8 ms·
Interesting tool, but I'm very surprised that they allow backdating posts. Backdating posts opens up a world of social engineering scams. You can create an acc
by Aurornis 2y ago
Interesting tool, but I'm very surprised that they allow backdating posts.
Backdating posts opens up a world of social engineering scams. You can create an account that appears to have predicted a lot of past events, sports scores, or stock prices with timestamps prior to those events occurring. The scam is to create an account that appears to have great stock advice or sports betting predictions and then charge people for it.
- jer0me 2y agoI believe this is possible because of how the AT Protocol works. Bluesky shows a warning[1] on these posts and displays both times, but sorts them by the backdated time. [1]: https://bsky.app/profile/bluemigrate.com/post/3lc3r4fqen62l https://bsky.app/profile/bluemigrate.com/post/3lc3r4fqen62l
- dietr1ch 2y agoIt'd be cool if they also verified the dates to get rid of the warning of honest backdated posts.
- pimlottc 2y agoWhat constitutes an honest backdated post? How would they be able to verify it?
- tough 2y agothey could fetch the post reference on x.com with the real date, and store a zkProof of its existance, relying the verfiability-trust then to x not messing with them
- krainboltgreene 2y agoYou going to donate your CPU for that? Only about a billion or ten tweets.
- dietr1ch 2y agoYou don't need to migrate everything, just getting the ones from users that migrated from twitter would help a lot seeding Bluesky profiles. You can also link Twitter to Bluesky with either OAuth, or a Twitter post with a Bluesky challenge to prove you have control of the account.
- pimlottc 2y agoThat sounds like a lot of manual work, as I don’t expect Twitter to offer an API for departing users…
- rad_gruchalski 2y agoNot an API but if you're a departing user: https://www.theverge.com/23453703/twitter-archive-download-how-to-tweets https://www.theverge.com/23453703/twitter-archive-download-h.... Bottom line: it's possible to download all account history with tweets in JSON format with dates, and more.
- pimlottc 2y agoSure, but now you're back to trust. Unless it's signed, which it doesn't sound like it is, anyone could fabricate their Twitter post history.
- celticninja 2y agoOpen a PR
- toomuchtodo 2y agoOr use the Wayback Machine? You can trust its captures, courts do. Queue archiving jobs per handle, backfill from the archives after the initial archiving request has completed. https://katharinabrunner.de/2024/02/archiving-websites-the-internet-archives-save-page-now-spn-api/ https://katharinabrunner.de/2024/02/archiving-websites-the-i... https://x.com/paulmcgorrery/status/1178561480385421312 https://x.com/paulmcgorrery/status/1178561480385421312 (Dyno Nobel Inc v Orica Explosives Technology Pty Ltd (no 2) [2019] FCA 1552) https://www.michbar.org/journal/Details/Old-websites-seldom-die-using-the-Wayback-Machine-in-litigation?ArticleID=4698 https://www.michbar.org/journal/Details/Old-websites-seldom-... https://www.lexisnexis.com/community/insights/legal/b/thought-leadership/posts/internet-archive-wayback-machine-helps-lawyers-go-back-in-time-to-strengthen-cases https://www.lexisnexis.com/community/insights/legal/b/though...
- arcticbull 2y agoWouldn't that require a very expensive API contract that X would be quite uninterested in signing?
- pjc50 2y ago> they could fetch the post reference on x.com with the real date Twitter posts are only available to authenticated users, and the API is really quite expensive now - that was one of the many reasons people have wanted to move off it!
- kurisufag 2y agonope. post here from 9/11 2001, no warning [0]. it's fine if they added a check recently to flag backdated posts, but there's no telling how many incorrectly-timed things went up before they added that ([0] is from about a year ago, fwiw). the whole early history of the platform is questionable, and it's just shoddy protocol design. [0] https://bsky.app/profile/lul4.bsky.social/post/3kgaesbxs7f25 https://bsky.app/profile/lul4.bsky.social/post/3kgaesbxs7f25 (if you work for bsky please don't add a flag to that, it's my favorite party trick)
- jer0me 2y agoLooking at the JSON data in dev tools, it looks like there are separate `createdAt` and `indexedAt` fields, the latter of which was probably a later addition. For your—likely pre-migration—post, both are set to 9/11. On more recent posts, they're separate dates.
- extraduder_ire 2y agoThat post does indeed predate bluesky tracking index times, I remember seeing it before they announced that change. I believe it was motivated by other migration services becoming popular. Forward-dating was fixed even earlier, I think, since it might allow people to "pin" their posts to the top of reverse-chronological feeds. Some of my favourite backdated posts are from the years 1776 and 1.
