6 ms·
IBM's CEO doesn't think AI will replace programmers anytime soon
- neuroelectron 2y agoThis man is incredibly prescient. No wonder he is CEO of IBM!
- belter 2y agoSome will take your comment as irony, but he has a Phd in Electrical Engineering from UIUC and I would trust him more than an MBA. "In a leaked recording, Amazon cloud chief tells employees that most developers could stop coding soon as AI takes over" - https://www.businessinsider.com/aws-ceo-developers-stop-coding-ai-takes-over-2024-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/aws-ceo-developers-stop-codi... ""If you go forward 24 months from now, or some amount of time — I can't exactly predict where it is — it's possible that most developers are not coding," said Garman, who became AWS's CEO in June. "Coding is just kind of like the language that we talk to computers. It's not necessarily the skill in and of itself," the executive said. "The skill in and of itself is like, how do I innovate? How do I go build something that's interesting for my end users to use?" This means the job of a software developer will change, Garman said."
- dartos 2y agoThat last quote hurt me so much. If that’s my job, why do I have no influence on the product? What’s the point of product managers?
- anticorporate 2y ago> What’s the point of product managers? Many of us have been asking this for years. Including those of us who have been product managers.
- belter 2y agoCan you imagine the CEO of the lead cloud provider telling his Developers: "Coding is just kind of like the language that we talk to computers. It's not necessarily the skill in and of itself"
- dartos 2y agoYeah, they do it all the time. they’re talking at the devs, but really talking to the market, since their job is partially to pump their own stock price. You can’t believe public CEO statements.
- toyg 2y agoLol, I'm a junior PM and I have the same question - in the end, developers tend to do whatever the fuck they want anyway...
- dartos 2y ago> developers tend to do whatever the fuck they want anyway Can you get me a job where you work? Everywhere I’ve worked in the past 10 years as a developer, I’ve had 0 ability to do whatever the fuck I want.
- toyg 2y agoLol, nice try, I have enough self-running devs... I guess it's a cultural thing. Our CEO and CTO still commit code every other week (occasionally driving us mad), it's still a very bottom-up org despite having thousands of people now.
- csomar 2y agoThat's the CEO of AWS. At this rate, in 24 months china is going to take over the software industry despite their significant lag compared to the US.
- pjmlp 2y agoPeople love to throw jabs at one of the companies that happens to be a champion of patents per year, and also responsible keeping the lights on for many critical projects on the Linux ecosystem since 1998.
- dijit 2y agoWe like to shit on IBM, but they dominated many industries when they tried. IBM pushed Linux very hard and contributed significantly to it's adoption- it would be revisionist to think otherwise. They also created quite literally legendary laptops, before deciding that they didn't want to and then moved on. I mean, their stock is not hurting as much as we think of them as a relic of the past: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/IBM/?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAARSrXSbPLE1Em1YaTKY_aSO4FoKH7KPDV5GoS1TO_FzdI1k-JlMSKk_pIKSsqUFI4qdaJNGm3eNUOdquRJF8RajWQWa90BAq_Bkg9XjGiuK3UpLMC5zKNSPd0B9B0IyeyfWTMK5a23zrd0B4r93u8wdtZZcVdyWs7qnE3U13eRG https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/IBM/?guccounter=1&guce_refer...
- toyg 2y agoThey also were pioneers of modern industrial practices. They researched the best approaches to workforce scalability, settling on a model of many distributed offices spread around cheap peripheral suburbs - something that might sound banal today, but it in the 60s/70s, when even factories were supposed to be as close as possible to downtown, it was pretty bold. IBM has many shortcomings but they did manage to survive and navigate a century of tumultuous technological changes. Very few companies have done that.
- mepian 2y ago"The statements are also a bit of a reversal for Krishna, who said in 2023 that IBM planned to pause hiring on back-office functions that the company anticipated it could replace with AI tech." I suspect his enthusiasm for AI is going to keep cooling down.
