9 ms·
Zoom bias: The social costs of having a 'tinny' sound during video conferences
- rolph 2y agonot just tinny sound. if it is an annoyance, chore, or PITA, to listen, even if its something asked for, there had better be compelling content , else it is dumped quickly
- SoftTalker 2y agoI use this as leverage to make calls go faster. I bought the cheapest mic on Amazon, it manages to be over-sensitive to background noises such as my computer fan but still barely captures my voice adequately. It's annoying enough that nobody wants to stay on the call any longer than necessary.
- alabastervlog 2y agoInvesting in a decent mic and paying a little attention to lighting is the new "buying a decent suit and having it tailored".
- happytoexplain 2y agoYup. But the AV setup is cheaper, easier to maintain, and more comfortable.
- alabastervlog 2y ago> more comfortable Only if you don't try to wear it.
- theultdev 2y agoA mic and lights can be cheaper than a department store suit. Wouldn't really call it an investment.
- crazygringo 2y agoAn investment of time and effort. Audio gear is surprisingly complicated for non-experts to research, evaluate and monitor. (Like even making sure your app is using it, and didn't reset to your laptop mic when you accidentally unplugged it for a minute.) And fixing your lighting can require rearranging your entire office if you have a window behind you. Or investing in expensive blinds, etc.
- 4b11b4 2y agough, true
- microtonal 2y agoAny tips for good mics? Any good options that are not immediately in front of your face?
- bbatha 2y agoYou'll want some kind of shotgun mic. The rode videomic2 is a good budget option. It has a standard 3/8" thread you can use with a desk boom.
- jcims 2y agoI've been using one for a few years now and am really happy with it. Every now and then (once every 1-2 weeks) it drops off of the list of inputs on OSX but unplug and plug it back in usually fixes that.
- j45 2y agoSennheiser MKE-600 is next up for me. have a graveyard of other mics that don't sound as well for my voice. Listen to a bunch of the shotgun mics on youtube and see which your voice might sound the best with.
- aroch 2y agoI’m a fan of Saramonic’s MV2000 (https://saramonicusa.com/sr-mv2000-large-diaphragm-usb-studio-microphone-with-magnetic-tabletop-stand-headphone-out-and-multi-color-led-for-computers-and-mobile-devices/ https://saramonicusa.com/sr-mv2000-large-diaphragm-usb-studi...) is an affordable, good quality cardiod mic. Frequently available for $50 and supports live headphone pass through if that’s your jam.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kstrauser 2y agoI bought a Yeti Blue a while back, and several people commented positively on its sound quality. I'm pleased with it, especially given its decent price: it's not a bank-breaker for being such a huge upgrade over the built-in laptop mic. As a bonus, it has a hardware mute button on it. Now I usually leave my Zoom unmuted, and use the button to toggle whether my coworkers can hear me. It's more convenient than clicking the Zoom button or finding the keyboard shortcut.
- dist-epoch 2y ago"investing" is a strong word, when you can get really good microphones for $50-100.
- polishdude20 2y agoIs a MacBook pro m series mic not good enough usually?
- snickell 2y agoI was wondering the same. I’d love to see a quick head to head, in realistic non studio wfh environment, starting with macbook mic, and then at $50, $100, $300 mic investments. Anyone got the setup already in front of them at their zoom desk and want to make us a 5 minute comparison video?
- J_Shelby_J 2y agoThey're not even remotely comparable. Apple has some of the WORST quality microphones - mostly due to the fact that they have zero headset with boom mics.
- williamdclt 2y agoThey’re not talking about headsets but about built-in MacBook mics. Which are definitely pretty good
- nickthegreek 2y agoI just got back from an All Hands meeting in our main office. Most people do it remotely. We had remote people presenting from their M-series macbooks. I was reading this thread prior to the all hands, so I was paying attention to the quality of the voices. Audio was being pumped through the ceiling speakers. They all sounded great and it convinced me that I did not need to throw money at an imagined problem... I of course reserve the right to change my mind as soon as I see a great desktop mic on a sweet deal.
- IshKebab 2y agoMacBook mics tend to be very good in my experience. Easily puts you in the "hooray I can actually hear you" category. It's webcams (Logitech shit) and headsets that are the worst.
