6 ms·
Washington Post editor resigns after accusing CEO of killing column
- drak0n1c 2y ago104 points, zero comments, 2 hours ago. Might be botted.
- nunobrito 2y agoSome propaganda bots still work despite defunding of USAID. This is how they used to influence opinions across the masses.
- Gud 2y agoWithout evidence you are just dumbing down the internet.
- consumer451 2y agoIs there any proof of USAID funding propaganda networks in the USA? If so, please share.
- ceejayoz 2y agoI assure you, if I had bots my submissions would tend to do better. It was an oddly long time without comments, though.
- byearthithatius 2y agoOver 100 people upvoted this but nobody has any thoughts? I will share one. It is a negative side effect of capitalism that monetary power controls information flow.
- warkdarrior 2y agoClearly some people benefit from controlling information flow, and some people are impacted negatively. Bezos may make another $1B by controlling WaPo opinion pages, while I, as a reader, may lose $1 or rights or whatever from the same action. How do you balance the two?
- jaredwiener 2y agoI think you just hit on the the biggest threat to journalism right now -- how to you quantify the value of the reporting to the reader. Financial news outlets have long been successful at this -- Bloomberg, CNBC, Wall Street Journal, etc. They are able to build strong businesses with a relatively small audience often because that audience is willing to pay large sums of money for access. (Bloomberg Terminals reportedly cost up to $25k/yr! https://www.bluegamma.io/post/bloomberg-terminal-pricing#:~:text=How%20much%20does%20Bloomberg%20Terminal,the%20market%20data%20platform%20spectrum.) https://www.bluegamma.io/post/bloomberg-terminal-pricing#:~:... Still -- how much value do you get from the Washington Post? How much value do you get from knowing about the inner workings of your government? Federal, state, municipal, any of them? Does being a better citizen have a financial incentive? Can you put a price on knowing about the situation in Ukraine, or Gaza, or even the dangerous intersection downtown? And without that, how do you justify payment for journalism, which itself is expensive? Or is the answer that the payment comes from people who want to push a narrative, or control the conversation? Is there a monetary value to preventing that?
- bobthepanda 2y agoIt used to be ads; before the Internet there was limited advertising space that reached lots of people, so papers could fund themselves with their wide distribution even in the face of competition from TV. Of course, the Internet blew that wide open. A couple of places have tried diversifying content towards what readers will pay for; NYT has done probably the best job with the branching out towards cooking, Wirecutter, etc. that people do want to pay for. Buzzfeed attempted to do the same for clickbait to fund real journalism but that fizzled out.
- jaredwiener 2y agoAdvertising is a monetization strategy. I'm asking how do you quantify the underlying value. As a consumer of news, how am I richer now than I was before reading? And is it possible to put a number on it?
- toasterlovin 2y agoOn the other hand, it’s a positive side effect of capitalism that something other than political power controls information flow.
- jaredwiener 2y agoIs that true, though? CBS urges FCC to reject complaint over '60 Minutes' Harris interview https://www.forth.news/threads/CM14g5qJY2k92yLkDHSHT https://www.forth.news/threads/CM14g5qJY2k92yLkDHSHT
- gopher_space 2y agoI'm not really waiting around hoping for someone to control things for me.
- didibus 2y agoIs that a temporary state, until both powers converge, as is happening now?
- manifoldgeo 2y agoI upvoted this post and would not have commented if not for yours, so maybe my reason for (almost) abstaining is similar as other people who upvoted. What follows might be a ramble and is just my anecdotal experience on HN: I've been an HN user for years, and I've found it somewhat hard to comment on anything related to economics or non-technical / pop-cultural topics. Many HN users are experts in their technical fields, and they seem to think this automatically translates to expertise in political science, sociology, psychology, and all the other fields of endeavor where we can't just point to source code to justify our positions. I mostly find that HN commenters are a thoughtful bunch. But, there's a small, noisy group of armchair experts waiting to swoop in and correct your grammar or disagree on some technicality over social issues like this. Since HN is tech-focused, even posting something not directly related to technology can get your post flagged and taken down as irrelevant. So in a way, discussing these things is disincentivized by the site's purpose. I get that WaPo is an online platform and therefore in-scope, but it's "scarier" to comment on because it's more social than technical. In part, the act of being a thoughtful commenter also means steering well clear of any flame wars (that aren't related to NixOS, Rust, or LLMs). I.e., it's like jazz in that it's about the notes you don't play— it's the comments you don't make that foster a good online experience. This is also a US-specific article, and lots of American people are overwhelmed by the onslaught of post-election political news; so, this might be a cultural thing in that people are not commening as much because they're dealing with a big inbox of emotions to sort through. I still take active interest in political posts like this and personally think Bezos is a modern-day robber baron in the new Gilded Age. But, I'll seldom say so, opting instead to upvote so others can see the post and then move on silently.
- mnky9800n 2y agoThe llm flame wars aren’t even fun anymore.
