7 ms·
Amazon denies tariff pricing plan after White House calls it "hostile/political"
- j4coh 2y agoWouldn’t hiding it also be political? Seems being transparent is closer to behaving neutrally to me.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoNeutral behavior is not desired. The admin desires to take unilateral, unchecked action without repercussions, while controlling the narrative. Enact tariffs while publicly stating "everything is fine." "Why are you making us look bad by sharing the facts of the actions we're taking?" is how you can think of this. Never assume rational and good faith behavior from bad faith actors. Watch what someone does, not what they say. The words are free and meaningless.
- staticautomatic 2y ago100% you’re either a militant conformist or an enemy.
- j4coh 2y agoAmazon has now backed down and will hide them, so it seems the strategy works.
- protimewaster 2y agoThat's what I would think. Though, as other users have pointed out, Amazon is being selective about what what they show. If they really wanted to be transparent and neutral, they'd need to show everything that makes up the price (how much the seller/manufacturer gets paid, what Amazon's cut is, how much goes to the payment processor, etc.) Personally, I think it would be pretty great if they showed all that, but I don't see that ever happening.
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoIsn't this different? This tariff isn't a seller's cut, it's a tax, and when I look at my Amazon invoice I see the taxes I paid.
- protimewaster 2y agoYeah, I agree it's different, but it's all selective transparency. They're willing to be transparent about things they can directly blame on the government (tax, tariffs) but not other things that influence the price (Amazon's markup, the payment processing charges). It would be better if they showed all of that, IMO.
- Analemma_ 2y agoNo, that's not the same thing. Tariffs are taxes collected by customs agents (no matter how much this administration wants to pretend they aren't), and taxes already show up as itemized additions to your receipt, unlike margins and seller fees.
- protimewaster 2y agoTo me that just means they're already doing selective transparency. They treat government influences on price as different than other factors that influence the price.
- j4coh 2y agoEvery receipt I’ve ever gotten in my life has separated tax, and I don’t recall I’ve ever seen seller margins or anything like that on a receipt before.
- protimewaster 2y agoYeah, I'm not saying Amazon is the only one doing this. But I am saying that if they're saying that consumers deserve transparency, this just scratches the surface.
- zasz 2y agoWell, in the literal sense it would be neutral to be transparent, but "political" in the sense that the White House is using means "you're being mean to me."
- mingus88 2y agoIt’s such bare hypocrisy, but it’s just another reminder that they have no actual beliefs aside from power, so everything they do or say is fair game.
- danaris 2y agoThere is no neutrality. No, seriously: "political neutrality" as a concept is inherently and fatally flawed. The closest you can ever attempt to come is either a) maintain/support the current status quo—this is obviously a big problem for anyone the status quo is not serving b) tailor whatever you're saying/doing to try to cleave to the exact current center of the political landscape—this is obviously going to be very fraught and highly subjective; no one actually does this Anyone who says they're "apolitical" or who tells you to make something "politically neutral" is nearly guaranteed to be just a beneficiary of the status quo advocating for preserving it, often without even realizing that's what they're doing. Ultimately, it's much more honest and positive in the long run to be honest about your own biases and, yes, be as transparent as possible.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoThis is false. Or at least it's almost totally false. I can try to judge things by whether they are true or false, accurate or misleading, good or bad ideas, regardless of who said them. Yeah, I fail sometimes - partly because I do have biases, and partly because I don't have infinite amounts of time and energy to dig in to find out the truth. Still, I don't judge what the administration says by which brand of administration it is. I prefer my news sources to be straight rather than slanted. And I can say that without being a supporter of the current status quo. I find Trump's bullying to be reprehensible.
- toofy 2y agointeresting, out of curiosity did this lead you to not see his bullying and behaviors coming? did this lead you to deny yourself the bigger picture of past behaviors, context, etc…?
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoWhat have I said that made you think that I ever supported Trump? I didn't, ever. What made you think that I was blind to what he was? I could tell what he was before he was elected the first time.
