. Thinkers, like people on dates, put their best foot forward first. As you get to know them is when you find out they never wash their underwear. The alternative, I guess, is finding meaning in things other than work, and that’s okay too. Or you can do both.
- throwaway9914 2y agoSpecifically, if your work is a typical job, it makes your meaning dependent on a business relationship where one side has a lot more power than the other side. Example: an employer may end or modify the relationship for factors that are unrelated to your goals at any time. In general, depending on work for one's ultimate meaning is dumb because whether or not you worked "hard enough" is judged by other people, not the entity responsible for putting humans (and therefore you) on the planet in the first place--you're already here so you obviously are supposed to be here, otherwise you wouldn't be. Good work makes you deserve to be among others but it can't make you deserve to exist on the planet.
- BowBun 2y agoI think you can tease this out a bunch of ways. >where one side has a lot more power than the other side This is life, in its entirety. Even those who feel like they live a 'free' life should realize they depend on things like national security and access to healthcare, right? So the power dynamic there doesn't make sense to me, unless you're also constantly in fear of all these other systems falling apart. Humans have worked to earn money to live forever. There wouldn't be money to give to workers if there wasn't an imbalance to begin with. Even farmers sustaining their own land have to pay workers to harvest. > whether or not you worked "hard enough" is judged by other people This IMO is a personal failure. Others don't determine whether I'm satisfied with my work, I do. I'm proud of my work even if others don't care for it. > not the entity responsible for putting humans (and therefore you) on the planet in the first place--you're already here so you obviously are supposed to be here, otherwise you wouldn't be There is no entity responsible, just like there is no reason for 'being here'. Your parents are to thank for raising you, but it could have just as well been other parents or another child! Our lives are a gift we're lucky to experience and we should enjoy it to the fullest on our own terms. If work fulfills you, great. If it doesn't, then do something else. I really dislike people putting their value systems on others, especially around these kinds of topics. Telling people that what they think is valuable is in fact not is akin to telling people to believe in your faith, or how to raise their kids, etc. Edit: Also curious why you would create a throwaway for this kind of opinion.
- djoldman 2y ago> Employees, no matter what their job, crave recognition, autonomy, and a personal connection to work, which is why they often contribute more than they’re paid for. Baker’s point is that celebrating workers’ “proactivity” disguises an essentially exploitative relationship. The story of the modern Western economy is that all the low-hanging fruit has been plucked from the tree of technological and productivity improvements (in the context of the regulatory environment). Therefore, the proportion of profit and revenue rooted in exploiting human flaws is and will continue to rise. Examples are: * Humans engage with drama and negative content (ad supported media) * Humans overindex on a sense of family/belonging/tribe (employers as family extract more work for less pay) * Etc Perhaps the biggest is regulatory capture and exploitation of regulatory loopholes.
- narrator 2y agoThe irony of "higher" standards of living is that meanwhile, African countries, and a few strict islamic ones, have much less of all this and they're the only places reproducing at faster than replacement rate.
- const_cast 2y agoIt's just a human geography thing. Developed countries reproduce less because they provide greater autonomy to women. Underdeveloped or developing countries reproduce much more. Turns out if you give women a choice to have children, a lot of them will say no. They'd rather have career. Having children has, like, a lot of downsides. It can literally kill you.
- pas 2y agoThere's no magic number of people that we have to have. The fertility rate will continue to fluctuate depending on the circumstances. Currently the balance of incentives-disincentives regarding having kids in many places is simply favoring the "not" side. Having a smaller population with advanced automation technology is completely okay. And if a society feels it really values having more people around through births (and not through migration for example) they can alter policies to support families. (For example see how the child tax credits policy is not made permanent, also it's ridiculously small compared to cost of living and cost of child rearing. Then there's the cost of education, cost of having a bigger house, then there's the whole fucking problem of logistics, which is extremely costly in the US [because streets are not kid safe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43364761 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43364761 )
- _ywwk 2y ago[flagged]
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoI’m surprised that the author thinks devotion to vocation is uniquely American. The Japanese take their jobs so seriously, that some have committed suicide, upon losing their jobs. Some CEOs have committed suicide, if their business fails, or there’s a big scandal (an idea that I sometimes think could be useful on this side of the pond).
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 2y agoYou almost had me agreeing with you, but advocating for someone to kill themselves is way out of line.
- geysersam 2y agoI didn't interpret what they wrote as encouragement to suicide.
