3 ms·
Lawmakers are skeptical of Zuckerberg's commitment to free speech
- shortrounddev2 2y agoWe are approaching Marky Mark and the Zucky bunch completely wrong. The rhetoric we use is as if he was running a government department (freedom of speech) and not the largest publisher in human history. On some level, I feel like our regulatory or philosophical model for how to approach Facebook is based on cable TV news, where people often argue for a return to the fairness doctrine. Facebook is completely different from cable news. Nothing in history has encompassed marshall mcluhan's idea of the global village quite like modern social media has. The grip that Facebook has on our central nervous system is unparalleled and we talk about it in terms of "fairness" and "representing viewpoints" and not "biologically, neurologically, how is this technology fundamentally changing what it means to be a human being". I don't know how to pass legislation to do so, but I believe it's in our best interests, as a society, if the maximum natural size of a website is like, 100k users, MAX. With the diversity of communities available, fairness of moderation will no longer be as important because you have more alternatives than the billionaire consensus factory
- milesrout 2y ago[flagged]
- damnesian 2y ago>largest publisher in human history You are of course correct, as far as scale, but I can't help feeling skeptical about how equivalent its effects are when compared to old media. On VJ day, practically every American read the headline in one of a handful of the nation's biggest newspapers. Today, we'd find this news from a post by our favorite influencer, with a built-in twist to boost engagement. There's no doubt social media has blanketed our society in its influence. but the signal has been completely scattered, lost in the sea of noise. In terms of simply learning new things, it's in one ear and out the other. You can learn all kinds of things through social media, but it requires a great deal of effort to weed out the torrent of irrelevant, useless junk data. Not a linear scale, really.
- Covzire 2y agoWe shouldn't need any new laws since it's so fundamentally and blatantly explained in the first amendment that no government official shall tell anyone what they can or can't say. SCOTUS has carved out certain language about credible threats of incitement of violence and the like and I'm ok with that. Where it gets muddy though is during COVID+Social Media, we found a new threat against speech, e.g. the suppression of "reach" which accomplishes the exact same goal as suppressing speech, but it's legality is clouded by semantics. So we desperately need new laws clarifying that government officials may not suppress 'reach' just because they don't like what a person or persons are saying, and most importantly we need it crystal clear that this applies even in the face of a pandemic, so that the government's embedded rent seekers can't once again force a lying narrative on the people that nobody can find their way out of, save for those who engage in 'conspiracy theories' and listen to 'conspiracy theorists'.
- pjc50 2y agoThe problem with this is that if you allow people to spread big enough lies you end up with things like the Rohingya massacre, or the resurgence of measles. You will of course reply "I don't care, my free speech is worth any number of lives of other humans", but other humans may take a different view.
- Covzire 2y agoHistory repeatedly shows the collective intelligence of the masses is superior to government bureaucrats. Every, single, time. I specifically mentioned COVID because everything we take for granted now as basic truths were revealed very early on in the pandemic, but got suppressed by bureaucrats who thought they knew better (or were paid not to know better).
- ben_w 2y ago> Every, single, time No, it really doesn't. The wisdom of the crowds has some domains where it's good, and others where it's bad. Bandwagons, groupthink, whatever you want to call it, that effect is also real. If I pick a random person and ask them what they think the "basic truths" of COVID are, 20-40% of the stuff they will say will still be false today — it just doesn't matter any more that they're wrong. I feel this should be easy to spot by having two large populations that hold mutually incompatible beliefs, such as the way Americans love the 2nd amendment while the UK bans not only guns but also knives in pubic without good reason.
- Applejinx 2y agoThat's an interesting take, AND it is enforceable. It's very difficult to serve immense numbers of people with social media. Scaling takes resources and technical expertise and lots of energy. You could treat it like trying to catch pot growers by watching their electric bills. I don't think there's a way around that, technically: to do the monoculture (and control it) absolutely requires intention, resources and concentration of effort in an obvious way. Yeah, you can secretly administer multiple internet social communities and pretend it's not you, but that already happens too, and it's less effective than the monoculture, plus if you're doing that it smells funny, makes people ask 'why are we being governed to think this way through secret avenues' which is something people strangely don't ask about the monoculture. Whether you can get society to sign on to this 'central control can get this big and no bigger' is much like asserting 'rich men can get this rich and no richer'.
- dmonitor 2y agoNot too difficult to realize what they mean is "please feel comfortable posting your most radical opinions and we'll signal boost the ones that help our agenda"
- milesrout 2y agoI think what they mean is what they say unless proven otherwise. Attributing dishonesty to someone without any evidence is passé.
- dymk 2y agoThe last 10 years of how Facebook operates show how naive a view this is to take of Zucc
- digdugdirk 2y agoYou should really only get one pass for human rights violations before skepticism is the default response. Facebook already used theirs on genocide. After something like that, why should the public give them any benefit of the doubt?
- smallmancontrov 2y agoIf you don't see heaps of evidence you haven't been paying attention. Not for a long time.
- freejazz 2y agoTaking Zuckerberg at his word is beyond naive, it is moronic.