- kcb 2y agoA good non-bluetooth headset. Logitech makes some with a wireless dongle. I use a Sennheiser DECT headset. Most DECT headsets have pretty tinny cordless phone type sound but this one has an ultra-wideband mode that sounds pretty nice. Can also walk around the house with 0 connection issues.
- sethammons 2y agoMy background is very tailored. A wall of 80s/90s themed stuff and a large pixelated "loading" bar with magnetic blocks for the progress bar. I get compliments regularly and I am sure it helps me stand out in a sea of screens. I run an HD obsbot camera and a great mic. I am fully convinced it helps.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoCould you share the background?
- Contax 2y agoI'm specifically intrigued by that loading bar with magnetic blocks.
- sethammons 2y agonothing too wild. Found a wall sticker on etsy of a pixled loading bar: _____________________ | | |___________________| L O A D I N G The sticker is on the wall and looks all pixled, and then I have 7 black, thin foam 5"x6" rectangles that I've glued magnets to the back of, and then on the wall, I have nail heads that the magnets connect to. I can load up the bar, one block per day, or I can just have it as my energy indicator haha.
- Contax 2y agoAh, I was imagining something way more complex and wilder, with electronics and LEDs and what not :D But that's cool too, if simpler, nice way to track stuff. Thanks for explaining! ;)
- noname120 2y agoIs it not too distracting for a job interview?
- hammock 2y agoLighting makes a HUGE difference. Just get an Elgato Key Light Air from Amazon, set it to ~5700K and full brightness and watch the magic happen. It takes a while to get used to having a lightbulb in your face but it's so worth it. That, and the new Macbook Pro's portrait mode feature on the webcam. It's good enough that most people won't want to bother with setting up a DSLR
- randycupertino 2y agoFor a good visual on how much lighting helps check out youtuber Hannah Poston's "Why do I look so young" where she shows herself with and without her lighting setup: https://youtu.be/S9TTLmTZnf4?si=gJoSCwWK8bg2rerL&t=41 https://youtu.be/S9TTLmTZnf4?si=gJoSCwWK8bg2rerL&t=41
- __mharrison__ 2y agoI "invested" in early 2020 when all of my training moved to Zoom. I've gone through a lot of equipment and frequently am complimented on my sound, camera, and background. My rank order for investment: 1. Mic - See my mic comment in another thread 2. Lighting - It is hard for good cameras to compensate for poor lighting. Good lighting on the other hand, does compensate and helps laptop webcams perform much better. I currently run a Godox ULC60bi with a huge parabolic diffuser. Probably overkill for many. You can get cheap fluorescent or LED lights with a diffuser. Would avoid a ring light especially if you wear glasses. 3. Camera - I have used Canon M50 and Sony A6500 as webcams. These days, I use an Insta360 Link. It's not quite as good as the cameras (you can add more "background blur" with their software), but it's more convenient. I still get compliments on this. 4. Background - Blur, doors, and bedrooms are what you see 90% of the time. A good background helps you stand out. I have a bookcase with the books ordered in color. Folks always comment about it. There are lots of other common looks, look on Youtube or X (Kevin Shen) for office makeovers. 5. Teleprompter - Not for scripts but for "looking in the eyes" of my students or the person on the other end of the call.
- __mharrison__ 2y agoWow, this is being downvoted. (Please help me understand why as this comment is a summary of interactions that I have when folks ask me about my equipment.)
- tetromino_ 2y agoMy guess is because for the median HN reader (an ordinary techie who doesn't talk much on video, and when he/she does, it's mostly to other ordinary techies), your setup appears to be expensive overkill.
- ajcp 2y ago4b. Collapsible green screen[0]. Can't recommend this enough if you don't want/have the ability to stage or curate your background (my "office" doubles as a guest room). It's also excellent for presenting and handy for any number of one-off things. When I don't need it I just slide it under the bed, easy. What teleprompter do you use? How do you use it? 0. https://www.amazon.com/FUDESY-Collapsible-Auto-locking-Greenscreen-Photography/dp/B0895P91B8 https://www.amazon.com/FUDESY-Collapsible-Auto-locking-Green...