- duxup 2y agoThe state of the American GoP is absurd. Everything is political to them, the Republican party are the ultimate "snowflakes". Science, basic facts, a minority or woman on some military website, pricing on your website ... I'm drinking coffee right now, that's probably offensive to them in some way.
- croisillon 2y ago[flagged]
- jb1991 2y agoIf those coffee beans weren’t grown in the United States, well then yes it is offensive to them.
- duxup 2y agoAs far as tariff policy goes it would seem that way, although I kinda suspect as far as the Administration is concerned, they don't "really" care. I doubt there's as much ideology behind their actions as it would seem.
- mingus88 2y agoIt would be wild to see Kona coffee suddenly become as affordable as the rest of what Americans drink every day And then the supply runs out, Kona prices shoot up further, and boom, America is great again or something
- ineedasername 2y agoAt its core, I think it comes down to the language of morality that’s used. Differences aren’t framed as disagreements, but often as deliberate attacks for their own sake. It goes further: the language often doesn’t just describe policies as harmful, but conveys them as evil or immoral, either directly or by implication. This makes compromise almost impossible. In normal negotiation, sides might trade policy priorities—accepting cuts in one area to strengthen another. But when every issue is framed this way it’s no longer a deal making compromise. It’s compromising, moral values. This is then especially a problem in primary races where a challenger can attack any and all bipartisanship as absolute failure.
- aurareturn 2y agoWhite House should be furious. This definitely makes the Trump Administration look bad since it's a separate price added onto the final price. There are 180.1 million Amazon Prime US subscribers. This means potentially 180 million Americans will see the tariff effects directly. Not counting total US Amazon shoppers due to lack of numbers. Edit: people are downvoting me because of the first sentence. All I’m saying is that if I’m the Whitehouse, I’d be furious too. I never said I think the tariffs are a good idea.
- mcmcmc 2y agoFurious at themselves maybe, this is entirely their own fault.
- Tagbert 2y agoWhat is wrong with displaying this? It is an additional tax added to products, very much like sales tax. It is entirely appropriate to display taxes and similar fees on an invoice. It would be disingenuous to hide it.
- xingped 2y agoHe's not saying it's wrong, just that it's expected for the white house to be mad for being called out. (Not that it's reasonable, but just expected.)
- gryfft 2y agoI think people are reading an implication of "would be justified and righteous" into the use of the word "should" in the phrase "the White House should be furious" in the GP comment.
- aurareturn 2y agoYes, this is correct. Amazon showing tariff surcharge is a huge deal to Trump's approval rating due to the fact that 180m Americans subscribe to Prime, which means many people will directly see the effect of the tariffs. But I think people got too angry too fast to understand my point.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoHostile and political? Probably. It's also telling people the truth about how much Trump's policies are costing them, or at least costing them on those particular purchases. This is self-defense by Amazon. "Don't blame us that things got more expensive." But yes, it's also political (that's kind of inevitable when politics is the source of the additional cost).
- bslanej 2y ago[flagged]
- formerly_proven 2y agoInflation isn’t a tax…
- bslanej 2y agoThe same result for the average poor sap, the only difference is who’s pocketing that price increase.
- echoangle 2y agoAnd you think the seller is pocketing inflation price increases? If you're really talking about inflation, there's nothing to pocket, because the profit after increasing the prices has the same buying power. And every other price increase is not related to inflation.
- blitzar 2y agoI am sure they would be happy to give back their salary increases as well.
- Tagbert 2y agoInflation is a systemic issue that cannot be specifically identified. A tax is a deliberate fee that is distinct from the actual cost of items. Not showing the cost of tariffs would be a deliberate attempt to hide the price of that tax.
- someothherguyy 2y agoIt can function or be utilized as such. For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seigniorage#Seigniorage_as_a_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seigniorage#Seigniorage_as_a_t...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- roman_soldier 2y agoIt is hostile and political, do they break down their prices for other added costs, i.e. inflation, higher taxes? Never seen it before, so why do it here then.
- 34679 2y agoYes, they do. Taxes and shipping are separate line items on every Amazon invoice.
