6 ms·
China just approved flying taxis – no pilot needed
- not_your_vase 2y agoI definitely don't want to belittle the achievement, but I would imagine that creating safe self-driving helicopters is much easier than creating safe self-driving cars. (At least as long as the skies are just as empty as they are today. Once it's full of things like the roads, that will be a different topic)
- pryelluw 2y agoCan you expand on how you reason it would be easier?
- ein0p 2y agoMore degrees of freedom, easier collision avoidance. The mechanical part is a lot harder, of course, but the "self driving" part is a lot easier. We had autopilot and auto-land in planes well before we had anything of the sort in cars.
- wat10000 2y agoA self driving car needs to be able to reliably drive within ~1 foot of arbitrary obstacles, recognize junk in the road, recognize people in the road, obey vague hand signals from random cops, obey every weird traffic sign in the world, obey every traffic law, and disobey signs and laws when convention requires it. Helicopters don’t have to deal with any of that. There won’t be any random obstacles. No human drivers to contend with. No conflict between legality and practice to navigate.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- voidspark 2y agoOpen space. Fewer obstacles up there in the sky, separated by large distances. Simple trajectories. We've already had autopilot systems for decades.
- theamk 2y agoSelf-driving car senses objects and must make difficult decisions: Is this radar reflection from stationary light pole or from a moving object? Is this a parked car or a moving car? Will this pedestrain/biker jump on the roadway? What if the car next to me going to turn left sharply? No such thing exists in the air. The air is mostly empty, there are no stationary objects next to the route. If there is a building, aircraft can fly as far as 500 meters away from it - try finding a driveable road with no obstacles at that distance. There is no people or large animals. There is not even curb to hit. Importantly, I bet there are no legacy vehicles in the approved routes - and I am sure they will have some sort of V2V tech to ensure that all objects in the air will transmit their position and intention.
- NoahKAndrews 2y agoAirplanes already broadcast their position! It's called ADS-B.
- ablob 2y agoNot every airplane does that. Commercial planes mostly do, but its not mandated under all circumstances as far as I know. (Speaking for my region only)
- cynical_spar 2y agoAll commercial planes have it at this point. And most part 91 airplanes (General Aviation) have it at this point. Without ADSB you cannot fly in or near class A, B, or C airspace and must stay below 10,000 feet. Which largely makes having an airplane useless for most people. There are still airplanes flying that have no electrical system but even then some of them have retrofitted a system.
- ablob 2y agoI was answering with the purposes of flight-taxis in mind. I doubt that they will fly in high altitude and deem it quite likely that they might want to pass uncontrolled airspace at some point. And if you're flying in uncontrolled airspace you just can't count on the presence of it. In fact, missing transponders are an occasional source of accidents in these spaces. There are lots of gliding enthusiasts that aren't equipped. P.S.: Commercial planes (esp. big ones) should have hardly any contact points with flying taxis.
- metalman 2y agoeverything with a mass over 1kg+- in the air, is carrying a "gps" and something that is transmitting its location, and all air traffic world wide is(theoreticaly) assigned a flight path for each trip,witha specific flight level, ie: the planning is 3d, so the density per layer, never gets very high, and there are specific paths taken to change layers, there are never any dogs, or horses, or people trying to deek, there are no signs or maps, and in case of fully automated vtol taxis, navigation will be to mm accuracy, with likely a routine to land fully autonomously on loosing the network, and a backup ballistic recovery parachute, if power is completly lost or another emergency situation occurs. and also likely is that forward speeds will be low enough, that collisions with birds will be a low probability, and rotors will likely be schrouded, keeping the idiots heads attached when determinidly trying for that gota have selfie.
- cynical_spar 2y agoThis is not correct. There is no hard requirement for GPS nor anything that requires “something that transmits its location”. There is also no requirement for a flight plan or communication with ATC. I can take off from an uncontrolled airport with no GPS, no transponder, no plan, and no radio and as long as I’m in the correct airspace I’m completely legal and within my right to do so. There are some differences with these rules through out the world.
- echoangle 2y agoThis is just plain wrong. With glider planes, you can fly around wherever you like (in the non-restricted airspace) and aren’t required to have ADS-B or FLARM in Europe. Most people don’t do it but you could entirely rely on visual detection to prevent collisions.