- heraldgeezer 2y agoWaaay cheaper and easier than a tailored suit.
- minimaxir 2y agoProtip: Don't use Bluetooth headphones as your microphone input source. The audio gets massively compressed. https://www.reddit.com/r/MacOS/comments/10dit8y/lowquality_bluetooth_audio_when_entering_a_call/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MacOS/comments/10dit8y/lowquality_b... Use the laptop microphone as the input instead, or if no microphone is present just buy an external microphone. You probably don't need a $300 podcast-class microphone since the audio still gets compressed in transit, though.
- cosmic_cheese 2y agoThese days, most premium and/or business laptops (MacBooks, ThinkPads), etc have mic arrays that are far superior to those on earbuds anyway, being capable of eliminating background noise without negatively impacting audio quality.
- j45 2y agoLaptop mics huge upgrade from the past, and very convenient when I don't have something handy, they are not the best or even close. A decent mic will still outperform.
- bravetraveler 2y agoThe array isn't enough to mask your mitts smashing/sliding on the device while typing and talking. For the love of everything, use something standalone. Ideally not a desk mic. Vibration works against those... just like what's built into any given laptop. It's a form-factor/usability thing. Decent audio isn't a price problem, it's entirely about selection. What you suggest is my last choice. A backup. Headsets and forgive me, wires I can replace, are hard to beat. I like to type, talk, and be heard. Sometimes all at once.
- cosmic_cheese 2y agoI wasn’t meaning to say to use laptop mics at the exclusion of a standalone mic, just that if you already have a nicer laptop then the parent comment’s recommendation to switch inputs for a “free” instant quality boost is particularly pertinent. It’s also applicable to situations where one is away from their desk. The degree to which vibration of is a problem depends on your setup. If your laptop is mounted on a VESA arm bolted to your desk and you’re typing on an external keyboard for example, it’s not going to come through too easily, especially if you have the keyboard placed on a desk pad. This is true of a standalone mic on an arm too.
- the_pwner224 2y agoThe most important thing for good sound is distance between the mic and your mouth - since SnR falls off with the square of distance. Some people use a standalone mic mounted to an arm on the front of their desk, but I find that to be too intrusive and ugly. The ideal setup is a headphone with a boom mic. A lot of business conference headphones have a boom mic, as well as gaming headphones, but they all cheap out on the actual microphone element. For ideal sound quality you want to get a V-Moda BoomPro (wired, $20) or an Antlion ModMic Wireless ($140). These tack onto your existing headphones with a small magnetic clip (so you can take it off when not in a call). You can look up sound quality comparisons on YouTube, these two devices are far ahead of even the most expensive business/gaming headsets. It makes a vast difference in sound quality. The ModMic Wireless also works around the "Bluetooth sound quality is shit in headset mode" issue, since your headphones are in output-only (A2DP) mode and the ModMic has its own separate Bluetooth connection for mic-only. Finally, camera quality and lighting are important too. Here's a good article on lighting: https://languageoflight.blog/2020/10/08/time-zooms-by/ https://languageoflight.blog/2020/10/08/time-zooms-by/. For the camera you can use an actual camera (DSLR/mirrorless, ideally with a fast lens) with an HDMI capture card, there's plenty of info about this available on the internet. An old iPhone can also work quite well afaik? Either way, it'll be much better than a webcam, particularly if your room's lighting conditions aren't ideal.
- tdeck 2y agoWhat about lav mics? Are they a good option if you're willing to clip one on?
- the_pwner224 2y agoI think so, but I've never tried. I like to move around during calls so for me the ModMic Wireless + my existing Bluetooth headphones was the best option. I don't think there's any system out there that can beat the physical flexibility and ease of use of this setup. The ModMic comes with a tiny magnetic nub that adheres (permanently) onto the headphones. Then the ModMic itself snaps onto / off of that magnetic element, so it takes literally 2 seconds to take it on/off.
- 2y ago
- pelagic_sky 2y agoI use my Rhode condenser mic, that I use for recording vocals, as my Google Meet mic while at home. I've lost track of the amount of people who have said "WOW" when I start talking and then go on to tell me how good my voice sounds. It's kind of lame, but true that I do stand out more when presenting to executive leadership. I've even had one VP remember me because of my mic and audio quality.
