5 ms·
A study of lightning fatalities inside buildings while using smartphones [pdf] (2024)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mike-the-mikado 2y agoIn all cases, the phone was charging at the time.
- LinuxAmbulance 2y agoTL;DR: Don't hold your smartphone while it's connected to a wired charging cable and there's a storm outside.
- jihadjihad 2y ago... when in Brazil?
- LinuxAmbulance 2y agoAll the deaths happened in Brazil, your logic is shocking, but sound.
- NikkiA 2y agoSince the study was authored by brazilians who only used data from brazil, it's hard to tell if the fatalities were enabled by the brazilian electrical system and would not happen elsewhere. Especially given that 4/5 were in rural areas.
- CydeWeys 2y agoIt does seem like there's potentially some kind of bad electrical system / lack of grounding issue going on.
- 0xDEADFED5 2y agotypically phone chargers aren't grounded, so probably not relevant? lightning travels through the ground, so i'd expect the ground wires to be rather dangerous. also, neutral is bonded to ground at the meter (at least here)... so also not good?
- dylan604 2y agoNeutral bonding to ground is definitely not how it is done everywhere. A proper ground according to modern standards will have a true grounding rod that the buildings ground wiring is connected. Of course wiring predating those standards are a mix of how they are handled. Some older wiring used the buildings metal plumbing as ground which is why people say not to shower during an electrical storm.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- userbinator 2y ago"potentially"? ;-) Look around on the Internet and you'll definitely see how a lot of electrical systems in Brazil are not quite up to North American standards. Grounding is part of it.
- PaulHoule 2y agoMy guess is that Brazil’s infrastructure is not that different from other countries, since they run a 60Hz grid I’d imagine they use the system introduced by Edison’s company General Electric.
- NikkiA 2y agoThat's actually a fairly recent (1970s) change, prior to that it was a mix of 50 and 60Hz, 110V and 220V, with no national standard. Also, rural household wiring is often dogshit all around the world with many places having bad earthing.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoAre you crazy! If you die in Brazil, you die in REAL LIFE! https://m.xkcd.com/180/ https://m.xkcd.com/180/
- foobarian 2y agoBrazilian currency being the real, you would kind of die in "real life" indeed
- pixl97 2y agoCould also be that Brazil has a lot of high population cities in high lightning zones. Couple that with illegal electric hookups and it sets up a dangerous situation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Scipio_Afri 2y agoI guess it's another good reason for why I shouldn't have my phone charging in the bed with me while I sleep; the other good reason being battery fires.
- sharpshadow 2y agoAnd to avoid unnecessary RF exposure.
- yieldcrv 2y agoalthough anyone saying this outloud likely wont have their mind changed, for the rest of you all that want to remain informed: cellular devices and radios do not emit ionizing radiation - which is the kind that messes up cells, and nonionizing radiation can only increase heat which is why all devices operate under a power limit people are studying other potential biological effects of nonionizing radiation and there is zero consensus of there being any. so some people, including some smaller government agencies, exercise caution
- someothherguyy 2y agoWhat the parent comment was likely referring to: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/coil-mattresses-cause-cancer-amplifying-radio-waves/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/coil-mattresses-cause-canc... What is known: https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/radiation/cell-phones-fact-sheet https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/r...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- codr7 2y agoCan you see any potential risks with blasting the body with same frequencies as it uses to regulate itself, while its supposed to be regenerating?
- 2y ago
- mscdex 2y agotl;dr: Use surge protectors when you care about your electronics and/or your health.
- capitainenemo 2y agoI would not count on a surge protector to save you if there was a direct lightning strike. Even a hefty UPS, but especially not the small ones in a power bar or some consumer electronic chargers. Better to not have your laptop or phone plugged in at all when using it during a storm.
- zdragnar 2y agoSurge protectors definitely help handling surges from distant strikes, but they won't survive a more direct one. Lightning measures in the millions of joules, well above what any available surge protector is rated for. Given that lightning is an arc through air, breaking the circuit once the surge has started won't save you if your circuit gets a direct or near-direct hit.
