4 ms·
This will be interesting for the 5th amendment. They cannot arrest you for putting "drug dealer" on your tax forms as your job since you are compelled to answer
by bluGill 2y ago
This will be interesting for the 5th amendment. They cannot arrest you for putting "drug dealer" on your tax forms as your job since you are compelled to answer that question honestly. The defendant was compelled to appear in court which means he couldn't protect his own privacy by being elsewhere - are these the same thing?
I don't know how courts will see it, but it is an interesting legal question that I hope some lawyers run with.
- zdragnar 2y agoThey cannot use your tax forms as evidence against you, but if there is a warrant for your arrest, they can arrest you wherever they find you. If there's a warrant for my arrest on suspicion of murder and I show up to court to argue a traffic ticket, of course they'll take me in on the murder charge too.
- nashashmi 2y agoDo you know if an arrest warrant was issued? I don’t think ICE works on warrants
- prepend 2y agoICE works on “administrative warrants” that are different than “judicial warrants” [0] I didn’t know the difference until today when I was reading about the case. I think the difference is the ice warrants are like detention orders and are different than a judge’s arrest warrant that grants a lot more power. [0] https://www.jsonline.com/story/news/local/2025/04/23/what-is-the-difference-between-ice-administrative-judicial-warrants/83219950007/ https://www.jsonline.com/story/news/local/2025/04/23/what-is...
- ggreer 2y agoYes, an arrest warrant was issued. From the complaint[1]: > On or about April 17, 2025, an authorized immigration official found probable cause to believe Flores-Ruiz was removable from the United States and issued a warrant for his arrest. The warrant provided, “YOU ARE COMMANDED to arrest and take into custody for removal proceedings under the Immigration and Nationality Act, the above-named alien [Flores-Ruiz identified on warrant].” Upon his arrest, Flores-Ruiz would be given a Notice of Intent/Decision to Reinstate Prior Order. He would then have an opportunity to contest the determination by making a written or oral statement to an immigration officer. He'd been deported in 2013 and snuck back in some time later. He was in Milwaukee county court that day because he'd been charged with three counts of domestic battery. 1. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.wied.111629/gov.uscourts.wied.111629.1.0.pdf https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.wied.11...
- perihelions 2y ago- "They cannot use your tax forms as evidence against you," That's no longer true (in practice), https://apnews.com/article/irs-ice-immigration-enforcement-trump-d2ac6f7ac0a1f60e907cd3b52d0db34d https://apnews.com/article/irs-ice-immigration-enforcement-t... ("IRS acting commissioner is resigning over deal to send immigrants’ tax data to ICE, AP sources say")
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y ago>They cannot arrest you for putting "drug dealer" on your tax forms as your job since you are compelled to answer that question honestly. They recently forced their way to into IRS records, so that is no longer true either.
- nashashmi 2y agoBut they wanted to get intel on suspected illegals. They just cannot use the data provided to the IRS as evidence. They have to get separate evidence.
- saalweachter 2y agoSeparate evidence for ...?
- nashashmi 2y agoevidence of crime separate than what is obtained via compulsion of circumstances.
- saalweachter 2y agoWhat do you need the evidence for, I mean?
- nashashmi 2y agoCriminal prosecution
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoThis is not normal/acceptable in the US. I remember when parallel construction was thought of as a horrible/unacceptable violation of the Constitution in the US. Now the 'Constitution' party doesn't give AF and loves it. It's crazy how far we let slippery slopes take us. All because of convenience or 'it's not that big of a deal yet'.
- staticman2 2y agoI'm not sure if this is intended to be a hypothetical but there is no IRS form where "Drug Dealer" is the correct answer. Drug dealing income would be disclosed as "Other income". If you volunteer "drug dealer" my guess is they could use it against you. Similar to showing up at FBI headquarters and shouting "I'm a drug dealer!"
- toast0 2y ago> I'm not sure if this is intended to be a hypothetical but there is no IRS form where "Drug Dealer" is the correct answer. What else would you put in the Occupation field at the end of the form?
- staticman2 2y agoMerchant? Salesman? Deliveries? Distributor? Client services? Sales? That field isn't actually used for anything other than determining if you are eligible for tax breaks like the school teacher deductable.
- jandrese 2y agoIndependent salesman.
- rjbwork 2y agoIndependent Pharmaceutical Sales Consultant
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- amacbride 2y agoImport/Export Specialist
- zepton 2y agoSchedule C to Form 1040 (self-employment income) asks for your "Principal business or profession, including product or service". It's pretty clear that the only correct answer for some people would be something like "drug dealer".
- whats_a_quasar 2y agoThis doesn't really have any fifth amendment implications. The prohibition against self incrimination reads "no person ... shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself." That doesn't relate to being compelled to attend a proceeding in person where another federal agency can arrest you. If the government can legally arrest you, it does not matter if they determine your location based on another proceeding.
- jibal 2y agoYour comment has no connection at all with this case.
- sanderjd 2y agoThe thesis is that immigrants have no constitutional rights because they aren't citizens, or the stronger form, that they are invaders and thus enemy combatants. The Supreme Court is going to have to clarify the existence or non-existence of constitutional rights for people living here unlawfully. And then the populace is going to have to make sure that the president doesn't conclude that he can ignore that ruling if he doesn't like it.
- Aeolun 2y agoOn that basis tourists have no constitutional rights either. I find it hard to believe anyone would want to visit the US now, but surely that has an even further chilling effect.
- sanderjd 2y agoTo be clear, I agree. It's a dangerous thesis, but also just idiotic. They're doing a speed run of turning the US into North Korea, where nobody will want to travel here or trade with us.
- axus 2y agoAxios was keeping a list, but I guess there's too many to keep track recently: https://www.axios.com/2025/03/20/tourists-us-residents-detained-arrested-deported-ice-immigration-trump https://www.axios.com/2025/03/20/tourists-us-residents-detai...
- ClumsyPilot 2y agoIs that a serious thesis anyone serious is entertaining ? Would that mean that you can defraud or kill a tourist with no consequences?
- const_cast 2y agoIt's serious in that it's the primary reasoning the Trump administration is using for the lack of due process.
- 2y ago