- ycombinete 2y agoI’ve had a similar experience, where a friend suggested that Teams must boost the host’s audio, based on how clear my voice was in a group meeting we had. And I just use the mic attached to my Game Ones which isn’t even a condenser.
- earslap 2y agoThere are also documented effects of your camera quality, and even where your camera is placed (as you tend to look at your screen during a call so your gaze is always relative to it).
- __mharrison__ 2y agoTeleprompter!
- earslap 2y agoprobably not very relevant in a zoom meeting but there are people hypersensitive to the eye movements of someone reading from a teleprompter as well! When I figure someone is reading from a script with their eyes moving, it really affects my focus for some reason. Here is someone trying to find the ideal setup to prevent it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LkRMtWfhn4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LkRMtWfhn4
- calvinmorrison 2y agoI moved my whole team to $30 logitech headsets and they're miles better than the laptop, airpod, and standalone webcam mics we have on file. Clarity is great for guys who work at the coffee shop. I play music while on calls and nobody can hear it. Sometimes simple works.
- dplgk 2y agoWhich headset?
- calvinmorrison 2y agoLogitech H390
- m3kw9 2y agoHow is this bias different than dressing and looking well? The screen/sound is where the rubber hits the road and if you have a messy room, noisy environment, crapy mic setup, poor internet quality, it all adds up to a chance you are not really detailed oriented.
- jmmcd 2y ago> "During videoconferencing, of course, you know how you look, since you can see yourself too," Walter-Terrill noted. "But on a call with dozens of people, you may be the only one who doesn't know how you sound to everyone else: you may hear yourself as rich and resonant, while everyone else hears a tinny voice." Not quite! You don't really know how you look, because you see yourself before transmission.
- aranelsurion 2y agoSome apps also show you mirrored image for some reason, so everyone else is seeing a mirror image of what you see.
- jmmcd 2y agoYes indeed. This is because it's very disconcerting to see yourself non-mirrored.
- IshKebab 2y agoYeah I can't really blame people for not realising they have shitty mics and shitty internet because it's really hard for them to tell! Basically the only way is to start a meeting, record it, and then watch it back. But what a faff! Why is there no "play me back but delayed" test meeting option? Apparently Zoom has this but I'm using Google Meet at the moment... Their answer is "ask someone else". No really. https://support.google.com/meet/thread/45440945/is-there-a-test-meeting-like-zoom-has-to-check-out-equipment-connectivity-etc-before-real-meet?hl=en https://support.google.com/meet/thread/45440945/is-there-a-t...
- deadbabe 2y agoOne thing you should do is not use your camera all the time. Use a really good profile picture, people will imagine whatever you look like in their head and you build an air of mystery and exclusivity. Save your on camera moments for when you want to grace others with your presence and court attention. Most people on camera just look bored, small, and uninteresting. By being more deliberate, you can avoid giving that impression.
- iteratethis 2y agoTotally agree. I also consider it weird that in a group call somebody could be directly staring at you but you can't tell. Highly unnatural.
- topher6345 2y agoI'm using quite an elaborate stack for daily zoom calls wich may be interesting for those seeking a richer sound: A Mic Parts S-25 I built from a kit https://microphone-parts.com/collections/microphone-kits/products/s25-microphone-kit https://microphone-parts.com/collections/microphone-kits/pro..., Medium Diaphragm Condenser (requires 48V phantom power) into a JHS Colorbox V2 https://jhspedals.info/products/colour-box-v2 https://jhspedals.info/products/colour-box-v2 an electric guitar effects pedal emulating a Neve recording console channel strip, can do XLR in/out and pass 48V phantom power to the mic into a Focusrite Scarlett with Apple Airpods Pro as in ear monitors It works for me - I usually audition the mic and the Airpods before unmuting The colorbox helps increase the gain level so I don't have to be so close to the mic, I usually place it upside-down using a boom mic stand, at around 1 foot away from my mouth at a 45 degree angle from my forward gaze (to avoid plosives and sibilance), Its in frame as a conversation starter but doesn't necessarily have to be. I find my voice is more intelligible if I use the colorbox to reduce some of the midrange content. It also imparts some compression and harmonic distortion. I watch the Scarlett input indicator to avoid clipping at the digital input I find myself with less vocal fatigue using this equipment than the Airpods Pro as a mic. Also it just seems a little more exciting to think my voice travels through transistors and capacitors I soldered, through a recreation of a circuit that some of my favorite music was recorded though.