- foobarian 2y agoDon't houses have spark gaps for that sort of thing? I don't remember this being a problem since I was a kid, when we used to have to unplug TVs and modems Edit: come to think of it that's when I moved to New England so it could just be the nonexistence of lightning here. Which I do miss.
- zdragnar 2y agoMy parents lost their treadmill during a storm in a midwest US house built circa 1998. I think the power came as a surge through the grid rather than directly from the environment, though.
- CydeWeys 2y agoSurge protectors are not rated for lightning. There are protection systems for lightning (ham radio operators use them), but they're quite a bit more expensive and also involve driving a copper stake into the ground to establish a preferential path for the lightning.
- neilv 2y agoI usually use my laptop plugged into AC, rather than on battery, but will unplug at the first thunder. If it sounds like a bad storm, I'll start unplugging other electronics. I thought I was doing overkill abundance of caution, but maybe it's actually a good idea.
- dylan604 2y agoI do the same thing. The 20-30 minutes it takes for a major storm to roll through is not worth the time/hassle/money of getting fried electronics replaced. Surge protector or not, I just unplug them. Since most of my equipment is connected to some sort of device with on/off switch, it reduces the number of plugs that need to be disconnected to 3. I feel like a surge protector is just there for when something happens to mains from human causes. Putting all of my luck on them for lightning is just too much faith in modern manufacturing and faith in companies honoring a warranty on those devices.
- taeric 2y agoIts funny what you can get used to. We had so many storms and general bad weather events growing up, that I don't really give them any thought. Certainly didn't back then. Out in Seattle, though, if there is a single crack of thunder, everyone is at the windows trying to see what happened. It is almost comical on how this place never really gets a storm. Does make me somewhat at odds with the crowds that hate firework noise, "because it scares pets." I'm in agreement that it is just obnoxious and I don't miss it. I'm pretty sure thunder was far more frightening for any pets I had, growing up. All that is to say, probably wise advice on unplugging things. I know that quality of power has gotten a lot more relevant in recent years, such that you should only be worried about very local events. Still, seems safe enough not to take a risk, if you can avoid it.
- reneherse 2y agoLiving in storm prone regions for most of my life has given me the same habit. All my sensitive electronics get unplugged when storms approach. Two of my family members have had devices fried by lightning strikes over the years, and not even in regions known for the worst electrical storms. I keep some portable battery packs handy in case I need to charge a phone, and if I'm working will switch to my laptop and tablet screens. Of course, one can't conveniently unplug everything (HVAC, big kitchen appliances, etc.) but it's easy enough to safeguard work and lifestyle electronics. Turning the TV off and listening to the storm is usually a nice change of pace, too.
- Frieren 2y ago> The data collection indicated a worrying series of fatal accidents in Brazil, all concentrated in five months. The recurrence of these accidents in rural regions and the intense sound of the discharge reported by witnesses indicate the proximity and intensity of the lightning during the accidents. So, rural areas without lightning rods nor any other safety mechanism. Good study that can save lives by taking prevention measures in rural areas in developing countries. But it will probably not affect anybody living in New York.
- cryptonector 2y ago> But it will probably not affect anybody living in New York. There are vast swathes of American rural land with too-few and far between lightning rods. Maybe not in NY, I wouldn't know, but near as I can tell no U.S. state requires the installation of lightning rods in rural areas.
- 00N8 2y agoI found this bit at the start surprising: "Lightning is one of the leading causes of climate-related deaths worldwide. In recent decades, there has been a considerable increase in lightning due to worsening global warming [1], [2]." Increased lightning makes sense, but I'd still have expected most climate-related deaths to be caused by flooding, heat waves, disease & crop failures, with lightning being a much smaller factor. Do they just mean it's in the top 5 or 10 climate-driven causes, or is lightning really killing people on the same (or greater) scale as these other things?
- intrasight 2y agoUnlike those others, with lightning it's directly attributable to weather. That's the only thing I can think that would justify the ranking.
- cwmoore 2y agoIf I have been struck by lightning through the phone networks during a storm, and some losses ensued, to whom would I address my complaints?
- danparsonson 2y agoGod?