6 ms·
How the American Medical Association Screws Doctors
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- readthenotes1 2y agoThis could be straight out of Systemantics, written about systems in general by a physician. One of the observations goes something like: Systems grow to perpetuate themselves, not provide the service for which they were created.
- devwastaken 2y agosimiliar to the iron law of orgs / oligarchy. all orgs that live long enough eventually exist to just perpetuate the org. the “reasons” become marketing and politics but are no longer seriously considered in their effectiveness.
- readthenotes1 2y agoThat's probably taken from Systemantics
- tcj_phx 2y agoThe American Medical Association (AMA) was founded in 1847 to lobby for making competition to the Medical Doctors (M.D.) illegal. At the time, upstart approaches to medicine [0] did not believe bloodletting and calomel were effective medicine, and the doctors didn't like that their communities did not have faith in their omniscience. Most states had AMA-approved licensing laws by the early 1900's. After outlawing competition, the Carnegie foundation (a proxy for the early pharmaceutical industry) financed the Flexner Report (1910) to help the M.D.s improve their standards for medical education. The report said, essentially, that all medical schools should be like John Hopkins. The Doctors of Osteopathy (D.O.) was the only medical philosophy that was organized enough to secure equivalent licensing laws. Osteopathy founder A.T. Still required his students to at least be aware of pharmaceutical options as a 'last resort' for their patients. The modern D.O. license is legally equivalent to the M.D. license. The AMA standardized on "allopathic medicine". While a lot of progess has been made at understanding and improvinghuman health, modern medicine still has sacred cows, which are quite profitable for the medical-industrial complex (Statin drugs, anti-dopamine drugs, overuse of steroids, etc). At least modern doctors only bleed people when it's a useful treatment - for hemochromatosis (excess iron stores) and the use of leeches for limb reattachment, etc. [0] "Herbal medicine, eclectic medicine, and homeopathic medicine were some of the pre-1850 approaches to health that, whatever faults they might have had, did not encourage practitioners to bleed their patients to death or poison them with mercury." - https://www.madinamerica.com/2024/07/theodoric-arizona/ https://www.madinamerica.com/2024/07/theodoric-arizona/ 1444 [minor edits] [edit 2] having finished the article, I think it’s a good take on the problems of American healthcare. Liked this quote towards the end: “There are two kinds of populist approaches to health care. [Bernie Sanders…] And the second is that of RFK Jr, who, to oversimplify, seems to think that expensive medicine itself is often a ruse by large corporations to keep Americans on an unhealthy sugar-and-seed-oil diet. Whether RFK Jr. is right or wrong is a less interesting question than why most of the powerful lobbyists in D.C. didn’t oppose him.”
- ninetyninenine 2y agoI’m a doctor — and I’ll say it proudly: the AMA deserves every royalty they collect, and probably more. They’ve done more to protect the integrity of American medicine than any other institution. Without them, we’d be working 80 hours a week and still struggling to afford a one-bedroom apartment — just like doctors in France, where a cardiologist makes less than a dental hygienist in Ohio. People don’t realize how bad it is out there. In some countries, doctors are taking public buses to work, skipping lunch to see 50 patients before noon, and retiring with the same savings as a schoolteacher. Meanwhile, patients complain that a 15-minute consultation in the U.S. costs $300. You’re not paying for the time — you’re paying for the privilege of certainty, of safety, of knowing your doctor passed through the most rigorous, exclusive system in the world. And who built that system? The AMA. They’ve helped ensure that American medical training remains second to none. Not just in quality, but in difficulty. The years of unpaid labor, the crushing debt, the endless exams — it’s not a flaw, it’s a filter. Without those standards, the profession would lose its weight, its dignity. If becoming a doctor were simply a matter of competence and compassion, we’d all be wearing name tags and making $60,000 a year. But thanks to the AMA, we’ve maintained the sanctity of the white coat. We’ve ensured that when a patient walks into an American clinic, they know they’re not seeing someone who just slipped through the cracks. They’re seeing someone who’s been tested, refined, and yes — financially punished enough to demand respect. Let’s not pretend this work is trivial, either. Just last week I diagnosed a UTI, prescribed a $4 antibiotic, and quite literally saved someone’s life — that’s a bargain at $500. If I’d been compensated based on the value of that outcome, I’d be driving home in a McLaren, not a Lexus. And let’s be clear: this system doesn’t just benefit doctors. Everyone in medicine — from PAs to NPs to specialists — benefits from the professional ecosystem the AMA has helped shape. We’re not just providers. We’re institutions. So yes, I’ll keep paying my AMA royalties. I’m paying to be part of something that still means something. I’m paying for the architecture that keeps American medicine elite, untouchable, and worth every penny. And if someone wants to pay $100 for a doctor visit? There are countries for that. You just might have to bring your own stethoscope.