- gmuslera 2y ago1 word: birds. Anyway, detecting and avoiding obstacles should be in the menu. Maybe not as complex as at street level with people and cars doing unexpected things, but maybe with some added complexity that need to have into account like weather, inertia and things near landing sites.
- ablob 2y agoI'm not sure you can avoid birds like a skateboad running onto the street. If anything I expect dynamic avoid areas or timed "no fly" zones depending on bird mass. Maneuvering to avoid birds seems like a recipe for disaster.
- euroderf 2y agoIf a drone flies at a speed that gives birds time to take notice and react/avoid, does it remove the danger ? I wonder if there is wide variation among species.
- constantcrying 2y agoNo they are not. I get what you are thinking. Detection, maneuvering and trajectory planning are all much easier than on a road. If you mandate built in transponders collision avoidance is also easy. But what you are forgetting is everything that isn't normal operations. What do you do if anything fails? A car can just stop, break failures, even steering failures can all be reasonably mitigated. This is not the case when you are in the air. Any failure mode needs fast and accurate reactions, even when critical systems have failed. That is why a passenger plane has two pilots. A modern passenger plane can do most of the flying by itself, yet the pilots need to be there. Aerospace standards are higher and more difficult to adhere to, ensuring any kind of reasonable safety is extremely difficult. How many of these flying into sky scrapers are acceptable?
- hedora 2y agoThis thing has 8 motors. It’s easy to imagine that it could have 8 independent batteries and could be able to perform a controlled descent if two fail. Similarly, it could have redundant sensors and use commodity “majority rules” logic circuits where all calculations are run three times. On top of that, they can already cut over to ground control if the computer can’t proceed. With all that, it’s “just” a software problem.
- constantcrying 2y ago>This thing has 8 motors. It’s easy to imagine that it could have 8 independent batteries and could be able to perform a controlled descent if two fail. Similarly, it could have redundant sensors and use commodity “majority rules” logic circuits where all calculations are run three times. On top of that, they can already cut over to ground control if the computer can’t proceed. Most of these are a total nightmare to implement. There is no such thing as a "controlled descent" into a dense urban center. Even keeping maneuverability with a single defective motor is a hard task, you need to develop and test for this. >On top of that, they can already cut over to ground control if the computer can’t proceed. So ground control can do what? The only reasonable way these could ever safely operate is with a high degree of sensor fusion, information about nearby crafts, their trajectories, obstacles, etc. combined together. You can not put a human into that system and have him make split-second decisions. >With all that, it’s “just” a software problem. Passenger plane automation is also "just" a software problem. It is just an enormously difficult software problem with exceedingly high stakes. The problem is not that it is "impossible", but that it is extremely difficult and not worth the risk getting it wrong. Again, what is the acceptable failure rate for these things crashing into sky scrapers? If it is zero, we are very far away from them being able to take flight.
- AngryData 2y agoI wouldn't trust anything that can't auto rotate or glide to be safe to fly. A drone style copter falls out of the sky if there is any failures at all at any point in time in flight making it an inherently unsafe method of travel.
- tekla 2y agoI wish to see the safety test of what happens when a blade breaks off and hits the passenger bay.
- bigyabai 2y agoYeah, without a reinforced nacelle you could easily end up with a fatal birdstrike here. One shudders to imagine how thin that polyethylene window is...
- howard941 2y agoIt doesn't even need to hit the passenger compartment. The partially missing, unbalanced rotor could be enough to take it out.
- Gigachad 2y agoFrom the demo video, they claim it has more rotors than needed. So presumably it could detect one of them breaking and just turn it off.
- _kava 2y agoIt is both amazing and sad to see China is literally in the future compared to the US in terms of infrastructure and social development. A trip to one of the major cities in China made it clear to me that they are ahead of the world right now. The amount of tech and the level of integration are unbelievable. In comparasion, the streets of SF, one of the crown jewels of the US technosphere, are just so "normal" I find it hard to believe. It is the same feeling I had decades ago walking into a then-modern metropolis in the US for the first time. All the cool tech, the convenience, the upscale atmosphere, the extravagance of it all were striking. I have not felt that again for a while and I just think it can't happen again with what I am already used to now. Incredible that China managed to evoke that sense of awe in me again.