- mtkd 2y agoThat is different things though -- you can replace functions with AI tech without needing AI to write all the code and that is happening in a big way right now -- Krishna was talking about reducing customer facing roles by around 30% over 5 years in that earlier statement As of right now the code assistants mostly just make existing coders more productive -- predicting 20 or 30% of new code in near term will be generated is not unreasonable -- 90% is a stretch as has been discussed here many times
- tananaev 2y agoThis is what he says: > He disagreed with a recent prediction from Dario Amodei, the CEO of Anthropic, that 90% of code may be written by AI in the next three to six months. > "I think the number is going to be more like 20-30% of the code could get written by AI — not 90%" I kind of agree with him. Definitely not in six months :)
- jonplackett 2y agoI can kinda see it doing 90% of the code by volume, but it would be the easy 90%. And the remaining 10% will need to be done by someone who actually knows what they’re doing. Still amazing for time saving but so far I haven’t been able to get even a SwiftUI class written to the standard I’d use it as-is.
- aprilthird2021 2y agoI agree with you. The same way compiling code meant that 99% of the code was machine-generated, but you still wrote tons of code. Lots of code is boilerplate or large switch statements (esp in OOP), or other such things. All of which AI code completion makes a breeze. The actual hard parts of code (often the various ways of connecting two disparate systems), AI doesn't really help with unless you tell it what to do and how, so you're still the ultimate important decision-maker in this scenario and can't be "replaced"
- fsloth 2y agoAgree, excellent for commodity boilerplate where there is basically just a bunch of 1:1 mappings that need to be filled. Terrible for novelties and problems in a large solution space. The more degrees of freedom there is to fail, the worse it will work.
- wanderingstan 2y agoThere will also be Jevons Paradox happening: LLMs reduce the “cost” of writing code, so more code gets written. I already find myself building prototypes that I never would have attempted previously; it’s just too easy to have the LLM whip one up. LLMs also make it easier to do “grunt work” coding of writing validation checking and unit tests on non-critical code where previously I wouldn’t have bothered.
- jmclnx 2y agoI will admit, he seems to be a very smart person and probably right. But my feeling about AI is it a scam to wrestle money from stupid investors :)
- jonplackett 2y agoI would be very interested to know from everyone here: What is the most impressive thing you have managed to get an AI to code - WITHOUT having to babysit it or give it any tips hints or corrections that a non-coder would have been unable to do.
- dgacmu 2y agoNothing that I've cared much about. Little python utility scripts like "merge the rows of these CSV files in such and such a way" are about the only thing that has worked first time without me adding more of the "how" to do it.
- bartwe 2y agoPhysics system for soap bubbles in a gamejam game
- jvanderbot 2y agoI can take my blog or website, fire up aider, and ask it to completely reformat or restyle it or add effects. It does a fantastic job at that, and that's something I'd have to pay $20 on Fiverr to get done before because I cannot coordinate colors or style things to save my life.
- aprilthird2021 2y agoThis is a good example. It's really good at updating old, small projects. Whereas most humans need to build context about the project, and do so slowly. I wonder over time how those small, infrequent updates might hamper the ability to perform the next, small infrequent update (as your code begins to resemble less and less any examples the AI might have seen and more and more a kludge of differing styles, libraries, etc.), but that's really not any different than how most projects like a personal website operate today.
- jvanderbot 2y agoWell in this case this is a complexity-preserving change. The same few template files get updated with each change. So, I can't say for sure but I imagine this is effectively zero cost.
- john_alan 2y agoIf all code is written by AI or by "vibe coders" then what happens when companies are selling products they don't themselves understand? - sounds like a recipe for disaster to me. I think it's pretty obvious that generative AI isn't replacing the need for engineering - ever.
- micromacrofoot 2y agocompanies already sell products they don't understand all the time, it's practically in the job description of salesperson to make shit up
- jalict 2y agoThis happens regardless as people leaving companies and whatever they produced. You will find so many examples of code out there in production and works through hopes and dreams. And you know what? If it works it works - regardless how it was produced.
- acedTrex 2y agoKrishna sucks a ton, I see IBM Granite is not performing financially up to expectations.
- roenxi 2y agoThis is close to being an appeal to authority. These companies - and IBM is the classic case of this - are the last to pick up on new trends and are usually blindsided by new technologies. If AI was perfectly superhuman IBM's CEO is still going to be one of the the last people in the tech world to pick up on it. He'd hopefully be ahead of other industries. Startup CTOs are the people deciding how much code is going to get written by AI. They're going to be building products in new, untested ways. Mostly failing, some succeeding. Technical growth doesn't come from established majors. The entire AI boom left Google doing a cartoonish impression of being run over by a gaggle of bystanders heading to the next big thing and they thought they were actively researching and leading the field of AI. As news of what IBM is doing he's a leading authority, but following IBM's exploits is going to be skating to where the puck was last year on a good day.