- code_for_monkey 2y agoI think Lucy is going to let Charlie Brown kick the football this time
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoSounds like curation which sounds like a form of speech except in this instance (due to Section 230) they aren't liable for it. Dangerous loophole!
- code_for_monkey 2y agoI dont know why anyone wouldnt be. Why would people, at this point, not approach the things Zuck, or Musk, say without extreme caution? They want to be rich god kings, they dont care about free speech. They say stuff they think will move the needle that direction.
- 9283409232 2y agoI honestly believe people aspire to be rich assholes so they don't want to demonize the rich assholes because they want that to be them one day.
- code_for_monkey 2y ago"elon musk cares about free speech" yeah and your dad is coming back with those cigarettes any day now
- danaris 2y agoI think there's another explanation that works just as well to explain the observed behavior: A large percentage of people genuinely buy into the "just world" fallacy, regardless of whether they consciously recognize this. They believe that if someone is in a position of power, they deserve to have that power. Of course, many of them also believe that, variously, the world is inherently just, people are inherently good, or the world's structure is ordained by a loving God. Therefore, these people deserving power isn't just Fated, it's also because they're better people. Smarter, better leaders, possessed of the qualities that fit one to rule. Therefore, "the people in power are smart, have the best interests of the many at heart, and are worth listening to" is effectively axiomatic for a great many people in our society.
- 9283409232 2y agoI took religious studies in college and one consistent thing across most stories in religion is that the kings, emperors, and other people in powerful positions are almost always evil and commit heinous atrocities so people not being to draw the parallel to people living today is disappointing to say the least.
- nradov 2y agoCitizens are skeptical of lawmakers' commitment to free speech. https://netchoice.org/democrat-leaders-dont-like-the-first-amendment-republicans-should-tell-voters/ https://netchoice.org/democrat-leaders-dont-like-the-first-a...
- no_wizard 2y agoConsidering the big donors and membership[0] of this organization its definitely not an unbiased take and is trying to frame any discussion over regulating hate speech as a radical anti-first amendment stance and makes an unsubstantiated claim that one Republican house member using their chairman position to "investigate" Lina Khan[1] as if the Republican house committee had no ulterior motive seeing as their donor class was very critical of FTC regulations under her leadership, never mind that nothing the committee claimed was substantiated. [0]: https://netchoice.org/about/#our-mission https://netchoice.org/about/#our-mission [1]: https://oversight.house.gov/release/comer-probes-ftc-chair-khans-participation-in-democrat-campaign-events/ https://oversight.house.gov/release/comer-probes-ftc-chair-k...
- maeln 2y agoFree speech is about the government, not whatever private social platform on the internet. Thank god we are allowed to moderate content, every "free speech" absolutist platform is 1. a lie (they regularly censor opinions against theirs) 2. instantly become a cesspool full of edgy people who find it extrimely funny and worth their time to pollute the whole plateform with slurs.
- seydor 2y agoi believe there is a general understanding that public spaces should allow free expression up to a point, but definitely not silence for political reasons. Facebook can be considered broadly a public space because it is so widely popular and monopolistic in a way that previous media have never been. There is a limit to calling something private when it is being used by so many , and it is separate from its private company ownership. If it were a niche site nobody cares. BTW "we" don't moderate anything, the people who run those websites do
- scarface_74 2y agoFacebook is in no legal framework a “public space”. It’s a private entity.
- Applejinx 2y agoNote, however, that its whole marketing angle is that it is to be THE public space: the only internet public space to care about. Not a legal positioning, a social pressuring.
- freejazz 2y agoOkay? And people gather at the mall, or outside the movie theatre near my house... that doesn't make it not private property.
- maeln 2y agoFacebook is not a public space. You can make your own website and platform if you want to say thing that they don't want you saying over there. You cannot make your own government on the other hand, hence why it is important to point out the difference.
- agentultra 2y agoZuckerberg is committed to Zuckerberg. If it makes Meta profitable and raises the value of his estate, he’ll do that. If that’s allowing alternative health nuts sell their ancient cancer healing remedies on Facebook, he’ll do that. If that’s selling user profile data to DOGE for a big juicy contract, he’ll do it. Regulation and enforcement has to come from somewhere and it won’t be Meta.
- yodsanklai 2y agoNeither Meta nor any big public corporations. Their mission is to make profit for shareholders.
- agentultra 2y agoProfits over people, every time.
- WesolyKubeczek 2y agoIt's still very easy to get a moderation strike because your post or comment contained a word that maybe in certain contexts (not necessarily one in your post) could maybe probably offend a group of people. It's almost as if Facebook had remote villages that didn't get the memo from their overlord.
- bentt 2y agoThe problem is not whether Zuck allows free speech on his platforms. The problem is that his platforms are so powerful that it matters whether he does or not.
- bilbo0s 2y agoIn fairness, the lawmakers themselves have no commitment to free speech. Isn't Krebs getting investigated by the secret services for saying unpopular things?
- throwaway48476 2y agoFacebook put itself in a monopoly position by buying out the competition and tried to push an 'internet' where only their products were accessible. They did everything possible to attempt to monopolize but now don't want to be treated as a monopoly.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]