- tinix 2y agoI'm really surprised there's no discussion about DECT headsets here. It operates over the 900 megahertz ISM band. I'm able to walk all over my house and property without audio dropping out, and it doesn't suffer from Bluetooth codec compression issues. https://www.eposaudio.com/en/us/headsets/dect-headsets https://www.eposaudio.com/en/us/headsets/dect-headsets I will say they suck for listening to music though (if you're an audiophile)... but I would just switch to good studio monitors for that situation.
- Defletter 2y agoWhile that may very well be true, I'd be willing to bet that these effects are much more pronounced (and rightly so) with people who hotmic / don't use push-to-talk. As while this can be mitigated some with diligent muting by the host (or whoever), or with a raise-hand-to-talk system, it's still completely lacking in consideration for others, whereas tinny audio is something that sometimes cannot be helped.
- iteratethis 2y agoJust get a wired business headset. No lag, no echo, great audio quality both ways. When I know one of my peers made a sizable audio investment, as of then I pretend I can barely hear them.
- pavel_lishin 2y agoI purchased a nice microphone for podcasting, and it works so well during work meetings that people will comment how much better I sound even if I forget to plug it in.
- MathMonkeyMan 2y agoI second this. The cheap USB ones sound fine and never fail. If I'm sitting at a desk at home anyway, I prefer to plug things in. Power: don't have to think about battery life or power saving modes. Ethernet: don't have to think about wifi. Headset: don't have to think about bluetooth, codecs, or battery. Keyboard: low latency, has followed me through four jobs. I do use one of those wireless logitech mice, though. The AA battery gives it a nice weight.
- 0xTJ 2y agoI (panic-)picked up a decent-quality but not overly professional podcaster-type mic ahead of my online Master's thesis defense, and now use it as my exclusive audio input method for Zoom and Teams calls. I have earbuds wired to its monitor output, which combines the mic with audio out from the computer, and it's just such a stable, easy, and good solution for my usecase.
- hammock 2y agoThe demonstration website for the study has the recordings used: https://perception.yale.edu/Brian/demos/Misc-AuditoryFluency.html https://perception.yale.edu/Brian/demos/Misc-AuditoryFluency... I would like to know the effect size but can't find the full paper.
- yencabulator 2y agoThat's really heavy distortion on those samples. 1. I'd be surprised if it didn't have an effect. 2. Your average video call seems much better quality.
- turtleyacht 2y agoFor Macs, Quicktime with New Audio Recording lets you hear yourself (if you're wearing a headset or earbuds). This helps modulate tone and prevent "yelling at the computer" phenomena. A recording doesn't have to be made. It's like having a free audio "monitor."
- supergeek133 2y agoSo many people are overengineering this... I have a wireless Jabra headset. Works great. At home I use one of those usb speakerphone pucks, works great. Not these super special desktop mics that streamers or radio broadcasters use. The people who try to use their webcam mic or the built in mic are the ones causing most of the problem (yes I'm also looking at you Macbook users). I always thought it'd be a great idea if in your internal Teams or Zoom instance you had a "send this person a new headset" button to fix the problem.
- noname120 2y agoIn my experience MacBook Pro mic is incredibly good, miles ahead of any (expensive) headset I've tried. Do you have a different experience?
- ajmurmann 2y agoHow do you have the macBook pro microphone in a proper position? If I only use the macBook the camera is in a bad spot. Usually my macBook is plugged in which means my decent, external camera on my monitor is in a good location and so is my lighting. However, it means my macBook is off to the side.
- shreddit 2y agoI do have a (not cheap) BT headset and still use the builtin microphone of my mac. Why? Because when i use the mic of my headset it changes the type of BT connection and the sound i hear is basically unbearable.