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoSuicide? No. Taking personal Accountability for the corporation under your direct management? Yes. P. S. I'll bet that the second one is the scariest one for most C-types.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- simpaticoder 2y agoListening to Cryptonomican 20 years after reading it. It is a curious embodiment of this "cult" but from a deeper, more epistemic place. The way Steaphenson treats the world, the way he describes it, is frenetic, packed with trivia and connections and ADHD deep-dives into related topics...but there is no heart to it. It's an empty, mechanistic view of the world, reducing almost every person a neat little network of abstractions, and then moving on. It is a strange book in that it seems to be a promotion of a narrative viewpoint rather than about the plot or characters. It is certainly the viewpoint of the "modern" tech entrepenuer, circa 1999. Somehow both extremely open minded AND judgemental; utterly unsentimental about anything, including the self; mere acceptence and wariness about indelible human needs. And so on. Word on the street is that Cryptonomicon was required reading at Thiel's early Palantir. I read it now and it definitely hits differently. To accept that you must dwell in something in order to understand it, and therefore in order to wield power over it with any wisdom, is the antithesis of "The Cult of Doing Business". The hubris is baked in deep at an epistemic level, which is demonstrated to lead to epic moral hazards at an epidemic level.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- anon_hn_pltr 2y agoIt definitely wasn't required reading. I have never met anyone who's read it or even mentioned it.
- fullshark 2y agoI heard that anecdote but it was at paypal/x, which makes more sense given the book's plot.
- FredPret 2y agoBut Stephenson describes things in this mechanistic, ADHD way. It’s just his technique - he still paints a picture of people with rich inner lives and strong desires. Maybe the characters’ sentiments (mostly pro-Western tech optimism) don’t resonate with you, but that hardly means they don’t have any.
- bgnn 2y agoThis isn't uniquely American, but obsession with wealth accumulation as an individual is. I don't think this applies to all Americans at all, but it is just mire commonly accepted than other cultures.
- ativzzz 2y agoWealth is freedom. One of the core tenets of Americanism is "freedom", in quotes because most of us are far from free, just different from "freedom" in monarchical/feudalistic societies. We are bound to the accumulation of wealth. However, some of us are able to break free. Software engineering for instance is a profession that allows this. It doesn't require the full commitment of your life to attain wealth, like finance or law or medicine for someone who has some intelligence and drive.
- yfw 2y agoThere is no freedom. Everyone lives on earth. Despite all the billionaires building bunkers might think otherwise. Microplastic pollution and global warming will kill everyone.
- bgnn 2y agoWealth providing freedom is not an objective fact. It depends on your philosophical standpoint. I know a lot of people who would rather live cheap and small and be creative (as in arts). What you describe is for them wasting your potential to create. In certain cultures a stable job (like being government employee) is the ultimate freedom because you know how will you live, even in your retirement, no matter what. Some cultures like Japan and Korea extended this to private sector. But at the end, is it really freedom what people seek, or is it stability and safety for future? This is why people gave away their freedom in transition to feudalism in history. At the end if the day, how free are you if you are from one economic downturn or one costly disease away from losing it all?
- xrhobo 2y agoIt is very deep in American culture. I think this sums it up when Tocqueville was talking about America not having a true aristocratic class, circa 1830s “In a democracy private citizens see a man of their own rank in life who becomes possessed of riches and power in a few years; this spectacle excites their surprise and envy, and they are led to inquire how the person who was yesterday very equal is today their ruler. ” ― Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America In 21st century America, the internet and social media has poured huge amounts of gas on this fire that was already burning quite hot for a long time. Even in my own lifetime, the character Gordon Gekko in the movie Wallstreet has gone from a villain to pretty much the aspiration and hero of most high school seniors. Greed is good, greed make number go up.
- jmogly 2y agoIt’s a crisis of faith, caused by a 10,000 year search for meaning that isn’t there. We had our first surplus as a species when we discovered agriculture and husbandry. The human mind has wandered since. We’ve built systems of belief, technological systems, political systems, every possible system you can imagine. All to deal with the simple fact that our minds feel like they should be doing something, but there isn’t actually anything that needs to be done; surplus. Since our first surplus all those years ago, we have continued to increase our surplus relentlessly. The problem is the more surplus we have, the more the mind idles, the more we try to invent things for the mind to do. That is where I see the cult, the cult consists of faithless wanderers who have decided that the only valid use of surplus is to gain more surplus, whether it’s through positive means like improving technology or business, or negative means like slavery and exploitation. It’s a hollow existence. There is a righteous path, it’s using our surplus to embrace the positive aspects of our spirit rather than the negative ones.
- bckr 2y agoI don’t have a lot of surplus. I hope to, I’m working towards it. I have the privilege, talent, and positioning. But I can’t understand how anyone just below me in the hierarchy making ends meet.
- jmogly 2y agoI think that is one of the most interesting take aways from this line of thought. It is nearly impossible to reconcile the idea that we as a species have unimaginable surplus, but nearly all of us feel we are living precariously on the edge of ruin, or are living in destitute poverty. There is plenty to go around, but because the worst parts of human nature have triumphed the good, we are forced to live in an incredibly inequitable distribution. Rather than build a system that works for everyone in an altruistic manner, we have a system that funnels surplus to our most sycophantic, manipulative, exploitative, brutal members. It might just be human nature, our worst instincts tend to beat our best instincts.