- usrusr 2y agoAre you suggesting that the quality of treatment depends on the conveyance the doctor used to get to work? Have you even been to France, to dig into just one example?
- mschuster91 2y ago> Before his confirmation hearing, RFK Jr was thinking of attacking the lucrative AMA revenue stream. As the Financial Times reported, “Kennedy’s team has discussed how the CPT process could be done in-house by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, according to three people briefed on the matter.” Congratulations, the author managed to find the one thing where RFK Jr actually makes a good point. The "economic termites" problem also applies to other parts of the economy. Software patents like Amazon's for "1 click purchases", the hot mess that is mobile phone standards where a wanna-be startup has to negotiate with a bunch of different patent pools (which is why you don't see new players other than Qualcomm, Apple/Intel, Samsung and MediaTek (who probably got started by just shitting on IP laws - if going by bunnie's old "gongkai" post, at least the people using their stuff in the old days certainly did), video/audio codecs that have the same situation, even ham radio has its issues - DMR for example is an ETSI standard, but the most commonly used voice codec theoretically has a patent that (IIRC) runs through end of the year, and Yaesu's C4FM is fully proprietary. > 1. Liability Insurance: From what I understand, this cost has gone up faster than inflation. The problem is, if you fuck up say a child's life during birth by noticing too late the child is running out of oxygen... two decades ago, the child would probably be dead by age 10 or even earlier. With modern medicine, it is manageable to keep that shell of a human alive until it dies at age 80 - that cost has to be paid for by liability insurance if it can be shown that the cause was a mistreatment. We have that problem with midwifes in Germany, who are dropping out in droves because insurance prices exploded [1][2][3]. [1] https://www.bundestag.de/webarchiv/textarchiv/2014/49932222_kw12_sp_hebammen-216410 https://www.bundestag.de/webarchiv/textarchiv/2014/49932222_... [2] https://www.zeit.de/gesellschaft/2015-07/hebammen-elternprotest-versicherung https://www.zeit.de/gesellschaft/2015-07/hebammen-elternprot... [3] https://www.br.de/nachricht/hebammen-mangel-bayern-102.html https://www.br.de/nachricht/hebammen-mangel-bayern-102.html
- Suppafly 2y ago>Software patents like Amazon's for "1 click purchases" I'm not sure why this is mentioned, it's hardly a drain on other retailers to have a second click in their process. >We have that problem with midwifes in Germany, who are dropping out in droves because insurance prices exploded [1][2][3]. I'm not convinced that's a bad thing, especially in Germany where there seems to be a lot of woo based practice masquerading as actual medicine. If the insurance prices are exploding due to actual malpractice, the profession probably should clean up their act which necessitates people leaving the profession. Sure you probably lose some of the good with the bad, but maybe they should have cleaned house a little earlier.
- xnx 2y agoAMA screws doctors too? I thought its main job was to screw patients by keeping the amount of doctors artificially low to keep prices high.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- darth_avocado 2y agoLooking at how their revenue from membership dropped and are now relying on royalties, they are screwing themselves too. If they had more doctors, they wouldn’t have to rely on royalties.
- phkahler 2y agoMaybe they're just not relevant any more. What would they do if their money came from doctors instead of royalties? TFA says they're like a startup incubator, which is fine but why should anyone be funding them in that case?
- HelloMcFly 2y agoAMA is not the main culprit in supply of doctor's, that would be available spots for residents (and further downstream, available slots for sub-specialties e.g., pediatric nephrology; pulmonary critical care). You can expand med school enrollment until the cows come home, but you'll just be increasing the number of aspiring doctors who don't "match" to a program to continue their training. Solving this is complex and complicated, in large part due to the fact that residences and many fellowship programs are funded through medicare/medicaid via congressional actions, sometimes with additional state funding. Also keep in mind that most doctor's have high salaries and high debt load, they're not as rich as people think. There are sub-specialties though that are aboslutely rolling in cash (interventional radiology, dermatology, ortho as some).
- Suppafly 2y ago>Also keep in mind that most doctor's have high salaries and high debt load, they're not as rich as people think. I suppose it depends on what people think, but doctors do alright.
- betimsl 2y agoThey probably screw the patients too.
- m3047 2y agoIf you're on Medicare and trying to figure out whether something is covered, CPT codes are the glue in a rat trap, the pin sticking bug to a board, you get the idea. Everything is done by CPT codes. But you can't go and reference them yourself, even on the Medicare web site (no, really you can't). Doctors will tell you something is covered, then you have to demand the CPT code from them and call Medicare to find out if it's covered. Or, you can trust the doctor... who will be correct until they aren't. Sometimes doctors don't even know what CPT code they'll use until they see you.