- sepositus 2y agoIs there hard evidence of this beyond random anecdotes? Genuinely curious as I haven't visited there.
- bamboozled 2y agoHave you been to SF? It’s like a zombie movie with shocking public transport. There are many nicer cities which seem futuristic compared to SF. I’ve not been to a Chinese metropolis but if you just look at some photos it wouldn’t be hard to imagine somewhere like Shenzhen being much further ahead.
- Axsuul 2y agoSF varies widely be neighborhood. Public transport is not the final solution for SF, instead it’s driverless cars.
- bamboozled 2y agoIt's a cop out in my opinion, it will never scale or be as useful , reliable or enjoyable to use as a well designed, operated subway. Besides Tokyo, Shenzhen, Beijing etc, will have both, subways and driverless, flying taxis, drone delivery and still be ahead of most major US cities in terms of transport options. You have to visit a top tier East Asian city to understand just how good they have these things running, safe, clean, reliable, always on time. Like, it's amazing. Uncomprable to anything I've experienced in any major US city. I think if a New Yorker went to Tokyo they'd be amazed how far ahead they're public transport is. There are also health benefits to using public transport which I think we will see play out with self-driving, people will just become slobs when a car comes to their door, picks them up and drops them at the next door. Using a subway is actually a bit of healthy exercise.
- perihelions 2y agoHere's an alternate source, https://www.flyingmag.com/china-approves-passenger-operations-with-self-flying-electric-aircraft/ https://www.flyingmag.com/china-approves-passenger-operation... ("China Approves Passenger Operations With Self-Flying Electric Aircraft") With some clearer wording on what's been approved so far, - "Early EH216-S operations will come with heavy limitations, which EHang said it aims to lift in phases. For example, flights are restricted to Guangzhou and Hefei and must land where they lifted off[...] In other words, the EH216-S is approved for applications like out-and-back aerial tourism but not air taxi services in cities." (I don't want to derail this thread too strongly, but the current source looks very much like AI slop. The text is egregiously LLM, and, if you zoom in [0] on the people in the backgrounds of the photos, there's some Lovecraftian horror going on with those faces!) [0] https://engineerine.com/wp-content/webp-express/webp-images/uploads/2025/04/LATEST-2025-04-09T222434402-Picsart-AiImageEnhancer-2048x1075.png.webp https://engineerine.com/wp-content/webp-express/webp-images/...
- yoyo458 2y agoIt doesn't mention how much noise does it make. Even though it's electric, drones are usually damn noisy and annoying, and something of this size can't possibly be any better.
- kaycebasques 2y agoThis is my main concern as well. The article [1] that perihelions linked to says that the approved vehicle is produced by EHang and the model is called EH216-S. A quick search yielded this Reddit thread [2] which suggests the noise level is 80dB. [1] https://www.flyingmag.com/china-approves-passenger-operations-with-self-flying-electric-aircraft/ https://www.flyingmag.com/china-approves-passenger-operation... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/ehangstock/comments/mmz42r/for_anyone_wondering_about_the_216s_noise/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ehangstock/comments/mmz42r/for_anyo...
- netsharc 2y agoSeems as noisy as a standard helicopter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=22&v=9-Vr_Kd1W0E https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=22&v=9-Vr_Kd1W0E
- dzhiurgis 2y agoThats nowhere near the noise of helicopter.
- TulliusCicero 2y ago> These vehicles are expected to redefine how cities tackle traffic congestion and pollution Counterpoint: no they're not. These sorts of very large drones may well become more popular, but they're not gonna become widespread enough to impact traffic congestion. The realistic target is becoming a moderately more popular version of helicopters for the sufficiently affluent.
- whazor 2y agoImagine the perfect city, with lots of green parks, great restaurants with outdoor seating, shops, do you think it should have noisy drones in it? Or a thousand drones?
- arthurofbabylon 2y agoI’m currently in a part of the world where helicopter delivery is so cheap and common that locals are complaining. “It should be more expensive…” someone told me last autumn. The helicopters (and drones!) are loud and annoying. Until these problems are solved, locals will resist converting all airspace into the equivalent of a loud, high-speed roadway.
