8 ms·
Brain scans of infants reveal the moment we start making memories
- dwighttk 2y agoBrain scans are like those scientists putting together the iguanodon skeleton… we may eventually get to a likely story but we’re gonna spend a lot of time on to be discredited
- ofrzeta 2y agothe truth is the scans "offer some intriguing clues" but future studies "might shed light on the minimal brain architecture needed to support vivid autobiographical memories."
- CarRamrod 2y ago>Failure of any of these steps [encoding, long-term etching, and recall of memory] causes amnesia. So, which steps are responsible for the erosion of baby memories? >Who knows! Kids squirm around too much in MRI machines! But they start encoding things around a year, or maybe before, or maybe after! I've been clickbaited
- larodi 2y agototal clickbait, indeed, author makes no substantial claims of any sort.
- Dylan16807 2y agoThat is not an accurate summary. The article clearly discusses how they limited squirming enough to gather actual data.
- catlikesshrimp 2y agoA Very long time average, by the way. 8 minutes is a long time for a baby to stay at once: not squirming, not upset, not touching mother and awake.
- CarRamrod 2y agoi'll let you go ahead and explain how they controlled for squirming, I'm interested
- Retric 2y agoThey presumably don’t have any extra information except what’s in the article which said they “often squirmed” rather than always, which means simply repeating the process enough gives times when they didn’t. If you want technique: “infants were _ to reduce movement.” If you missed what was in the blank you might want to reread to see what else you missed.
- ziddoap 2y agoYou can find the answer in this link: https://singularityhub.com/2025/03/20/new-baby-brain-scans-reveal-the-moment-we-start-making-memories/ https://singularityhub.com/2025/03/20/new-baby-brain-scans-r...
- SwtCyber 2y agoHaha, fair... there's definitely a bit of "science marches forward... sort of!" energy here
- locallost 2y agoI didn't read the article, but when I got kids I was surprised they can actually remember for a very long time. Both of my kids could at e.g. 3 remember things that happened a year earlier, which still surprised me with the younger one. There was however a point when the older one could no longer remember some things from the past, as if there was a cutoff line to a previous life and he had transitioned into a new phase of his life.
- leoedin 2y agoThat’s been my observation too. My completely amateur theory is that a young child’s perception of the world - their ability to contextualise what they’re looking at - changes so much that even if those old memories are still hanging around, they don’t really make sense any more. It’s more like a sliding window than a hard cutoff.
- giancarlostoro 2y agoI read a similar discussion here on HN before and the explanation that its how our brain decodes memories shifting over time really hit me. I have a theory that if that in fact is the case, then things like journaling would help to retain memories in a superior way, since we can review such things as our encoding changes and retain it while we can still decode. Even if we dont remember it as richly though we will still be able to go back to a journal to remember something at a bare minimum.
- magicalhippo 2y agoI don't know what the state-of-the-art is, but there was some work done that suggested that memories are formed encoded in the language you know at the time of formation. I dug up some of this a while back[1]. My dad, who taught our language to immigrants, mentioned that it was known in that field that immigrants who lost their native language would also lose a lot of the knowledge they had from their home country, like stuff taught at schools. Thus the memories might be there, one just can't make sense of them anymore and so they become forgotten. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37204047 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37204047
- milesrout 2y agoI can remember very vividly experiences that cannot have happened after I turned 2. It is nice to have something I can show people when this infrequently comes up, because I have had people insist that these must be false memories, as children cannot form memories before 3. Or before 5. Or in one case, before 10? Like what?
- sethammons 2y agoI've had people full on state as fact children can't recall anything before age [4-7]. 10? Wow haha. My earliest memory is at around 18mo. When I was nearly a father myself, I told my mom of my early memory and she remembered it too and told me how old I was. My kids, especially the first, would routinely recall things when she was 3 that happened when she was 2 or slightly younger. I can recall thinking, "I barely remember that, how the heck do you remember that!?" However, she had forgotten most of those early early memories a few years later.