- ALLTaken 2y agoIs nobody using a DJI Mic2?? I hoped you guys would recommend something better than the DJI Mic2, not because it's expensive, but there surely should be better mobile/wireless mics, no? I hope someone knows, hey I am even down buying those talkshow moderator style mics, like the DPA 6066, that was recommended here. But don't they require a bulk of stuff wearing in your back attached to your pants/belt? For sound I would wear regular noise-cancelling in-ears, here the difference isn't that big, unless you're audiophile like me and many others in this thread. Especially so, if you have above average hearing, the world is optimised for lower-quality sounds :( Why the focus on just the Laptop/PC? Mobile Phones also feature crappy mics, especially when on loudspeaker. Yeah I noticed it depends very much on the software being used too, but WhatsApp sounds tinny, Instagram sounds crystal sharp, Zoom/Meets sounds tinny. What if you have to use the screen and still need to listen on your mobile phone? Bummer, the microphone switches to crap-quality on loudspeaker. Test yourself and record a message with loudspeaker on and off. Especially with background noise it's getting worse, whatever that algorithm is doing, it's tinning your voice to filter the stuff out.
- jccalhoun 2y agoI regularly hear people on podcasts, radio, and tv who go on shows with shitty mics. I don't understand how. "I'm going on a national radio show. Maybe I should get a decent mic? Nah, screw it. I'll just sound like garbage." And no one behind the scenes on the show sends them a mic? Or at least tells them not to use airpods as their mic? Certainly there times when an interview is set up quickly. But I've heard entire 90+ minute podcasts where the guest was on a terrible mic.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- basisword 2y agoPSA: If you use AirPods on a call, please don't use the mic. Set Zoom to use your laptop mic or another external mic. I don't understand how people don't realise a microphone next to your ear if going to sound like shit. The mic needs to be in front of your mouth. Same goes for people with those Bose noise cancelling headphones (or equivalents). The mic is shit. And that's expected given its position. BTW, the old wired Apple headphones with the cable remote/mic are a decent cheap solution.
- heraldgeezer 2y agoWork headset is fine. At home I have a Blue Yeti + Logitech Brio that sounds and looks good.
- xuhu 2y agoWould I sound better on Zoom if I took out one wireless earbud and spoke into it ?
- MathMonkeyMan 2y agoAs long as you hold it out towards the camera when it's somebody else's turn to speak.
- iainctduncan 2y agoI'm a bit surprised the article didn't get into what kind of mic too. It's not just about the quality, there are specific favourites of broadcasters that have a particularly nice proximity effect, the phenomenon by which some mics make one sound bassier when speaking very closely to them. This sound has come to be associated with trustworthiness and so on. So yeah, more expensive is not necessarily better - a wide diaphragm condensor in an untreated lively room is going to sound less authoritative than a cheaper but decent dynamic mic dead close. An affordable mic that sounds really good for this is the Seinheisser e935. It's not as heinously directional and tight as an SM57 so doesn't ding you when you move, but still has a nice close, warm proximity effect. I use it for zooming and I have much more expensive mics on hand. A more expensive broadcast favourite with a milder proximity effect is the Electro-Voice RE20. Killer live mic too. Also - pop shields are good.
- ALLTaken 2y ago[dead]
- turnsout 2y agoI've done it all… wired earbuds, AirPods, dedicated mic with custom noise reduction & EQ. It comes down to this: I don't want stuff in my ear all day, and using a pro mic just comes across as "try hard" in most contexts. It's not a benefit. These days I just use my laptop's mic & speakers like 99% of the people I talk to over Zoom.
- J_Shelby_J 2y agoMy time to shine. https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/why-is-professional-audio-in-the-wfh-age-so-difficult.46268/page-2 https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/w... TL;DR: Audio-Technica ATH-M50xSTS XLR + USB audio interface (if you want to fiddle, get one with onboard compressor, eq, and noise gate). I've also been routing the steel series arctis nova pro into the audio interface. No steel series software and the interface's compressor and EQ is much better. But the nova pro, despite being the BEST sounding wireless headset mic, still sounds like trash compared to the compressor mic on the wire headset. Seriously, RTINGS has sound clips of every headset they've ever reviewed. Go listen to them. They're tragic. Especially Apples.