- out-of-ideas 2y agoi can certainly say i would not want to hear that daily or (or with any regularity) - yt wCm68PmmSQ8 to listen to it. still not even used to the small airport with newer air traffic routes rumbling residential neighborhoods nightly afterhours. but oh well i guess; more people seems to follow more noise and light pollution (and i dont want to abandon the quietness)
- maxglute 2y agoHope this doesn't take off (kek), EVs have made PRC cities increasingly tranquil, dealing with rotors would be huge step down in QoL. Fine for quick transit across water. That said, maybe they can optimize for size:volume. it would actually be pretty good to displace delivery network from ground level. Maybe even straight to 40th storey balcony / living room delivery sometime.
- Gigachad 2y agoIdeal use case seems like medical. Air taxi someone directly to the hospital as fast as possible.
- plsbenice34 2y agoWhy not a helicopter with space to do CPR etc? As is already done...
- petermcneeley 2y agoWe got 140 characters and China got flying cars.
- outer_web 2y agoAdditional reading: https://hindenburgresearch.com/ehang/ https://hindenburgresearch.com/ehang/
- dkekenflxlf 2y ago++1
- belter 2y ago"EHang’s much-touted, recently granted certification comes with numerous flight restrictions that it has failed to fully disclose to investors. The restrictions invalidate the bulk of its potential commercial use cases, including restrictions against flying in densely populated areas, in shared airspace, and out of sight of a ground crew. EHang claims restrictions will be progressively lifted, but according to China-based eVTOL experts, EHang’s flagship aircraft would need a billion-dollar redesign and an entirely different class of certification to avoid the limitations." Also from the Chinese Civil Aviation Authority: https://www.caac.gov.cn/XXGK/XXGK/BZGF/ZYTJHHM/202202/t20220222_211914.html https://www.caac.gov.cn/XXGK/XXGK/BZGF/ZYTJHHM/202202/t20220... "EHang EH216-S Unmanned Aerial Vehicle System Special Conditions.pdf" (in Chinese) - https://www.caac.gov.cn/XXGK/XXGK/BZGF/ZYTJHHM/202202/P020220222611863596239.pdf https://www.caac.gov.cn/XXGK/XXGK/BZGF/ZYTJHHM/202202/P02022...
- hnfong 2y agoAn IRL Youtuber streamer recently tried one of these: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQGAuf0rFLA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQGAuf0rFLA Might be a bit of a stretch to call these "taxi"s but anyway here's your futuristic flying car from China...
- ashoeafoot 2y agoOkay, so the ccp backdoored the things(cause of course ) and so all ot takes is some domestic terrorist load one with fuel and smash it into some party hq? Will be interesting wether thex can burry that sort of 9/11
- lloyds_barclays 2y agoI heard that the entire country is in a state of panic after two Xiaomi SU7 autopilot crashes. Motorways have put up signs warning drivers not to use autopilot or assisted driving. Authorities and manufacturers are now trying to explain the previous false advertising.
- FirmwareBurner 2y agoTesla: "First time?"
- victor106 2y agoIt’s sad to see America fighting over old manufacturing jobs while China is leaping ahead. It used to be the other way round. I hope America goes back to its previous innovation cycle
- WorldPeas 2y agoWe have helicopter rental “blade” in New York and various other cities, and similar devices to this in development. As is usually the case(and is usually to our benefit), we have an external bias, and more stringent aerospace laws. I applaud them for this but do not turn this into some “America bad” doomerism
- AngryData 2y agoI overall agree with you, but not about these. Drones have no way to recover from any sort of mechanical or power delivery failure. They can't glide or auto-rotate and have zero control or maneuverability on any failures, they just fall straight out of the sky. In open clear areas an emergency parachute might be fine, but drone style flight is not efficient at all so not suited for longer distances and you only really need taxis in more urban areas where deploying a chute will likely just smack you into the side of a building and you fall anyways.
- constantcrying 2y agoXPENG is also building an EV with a built in passenger drone. I think it remains to be seen whether they will ever be a viable mode of transport. Helicopters have been used, usually by the very rich, for quite a while. They need serious infrastructure and have very high associated costs.
- woodpanel 2y agoi guess Lilium-like scams can go so much further if basically all entrepreneurialism is just a function of Founder-Proximity-To-The-Ruling-Party