- keybored 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- moshegramovsky 2y agoI have run into many of these types over the years. It's amazing to watch them run up their ladder of manipulative tactics until they realize that they aren't going to get what they want. Then you see who they really are. The whole problem is that being genuine matters. The best boss I ever had never tried to be charismatic. He was a good listener, he was fair, and he took us seriously. The Naploean Hill/Dale Carnegie types make my skin crawl.
- greenie_beans 2y ago21st century version is naval's twitter thread about becoming rich and paul graham's blog and tim ferris's 4 hour work week. i call it "microfeudalism", a riff on technofedualism and microcelebrities
- rubitxxx 2y ago> But it’s even better to treat love itself as the most important work. While Maslow's hierarchy of needs help us understand motivation, this is the most true.
- CrulesAll 2y agoStrip him of his tenure, and let's see if love pays the rent.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoIf you’re ever unable to pay the rent it will most likely be bonds of love that keep you alive.
- CrulesAll 2y agoAuthor is an arts graduate. General Patton warned against such historians. It is why he recommended autobiographies rather than biographies. The words of Caesar rather than the words written about Caesar. You also delegate your agency to critique. Patton took the good of Napoleon and savaged the bad. To paraphrase Patton, it's a type of tall poppy syndrome. The historian lacks the skills, talent, and mindset that causes men and women who achieve success in the real world. They resent those who remind them of what they lack. Because of his tenured position, he wants for nothing while, outside of STEM, contributes very little. He is wholly reliant on the types of men and women he bashes. It's the dilettante who mocks the farmer as he eats the farmer's food. Reminds of the critique of self righteous pacifists during the World Way 2(Godwin violation. Apologies.) "How easy it is to be a pacifist safe and secure behind the security of the American Navy's big guns." How easy it is to mock entrepreneurs, capitalism, and strivers when they permit your standard of living and very existence.
- pessimizer 2y agoHow easy it is to mock Stalin's USSR from behind the tanks of the Red Army, I think you mean. The USSR won WWII. So now I think you have to become Communist, or at least get a degree in Marxist-Leninist political theory, in order to comment on WWII.
- CrulesAll 2y agoNo one was allowed mock Stalin, comrade. In socialist society, you will be told what you mean. The USSR won WW2 with no air force. I can't recall the USSR's long range bombing of Tokyo nor Berlin which is odd because that would kind of be essential to such an argument. Destroying the industrial heartland seems kind of important, comrade. Nor do I recall the great victories at sea? Stalin had no aircraft carriers. Again quite strange. They won WW2 without a de facto air force or Navy. They also seemed to limp into Berlin with horse and carts. Which again is odd because you said they were victorious. It's even odder when Patton said he could be in Moscow within a week. Probably capitalist lies, comrade, and not real socialism.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mlsu 2y agoKeep your own house. I like working, I’m not quite sure what I would do otherwise. It is perfectly acceptable to have genuine relationships with your coworkers, employees, and customers, but “genuine” is the key. What’s bad for you is not work, but lying and trying to pull a fast one on everyone around you. Work, family, and a little leisure. Those are the three pillars. This hasn’t changed since we grew a brain stem, it comes far before language or farming.
- ranprieur 2y agoThis all makes more sense if you go through the article, and every time you see the word "work", substitute "work for money".
- ashoeafoot 2y agoIts because buisness escaping control forms a "nature" complete with behemoth out crowding the smaller critters, destroying the ecosystems that fed them, plagues and forrest fires. The state if it exist is a park if its not, its a dark forest. Worshipping this is just nature whorship redecorated.
- akomtu 2y ago> One of the strangest features of American work culture is the constant pressure to treat one’s job as something more than a job: a calling, a means of expressing oneself, a vehicle for personal growth. This pressure comes from bosses <...> The idea behind this - expressing oneself - isn't American. When ideas like that come to this world, they come to many nations at the same time, the greatest minds pick them up and create their own interpretation, based on local culture and their beliefs. Some of those great minds see the great ideas well and express them cleanly. Others distort the ideas with their egos and sometimes even add poison, creating intentionally misleading interpretations. The idea that you need to express yourself, find a calling that's bigger than you, is true and spiritual in nature. It draws attention to a core aspect of what we are. However some of the great minds are also selfish: they are able to see this idea, they recognize it as an important and powerful truth, but then they find a way to distort it for personal gain. So they create a thin lie around this truth: that you need to express yourself thru work for self at the expense of others, because that's the only way to survive and thrive in this world of scarcity. Most people will be fooled because this lie is an artwork of minds far greater than them. So the common folk embrace this false interpretation and start living according to it.
- imgabe 2y agoA weird thing to be coming from an academic, which has 10x the cult of “make your work your entire identity” that corporate America ever did. But they don’t make any money doing it so I guess that’s why it’s ok?
- pas 2y agoIf you get tenure you make pretty good money, no? (Which is the academia equivalent of IPO, or successful exit, or that mythical first one million.) Also the message can still be very true even if it comes from a messenger you don't like.
- imgabe 2y agoIt's not just not liking the messenger. It's questioning the sincerity of their message when they don't practice it themselves.