- porridgeraisin 2y ago> 18mo I wonder if it's something to do with the memory being reinforced (maybe in surprising ways). E.g one of the memories I have from around a similar time is me receiving a toy gift (video memory) . It makes for a decent display item and has been kept out in one bedroom or the other in every house my family lived in since. So I would have seen it every now and then throughout my childhood. Perhaps, this reinforcement can occur in other, more non-obvious ways in a child's brain, offering a similar explanation for your experience.
- quesera 2y agoIt's surely true that a memory fragment can be kept alive or reinforced by stories or physical tokens (objects, photographs). This can be true of a high-fidelity "correct" memory as well as of a sketchy incorrect one! It's also well-established that "memories" can be purposefully created by the application of the same tools.
- CarRamrod 2y ago
- SwtCyber 2y agoCurious to see if future studies tie this in with memory consolidation during sleep
- hnpolicestate 2y agoI have two early childhood memories. I remember a brief moment standing in my crib during the morning. And a dream I had in Pre-K where my pre -k teacher was the moon above me at night. Pretty early memory?
- Workaccount2 2y agoPeople might call BS on this, but I can recall the full layout of the home I lived in until I was 2 (to the shock of my family when I laid it all out). I have a memory from my first birthday as well. There are many people who have legitimate memories from very early on.
- bildung 2y ago"The early years are chaotic. The brain undergoes extensive rewiring. This makes it a difficult to form lasting memories." That is reduced too much from the actual state of research, presumably for the sake of accessibility. We obviously already learn before the hippocampus starts to really develop (18-24 months). But what episodic memory means is that the learned things have no episodic context, i.e. they are learned and applied more broadly, not just in the situation where they were learned in the first place. Learning in the early years isn't "chaotic", it is just very generalized.
- drooby 2y agoSomething must be slightly unusual about me.. because I have retained some very early memories.. I have confirmed with my parents the placement and orientation of my crib. I can tell you the exact process that my parents performed to change my diaper. I remember being bathed in my tub with my toys.. list goes on. These are visual memories, I can see them right now. I'm nearly certain they are real.. it's possible my brain has made some up, but I've confirmed enough with my parents that I feel confident that they are real. I swear I remember waking up in the middle of the night once in my crib.. heart beating out of my chest.. I was really scared of something.. and I just remember this pure consciousness .. staring up into the darkness. Same consciousness I have now.
- deepsun 2y agoA lot of early memories are induced, e.g. parents told you a story, and your brain "fills it up", so you think it's your own memory, but it's actually more of imagination. Or you imagined where the crib were, and parents confirmed, so you think you remembered. Watching crime witness testimonies reveals how much we actually imagine, not remember.
- netsharc 2y agoI've wondered whether one can train a child to remember things by recalling things that happened to them repeatedly, but I guess it will create such an induction. And they don't even have language to understand "Remember Monday, 2 days ago, grandma visited.". And perhaps under a certain age, the brain really has no programming to store anything as memories...
- dhosek 2y agoIt’s actually remarkably easy to induce false memories in people. There’s substantial research on this.
- SlightlyLeftPad 2y agoThere’s nuance here. I think I experienced the same thing maybe not quite as young but I distinctly recall the crib I was in as well as the day I got upgraded to a regular bed. Along with that I remember specific objects that I had around me which were later confirmed by my parents’ photos. There a potential selection bias in the criminal witness example which is capturing adult memories that may be less sticky than those from an early age. That could explain some differences there.
- hereme888 2y agoThis supports the observations made by Dr. Piotr Wozniak, inventor of spaced-repetition algorithms, from anonymous data gathered from users of all ages: children up to around age 7 have poorer-memory than adults because their brains are focused on rewiring.
- sidewndr46 2y agooh boy! another brain imaging story. I wonder if they can also identify the moment trout start making memories?