3 ms·
There's a problem with just directly comparing them - because JKR probably brings in more revenue to the UK than fishing, with Potter copyrights. But most of t
by bombcar 2y ago
There's a problem with just directly comparing them - because JKR probably brings in more revenue to the UK than fishing, with Potter copyrights.
But most of that revenue goes to JKR, whereas most of the fishing revenue may end up in "working class" people's pockets.
- 3abiton 2y ago> But most of that revenue goes to JKR, whereas most of the fishing revenue may end up in "working class" people's pockets. I am sure JKR has to pay taxes still, which goes back to the government.
- throw0101c 2y ago> I am sure JKR has to pay taxes still, which goes back to the government. Does JKR personally own the copyrights, or have they been sub-licensed to a corporation in (e.g.) Ireland?
- edm0nd 2y agoWith the levels of money involved, highly likely its all wrapped in legal fuckery.
- ForOldHack 2y agohttps://www.newsweek.com/jk-rowling-making-money-hogwarts-legacy-what-we-know-1777087 https://www.newsweek.com/jk-rowling-making-money-hogwarts-le...
- bunderbunder 2y agoBut still, the money that's going straight into working class people's pockets is probably better for the UK in the long run. Don't worry, it will get taxed over and over and over and over again as they pay each other for things. Velocity is one of those critically important concepts that often gets left out of these discussions because it's hard to understand if you haven't formally studied economics because it's all about second order effects. But it's a big part of understanding why, historically speaking, maximizing corporate profits doesn't seem to correlate all that well with overall prosperity trends.
- tim333 2y agoThere are quite a lot of people who make money from Harry Potter apart from JKR. People running cinemas, bookshops, making the movies, running the studio tour and so on.
- bunderbunder 2y agoRight. And the more of that that happens, the better for the economy overall. The less of that that happens - implying more of it ends up in JKR's proverbial dragon hoard, not doing much good beyond being an impressive pile of wealth for the dragon to sleep on top of - the less good for the economy overall.
- ViktorRay 2y agoI don’t think your comment is accurate. When rich people get large amounts of money they don’t hoard it like they did in Roman times. That money either goes into the stock market or to a bank. If it’s in the stock market that money is being used in investments that further economic growth. The portion of the leftover money that’s in the bank is then lent out by the bank to others in the forms of loans and so on for purchasing houses, starting business and so on. The idea that the pile of wealth is simply hoarded to be slept on is out of date and not representative of modern economics. Also, as for JK Rowling specifically, she had donated a significant amount of her wealth to charity.
- singleshot_ 2y agoMy largest investment is my home. I’m not sure there’s any other way to think of my home as anything other than “a pile of wealth… to be slept on.” Am I missing something about modern economics?
- _carbyau_ 2y agoYou are missing the wealth required to invest and put in the bank, such that your house is an afterthought.
- raffraffraff 2y agoAnd apparently she really does pay all her taxes (£47m last year, roughly $60m)
- fwip 2y agoJKR's net worth is less than a billion, which means she's probably not raking in over a billion annually.
- dubiousdabbler 2y agoIsn't this because she gives so much to charity?
- tweetle_beetle 2y agoQuoting Wikipedia's source, Forbes estimated her donations were $120 million to date in 2012. However, she co-founded her own charity in 2005, of which she is the president, and I suspect most of it has been donated in that direction. Personally, I'm always dubious of the rich and famous genuinely finding unmet cases for charitable organisations. Especially when they've made a fortune outsourcing being morally dubious to others - she can save children because others are paying her to be allowed to sell low quality merchandise almost certainly made in exploitative conditions. She's not alone, there's many more e.g. Messi donating lots to children's cause through his own charitable organisation after gladly being a global ambassador for unhealthy snacks targeted at children.
- throwaway48476 2y agoDuring feudalism the rich donated a far larger percent of their assets. The trend has been that the rich donate a smaller percent since then
- weberer 2y agoAre you counting tithes as donations?
- throwaway48476 2y agoTithe/charity/donations/taxes. It's fungible from a socio economic perspective.
- Symbiote 2y agoThe comparison was with Warhammer, not Rowling. Warhammer requires designers, moulding experts, warehouse staff and so on. Games Workshop is a public company, in case you want to look up their accounts for the comparison.
- bojan 2y agoI do wonder how much of fishery money ends up in the working class pockets. I assume the surviving companies survived because they have economy of scale, meaning most of the profits goes to corporate. If somebody has the numbers, I'd like to know.
- pavlov 2y agoThere are lots of JKR-adjacent industries that employ working class people. The Harry Potter World theme park in London has over two million visitors annually. That tourism must be more economically significant than fishing for cod.
- ModernMech 2y ago> But most of that revenue goes to JKR, whereas most of the fishing revenue may end up in "working class" people's pockets. What an amazing argument to tax the rich!
- chgs 2y ago“Working class” fishermen sold their rights years ago. same as “working class” farmers who sell a field for a couple of million quid