- SirMaster 2y agoMaybe I am missing something but sales tax is something that the seller pays. It's a % of the retail price and so they collect it from the customer, so it's added in and shown to the customer. Tariffs are paid by the importer and I would think that they would put that into the price of the good itself based on their desired profit margins etc. How would Amazon even know what to put for the tariff amount? It's not a % of the retail price, it's a % of the import price which the seller doesn't typically share with the end customer.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y ago"What it costs now" - "What it cost in March" = "Tariff cost" The math is not perfect, but to a good approximation (certainly a far better approximation than the administration's insane computation of international "tariffs") that will indicate the cost to the consumer of Trump's tariff policies. So yes, if the importer eats a significant chunk of the tariff cost and doesn't pass it on to Amazon/the consumer, the computation will reflect that (as it should). And if they don't, it will reflect that too (as it should).
- roman_soldier 2y agoHave they shown tariffs before on their prices?, I don't think the US had zero tariffs before Trump increased them
- zzzeek 2y agoHow long before the White House makes a "deal" with Amazon that somehow shields Amazon specifically from tariffs affecting their prices in exchange for removing the display; just shoveling US taxpayer money at them (after all we're saving billions that we used to spend on things like cancer research). Then we'd be at a place where Amazon's prices end up being dramatically lower than every other seller in the US, further entrenching their monopoly status, and taxpayers would actually be footing the bill. Talk about picking winners and losers...
- malfist 2y agoYou'd think Amazon's $40M bribe, I mean "Melania documentary" would be enough to get them a pass
- lucasyvas 2y agoPrice transparency != “hostile and political” Typical gaslighting behaviour. If you have as many customers as Amazon and the price increases that noticeably, that’s them being by forced to cover their own ass versus taking the heat when they shouldn’t.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Zak 2y agoI've seen gas pumps that prominently enumerate all the taxes included in the price, which were more than 50% in some European countries. It's a bit political for a business to call attention to otherwise-hidden taxes in the prices of its products, but both rational and fair.
- EvanAnderson 2y agoOhio has those stickers, mandated by law (2017 Ohio Fuel Tax Transparency Act). A Republican legislature passed the law, signed by a Republican governor.
- duxup 2y agoRepublicans used to have some semblance of ideology that you could kinda count on them sticking to occasionally... ish. That's all gone now. It doesn't even matter what they said 5 minutes ago, hate big tech?, next thing you know they hand big tech the purse strings of government.
- mingus88 2y agoTheir ideology is power. The writing has been on the wall demographically for decades. Their base has been shrinking, fewer people are religious, white folk are losing status. It’s become harder and harder to win an election for turn since GW Bush, and even that went down to the courts. Many districts are only red due to blatant gerrymandering. But even that gets harder to wield so what seems to have happened is that while they still can ostensibly win an election, they crank the wheel and destroy the rules so that they never have to compete on a level field again
- joquarky 2y agoOne of their biggest ideologies fell apart when the 2008 financial crisis occurred. The Tea Party picked up the remnants and spiraled.
- jeroenhd 2y agoI think including the taxes on fuel would be good, as it'd show people the ridiculous amount of money they're paying to maintain the infrastructure their cars use (though fuel taxes often don't come close to covering road maintenance). Such a system could get complicated quickly, though, and showing the profit margin also wouldn't be of interest to many salespeople. Making fuel price total up to €2.09/L is easy if petrol were only taxed at €0.7891/L, but the 21% VAT being applied to the total sales price after the per liter tax (and the 9% profit margin) makes the math a tad more complex. I don't think you could call those taxes "hidden" though. Anyone can look up how much tax they pay. It's not like taxes are sent out in secret to gas pumps every day.
- addoo 2y agoThis is political, so are the tariffs. It’s the same cat and mouse game with local/state regulations on restaurant staff compensation and ‘service fees.’ No love for Amazon in general, they’ve been gaming the system for a long time, but it’s not hard to see why they would do this. Prices will go up, this an easy way to deflect the blame (and to be fair… it’s an accurate deflection).