- WhyOhWhyQ 2y agoIt's not an "appeal to authority" to report on the opinions of tech leaders. The only way it would make sense to call this an appeal to authority is if you think TechCrunch is making an argument for a side. This just looks like ordinary reporting, however.
- roenxi 2y agoBut it is close to one to look to him as an authority on where AI is going. He's technically only commenting on exactly what IBM is going right now; which isn't where we expect the interesting things to happen.
- Philip-J-Fry 2y agoHere's a thought: Does it count as AI written code if you're basically just telling it to fill in a template? My common use case is basically just writing some code in the style I use. Then I'll tell the LLM, "Do X based on Y using the rest of the methods in Z". The code I would write would look exactly the same. I just the LLM as a shortcut to getting the code written. Like, I'm not depending on any sort of knowledge within the model. I just use its natural ability to be a smart templater. If using AI this way counts as AI written code. Then sure, I reckon you could easily get to 90% AI written code in loads of applications. But in terms of developing a product or feature from just plain english prompts alone? Definitely lower, and definitely babysat with someone with software development knowledge.
- simonw 2y agoI call that AI-assisted programming and I think it's a very appropriate way to use this tech - it's effectively a typing assistant, saving you on time spent entering code into a computer. I called this the "authoritarian" approach here: https://simonwillison.net/2025/Mar/11/using-llms-for-code/#tell-them-exactly-what-to-do https://simonwillison.net/2025/Mar/11/using-llms-for-code/#t...
- FinnKuhn 2y agoI think using AI in this fashion is different though as this is basically just using it as a fancy auto-complete...
- PaulHoule 2y agoLately I’ve done a lot of asking Copilot to do things like write a Provider for a ContainerRequestContext in JAX-RS which turned out the same as if I wrote it myself but I would have spent more time looking up things in the documentation. I had a bunch of accessibility-related tickets that were mostly about adding aria-attributes to React code involving mainly MUI components and got good answers off the bat with the code changes made but going back and forth with it we found other improvements to make to the markup beyond what was originally asked for.
- BoingBoomTschak 2y ago"CEO of a (human) consulting company says AI won't replace consultants any time soon". I mean, he's right, but come on.
- signatoremo 2y agoIBM hasn't been a primarily consulting company since they split into two in 2020. The one you were probably thinking of is now called Kyndryl. https://www.kyndryl.com/us/en https://www.kyndryl.com/us/en IBM still has a consulting business, but focus on AI, so if anything "replacing human programmers" would be their breads and butter.
- BoingBoomTschak 2y agoWhoops, thanks for the heads up!
- DannyBee 2y agoThe notion of replacing programmers is not well thought out most of the times i see it. At some point, you have to be able to replace all of them (or all the work they currently do), or else all you do is screw up the pipeline you need. I've seen lots of AI companies who believe they will replace junior software engineers, and leave the senior ones in place to do really complex things and drive the AI. One serious problem with this, obvious, but often totally ignored or handwaved, is that senior software engineers do not grow on trees, they were yesterday's junior software engineers. So once you've gotten rid of all the junior software engineers, you will no longer generate any more senior ones. When combined with likely increased attrition of senior software engineers, seems like a wildly bad plan. Or at least, something that needs to be taken into account but never is. Now, plans to replace all of them are at least logically coherent, but also seem far-fetched at best right now. By numbers, people do appear to be replacing software engineers with AI (the number of new software engineer jobs has dropped something like 30%, even relative to other jobs, but no linked causation obviously), but every company i talk with that is doing this keeps telling me they are just replacing their junior engineers, which is hilarious - they all expect they can just continue to hire senior engineers they need from "somewhere else". Freeloading works until it doesn't.
- techpineapple 2y agoI suspect we have this problem already in SRE. Back in the day, there were lots of manual processes to do to check on the health of servers, install packages, troubleshoot network problems. Now, there’s this mountain of ops knowledge you have to know to be productive, not to mention also have software engineering skills, but there’s very little manual tasks to do to step stone your way to that knowledge.
- TheNewsIsHere 2y agoAgreed. I have yet to see any evidence that AI companies are actually thinking about what they’re saying. They’re just trying to move markets and make money. In some cases they’re saying two different things. For example, Microsoft (arguably more a general software company desperately chasing AI rather than an “AI company”) would in one breath have you believe that the modern workplace will not survive without AI, while in the next breath Nadella is on the record noting that AI can’t exist without an ROI, and they’re not yet seeing an ROI that justifies it generally. The OpenAIs of the world can’t imagine a world where the premise of their product isn’t the default/a given, so they simply engage as if their vision is entirely sensible.
