3 ms·
Regarding the Thunderscope project, I wonder if it would be feasible one day to have a scope that can sample USB3 signals. (Actually, a device that can measure
by amelius 2y ago
Regarding the Thunderscope project, I wonder if it would be feasible one day to have a scope that can sample USB3 signals.
(Actually, a device that can measure bit error rates would be great too).
- Mbwagava 2y agoTbh, I am surprised this isn't possible. One would assume sampling a signal is the fundamental property of working with hardware.
- crote 2y agoA device communicating over USB3 has to sample once per symbol period, with a 1-bit frequency. Most of the hard stuff is offloaded to purpose-designed silicon, so that 5Gsps analog signal is quickly turned into, say, a 128-bit bus running at 39MHz. That's fairly easy to deal with - especially because most of it is either directly processed and forwarded (like webcams), or has some form of flow control (hard drives). If you're diagnosing signal quality you're going to want to look at the analog signals, which means sampling at a rate significantly faster than the baud rate, and at a 8-bit or higher resolution to actually see analog behaviour. Suddenly you're dealing with 400Gbps of incoming sampling data - and you have to do realtime analysis on that to trigger at the right time, and be capable of storing at least a few tens of thousands of samples for display.
- XorNot 2y agoWhen being able to do this cheaply for 1G Ethernet would be incredibly useful.
- crote 2y agoThat should already be possible with hobbyist-level equipment, no? 1000BASE-T has a bandwidth of 62.5MHz and communicates at 125 megabaud. Something like the $500 Siglent SDS804X HD should be capable of handling that.
- LiamPowell 2y agoI assume you mean decoding as sampling is just a matter of bandwidth. There are already decoders for USB 3: https://www.keysight.com/au/en/product/D9010USBP/usb-3-x-protocol-decode-trigger-software-usb-3-2-5-10-gbps.html https://www.keysight.com/au/en/product/D9010USBP/usb-3-x-pro...
- amelius 2y ago"just" :) Yes, I mean sampling. I want to see the eye-diagrams preferably, using a DIY device. It should be possible, perhaps using delay-lines (as now on the HN frontpage). Also, if a device like this exists, then maybe someone can write an open-source tool to compute the bit-error-rate from digital inputs. Or write some Wireshark extension to do decoding of raw signals. This Keysight company makes nice tools but they are out of reach of hobbyists and small companies, and cheaper tools should be possible since we're all having USB3 devices in our computers already (digital ones, ok).
- tverbeure 2y agoFor eye diagrams, you can make do with a sampling oscilloscope instead of a regular single-shot oscilloscope. My favorite presentation at Hackaday Supercon 2019 was this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=99u53V7uDFY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=99u53V7uDFY. Unfortunately, the author burned out on it and project is dead. But the presentation is still worth watching.