- whatshisface 2y agoThe tarrifs are an exception from the normal rules about keeping politics out of things, because they're non-toxified by partisan culture war. They came so far out of left field that nobody was pre-trained to interpret criticism of them as an attack on their identity.
- bertramus 2y agoAs an environmentalist, I am generally in favor of gasoline tax to pay for road maintenance. Without getting into the nuance of that position - I do not disagree with the fact that gas stations in my area break down the added cost per gallon into federal, state, and local tax per gallon. In fact I support it, transparency is important.
- seydor 2y agoI mean aren't tarrifs hostile and political? This has been stated by officials multiple times.
- Eextra953 2y agoOne thing I can't stand about the current administration is just how much they resemble a schoolyard bully. It's never their fault, they are always the victim, and they cry their actions have repercussions. Why is it hostile and political to display the tarriffs to the consumer? Can you imagine how ridiculous it would be if a local politician introduced a new sales tax and then got mad at the businesses for showing the new tax to consumers?
- esafak 2y ago[flagged]
- sjsdaiuasgdia 2y agoThis is pointless equivocation. Trump is turning all the dials up to 11 and that does actually make a difference. Some administrations / governments using bully tactics some of the time does not mean we can't call out one that uses bully tactics all of the time at high intensity and without concern for the broader impacts.
- mingus88 2y agoI don’t really care who wrote the playbook. I care who is using it.
- Zamaamiro 2y agoWhen was the last time the White House spokesperson for a different administration publicly called the free market actions of a private company "hostile"?
- kgwxd 2y agoI'm sure an example, or something like it, could easily be found to make a whatabout argument. The INSANE difference, in both volume and degree, of "comparable" things is the fact they'll never accept. They'll just double down. It's a death spiral.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Zamaamiro 2y agoYet another attack on freedom of speech and the rest of our civil liberties by the current administration.
- blitzar 2y agoI fear free speech is in retreat
- ErikAugust 2y agoThe White House calling somebody "hostile and political". Hmph.
- relaxing 2y agoEvery accusation is an admission for them.
- davidw 2y agoI wonder if they're going to start fiddling with official statistics to show 'good' numbers for things like inflation or employment.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- drooopy 2y agoThe party of small government and deregulation sure likes to to have the government regulate how private businesses and citizens should behave.
- yencabulator 2y agoThe party of free speech for those who agree with me. The party of law and order for those I do not pardon.
- jeroenhd 2y agoI think there's more to this than Amazon being annoyed at the stupid taxes raised on imported goods. Same with price labels on items with and excluding tax; people just like the lower numbers better, and stores that don't show low numbers will lose customers even if they operate at the same price point. Studies have shown that consumers will gladly visit restaurants that don't include tips in their prices over restaurants that do, even when the prices are exactly the same. In a country used to not seeing the total price on store goods, hiding the tariffs away as a "+145% tariff" label makes perfect sense. Just raising the total cost and hiding the tariff, what the American governments probably would prefer, would put Amazon at a disadvantage against other stores that do show the split. On another note, Apple got very upset at Facebook when they tried to pull the same trick regarding the 30% Apple tax. In that case, Apple forbade Facebook from making it explicit how much of the transaction was a tariff raised by an external party. Same trick, but different outcome (because Apple can force Facebook's hand).
- bertramus 2y agoIf we want capitalism to work at its best, the masses of decision makers that power the invisible hand require as much information as possible. I'm definitely not a fan of government using politics to obfuscate economic details of a tax, but I am also very much not a fan of captive market makers, like Apple, Google, or Visa, being able to unilaterally and forcibly bury this information. Prohibiting retailers from offering a different cash price (Visa/MC) or preventing app owners from charging 30% more than they do on their own website to cover the marketplace costs (or preventing them from allowing the app to funnel them elsewhere for subscriptions that span much farther than the app alone) are all the dark, informationless side of capitalism.
- TrackerFF 2y agoAliExpress, Temu, Shein, etc. should slap a "I did that!" Trump-sticker on their checkout page. Dunno, something like this: https://imgur.com/a/Z2hmyou https://imgur.com/a/Z2hmyou
- snvzz 2y agoIt would make some sense if they shown tariffs everywhere, not just in the US. As long as they pretend the US is the sole country that does tariffs, it is both political and an insult to intelligence.