- techpineapple 2y agoI’m starting to get suss about any percentages being thrown around, not because I don’t believe the numbers but because I don’t believe the context. First of all, I’m writing a game and the game is a 2 player game, and I noticed it rewrote the “move player” function for each player (move_player_1 and move_player_2) and they were the same, and this was like a poorly written 50-100 line function with an excessive number of comments, so is AI really writing 20% of code that would have been written? This is like evaluating the quality of a software engineer by the number of lines of code they write. Second. Let’s say you thought you were going to get a consistent 20% improvement. That would be amazing, but there’s two ways to conceptualize that. One is, if I have 5 engineers managing 5 pieces of software, I can do the same work with 4. But can engineers really take on the mental load of managing another piece of potentially complex software? The other option would be, I have 5 engineers managing 5 pieces of software, and we get 25% more work done. I think this is more likely. Every software project has a mountain of tech debt or nice to haves that you don’t have time to finish. Maybe AI makes software writing more pleasant because you can get more done in a sprint/pr, but doesn’t actually require less software engineers.
- 827a 2y agoIMO: One idea I've been pondering is this idea of contextual continuity in programming, or really any task you may ask an AI to do. If I code a system, then that system has a bug; or if I use Illustrator to make a drawing, then the stakeholder says they want the tree a different shade of green; correcting that error after delivery is reasonably easy. If I ask an AI to do either of these things, even if I'm still being paid to be in the room (many supporters would argue this system has replaced me, and thus I'm not even in the room anymore): How does this correction happen? The operator has to take off the vibehat, dig in to the inevitable machine-generated mess the AI has created, and learn everything its done in order to diagnose it (or, keep prompt-praying it comes up with a solution on its own). Getting past this feels like a fundamental issue with the proposed process. AIs are trained on human data, and prompted by humans, who are imperfect. I don't think its reasonable to assume that AI will ever be able to generate perfect solutions, if only because we will never be able to engineer prompts that adequately encapsulate what the prompter wanted, let alone if the AI makes no errors in its generation. If we can't get to that, its obvious to me simply knowing how much of my time is spent every day [writing code] versus [debugging existing code] versus [gathering requirements] that AI is doing any significant amount of any of that unsupervised will not result in a more productive system. It will always be most productive for me to leverage (or tightly supervise) AI in its generation, intercepting errors before they compound, directing the flow of output. I do think the roles and responsibilities of devs is going to change a lot over the next ten years; from crafters to soothsayers or oracles one might say. But I am still very comfortable betting my career on: 1. Someone (meaning: human) needs to do the soothsaying. 2. Those classically trained in software engineering will be the most effective people to do this. 3. The amount of stuff one individual can output will be amplified, but there will still be a reasonable per-capita maximum of output, and thus the industry, in its ever-increasing desire for code and ever-increasing need to manage the output of AI, will continue to demand more soothsayers.
- sebazzz 2y agoI've yet to see a LLM asking any critical question, in order to understand the problem better. Without this, it can never be a good programmer because good programmers ask questions.
- gt0 2y agoThis is a really good point I hadn't thought of before. How come LLMs always claim to understand exactly what you mean with no clarification or context? It's sort of immediately ridiculous that these LLMs could replace real people.
- jacknews 2y agoSeems like he's just shilling for the (Indian-dominated) 'in-shoring' (H1Bs) and 'outsourcing/offshoring' industries, both of which IBM has been rather active in, the last decade or two. I think AI will benefit more senior 'architectural' programmers the most. It won't completely replace programmers of course, and certainly not in 6 months, but it will quite likely substantially reduce the need for the boiler-plate programmers typical of the offshore and H1B industry.
- rinka_singh 2y agoI'm sorry but IBM has moved out of (Software) products and currently only does IT services. Its revenue (from Software) is completely tied to $/hour that it can earn from its contracts. Arvind Krishna is simply trying to talk his business up. My take: the truth will lie somewhere in between, with the balance moving into the AI corner with time. Also, the real truth will emerge from IBM's financials. The growth (or decline) of their revenue from Software Contracts will speak for itself over the next few years. Also, from what I'm seeing in the Industry, the number of Software hires have begun to decline with more engineers being let go.