- pfraze 2y agoMore specifically the reason we didn’t have an index time for that post was an architectural migration which lost our prior witness times. That was pretty early on. At this point we’d take pains to preserve those timestamps, and I’m fairly sure we will need to publish them for other folks to use at some point
- mayneack 2y agoI think the reason it works that way is because they want strong guarantees for the future portability of your skeets. It's sort of a correction for Mastodon's reliance on server admins' goodwill.
- Forgeties79 2y ago>skeets I’m cackling over here. How have I never heard this when people talk about blue sky?
- OrsonSmelles 2y agoTo the windoooooooooooooooooooow....
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoSurely this is what he was talking about. Lil John was decades ahead of his time.
- cookiemonsieur 2y agoA Lil Jon reference on a HN thread about Bluesky was most definitely not on my 2025 bingo card. But I'll take it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nextts 2y agoTalking of "Jon" and "Skeet", there is a fairly well known programmer called Jon Skeet. If you are a C# developer good chance he has answered you stack overflow question!
- miroljub 2y agoIf you are a bit older, you'd remember the same guy fighting for Java in bloody flame wars against C and C++ on Usenet. When I first saw him as a C# devotee on Stack Overflow, I was surprised it's the same guy.
- nidnogg 2y agoVery nice.
- ezfe 2y agoIf you look at the imported posts, they have a badge that says the date they were imported and says the date on the post is unverified.
- evbogue 2y agoYes, but this badge is generated at their Appview index layer and not at your PDS.
- chc4 2y agoIf you are syncing data from another PDS, there is no way to verify that posts have an accurate date, unless you have some central ledger which is antithetical to allowing self-hosting and being distributed.
- evbogue 2y agoCorrect. The trade-off here is on Bluesky you can delete or re-order your posts which you cannot do on a network with strict message ordering. Your PDS webmaster can also rewrite your messages for you if they become unhappy with your messaging.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoTake snapshots with the Internet Archive and have that be canonical/source of truth?
- chc4 2y agoYour PDS webmaster has a signing key for your repo, because they for all intents and purposes are you. That's the trust structure of how PDS' are setup. If you don't trust someone else to modify your repo don't give them your private (sub)key. The fact it's a subkey means that you are also able to rotate the key that the PDS has access to and modify your repo back to pre-defaced state if need be.
- 2y ago
- evbogue 2y agoBluesky was developed with backdated posts as a stated goal, see Jay's original prototype: https://github.com/arcalinea/smor-serve https://github.com/arcalinea/smor-serve
- jampa 2y agoYou can still do that even without changing the timestamp. Back in the old days of the internet, people used to get famous by claiming they predicted all the results of the FIFA World Cup by posting every possible outcome and then deleting those where they were wrong. Then, they would publicize their account just before the final match, and people would go wild.
- spullara 2y agobefore this people used to send out stock predictions by mail to power of 2 people with each prediction and its opposite, eventually you get down to a person who you have always sent the correct prediction.
- BiteCode_dev 2y agoJust realized the French lottery is only 19 068 840 combinations. You could send spam to 19 millions people, each with a number saying you can predict the lottery, and if they send you 10 000 euros in BTC, you could give them the next one.
- rglullis 2y agoI am more surprised by how we got to this world where people think in terms of what software developers "allows" us to do, or not do.
- Aurornis 2y ago> in terms of what software developers "allows" us to do, or not do. You can do whatever you want with the the software. It's right here: https://github.com/bluesky-social https://github.com/bluesky-social You cannot do whatever you want on someone else's hosted website. They don't allow you to delete other users and edit other people's posts because everyone agrees that would make it useless.
- rglullis 2y ago> You cannot do whatever you want on someone else's hosted website The whole thing with Bluesky and decentralized protocols is no server can enforce special rules. Sure, they could come up with something that says "our PDS will not accept backdated events", but they will not be able to stop someone else to set up a server that does that without any issue.
- pfraze 2y agoNetwork authority models are more nuanced than “nobody can tell me what to do” vs “one person controls everything.”
- rglullis 2y agoIndeed, but you are not answering the question: how can you reconcile the idea that ATProto is meant to be decentralized (i.e, no single authority) and at the same time have rules that are enforced (purely by software, I'm not arguing that rules could be enforced socially) by any particular server? You would need some form of distributed consensus mechanism, but then you either end up with some exclusive club to implement Paxos or you will need some blockchain-y solution, no?
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- lazzlazzlazz 2y agoOne of the many flaws of AT Protocol.
- latexr 2y agoAs demonstrated by the Waddle Dee Knows case. https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2022/02/how-to-become-a-fake-nintendo-insider/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2022/02/how-to-become-a-fake-...