- trebor 2y agoIgnoring tariffs for the moment... No one should be shocked that Amazon would do this. Remember back when it was controversial to apply sales tax to online shopping? The biggest lobbyist against it was Amazon, which they marketed as fighting for the market against the government. Then they got big enough to survive a reversal ... and swung the other way to weaponize the law against their smaller competitors. They've done a lot more than this, including creating their own brands to inject into a successful niche product or segment. They did all that off of sales/product data they aggregated from all sales on their platform. Amazon is a dirty player in the market, and everyone should remember that.
- Tagbert 2y agoThis is not really a related issue other than "tax". Amazon's policy around applying sales taxes is just a distraction for this issue.
- AlecSchueler 2y agoBut previously it also seemed like Amazon leadership was cosy with the administration.
- m463 2y ago> controversial to apply sales tax to online shopping You know, they had a point though. California wanted a washington corporation to collect taxes for it. They could not fight it because they were in another state. It struck me as basically "no taxation without representation".
- danielvf 2y agoI see a lot of comments here and in the other thread talking about Amazon's high profits on retail sales, so I looked up the last earnings report. For the year of 2024, Amazon made a 5.5% operating profit on non-AWS revenue. This is before taxes and, I think, before leases on buildings and property. https://s2.q4cdn.com/299287126/files/doc_financials/2024/q4/AMZN-Q4-2024-Earnings-Release.pdf https://s2.q4cdn.com/299287126/files/doc_financials/2024/q4/...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43831027 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43831027
- ImJamal 2y agoAre they only doing this in the US? If so that seems blatantly political.
- kmeisthax 2y ago> Why didn't Amazon do this when the Biden administration hiked inflation to the highest level in 40 years? Because the inflation under Biden was itself an accident. Trump is doing this on purpose. Furthermore, if you buy the idea that the inflation was caused solely by handing out stimulus checks during a pandemic, then it's at least partially Trump's fault, too. Remember that Trump's the one who pushed for all this stimulus, because he was worried about his re-election prospects in 2020. If you want a real criticism of this policy, it's that Bezos was spending $$$ to be at the Trump inauguration just a few months ago. Big Tech put their muscle behind Trump despite being the industry most reliant on foreign immigration and trade - the things Trump desperately wants to shut down. They did this because they're so shit scared of antitrust legislation that they're willing to break up America before America can break up them. Of course, it turns out Amazon needs a host country to survive after all, and Bezos didn't realize this. So instead of owning a broken-up business empire he's going to own no empire at all. Welcome to the bust-out.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y ago> Of course, it turns out Amazon needs a host country to survive after all It this is true (it might be, it might not be), there's no particular reason why it needs to be the USA. Bezos and the current management structure and employees of Amazon in the USA might prefer if it was that way, but there's little about the company that requires it, other than its biggest market also being the USA. Also: Bezos doesn't really own Amazon any more in any meaningful sense. He owns less than 10% of the stock.
- kmeisthax 2y agoI'll give you that Bezos is mostly gone from Amazon. However, Amazon does need to be in the USA, even if it's not their host country, because they're a retailer. They make their money by buying goods and selling them to the people who want them. Remember when Amazon used to only have one warehouse in one state, and relied on being able to ship things to get around sales tax? That didn't last - and not just because the law caught up with the loophole. They wanted to do next-day or same-day shipping that basically required them to have a warehouse in every city, and thus pay sales tax everywhere. Amazon moving out of the US would make them equivalent to Temu or Wish in terms of convenience, and their sales would crater. Not to mention Trump is closing off the loophole those companies used, too.
- SirMaster 2y agoTariffs are on the import cost. Wouldn't putting this tariff display in, and the customer knowing what the tariff % is leak the import cost to the end customer? Typically you don't share what that internal cost is with the end customer. Sales tax is different because it's on the retail price that the customer pays.