- sebazzz 2y agoThe side effect may be intended: even further distrust in traditional media.
- daheza 2y agoHopefully the market self corrects on this and washington posts loses subscribers. Forcing an opinion section to have only opinions you want is just the opposite of its purpose.
- smackeyacky 2y agoHistorically newspapers have always had some kind of slant in their opinion pages that bleeds out into their stories. The Murdoch family made their fortune doing it, "yellow journalism" is still very much alive and well.
- zerocrates 2y agoThe Post has already lost a lot of the subscribers who would leave over something like this, in successive waves after: Bezos spiked the Harris endorsement, the paper blocked a political cartoon depicting Bezos and others bowing down to Trump, and the announcement of this new "two pillars" editorial policy that the blocked editorial here would have commented on. All amid a stream of resignations. I don't know that the market can all that meaningfully discipline Bezos, even if a response had the kind of direction and magnitude that would. Though he clearly has sought profitability for the paper, running it at a loss is a drop in the bucket financially for him.
- lovich 2y agoThe market cant self correct here because the market is broken. Bezos is using his profits from one industry to prop up his unprofitable business in another industry, which also helps from any real competition starting up as they don't have access to Amazon profits This behavior and its consequences are why people call for monopolies to be broken up
- dylan604 2y ago> the paper blocked a political cartoon depicting Bezos and others bowing down to Trump So are we saying that Bezos is so plugged into the day-to-day operations of WaPo that he can yank the things he doesn't like, or is there some sycophant put in place that pings Bezos when they think it is something Bezos wouldn't like? I can't imagine that Bezos gives a damn enough to be checking in every day before release deadlines while cruising the globe on his super yacht.
- pm90 2y agoI really didn’t have Bezos being so grotesquely subservient in my bingo card. Shame on him and on WaPo CEO.
- ajross 2y agoIt's not a character thing, really. Grotesque subservience is a firm requirement to be successful in authoritarian environments. He wants to remain successful and will play the game by the rules presented. Lots of people operate that way, probably more than those that don't. That this has not been historically true in the United States is the notable outlier.
- bwestergard 2y ago"Grotesque subservience" is what _creates_ authoritarian environments.
- ajross 2y agoMeh, so does violence and conquest and coups. Certainly there's a feedback cycle between them, but the path to autocracy has many forks. Again it's the rule of law that's the exception, not autocracy.
- unsui 2y ago> That this has not been historically true in the United States is the notable outlier. So, bootlicker, got it. And yes, it is very much a character thing...
- know-how 2y ago[dead]
- spacechild1 2y agoIt's still a character thing, though.
- brianmurphy 2y agoThe article says her editorial was written to criticize her employer. Was she hoping to get fired instead of politely being told no?
- sterlind 2y agoEditorial freedom like this was actually quite commonplace at US newspapers. Op-Eds criticising the paper's owner signals viewpoint independence to readers, which boosts sales. In fact, it's usually easier to criticize the owners themselves than policies the owners care about.
- blackguardx 2y agoShe has been writing in the opinion section for 40 years, which previously printed many columns the newspaper didn’t agree with.
- Invictus0 2y ago[flagged]
- wtcactus 2y agoThis is not a journalist. This is someone that writes their opinion on a column. I’m sick and tired of "journalists" (probably should call them "professional opinion givers") using the journals to spew their personal opinions instead of reporting the news. I know I was born too late to experience the golden age of journalism where journals would actually stick to give you the news, but it’s just tiresome to see the journalist's personal opinions and ideologies now in full display on every article. I don’t care about what they feel about the theme, I just want the facts. And judging by how journals are faring, I’m pretty sure I’m not the only one feeling this.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> I know I was born too late to experience the golden age of journalism where journals would actually stick to give you the news... Can you clarify what time period that was? > This is not a journalist. This is someone that writes their opinion on a column. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journalist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journalist "Depending on the form of journalism, 'journalist' may also describe various categories of people by the roles they play in the process. These include reporters, correspondents, citizen journalists, editors, editorial writers, columnists, and photojournalists." You're thinking of a reporter.
- didibus 2y agoWell, she resigned in protest of the entire newspaper becoming an opinion piece. But the idea that news is without bias/opinion is a bit controversial. They have limited space, what they choose to report on and not, promote, etc. are all forms of opinion that reflects ideology. Maybe it is us in our era who are too naive and gullible, asking for something that isn't possible, instead of learning to think for ourselves and be critical.
- gopher_space 2y ago> But the idea that news is without bias/opinion is a bit controversial. It's not controversial, it's an idea only held by morons who didn't finish high school. To be clear, everyone in this country with a GED or higher has taken classes on media literacy and bias and understands that unbiased news isn't a thing and never has been.
- TacticalCoder 2y ago[dead]
- santoshalper 2y agoRegardless of your political stance, the owner of a newspaper dictating that they will be "writing every day in support and defense” of “personal liberties and free markets." means they are no longer journalism and are simply propaganda.