- icameron 2y agoWhite House should change their perspective: “Amazon changes pricing information to promote zero tariff USA Made products by highlighting products with no markup”
- Mr_Eri_Atlov 2y agoThe truth is often hostile to idiots and charlatans
- kevincrane 2y agoIf tariffs are so good, they should be happy that Amazon is doing free advertising of them on the Trump administration’s behalf. Why do they seem upset that people would know about the tariffs they’re so proud of? Such a mystery
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y agoAmazon has now retracted the "policy" https://www.eschatonblog.com/2025/04/cant-make-dumb-joke-anymore.html https://www.eschatonblog.com/2025/04/cant-make-dumb-joke-any... https://x.com/JStein_WaPo/status/1917221012560637966 https://x.com/JStein_WaPo/status/1917221012560637966
- rsanek 2y agotitle now doesn't match what the article says -- this was never implemented
- bananapub 2y agothe cry-baby-ness of the US Far Right is really something to behold. they seized control of the federal government and are now looting it and pushing all their deeply stupid hobby horses, but still they can't stop whinging about people merely noting what stupid stuff they're doing. wah wah wah. if you don't won't people calculating the costs of your tariffs, perhaps don't introduce the world's worst tariff regime?
- JohnTHaller 2y agoEveryone should include a line item to display the cost of the tariffs to the American consumer.
- bradlys 2y agoWhile senseless politics like this are going on that every person on HN is libbing out over - houses continue to be unaffordable, no universal healthcare, and wages will continue to stagnate compared to costs. Y’all are blind as hell to the real issues. This football version of American politics is so nonsensical. Not an ounce of material analysis even in something that could be as material as this.
- yongjik 2y agoIf White House enacted a different tax to, say, fund more highways, and Amazon decided to display that, then that might be a different matter. But this is tariffs. Tariffs work by making imported goods more expensive, which makes them less attractive to consumers, which makes domestic goods more attractive in comparison. That's the whole fucking point of tariffs. To make imported goods more expensive. Amazon is essentially running a free advertisement for White House, showing off how Trump's tariffs are doing their job! Exactly what else did Trump supporters expect to happen? Ponies and rainbows? Well, probably not rainbows - it's gay.
- urup2l8 2y agoConservatism is the fear of everything: change, new ideas, people that don’t look like us, education, science, the list goes on and on... Why do you think they love their guns so much? They are scared. You can’t go back to “the good ol’ days” because THEY’RE GONE!
- joshuamerrill 2y agoAmazon has every incentive to show tariff rates to the customer. They don't want to be the bad guy overcharging in the transaction. Neither do local merchants when they collect a sales tax. Neither does the homeowner when they rent their guest room on Airbnb. Neither does Lady Gaga when she sells a ticket through Ticketmaster. This isn't controversial. It's price transparency for the consumer and it helps them make better choices. What's unusual is the White House attacking a private sector retailer for a reasonable choice that's clearly theirs to make. Seeing the "+145% tariff" on your checkout page would puncture a hole in the narrative we've heard for years from Donald Trump that "China pays the tax." No, you and I pay the tax. And both the U.S. and China will suffer. Facts are stubborn things.
- megamike 2y agoThe media, from the WSJ to the NY Times, across the political spectrum, the blogosphere, the social media, ALL of them have been LYING to Americans about the tariffs from day one, bombarding them with bullshit and lies and braindead idiocies, ceaselessly fearmongering, every day all day long, in their efforts to sacrifice everything, including the entire US economy, at the altar of high stock prices, fat corporate profit margins, and one-sided globalization. I have never seen anything like that. No wonder everyone is in a sour mood and all the soft data is shitty. But there is an economic reality out there: businesses trying to make their businesses work, and consumers making records amounts of money and spending it, and having fun.https://wolfstreet.com/2025/04/29/despite-all-moaning-and-groaning-layoffs-discharges-plunge-hires-voluntary-quits-rise-driven-by-private-sector-strength/#comments https://wolfstreet.com/2025/04/29/despite-all-moaning-and-gr...
- apercu 2y agoThe white house and this incompetent cabinet and the GOP enablers are the hostile party here.